Soeson (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

Soeson (Migration) [2024] AATA 3037 (24 July 2024)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Mr Mart Soeson

CASE NUMBER:  1900025

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE:               BCC2016/933408

MEMBER:David Barker

DATE:24 July 2024

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa.

Statement made on 24 July 2024 at 9:36am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa – Subclass 801 (Spouse) – sponsor is deceased – cognitive, hearing and visual impairments – sponsor was the widow of the applicant’s maternal grandfather – sponsor was not the biological mother of the applicant’s mother – not satisfied the claim that the parties commenced a de facto relationship on 1 January 2013 is made out – no joint ownership of real estate or other major assets– financial aspect of the parties’ relationship – parties cohabited at the Bankstown residence until the sponsor entered residential aged care – lack of insight into the sponsor’s mental health conditions – at the time of the sponsor’s death the parties were living separately and apart on a permanent basis – not satisfied that the applicant would have continued to be the de facto partner of the sponsoring partner if the sponsoring partner had not died –  not satisfied that the applicant and the sponsoring partner were in a genuine and continuing relationship – decision under review affirmed   

LEGISLATION 
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 25, 35
Migration Act 1958, ss 5, 65, 361, 365
Migration Regulations 1994, rr 1.09, 2.03, Schedule 2,
cl 801.221

CASES
He v MIBP [2017] FCAFC 206
Re MILGEA and Dhillon [1990] FCA 144

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 20 December 2018 to refuse to grant the applicant a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The applicant applied for the visa on 7 March 2016 on the basis of his relationship with his sponsor. At that time, Class BS contained only one subclass: Subclass 801 (Partner). The criteria for the grant of this visa are set out in Part 801 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. Other members of the family unit, if any, who are applicants for the visa need satisfy only the secondary criteria.

  3. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy cl 801.221 because they were not satisfied on the evidence presented that the applicant and the sponsoring partner (the parties) were in a genuine and continuing relationship.

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 31 January 2024. Also present at the hearing were Ms Elfriede Riit (the sponsor), Ms Merike Kuusk, Ms Tatsiana Rubleuskaya and Mr Moreno Gialdini. The hearing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soeson (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3037
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by an applicant, a national of Estonia, against a decision of the Tribunal affirming the refusal of his Subclass 801 (Spouse) Partner (Residence) visa. The applicant claimed to have commenced a de facto relationship with the sponsor on 1 January 2013. The sponsor, who was 92 years old at the time the relationship allegedly commenced and 104 years old at the time of her death on 13 April 2024, was the widow of the applicant's maternal grandfather. The applicant had previously been granted a Subclass 820 (Provisional) partner visa on 24 July 2017.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant met the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 801 visa, particularly in light of the sponsor's death. This required determining if an exception to the sponsorship requirement applied under clause 801.221(5) of the Regulations. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the applicant was the holder of a Subclass 820 visa, would have met the requirements of subclause (2) or (2A) but for the sponsor's death, and satisfied the Minister that the parties would have continued to be in a de facto relationship had the sponsor not died.

