Soufflet Beheer v AWB Ltd (ACN 081 890 459)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Soufflet Beheer v AWB Ltd (ACN 081 890 459) [2006] FCA 51

CONTRACT – whether two writings were an offer and acceptance – whether there was accord and satisfaction – whether forbearance to sue was consideration – no contract formed because of absence of consideration

Pepsi Seven-Up Bottlers Perth Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 62 FCR 289 cited
Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas (2004) (“Pacific Carriers”) 218 CLR 451 cited
McDermott v Black (1940) 63 CLR 161 cited
Osborn v McDermott [1998] 3 VR 1 cited
Bartlett v Mouncey [1998] FCA 418 cited
Murphy v Timms [1987] 2 Qd R 550 referred to
Newton v State Government Insurance Office (Qld) [1986] 1 Qd R 431 referred to

SOUFFLET BEHEER v AWB LTD (ACN 081 890 459)

VID 587 OF 2002

KENNY J
8 FEBRUARY 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 587 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

SOUFFLET BEHEER
APPLICANT

AND:

AWB LTD (ACN 081 890 459)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 FEBRUARY 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding, including reserved costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 587 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

SOUFFLET BEHEER
APPLICANT

AND:

AWB LTD (ACN 081 890 459)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE:

8 FEBRUARY 2006

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 18 June 2004, the applicant, Soufflet Beheer, filed a Further Amended Application and, at trial on 20 June 2005, a Third Further Amended Statement of Claim.  By this application and pleading, the applicant made a claim for payment of a debt, alternatively, damages for breach of contract.  The applicant abandoned earlier claims involving estoppel, waiver, unconscionability and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The applicant’s claim is for the Australian Dollar equivalent of USD421,380.22.

  2. The parties were largely in agreement about the facts relevant to the applicant’s claim.  They disagreed, however, as to whether, by reason of these facts, a compromise agreement was reached whereby the applicant agreed to accept a sum of USD421,380.22 and respondent agreed to pay that figure.  For the reasons that follow, I find that no agreement was reached and the application, as contained in the Further Amended Application, should be dismissed.

    the parties

  3. The original application in this proceeding was filed on 11 September 2002 by Soufflet USA Inc (“Soufflet USA”).  Soufflet USA was a wholly owned subsidiary of Soufflet Beheer.  

  4. By deeds of assignment, Soufflet USA, assigned to its parent, Soufflet Beheer, its “right, title and interest in the debt” the subject of this proceeding and all of Soufflet USA’s “right, title and interest in the choses in action” the subject of this proceeding.  There is no dispute as to the applicant’s standing.

  5. Soufflet Beheer is incorporated in the Netherlands.  Soufflet Beheer is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soufflet Beheer v AWB Ltd (ACN 081 890 459) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Soufflet Beheer, the plaintiff, brought an action against AWB Ltd, the defendant, seeking a determination on various contractual disputes related to the sale and shipping of wheat. The primary dispute arose from a Charter Party agreement, where Soufflet USA contracted with AWB for the shipping of wheat to a specified location. The court had to decide on the interpretation of certain terms in the Charter Party and whether there was an effective offer and acceptance that constituted a new agreement between the parties.

The court examined whether AWB's communication on August 3, 1999, constituted an offer that could be accepted, forming a new contract. Soufflet Beheer argued that AWB's communication amounted to an accord and satisfaction, which would have required new consideration. However, the court found that AWB's communication did not constitute an offer for a new agreement supported by new consideration. Instead, AWB was merely asserting its position under the existing Charter Party regarding the freight balance calculation. The court held that there was no new agreement because AWB's communication did not depart from or replace the original Charter Party but sought to clarify a position within it.

