Song v South Beach Management Pty Ltd [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   SONG -v- SOUTH BEACH MANAGEMENT PTY LTD [No 3] [2021] WASC 282

CORAM:   ALLANSON J

HEARD:   11 AUGUST 2021

DELIVERED          :   17 AUGUST 2021

PUBLISHED           :   17 AUGUST 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3152 of 2019

BETWEEN:   CHANGFU SONG

First Plaintiff

YUANCHAO XUE

Second Plaintiff

TOPSTAR MARKETING (AUST) PTY LTD

Third Plaintiff

AND

SOUTH BEACH MANAGEMENT PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SOUTH BEACH TWO DEVELOPMENT TRUST

First Defendant

CAMERON ANDREW KEAST BARR

Second Defendant

LLOYD RICHARD CLARK

Third Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - where plaintiffs seek leave to issue subpoenas before defence - whether plaintiffs have legitimate forensic purpose in seeking the documents - whether the plaintiffs have shown exceptional circumstances for issue of subpoena before defence

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 36B r 2

Result:

Application granted

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : K A Dundo
Second Plaintiff : K A Dundo
Third Plaintiff : K A Dundo
First Defendant : D K Zusman
Second Defendant : D K Zusman
Third Defendant : D K Zusman

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : KD Legal (Perth)
Second Plaintiff : KD Legal (Perth)
Third Plaintiff : KD Legal (Perth)
First Defendant : Bennett + Co
Second Defendant : Bennett + Co
Third Defendant : Bennett + Co

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Sandy v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corp RNTBC [2019] WASC 322

Song v South Beach Management Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 402

ALLANSON J:

Introduction

  1. By letter dated 2 August 2021, the plaintiffs applied for leave to issue subpoenas to five recipients seeking documents which can be generally described as instructions, advice and draft documents relating to the establishment of the South Beach Two Development Trust and any deeds of variation to the Trust.  The proposed subpoenas cover the period from 1 January 2011 and 6 August 2014.  The proposed recipients have been identified by evidence filed in an earlier summary judgment application in this action.

  2. The plaintiffs require leave of the court for the issue of subpoenas pursuant to O 36B r 2(2B)(b) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). Leave is required because no defence has been filed.

  3. Under subrule (2B)(b), the court must not give leave unless satisfied there are 'exceptional circumstances'.[1]

    [1] O 36B r 2(2D).

  4. In Sandy v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corp RNTBC, Le Miere J said:

    The words 'exceptional circumstances' have their ordinary meaning. 'Exceptional' means 'out of the ordinary' or 'unusual', rather than 'unique'. The party requesting the issue of a subpoena should be able to demonstrate the precise issues in respect of which the documents are required.[2] 

    [2] Sandy v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corp RNTBC [2019] WASC 322 [4].

  5. This is the second application by the plaintiffs for leave in these proceedings.  I followed the decision of Le Miere J in the earlier application.[3] I am not aware of any other cases in this court where the operation of O 36B r 2(2D) has been considered.

    [3] Song…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Song v South Beach Management Pty Ltd [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs in this case sought leave to issue subpoenas before the defendants had filed a defence. The plaintiffs were Changfu Song, Yuanchao Xue, and Topstar Marketing (Aust) Pty Ltd, and the defendants were South Beach Management Pty Ltd, Cameron Andrew Keast Barr, and Lloyd Richard Clark. The plaintiffs sought documents that related to the establishment of the South Beach Two Development Trust and any deeds of variation to the Trust. The plaintiffs required leave of the court to issue subpoenas, as no defence had been filed. The court had to decide whether the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic purpose in seeking the documents and whether there were exceptional circumstances for the issue of subpoenas before a defence was filed. The court granted the application and found that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents, and the circumstances were exceptional.

The plaintiffs sought documents to determine if they would provide evidence to support a plea that the Deed of Amendment was prepared later and backdated. The court accepted that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in exploring whether the Deed of Amendment was backdated, as there were discrepancies in the documents. The court also found that the circumstances were exceptional because the defendants had already brought a summary judgment application in which the alleged backdating of the Deed of Amendment was addressed. The court was satisfied that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents described in the subpoenas, and the circumstances were exceptional. Therefore, the court allowed the application and granted leave for the plaintiffs to issue subpoenas.