The Tribunal found that the applicant had not established that he and the sponsor were in a genuine and continuing de facto relationship. While the parties had cohabited at a Bankstown residence until the sponsor entered aged care, and the applicant held enduring powers of attorney and guardianship for the sponsor, the Tribunal was not satisfied that a de facto relationship commenced on 1 January 2013. Factors contributing to this finding included the significant age difference between the parties at the commencement of the claimed relationship, the lack of evidence of joint ownership of real estate or other major assets, and the fact that at the time of the sponsor's death, the parties were living separately and apart on a permanent basis. Furthermore, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant would have continued to be the de facto partner of the sponsor if she had not died, given her cognitive, hearing, and visual impairments and her inability to communicate effectively with the Tribunal.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, concluding that the applicant had not met the requirements for the grant of the Subclass 801 visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal considered the submissions and comments made by the applicant and witnesses with respect to the hearing on 17 May 2024, but was not satisfied that it was established that there was a public interest reason as to why the hearing on that occasion be held in private. As a consequence the provisions of s 365(2) of the Act were not met and the hearing was held in accordance with the usual procedure in relation to Part 5 (migration) reviews.BACKGROUND The applicant is a national of Estonia and is 48 years old. He reports no previous interpersonal relationship prior to the claimed relationship with the sponsor. The sponsor is deceased, having died on 13 April 2024 at the age of 104 years. Infection and Alzheimer’s disease are recorded as the cause of her death.[6][6] NSW Births, Deaths and Marriages death certificate, issued 23 April 2024. The sponsor was born in Estonia and is reported to have come to Australia after the Second World War, arriving in 1948. She became an Australian citizen by grant in March 2016. The sponsor was married to the maternal grandfather of the applicant, from 1948 until the applicant’s grandfather died in 1987. The sponsor is reported to have met the applicant’s grandfather in Germany and they travelled to Italy together on a refugee boat and then to Australia where they married. There were no children from their marriage.[7][7] Psychologist assessment report prepared by Flora Truong, clinical and forensic psychologist, Healthy Minds Psychology, 13 January 2021 (pages 576–592 of the applicant’s submissions received 15 February 2024). The applicant and sponsor (hereafter referred to as the parties) claim to have met for the first time in person in 1996 when the applicant made his first visit to Australia. The visa application states that the parties commenced a de facto relationship with each other on 1 January 2013. The applicant was at that time 37 years of age and the sponsor was 92 years of age. The applicant was subsequently granted a Subclass 820 (Provisional) partner visa on 24 July 2017. Evidence provided to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (since that time incorporated into the Department of Home Affairs and in these reasons for decision referred to as the Department) in association with the visa application includes, but is not limited to:·Commonwealth Bank (CBA) electronic fund transfer receipts, 2017–2018;·Utility and telephone account invoices and related correspondence, 2016–2018;·Receipts, sales orders and other financial documentation, 2017–2018; ·Enduring Power of Attorney (EPOA) appointing applicant as attorney, dated 13 February 2017;·Appointment of Enduring Guardian appointing applicant as guardian of sponsor, dated 1 March 2017;·Support letters and Form 888 witness support declarations, 2016–2018; ·Correspondence addressed to applicant and/or sponsor at a residential property in Calidore St, Bankstown (the Bankstown address), 2016–2018;·Transcript of Academic Record for Certificate III in Spoken and Written English from TAFE NSW addressed to the applicant;·Photographs;·Statutory Declaration of the sponsor dated 14 March 2018;·Statement of sponsor dated 6 March 2016;·Skype call records September – December 2017.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In these overall circumstances the Tribunal took the decision to adjourn the hearing part heard and for it to be relisted forthwith, without the requirement the sponsor appear as a witness. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEWhat is the impact of the death of the applicant’s sponsor? The criteria for the grant of the Subclass 801 visa are set out in Part 801 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. They include the criterion in cl 801.221 which requires that at the time of decision the applicant meets the requirements of cl 801.221(2), (2A), (3), (4), (5), (6) or (8). These provisions include the requirement that the applicant is sponsored by a person with whom they are in a spousal or de facto relationship. Exceptions to the sponsorship requirement apply in certain circumstances where the sponsor has died, or family violence has occurred, or a child is involved. In the unfortunate circumstances of this case the sponsor is deceased. As a consequence it is necessary for the Tribunal to determine whether one of the exceptions exist to the legislative requirement that in order to qualify for a Subclass 801 Residential Partner visa, an applicant needs to