Solu Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Solu Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2019] AATA 2584 (15 August 2019)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2014/0549-0551; 2014/1055; 2014/3295-3304      

Re:Solu Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member A Poljak

Date:15 August 2019

Place:Sydney

The decisions under review are set aside and remitted to the Respondent for the appropriate calculation of duty and/or refund payable for the subject goods having regard to the following directions:

i.The Shadow Lines, Profile Handles and CD and DVD Rack are to be classified as  BASE METAL MOUNTINGS, FITTINGS AND SIMILAR ARTICLES FOR FURNITURE … within the first part of heading 8302 (classification 8302.42.00);

ii.The Mounting Track is to be classified as a “BRACKET” within the second part of heading 8302 (classification 8302.50.00);

iii.The Aluminium Rails, Aluminium Edge Profiles and Cabinet Finger Recess are to be classified under heading 9403 as FURNITURE…PARTS (classification 9403.90.00); and

iv.TCO 0823641 applies to the Shadow Lines and Profile Handles.

.......................[sgd].............................................

Senior Member A Poljak

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS AND EXCISE – customs duty – duty paid under protest – tariff classification of subject goods – aluminium extrusions in profile – interpretation of Customs Tariff Act 1995 – identity of goods in their condition as imported – whether cutting subject goods to size after importation affects classification – whether subject goods are materials not parts – specific design features and characteristics of subject goods for intended use - application of tariff concession order – decision under review set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) ss 163, 167, 269TG, 269TJ

Customs Tariff Act 1985 (Cth) s 7, Schs 2, 3
Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975 (Cth)

Customs Regulations 1926 (Cth) reg 126(1)(e)

CASES

Comptroller-General of Customs v Pharma-A-Care Laboratories Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 237

Re Acrow Australia Ltd and Collector of Customs (NSW) [1985] AATA 234
Re Acrow Australia Limited v The Collector of Customs of New South Wales [1986] FCA 208
Re Gissing and Collector of Customs (1977) 1 ALD 144
Re National Panasonic (Australia) Pty Limited and Collector of Customs, (New South Wales) [1985] AATA 132 (5 June 1985)
Re Tridon Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (1982) 4 ALD 615
Times Consultants Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (QLD) (1987)16 FCR 449
Tubemakers of Australia Pty Ltd and B.T.M. Agencies and Collector of Customs [1980] AATA 64

Vernon-Carus Australia Pty Ltd and Thomas Creevey and Associates v Collector of Customs [1995] FCA 1283

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Commonwealth of Australia Gazette (No. TC 04/01, 14 January 2004)

Commonwealth of Australia Gazette (No. TC 08/42, 22 October 2008)
World Customs Organization, Harmonized Commodity Description and Coding System – Explanatory Notes (Fifth edition, 2012)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A Poljak

15 August 2019

  1. These proceedings concern the tariff classification of aluminium extrusions in profile form imported by the Applicant, Solu Pty Ltd (“Solu”) from China (“the subject goods”) under Schedule 3 of the Customs Tariff Act 1985 (Cth) (“Tariff Act”).

  2. The decisions under review are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Solu Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2584
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Solu Pty Ltd against decisions of the Comptroller-General of Customs regarding the tariff classification of various aluminium extrusions imported into Australia. The dispute centred on whether these goods, including "Shadow Lines," "Mounting Tracks," "Profile Handles," and other related items, were correctly classified under heading 7604 of the Customs Tariff Act 1995, or if they should fall under different headings, such as 8302 (mountings and fittings) or 9403 (furniture parts). The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was tasked with determining the correct classification of these goods as imported.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were: (1) the correct tariff classification of the imported aluminium extrusions, considering their identity and characteristics in their condition as imported; (2) whether the fact that the goods might be cut to size after importation affected their classification; and (3) the applicability of Tariff Concession Order (TCO) 0823641 to certain of the goods. The Tribunal was required to interpret the relevant provisions of the Customs Tariff Act 1995 and apply established principles of tariff classification, including the importance of the goods' condition as imported and their design features for intended use.

The Tribunal reasoned that the identity of goods for tariff classification purposes is determined objectively by their characteristics as imported, not by their potential for modification or their description by traders, although these can be relevant. It was held that the "Shadow Lines," "Profile Handles," and "CD and DVD Rack" were correctly classified under heading 8302.42.00 as mountings and fittings for furniture, designed to create a handle-free look and act as a recess for opening cabinets. The "Mounting Track" was classified under heading 8302.50.00 as a bracket for wall mounting shelves, designed to create a "floating shelf" appearance. Other items, including "Aluminium Rails," "Aluminium Edge Profiles," and "Cabinet Finger Recess," were classified under heading 9403.90.00 as parts of furniture. The Tribunal also found that TCO 0823641 applied to the "Shadow Lines" and "Profile Handles."

