Soraya Ayoub and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2013] AATA 397

Division General Administrative Division

File Numbers

2012/5364

Re

 Soraya Ayoub

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President RP Handley

Date  13 June 2013
Place Sydney

Ms Ayoub’s application to the Tribunal lodged on 27 November 2012 is reinstated.

.............................[SGD].................................

Deputy President RP Handley

CATCHWORDS

POLICY AND PROCEDURE - application for reinstatement of application – application withdrawn by solicitor – no written authority to withdraw – whether there was a misunderstanding between applicant and solicitor about withdrawing application – whether application dismissed in error – whether appropriate to reinstate application in circumstances of particular case - application reinstated

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s 42A

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 14

CASES

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541
Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2002) 121 FCR 383
Grass and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 495 (2011) 126 ALD 580
Jackamarra v Krackouer (1998) 195 CLR 516

RE White and Secretary, Department of Families, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs (2007) 97 ALD 204

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President RP Handley

Date 13 June 2013

  1. Ms Ayoub applied to the Tribunal for a review of a decision of Comcare (the Respondent) dated 7 September 2012 affirming a determination which denied liability to pay compensation to Ms Ayoub under s 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act).

  2. On 4 April 2013, the Tribunal received a notice of withdrawal of the application from Ms Ayoub’s solicitors signed on that day. Acting on this notice of withdrawal, by letter of the same date, the Tribunal notified the parties that the application had been dismissed. The notification sent to Ms Ayoub was sent care of her solicitors. Ms Ayoub provided the Tribunal with a copy of a letter from her solicitor dated 11 April 2013 in which her solicitor, referring to their telephone conversation on 4 April 2013, stated: “We further confirm your instructions to withdraw the first claim for injury which fell within the exclusionary provisions as discussed.”

  3. By email sent on 22 April 2013, Ms Ayoub requested that her application be re-instated, stating:

    My case was withdrawn against my wishes by a solicitor that was previously acting on my behalf. This solicitor said that my case wasn’t worth his time or money as I have had my second claim with Comcare accepted (which was an aggravation of the claim that was withdrawn). I wish to please have your consideration in this matter as I am in the process of finding new legal representation and will represent myself if necessary. I am severely financially disadvantaged by the rejected compensation claim with Comcare, and as a single mother of two children I wish to have my case re-instated so that I have a chance to appeal their decision.

  4. Comcare opposed Mr Ayoub’s request to re-instate her application. The parties attended a Directions Hearing at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soraya Ayoub and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 397
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Soraya Ayoub and Comcare was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The central dispute involved Ms Ayoub's application for compensation that had been withdrawn by her solicitor, Mr Pitt, without her consent. Ms Ayoub sought reinstatement of her application, arguing that she had not authorised the withdrawal and wished to continue with her claim. Comcare, represented by Mr Lehmann, opposed the reinstatement, asserting that Ms Ayoub had given instructions to withdraw the application.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to exercise its discretion under section 42A(10) of the Administrative Appeals Act to reinstate Ms Ayoub's application, which had been dismissed due to withdrawal. The Tribunal had to determine whether the application was indeed dismissed in error and, if so, whether reinstatement was appropriate in the given circumstances. This involved assessing the evidence provided by Ms Ayoub and Mr Pitt regarding the instructions given and the understanding between them.

The Tribunal found that there was a misunderstanding between Ms Ayoub and her solicitor, Mr Pitt, which led to the erroneous withdrawal of her application. Ms Ayoub consistently denied authorising the withdrawal and maintained that she wanted to continue with her claim. The Tribunal accepted Ms Ayoub's evidence that she was misled by her solicitor's advice and that she had not intended for her application to be withdrawn. Consequently, the Tribunal exercised its discretion to reinstate Ms Ayoub's application, concluding that it would be unfair not to do so given the circumstances.

Ms Ayoub's application, originally lodged on 27 November 2012, was reinstated by the Tribunal. This decision allowed her to proceed with her claim for compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Thus, pursuant to s 42A(10), the Tribunal has a discretion to reinstate an application if the application was dismissed in error. It follows that the Tribunal must first be satisfied that the application was dismissed in error and, if it is so satisfied, secondly, consider whether reinstatement is appropriate in the circumstances of the particular case.EVIDENCEMs Ayoub Ms Ayoub denied having authorised the solicitor who was previously acting for her, Jonathan Pitt of Maurice Blackburn Lawyers, to withdraw her application. She said she never signed a written authorisation to this effect. She described a telephone conversation with Mr Pitt, which (according to Mr Pitt) took place on 4 April 2013, during the course of which she states Mr Pitt informed her that it was not worth pursuing her application, as a later application for compensation had been accepted by Comcare. Ms Ayoub said that contrary to Mr Pitt’s claim, she never wanted her application to be withdrawn: she wanted to continue pursuing her claim for compensation. Ms Ayoub said that Maurice Blackburn Lawyers agreed to represent her on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis. She denied that it had been initially explained to her that representation would be on a full fee basis if she acted against Maurice Blackburn’s advice. She said that in a telephone conversation with Mr Pitt on 31 January 2013, he described continuing with her application as ‘like flogging a dead horse’. She said she had more evidence to produce to support her case but Mr Pitt would not consider this evidence: he was convinced the application did not have good prospects of success. Ultimately, he agreed to postpone making a decision until the second application with Comcare had been decided. Ms Ayoub denied having told Mr Pitt that she did not want to run the case herself or that she could not afford to pay him. Ms Ayoub said she received Mr Pitt’s letter dated 11 April 2013 (a Thursday) the following week, possibly not until Thursday 18 April 2013. She was very upset to learn her application had been withdrawn against her wishes. She thinks that when she went to work the next day, she telephoned the Tribunal – probably, therefore, on Friday 19 April 2013 – to ask how to go about having her application reinstated. The following Monday (22 April 2103), she emailed the Tribunal asking that her application be reinstated and explaining her reasons.Mr Pitt At the Directions Hearing on 4 June 2013, Comcare’s solicitor, Mr Lehmann, sought an adjournment in order to obtain further evidence from Ms Ayoub’s former solicitor, Mr Pitt, about his instructions and Ms Ayoub agreed to waive any legal professional privilege attaching to her communications with Mr Pitt relating to the withdrawal of her application to enable Mr Lehmann to do so. Mr Lehmann subsequently filed an email response from Mr Pitt, dated 6 June 2013, in which he said that he had received instructions to withdraw her application in the telephone call with Ms Ayoub on 4 April 2013.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, accepting that an error was made as a result of a misunderstanding between her and her solicitor, it would be unfair in the circumstances not to reinstate her application. For the above reasons, I am satisfied that I should exercise the discretion in s 42A(10) of the AAT Act to reinstate Ms Ayoub’s application.DECISION Ms Ayoub’s application to the Tribunal lodged on 27 November 2012 is reinstated.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established