Soden v The Commissioner of Main Roads

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[1990] QLC 6

 
  LAND COURT,

BRISBANE.

28th February, 1990.

Re:  Claim for Compensation  (A88-88)

Phillip Clifford Soden and Marlene Edeline Soden
  - v -
  The Commissioner of Main Roads

-  JUDGMENT  -

(Hearing at Bowen)

At the date of resumption Mr. and Mrs. Soden were the owners of an aggregation known as Longford Creek which included Portion 2, Parish of Ben Lomond containing about 38 hectares and Portion 400, Parish of Ben Lomond containing an area of about 24 hectares.  In the overall aggregation some 60 hectares had been used for cultivation.  On Portions 2 and 400 about 20 hectares had been developed to cultivation all of which had been irrigated at various times and the balance land had been used for grazing.  The land is situated about 27 kms south-east of Bowen.  It is severed by the Bruce Highway  which resulted in a small triangular parcel of land in the south-western area being severed from the major parcel.
              On 28th April, 1984 the Commissioner of Main Roads took for road purposes an area of about 1,472 sq. metres being part of Portion 400, Parish of Ben Lomond contained in Certificate of Title Volume N912, Folio 5 and an area of about 3,634 sq. metres being part of Portion 2, Parish of Ben Lomond, contained in Certificate of Title, Volume N1182, Folio 187.  This is the date at which compensation is to be determined.
              A claim for compensation has been lodged in the Land Court and the amount finally contended for is the sum of $83,700 made up as follows:-

.                   Value of Land  $ 1,300.00
               .    Injurious Affection  $76,600.00

.    Disturbance:

Legal Fees  $  800.00
  Valuation Fees  $1,000.00
  Parking of Road Camp
  about 1 ha, noise, dust,
  use of the land, 40 wks
  at $100 per week  $4,000.00        $ 5,800.00

.     Total  $83,700.00

The parties have agreed on the sum of $1,300 for loss of land and the sum of $800 for legal fees and $1,000 for valuation fees incurred up to the date of lodgment of the claim in the Court.  The only matters in dispute are the claims for injurious affection and the disturbance item for parking of the road camp.
              Proceeding northerly on the Bruce Highway from Proserpine to Bowen one enters the subject land by a bridge over Eden Lassie Creek.  On the northern side of the highway and near the creek there is the claimants' residence and in close proximity a large shed to store equipment and for use as a packing shed for farm produce.  Adjoining this shed was a roadside stall.  The resumption has taken a thin strip of land along the opposite side of the road.  This varies in width up to 15 metres by 400 metres in length in the first area resumed and 105 metres in length in the second parcel resumed.
              Evidence was given by the claimant Mr. Phillip C. Soden of being advised by the respondent late in 1983 that it was intended to resume…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soden v The Commissioner of Main Roads and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] QLC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Soden v The Commissioner of Main Roads involves a claim for compensation by Phillip Clifford Soden and Marlene Edeline Soden for land resumed for road purposes by the Commissioner of Main Roads. The legal issues at hand pertain to the assessment of compensation for injurious affection and disturbance caused by the resumption. The claimants argued that the roadworks resulted in the closure of their roadside fruit stall, and they sought compensation for the loss of their business. Additionally, they claimed compensation for the use of their land by a road camp during the construction of the new highway. The Commissioner contended that no part of the new road intruded upon the resumed land, and thus, compensation for injurious affection was not warranted. The Commissioner further argued that the claimants' claim for disturbance due to the road camp was not a natural and reasonable consequence of the resumption.

The court examined the legal principles governing compensation for injurious affection and disturbance under the Acquisition of Land Act. The court found that the claim for injurious affection was not compensable as the damage to the claimants' retained land did not arise from activities on the resumed land, but rather from the use of the reserve land. The court also dismissed the claim for disturbance, as the establishment of the road camp was a matter between the claimants and the contractor, and not a consequence of the resumption itself. The court determined that the only compensable items were the loss of land and associated legal and valuation fees. The court awarded interest on the compensation for loss of land from the date of resumption up to the date of payment, and on the legal and valuation fees from an arbitrary date of 1 June 1987. The total compensation awarded was $3,100, with interest at the rate of 13.25% per annum.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established