The court concluded that AWB's fax did not demonstrate an intention to enter into a new contract but was instead a claim about the existing contract's terms. As such, the court dismissed the application and ordered Soufflet Beheer to pay AWB Ltd's costs of and incidental to the proceeding, including reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties also relied on an Agreed Statement of Facts. The matter was heard on 20 and 21 June 2005. There was cross-examination of all deponents. the facts of the caseThe Contracts for Sale The evidence disclosed that, on about 3 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a contract (the “Holding Contract”) by which Soufflet USA agreed to sell to Holding Company for Rice and Flour Mills (“Holding Company”) 55,000 metric tons of hard red winter wheat at a price of USD131.00 per metric ton C&F Free Out. It was a term of this contract that the wheat was to be shipped between 5 March 1999 and 15 March 1999. The Holding Company contract also provided that up to eight days delay was acceptable provided that Soufflet USA make certain allowances to Holding Company to be deducted in the invoice from the contract price. On 19 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a contract (the “Concourse Contract”) with Concourse Grain LLC (“Concourse Grain”) for the supply of the wheat to be provided to Holding Company. This contract required Soufflet USA to pay carrying charges and interest if it was unable to take delivery of the grain by 15 March 1999.The Charter Party On 18 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a Charter Party with AWB with respect to a vessel to be nominated by AWB. The Charter Party was in writing and included the following terms:(a)That the vessel proceed to a port in the US Gulf and “[t]he declaration of loadport orders to be declared by latest 15th March 1999”. (Clause 1)(b)That the vessel “be loaded at the average rate of 10,000 metric tons per weather working day”. (Clause 12)(c)If the vessel is delayed longer at the loading port than provided for in Clause 12 then “Charterers to pay Owners demurrage at the rate of USD [12,000] per day or pro rata for part of a day provided that such delay shall occur by fault of the Charterers or their agents.”If the vessel is dispatched sooner, “Owners to pay Charterers despatch at USD [6,000] per day or pro rata for part of a day for all working time saved”. (Clause 13 as amended by Addendum No. 3)(d)If “the Notice of Readiness at loading port not be delivered … by 12 o’clock noon on the 15th March 1999, the Charterers or their agents shall at the said hour and at any time thereafter, but not later than the presentation of Notice of Readiness together with the required certificate at the said office, have the option of Cancelling this Charter Party”. (Clause 16)(e)The nominated vessel’s age is “not more than 10 years but up to 25 years max acceptable, provided that Benef. bears overage additional insurance cost according to Lloyds rates”. (Clause 46 as amended by Addendum No. 3).(f)That, upon loading, the vessel proceed to an Egyptian Mediterranean Port (Damietta or Eldekhela). (Clause 4 and Addendum No. 3)(g)“All disputes from time to time arising out of this contract shall, unless the parties agree forthwith on a single Arbitrator, be referred to the final arbitration of two Arbitrators … . Any claim must be made in writing and Claimants Arbitrator appointed within three months of final discharge and where this provision is not complied with the claim shall be deemed to be waived and absolutely barred.” (Clause 36) (h)It was “mutually agreed that the Carrier shall not be liable for loss or damage occasioned by causes beyond his control, by the perils of the seas or any other waters; by fire from any cause, whatsoever occurring by barratry of the master or crew, by enemies, pirates or robbers by arrests and restraints of the Princes, Rulers or people by explosion, bursting of boilers, breakage of shafts or any latent defect in hull, machinery or appurtenances by collisions, stranding or any other accidents of navigation of whatsoever kind”. (Clause 37)The MV Panamax Star was the nominated vessel under the Charter Party (Addendum 1).Subsequent Developments