This case highlights the importance of the proper and timely disclosure of documents in litigation. The court found that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents, and the circumstances were exceptional. The court granted the plaintiffs' application to issue subpoenas before a defence was filed. This decision provides guidance to parties in similar situations and emphasizes the need for proper disclosure of documents in litigation.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiffs, Changfu Song, Yuanchao Xue, and Topstar Marketing (Aust) Pty Ltd, are suing South Beach Management Pty Ltd as trustee for the South Beach Two Development Trust, Cameron Andrew Keast Barr, and Lloyd Richard Clark. The plaintiffs are seeking leave to issue subpoenas to five recipients for documents relating to the establishment of the South Beach Two Development Trust and any deeds of variation to the Trust. The documents sought are described as instructions, advice, and draft documents covering the period from 1 January 2011 to 6 August 2014. The plaintiffs require leave of the court as no defence has been filed yet. This is the second application for leave in these proceedings. In the first application, the plaintiffs sought a more limited class of documents relating to the deeds of variation from a different subpoena recipient. The first application was allowed, but the plaintiffs did not obtain access to the documents returned under the subpoena as the defendants' objection to the plaintiffs inspecting the documents was upheld.

The plaintiffs filed an application for leave to issue subpoenas before the defendants filed a defence. This is the second application for leave in these proceedings. The first application was brought in circumstances where the plaintiffs had filed a statement of claim and were facing applications by the defendants for summary judgment, alternatively to strike out specified paragraphs in the statement of claim. The first application was allowed, but the plaintiffs did not obtain access to the documents returned under the subpoena as the defendants' objection to the plaintiffs inspecting the documents was upheld. The summary judgment application was later dismissed. The defendants were, however, successful in having several paragraphs of the statement of claim struck out, requiring the plaintiffs to substantially replead their case. The plaintiffs have leave to re-plead and have not yet done so. The question in this application is whether the plaintiffs have a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents described in the subpoenas and whether the circumstances are exceptional for the issue of the subpoenas before a defence is filed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Do the plaintiffs have a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents described in the subpoenas?
2. Are the circumstances exceptional for the issue of the subpoenas before a defence is filed?

Held
1. The plaintiffs have a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents described in the subpoenas. The court found that the true date of the Deed of Amendment is relevant to the exercise of powers by the Trustee, which will be in issue in the action.
2. The circumstances are exceptional for the issue of the subpoenas before a defence is filed. The court found that it is likely the defendants would object to the inspection of any subpoenaed documents and that there is a discrepancy in the documents which requires explanation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the plaintiffs applied for leave to issue subpoenas seeking documents relating to the establishment of the South Beach Two Development Trust and any deeds of variation to the Trust. The plaintiffs required leave of the court under O 36B r 2(2B)(b) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) because no defence had been filed. The court had to be satisfied that there were 'exceptional circumstances' for the issue of the subpoenas before a defence is filed. The plaintiffs argued that they had a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents and that the circumstances were exceptional.

The court accepted that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in determining when the Deed of Amendment of the Trust Deed for the South Beach Two Development Trust was executed. The court found that there were discrepancies in the documents that supported the plaintiffs' argument that they had a legitimate interest in exploring whether the Deed of Amendment was backdated. The court also accepted that the plaintiffs reasonably required the documents before a defence was filed because they might be relevant to limitation issues which were likely to arise in a pending summary judgment application.

The court found that the circumstances were exceptional for the issue of the subpoenas before a defence is filed. The court noted that the defendants had already brought a summary judgment application in which the alleged backdating of the Deed of Amendment was addressed. The court was satisfied that it is likely the defendants would object to the inspection of any subpoenaed documents. The court was also satisfied that there was a discrepancy in the documents which required explanation, although it may not be a sufficient foundation for pleading a serious factual allegation.

The court granted leave for the issue of subpoenas, finding that the plaintiffs had a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents and that the circumstances were exceptional. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the court will grant leave for the issue of subpoenas before a defence is filed where the plaintiffs have a legitimate forensic interest in seeking the documents and the circumstances are exceptional.