Soliman and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

Soliman and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4478 (9 November 2020)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2019/4404

Re:Maged Soliman

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:9 November 2020

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

.........[sgd]...............................................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access – lumbar and cervical spine impairments – shoulder impairments – persistent depressive disorder – section 24 – whether the applicant meets the disability requirements – whether the impairments are permanent – where Tribunal finds only mental health impairment is permanent – where there is no substantial reduction in functional capacity – inconsistent evidence of functional capacity – whether the applicant needs the NDIS for life – section 25 – early intervention supports – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

CASES

Mulligan and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 374
Mulligan and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 974

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Operational Guideline – Access to the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr L Bygrave, Member

9 November 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr Maged Soliman, lodged an ‘Access Request Form’ on 29 August 2018 to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS). This form was completed by Dr John Lui (general practitioner) who listed Mr Soliman’s disabilities as:

    -    back pain, neck pain, shoulder pain, L[eft] arm pain

    -    depression[1]

    [1] Exhibit T-T212, page 418.

  2. On 17 September 2018, a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (the CEO) of the National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA) determined that Mr Soliman did not meet the access requirements set out in the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act); in particular, he did not meet the criteria in section 24 (disability requirements) of the Act.

  3. Mr Soliman requested an internal review of this decision and, on 9 July 2019, a delegate of the CEO of the NDIA affirmed Mr Soliman did not satisfy the access criteria in either section 24 or section 25 (early intervention requirements) of the Act (internal review decision).

  4. On 19 July 2019, Mr Soliman filed an application for review to the NDIS Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). In accordance with section 103 of the Act, the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the internal review decision.

  5. The matter was heard in Sydney by video conference and conference telephone on 15–17 September 2020. Mr Soliman attended the hearing and gave evidence by conference telephone. He did not have the assistance of a disability advocate or legal representation, although this support was discussed with him prior to his hearing.

    RELEVANT LEGISLATION

  6. The Parliament of Australia expressly provided objects and principles in the Act to give guidance on the interpretation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soliman and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of Mr Soliman and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). Mr Soliman sought to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) due to impairments affecting his lumbar and cervical spine, shoulders, and left arm, as well as a persistent depressive disorder. The NDIA had previously affirmed a decision that Mr Soliman did not meet the eligibility requirements for the NDIS.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Soliman met the "disability requirements" under section 24 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth), specifically whether his impairments were permanent and resulted in a significant reduction in his functional capacity. The Tribunal also considered whether Mr Soliman met the "early intervention requirements" under section 25 of the Act.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the definition of "disability" within the NDIS framework, which requires a significant reduction in functional capacity resulting from an impairment. While acknowledging Mr Soliman's medical history of spinal and mental health conditions, the Tribunal found that the evidence did not establish that these impairments were permanent or that they caused a substantial reduction in his functional capacity. The Tribunal noted inconsistent evidence regarding his functional capacity and that he did not demonstrate a need for the NDIS for life.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Soliman did not meet the access criteria under either section 24 or section 25 of the Act. The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's internal review decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant Operational Guideline is the Operational Guideline – Access to the NDIS (the Access Operational Guideline); chapter 8 of the Access Operational Guideline is titled ‘The disability requirements’ and chapter 9 is titled ‘Early intervention requirements’.EVIDENCEMedical evidence – lumbar and cervical spine, shoulder and left arm On 11 May 2002, Mr Soliman injured his spine while lifting at work. Subsequent review and treatment of this injury is set out in detailed medical reports by Dr Lui, Dr Medhat Guirgis (orthopaedic surgeon), Dr Geoffrey Rosenberg (orthopaedic surgeon), Dr Andreas Loefler (spinal surgeon) and Dr Ashish Diwan (chief, spine service at the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of New South Wales). Dr Guirgis described the history of Mr Soliman’s injury and treatment in a report dated 19 January 2004, observing he continued to experience ‘symptoms and signs of post-traumatic mechanical derangement of the lumbar and cervical areas of the spine with right & left S1 sciatica’.[3][3] Exhibit T-T20, page 38. In 2006 and 2007, Mr Soliman was reviewed by Dr Rosenberg and Dr Loefler. On 21 April 2006, Dr Rosenberg reported that Mr Soliman was ‘suffering true mechanical back pain through degeneration of the disc at the L4-5 level’ and recommended surgery involving ‘L4-5 decompression, discectomy and instrumental fusion’.[4] Dr Loefler, in a report dated 30 March 2007, also recommended back surgery to ‘allow decompression of his nerve roots’.[5][4] Exhibit T-T60, page 90.[5] Exhibit T-T78, page 164. Mr Soliman underwent spinal surgery in mid-2007. Reports by Dr Rosenberg in the period from 10 December 2007 to 3 April 2009 stated Mr Soliman continued to experience pain and remained ‘much the same as his pre-operative status with back and right leg pain’, and proposed Mr Soliman have ‘revision surgery’.[6] The final report by Dr Rosenberg before the Tribunal is dated 5 August 2011 and noted Mr Soliman’s ‘situation remains much the same’ and advised ‘further investigation’ through ‘an MR scan’.[7][6] Exhibit T-T114, page 212 and T119, page 217.[7] Exhibit T-T149, page 251. On 16 February 2009, after Mr Soliman’s surgery, Dr Guirgis diagnosed Mr Soliman with: - Chronic Post-traumatic mechanical derangement of the lumbar area of the spine with several contributing factors:1.Progress of the discopathic cycle of changes at the operated upon level and above it.2.Post-surgical scarring.3.Chronic lumbar myofascial and ligamentous insufficiency.4.Implication of the lumbosacral nerve roots causing the lumbosciatic syndrome described above.5.The development of structural changes of chronic regional spinal pain syndrome at the local level, at the spinal cord level and the cerebral level.- Post-traumatic mechanical derangement of the cervical area of the spine caused by musculo-ligamentous sprain \ strain with intervertebral disc involvement which had also triggered & aggravated the effects of underlying spondylotic changes.- Symptoms and signs of chronic pain/anxiety/depression.[8][8] Exhibit T-T117, page 215.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I am satisfied Mr Soliman does not meet the access criteria in either section 24 or section 25 of the Act, I find the internal review decision made by the NDIA on 9 July 2019 is correct.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