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

AWB’s case was that its fax of 3 August 1999 was not an offer capable of acceptance. AWB contended that any response to that fax could not be an acceptance and there was no intention to enter into legal relations.the evidence In support of its case, the applicant relied on the witness statements of Jean-Marc Philouze made on 19 June 2003 and 6 May 2004 and adopted as correct at trial. Mr Philouze was chief of operations for Soufflet Négoce from 1997 to 2000. The applicant also invited the Court to take judicial notice of the contents of certain marine dictionaries and glossaries. The respondent relied on the witness statements of Rohitha Welmillage made on 11 August 2003 and Nicholas Simon Swales made on 21 April 2004, which were also adopted as correct at trial. Mr Welmillage was a chartering officer employed by AWB. He was the author of AWB’s fax of 3 August 1999. Mr Swales is a retired shipbroker. AWB put forward Mr Swales as an expert witness on the meaning of the terms ‘Vessel’s Final Accounts’ and ‘Final Accounts’ within the shipping industry. The parties also relied on an Agreed Statement of Facts. The matter was heard on 20 and 21 June 2005. There was cross-examination of all deponents. the facts of the caseThe Contracts for Sale The evidence disclosed that, on about 3 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a contract (the “Holding Contract”) by which Soufflet USA agreed to sell to Holding Company for Rice and Flour Mills (“Holding Company”) 55,000 metric tons of hard red winter wheat at a price of USD131.00 per metric ton C&F Free Out. It was a term of this contract that the wheat was to be shipped between 5 March 1999 and 15 March 1999. The Holding Company contract also provided that up to eight days delay was acceptable provided that Soufflet USA make certain allowances to Holding Company to be deducted in the invoice from the contract price. On 19 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a contract (the “Concourse Contract”) with Concourse Grain LLC (“Concourse Grain”) for the supply of the wheat to be provided to Holding Company. This contract required Soufflet USA to pay carrying charges and interest if it was unable to take delivery of the grain by 15 March 1999.The Charter Party On 18 February 1999, Soufflet USA entered into a Charter Party with AWB with respect to a vessel to be nominated by AWB. The Charter Party was in writing and included the following terms:(a)That the vessel proceed to a port in the US Gulf and “[t]he declaration of loadport orders to be declared by latest 15th March 1999”. (Clause 1)(b)That the vessel “be loaded at the average rate of 10,000 metric tons per weather working day”. (Clause 12)(c)If the vessel is delayed longer at the loading port than provided for in Clause 12 then “Charterers to pay Owners demurrage at the rate of USD [12,000] per day or pro rata for part of a day provided that such delay shall occur by fault of the Charterers or their agents.”If the vessel is dispatched sooner, “Owners to pay Charterers despatch at USD [6,000] per day or pro rata for part of a day for all working time saved”. (Clause 13 as amended by Addendum No. 3)(d)If “the Notice of Readiness at loading port not be delivered … by 12 o’clock noon on the 15th March 1999, the Charterers or their agents shall at the said hour and at any time thereafter, but not later than the presentation of Notice of Readiness together with the required certificate at the said office, have the option of Cancelling this Charter Party”. (Clause 16)(e)The nominated vessel’s age is “not more than 10 years but up to 25 years max acceptable, provided that Benef. bears overage additional insurance cost according to Lloyds rates”. (Clause 46 as amended by Addendum No. 3).(f)That, upon loading, the vessel proceed to an Egyptian Mediterranean Port (Damietta or Eldekhela). (Clause 4 and Addendum No. 3)(g)“All disputes from time to time arising out of this contract shall, unless the parties agree forthwith on a single Arbitrator, be referred to the final arbitration of two Arbitrators … . Any claim must be made in writing and Claimants Arbitrator appointed within three months of final discharge and where this provision is not complied with the claim shall be deemed to be waived and absolutely barred.” (Clause 36) (h)It was “mutually agreed that the Carrier shall not be liable for loss or damage occasioned by causes beyond his control, by the perils of the seas or any other waters; by fire from any cause, whatsoever occurring by barratry of the master or crew, by enemies, pirates or robbers by arrests and restraints of the Princes, Rulers or people by explosion, bursting of boilers, breakage of shafts or any latent defect in hull, machinery or appurtenances by collisions, stranding or any other accidents of navigation of whatsoever kind”. (Clause 37)The MV Panamax Star was the nominated vessel under the Charter Party (Addendum 1).Subsequent Developments

Decision

Reasons for decision

KENNY J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KENNY J

Somewhere between accord and satisfaction and accord executory “is the accord and conditional satisfaction, which exists where the compromise amounts to an existing and enforceable agreement between the parties for performance according to its tenor but which does not operate to discharge any existing cause of action unless and until there has been performance”: Osborn at 10. Accord and conditional satisfaction would be reached if a creditor agreed to forebear from suit for 30 days and to discharge the cause of action if the debtor paid a compromise amount within that time: see Bartlett v Mouncey [1998] FCA 418.Absence of Consideration The applicant contended that the consideration, from Soufflet USA, was the relinquishment of its full claim ($439,557.83 for both the damages claim and the freight balance) in exchange for a lower amount ($421,380.22 for the damages claim and a reduced freight balance). In the applicant’s submission, the contract was a paradigmatic example of accord and satisfaction. The problem with this view is that AWB was not asking Soufflet USA to make a concession when it submitted a different load port calculation. Rather, AWB was merely claiming that, under the pre-existing Charter Party, it owed a different amount than that claimed by Soufflet USA. As AWB correctly submitted (see [52]-[55] above), this was not a request for a new agreement supported by new consideration. This can be further illustrated with the following example. Suppose that on 5 August 1999, AWB had written to Soufflet USA claiming that it had discovered that the demurrage had also been miscalculated. Presumably, Soufflet USA would have replied that, as a new contract had been formed on 3 August 1999, the issue of demurrage was closed. In my view, that response would be untenable as AWB’s fax of 3 August 1999 demonstrates no intention to depart from or supplant the original Charter Party. The situation would be different if AWB had accepted that Soufflet USA’s calculations were correct but had nonetheless requested a reduction in the freight balance. In that case, it would have been seeking a new agreement. Similarly, suppose the solicitor from AWB’s hypothetical (at [53] above) asked the barrister to accept a reduced fee because the client was of limited means, in return for payment on an earlier date that that originally agreed. This request would be an offer because it goes outside the terms of the original contract and it would specify consideration capable of supporting the new agreement. In contrast, AWB’s claim about load port despatch did not go outside the terms of the Charter Party. For these reasons, I find that AWB’s statement about the freight balance calculation was not an ‘offer’ for a new agreement with new consideration. The issue of the freight balance calculation must be considered as independent from any agreement by AWB to pay the damages claim. This means that the only other candidate for consideration is forbearance by Soufflet USA from suing on its damages claim. Although forbearance can be consideration in some cases, it is a very poor candidate here.