Consequently, the decisions under review were set aside and remitted to the Comptroller-General of Customs. The Respondent was directed to recalculate the appropriate duty and refund payable for the subject goods based on the classifications determined by the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Mounting Tracks, illustrated at page 5.07 of the Catalogue:i.are imported in 3.6m lengths;ii.may be installed in their imported lengths, if used to mount a 3.6m or greater shelf, or otherwise will be cut to the length(s) required for installation after importation by the user;iii.are designed to be used with the Arm Blocks, illustrated on the same page, to support “floating shelves”, which are shelves installed on walls without exposed bracket supports;iv.a Mounting Track piece must be drilled before being fixed to a wall with screws, then two or more Arm Blocks are slid into the Mounting Track. A shelf is then installed by sliding holes in it over the Arm Blocks, and fixing each Arm Block with a screw.Other Evidence Mr Zhi Heng Li (Andrew Li), founder and Managing Director of Solu, provided evidence in these proceedings orally at hearing and by way of a written statement dated 26 October 2017. Mr Li advised at hearing that he designed the subject goods. The Shadow Lines, Mounting Track, Profile Handles, CD and DVD Rack designs were granted patents (now ceased). In regards to the Shadow Lines, Mr Li explained that they were designed for use in the manufacture of cabinets and that the whole purpose of the Shadow Lines was to give a streamlined look and eliminate the need for traditional handles that protrude from the face of doors or drawer fronts. When installed the Shadow Lines may act as a structural support for the cabinet. They can be installed in their imported length, or cut to length with no further fabrication, depending on the dimensions of the cabinet. In his written statement, Mr Li explained that “the Shadow Lines remove the need for handles on cabinet doors or draws as they create a recess in the front of the cabinet at the top of the door or drawer that allows the doors or draws to be opened by grasping the top of the door or drawer. They provide the cabinet with a sleek no handles look”. The Register of Patents describes the Shadow Lines (in various terms) as designed for construction in cabinets and also to create a handle free look for a cabinet. In regards to the Bold Line Profile Handles and Slim Line Profile Handles, Mr Li’s evidence is that they are designed for use in doors or drawers of kitchen or lounge room cabinets. They are usually cut to length, required for installation, but do not require any further work prior to installation. They are installed in the cabinet or drawers without the need for any security screws or other attaching devices, as they have a tongue that is designed as part of the Bold Line or Slim Line Handles, and a slide is cut in the top of the door or drawer. The slide is lined with glue and the tongue of the Bold Line Profile Handle or Slim Line Profile Handle is inserted into the groove and is held fast by compression and glue. Once installed, they act as a handle permitting the drawers or door of the cabinet to be opened without the need of separate handles. They provide the cabinet with a sleek no handles look.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no dispute between the parties that the relevant refund circumstance prescribed in reg. 126(1)(e) of the Regulations that “duty has been paid through manifest error of fact or patent misconception of the law” would be made out in respect of the dumping duty paid for any goods the Tribunal determines were not classified under heading 7604. The Respondent has agreed that in a remitter, it would calculate and pay refunds due on the subject goods not classified under heading 7604.DECISION The decisions under review are set aside and remitted to the Respondent for the appropriate calculation of duty and refund payable for the subject goods having regard to the following directions:i.The Shadow Lines, Profile Handles and CD and DVD Rack are to be classified as BASE METAL MOUNTINGS, FITTINGS AND SIMILAR ARTICLES FOR FURNITURE … within the first part of heading 8302 (classification 8302.42.00);ii.The Mounting Track is to be classified as a “BRACKET” within the second part of heading 8302 (classification 8302.50.00);iii.The Aluminium Rails, Aluminium Edge Profiles and Cabinet Finger Recess are to be classified under heading 9403 as FURNITURE…PARTS (classification 9403.90.00); andiv.TCO 0823641 applies to the Shadow Lines and Profile Handles.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In regards to the Aluminium Mounting Track, Mr Li’s evidence is that it is designed for the wall mounting of shelves. Once installed the Mounting Track and Arm Block (also patented) are hidden from view behind and within the shelf so that the shelf appears to be “floating”. They can be installed in the length as imported or cut to the required length, depending on the shelf with which it is used. The Register of Patents describes the Mounting Track (together with the Arm Block) as a “floating shelf track, block and arm is designed for fitting thick shells to walls with no exposed bracket system. The track is designed to pick up as many studs behind the wall on the block and arm is to hold the shelf to the track with adjustment”.Consideration The identity of the goods in their condition as imported is the starting point in resolving questions of tariff classification. In Re Gissing and Collector of Customs (1977) 1 ALD 144 the Tribunal said at 146: “Although it will frequently be possible to apply a descriptive word to the combination which is established as the entity, the naming of the entity is not an essential step in the process of identification. Identification is concerned with goods, not with the description of goods”. The classification of goods for tariff purposes is a practical “wharfside” task. In some instances it is necessary to obtain information to enable identification of the goods but “It ought to normally be possible to classify goods merely by looking at them and by considering their nature and the function which they were designed to serve”; Times Consultants Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (QLD) (1987)16 FCR 449 at 463. A useful (non-exhaustive) summary of principles relevant to the question of identification of the subject goods is set out in the Full Tribunal decision in Re Tridon Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (1982) 4 ALD 615 at 620–621 (paragraph 15). Those principles include that identification must be objective, having regard to the characteristics which the goods, on informed inspection present; in the identification of the goods, knowledge of how those who trade in the goods describe them will usually be relevant, but not necessarily conclusive; all of the descriptive terms, both specific and generic, by which the goods may fairly be identified, may be relevant to the classification of the goods within the Tariff; and identification will frequently extend to characterisation of goods by reference to their design features…, or by reference to their suitability for a particular use where those characteristics emerge from informed inspection of the goods as imported. The extent to which these characteristics may be relevant to the ultimate classification of the goods and whether evidence of the use to which the goods are put after importation is relevant, will depend upon the language of the Tariff Nomenclature. In Vernon-Carus Australia Pty Ltd and Thomas Creevey and Associates v Collector of Customs [1995] FCA 1283, Justice Northrop stated at [20]:“…In performing the task of identifying goods for classification, it is essential to have regard to the relevant classification heading. Some heading classifications make specific reference to a form or to a purpose. Where this is so, a “practical wharf-side” task, may not be appropriate. Evidence may need to be received relating to the formal purpose of the goods. In cases of this kind, the heading will need to be construed properly in order to determine what evidence is relevant to identify the goods”. [Emphasis added]Heading 8302 - Mountings or Fittings