When asked about the supports he is seeking from the NDIS, Mr Soliman told the Tribunal that he is unsure about the purpose of the NDIS and the supports he can access through the NDIS or the health system.CONSIDERATION At the outset, while the evidence shows Mr Soliman has a history of ischaemic heart disease and is receiving palliative chemotherapy for his rectal cancer, both Mr Soliman and the NDIA accept these are medical conditions that are being appropriately treated through the health system and are not an impairment or disability for the purpose of Mr Soliman’s NDIS claim. For this reason, my consideration of whether Mr Soliman meets the requirements in the Act to become a participant in the NDIS only examines his lumbar and cervical spine, shoulder and left arm conditions, and his condition of persistent depressive disorder.The disability requirements Mr Soliman must meet all the requirements specified in paragraphs 24(1)(a)–(e) to satisfy subsection 24(1) of the Act. I now consider each of these requirements.Paragraph 24(1)(a) – does Mr Soliman have a disability? Paragraph 24(1)(a) of the Act requires that a person has ‘a disability that is attributable to one or more intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments or to one or more impairments attributable to a psychiatric condition’. The following guidance outlined in chapter 8.1 of the Access Operational Guideline is consistent with Mortimer J’s decision in Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency[37]: For the purposes of becoming a participant in the NDIS the focus of ‘disability’ is on the reduction or loss of an ability to perform an activity which results from an impairment.The term ‘impairment’ commonly refers to a loss of, or damage to, a physical, sensory or mental function.The narrower definition of ‘disability’ employed by the NDIS seeks to target those people with disability who have a significant impairment to their functional capacity. This functional definition of disability focuses on outcomes for people with disability that are in the most need (Explanatory Statement to the Becoming a Participant Rules). [emphasis added][37] [2015] FCA 544 at [15] to [16]. These paragraphs specify that for a person to have a disability within the meaning of paragraph 24(1)(a) of the Act, they must demonstrate that:·they have an impairment, which is a loss of, or damage to, a physical, sensory or mental function; and·their impairment must be the cause of their reduction or loss of ability to perform an activity. The medical evidence before the Tribunal shows Mr Soliman was diagnosed by Dr Guirgis in 2009 and 2012 with chronic post-traumatic mechanical derangement of the lumbar and cervical spine. In 2019, Dr Rajeepan diagnosed Mr Soliman with chronic pain syndrome secondary to musculoskeletal degenerative disease, noting he had antalgic gait, scoliosis of his spine and pes planus. Dr Rajeepan also observed Mr Soliman’s movement in his neck, shoulder, lumbar spine and hips was limited due to pain.