Song Lin v Regina

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

CITATION:      Song Lin v Regina [2007]  NSWCCA 368

FILE NUMBER(S):
2006/5223

HEARING DATE(S):               11 December 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 21 December 2007

PARTIES:
Song Lin
Regina

JUDGMENT OF:       Basten JA Barr J Adams J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          05/11/1205

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Berman DCJ

COUNSEL:
J Overall
T Thorpe

SOLICITORS:
R Zhou
S Kavanagh

CATCHWORDS:

LEGISLATION CITED:

CASES CITED:

DECISION:
1. Grant leave to appeal and allow the appeal.  2.Quash the sentence appealed from and, taking into account the possession of cocaine noted in para 6 of the agreed statement of facts, sentence the appellant to imprisonment. Fix a non-parole period of 4 years, commencing on 2 January 2005, and a head sentence of six years. Declare that he is eligible to be released to parole on 1 January 2009.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE COURT OF
CRIMINAL APPEAL

2006/5223

BASTEN JA
BARR J
ADAMS J

21 DECEMBER 2007

SONG LIN v REGINA

Judgment

  1. BASTEN JA: I agree with the orders proposed by Barr J and with his Honour's reasons.

  2. BARR J:  Song Lin has applied for leave to appeal against a sentence imposed in the District Court. He pleaded guilty to the offence of knowingly taking part in the manufacture of the commercial quantity of methylamphetamine and asked the Court in sentencing him to take into account his possession of 0.26 grams of a prohibited drug, namely cocaine. He was sentenced to imprisonment for eight years with a non-parole period of six years. The maximum penalty is imprisonment for twenty years. The commercial quantity is 0.25 kilograms.

  3. Kar Wah Lau and Kam Wing Lo were involved in the same manufacturing enterprise. Each pleaded guilty and was sentenced. Lau was charged with the manufacture of the large commercial quantity of methylamphetamine. The large commercial quantity begins at 1 kilogram, and the amount with which he was concerned was agreed to be 8.8 kilograms. He was sentenced to imprisonment for twelve years with a non-parole period of nine years. The maximum sentence for that offence is imprisonment for life.

  4. Lo pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting Lau in the manufacture of the large commercial quantity of methylamphetamine. He was sentenced to imprisonment for six years with a non-parole period of four years.

  5. There are two grounds of appeal. The first is the that the sentence is manifestly excessive. The second complains of a lack of parity between the sentence appealed from and that imposed on Lo. These grounds may be dealt with together.

  6. The different ways in which the charges were framed against each offender, Lau with manufacturing, Lo with aiding and abetting manufacture and the applicant with being knowingly concerned in manufacture – was presumably intended to distinguish between their respective roles, though the precise charge finally preferred against each may have been a product of negotiation between the Crown and the individual accused. The forms of the individual charges is of limited use in assessing criminality. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Song Lin v Regina and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCCA 368
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Song Lin has appealed against a sentence imposed in the District Court, where he pleaded guilty to knowingly taking part in the manufacture of a commercial quantity of methylamphetamine. The appeal focuses on the sentence imposed on Lin, and whether it was manifestly excessive in light of the sentence imposed on Lo, who was sentenced as an aider and abettor. The primary legal issue was whether the sentence imposed on Lin was manifestly excessive, particularly when compared to the sentence imposed on Lo, who played a less significant role in the manufacturing operation. This required the court to consider the principles of sentencing and proportionality, particularly in light of the different roles played by each offender.

The court considered the role of each offender in the manufacturing operation. Lin played the role of organiser, while Lo was an aider and abettor. The court found that the sentence imposed on Lin was not manifestly excessive, despite Lo's lesser role. The court considered the totality of the offending, the roles of each offender, and the need for general deterrence. The court held that the sentence imposed on Lin was appropriate, given the seriousness of the offending and the need to deter others from engaging in similar criminal activity.

The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence was upheld. The court found that the sentence imposed on Lin was not manifestly excessive, and that there was no justifiable sense of grievance. The court emphasised the importance of considering the totality of the offending, the roles of each offender, and the need for general deterrence when imposing sentences in drug manufacturing cases. The original sentence was affirmed, and Lin's appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The different ways in which the charges were framed against each offender, Lau with manufacturing, Lo with aiding and abetting manufacture and the applicant with being knowingly concerned in manufacture – was presumably intended to distinguish between their respective roles, though the precise charge finally preferred against each may have been a product of negotiation between the Crown and the individual accused. The forms of the individual charges is of limited use in assessing criminality. The only reliable indicator is what each offender did and with what intent. That and the range of sentences applicable – up to life imprisonment for Lau and Lo and up to twenty years’ imprisonment for the applicant – were bound to be the principal determinants in sentencing. The facts A statement of agreed facts was tendered on the sentence of each of the three offenders. A laboratory was set up at a home unit at Carlingford, but there was no evidence about who established it. The unit was apparently under the control of a man who was never charged and was absent from Australia at all material times. Lau and Lo were Chinese subjects resident in Hong Kong. Lo came to Sydney in November 2004 and Lau in December 2004. The applicant was an Australian citizen resident living in Hurstville. The police watched the movements of the three and listened to their conversations between November 2004 and 2 January 2005, when they were all arrested. Upon Lo’s arrival in Sydney Lin helped him to find accommodation in Chinatown. There were meetings and telephone calls between Lin and Lo and between Lo and Lau. There were many conversations in Cantonese between Lin and a man called Gan, who was not charged, in which Lin asked how to get his hands on things he needed to buy. Lin purchased or spoke about the purchase of a large number of items, including an enamel basin, bottles of water, a funnel, a water tin, a stove or burner, a vacuum cleaner for use as a blower, a gas stove, a silicon gun, a gas pressure reducing valve, plastic bags, rubber gloves, tongs, sealer, glue and a drill. Several of these things were found in the laboratory or at the applicant’s residence after the arrest of the offenders. The applicant boasted to Gan about the way he had adapted a funnel by drilling to make the laboratory apparatus more effective. He frequently complained to Gan about Lau and Lo. He accused Lau of being secretive. He was contemptuous of Lo. He was seen in the company of both or either of them from time to time near the laboratory at Carlingford. He was not far from that place when he was arrested. The statement of facts also contained a concession that the Crown could not prove that the applicant knew that the large commercial quantity of methylamphetamine was being manufactured. The findings on sentence Lo was sentenced in June 2006, his Honour described his role thus - It appears that the role played by the offender in the operation was that of a labourer. His job was to shop, assist others in their shopping, to remove garbage from the house where the manufacturing process was taking place and generally it seems to run around at the request of others. The others are Mr Lau who was the cook, and Mr Lin who appears to have played the role of organiser. I will sentence the offender on the basis that he did what he was directed to do by others. He was, it must be remembered, not charged by the Crown as a principal in the first degree but as an aider and abetter.