at the time of decision be sponsored by a person with whom they are in a spouse or de facto relationship. Relevant to the current matter, cl 801.221(5) provides that: (5)An applicant meets the requirements of this subclause if the applicant: (a)is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa; and (b)would meet the requirements of subclause (2) or (2A) except that the sponsoring partner has died; and (c)satisfies the Minister that the applicant would have continued to be the spouse or de facto partner of the sponsoring partner if the sponsoring partner had not died. Clause 801.221(5)(d), which had provided that an applicant meets the requirements of this subclause if the applicant has developed close business, cultural or personal ties in Australia, was repealed through the action of the Migration Amendment (Family Violence Provisions for Partner Visa Applications) Regulations 2024, which have the effect of, from 1 July 2024, removing the requirement for Subclass 820 and 801 visa applicants to have developed close business, cultural or personal ties to Australia in order to meet the death exception. In making its findings, the Tribunal has considered the documents contained in the Department and Tribunal files and oral evidence provided by the applicant and witnesses at hearing. As discussed elsewhere in this decision record, the Tribunal does not have the benefit of oral evidence from the sponsor. This is because on the occasion she was brought to a hearing before the Tribunal on 31 January 2024 the Tribunal formed the view that due to the cumulative impact of impairments affecting the sponsor, she did not have the capacity to communicate in an effective and meaningful way with the Tribunal. The sponsor was unable to respond to questions put to her, or to make what comments she may have considered relevant to the circumstances of her relationship with the applicant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.The Tribunal’s decision to not hold the hearings in private The Tribunal’s powers in relation to reviewing decisions are derived from specific enactment provisions in relevant Commonwealth legislation, in conjunction with s 25(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act). Section 35 of the AAT Act relates to the form of the hearing that the Tribunal is to undertake. Section 35 provides that the hearing of a proceeding before the Tribunal must be in public, albeit that the Tribunal has the discretion to, amongst other things, direct that a hearing or part of a hearing is to take place in private;[1] and give directions in relation to the persons who may be present.[2] Section 35(5) states that in considering whether to give such a direction the Tribunal is to take as the basis of its consideration the principle that it is desirable:(a) that hearings of proceedings before the Tribunal should be held in public; and(b) that evidence given before the Tribunal and the contents of documents received in evidence by the Tribunal should be made available to the public and to all the parties; and(c) that the contents of documents lodged with the Tribunal should be made available to all the parties.However (and without being required to seek the views of the parties), the Tribunal is to pay due regard to any reasons in favour of giving such a direction.[1] s 35(2)(a) of the AAT Act.[2] s 35(2)(b) of the AAT Act. The position in relation to observers at hearings in the Migration and Refugee Division of the Tribunal differs between Part 5 (migration) reviews and Part 7 (protection) reviews. Hearings in relation to Part 7-reviewable decisions must be in private[3] whereas hearings in relation to Part 5-reviewable decisions are required to be in public, subject to two exceptions, which are: where the Tribunal is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so, it may direct that particular oral evidence, or oral evidence for the purposes of a particular review, be taken in private;[4] or, where the Tribunal is satisfied that it is impracticable to take particular oral evidence in public.[5][3] s 429 of the Act.[4] s 365(2) of the Act.[5] s 365(3) of the Act. Noting the presence of members of the public, who the Tribunal understood to be journalists, were wishing to observe the proceedings on 31 January 2024, 22 February 2024 and 17 May 2024, the Tribunal took oral submissions from the applicant on each occasion as to whether he would suggest the hearings should be not open to the public. On the occasion of the initial hearing on 31 January 2024, the applicant told the Tribunal that he had no concern in relation to a member of the press observing the proceedings before the Tribunal. However, on 22 February 2024, in response to the Tribunal clarifying if this remained the applicant’s position he asked that the hearing proceed in private and that the media be excluded from the proceedings. When asked why, the applicant did not indicate he had a personal objection to the hearing proceeding in public but contended that the sponsor had informed him that this was what she wanted as the issue is a personal one for her and she was not comfortable with details of the parties’ personal circumstances being published in the media. The applicant contended that details of the relationship had already been published in the media and this drew too much attention from the media and the sponsor did not like that. The applicant contended that the sponsor does not want to be a celebrity. The applicant contended that the sponsor told him that it was too much for her to deal with and that people had come to where she is living seeking interviews.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.