SNS DIWAKAR PTY LTD and Tax Practitioners Board (Practice and Procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SNS DIWAKAR PTY LTD and Tax Practitioners Board (Practice and Procedure) [2024] ARTA 82 (27 December 2024)

Applicant/s:  SNS Diwakar Pty Ltd

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2024/5961

Applicant:Shonek Raj Diwakar

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2024/6649

Applicant:Tax on the Beach Pty Ltd

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2024/6972

Tribunal:General Member R Smith  

Place:Adelaide

Date:27 December 2024

Decision:The application for a stay of the decision is refused. The interim stay order is discharged.

...........................[SGD].............................................

General Member R Smith

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to stay decision under review – termination of tax agent registration - whether stay necessary to secure the effectiveness of the hearing – whether the discretion to grant stay enlivened - stay refused – interim stay order discharged

Legislation

Administrative Review Act 2020 (Cth)

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

Cases

Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 890

Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 11 July 2024, a decision was made by the Tax Practitioners Board (the Respondent) to terminate the tax agent registrations of Shonek Diwakar (Mr Diwakar),[1] SNS Diwakar Pty Ltd (SNS)[2] and Tax on the Beach Pty Ltd (TOTB)[3] (collectively the Applicants), and to impose a two year period during which the Applicants may not apply for registration.

    [1] R1, T12, p 416.

    [2] R1, T6, p 381.

    [3] R1, T18, p 466.

  2. The Applicants have applied for a stay of the decision of the Respondent until final determination of the review.

  3. On 27 September 2024, the Tribunal ordered by consent that the decisions under review be stayed on an interim basis until the Tribunal hears and determines the stay application or until further ordered, subject to the condition that the Applicants do not accept any more clients.

  4. The Respondent opposes the stay application.

    BACKGROUND

    Mr Diwakar

  5. Mr Diwakar was registered as a tax agent with the Respondent on 5 July 2017.[4] His registration ceased on 14 August 2023 after he failed to renew his registration.[5] Mr Diwakar received a new registration on 20 September 2023.[6]

    [4] R1, T4, p 19.

    [5] R1, T4, p 19.

    [6] R1, T4, p 41.

  6. In lodging his application for registration on 12 September 2023, Mr Diwakar answered ‘no’ in response to the question ‘Do you or any associated entities that you have direct, or indirect control over, have overdue tax obligations?’[7]

    [7] R1, T4, p 298.

  7. On 24 September 2020, Mr Diwakar lodged his income tax return for the income year ending 30 June 2020. In that return he reported $40,441 of assessable income.

  8. Following an audit, the Commissioner of Taxation (the Commissioner) amended Mr Diwakar’s income tax return for the year of income ending 30 June 2020 to include a superannuation benefit of $2,505.00 he received from the SNS Family Superfund (the Fund).[8]

    [8] R1, T4, p…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SNS DIWAKAR PTY LTD and Tax Practitioners Board (Practice an... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 82
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

SNS Diwakar Pty Ltd and another party, represented by Mr Diwakar, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a stay of the decisions of the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) terminating their tax agent registrations. The TPB had found that Mr Diwakar had failed to meet the registration requirements by providing false information and failing to comply with tax laws, and that the companies also failed to meet registration requirements due to their directors' conduct. The AAT was required to determine whether the discretion to grant a stay was enlivened and if a stay was necessary to secure the effectiveness of the hearing. The Applicants argued that the decisions were based on incorrect assumptions and that they intended to take remedial action, but these arguments did not challenge the factual findings underpinning the TPB's decisions.

The AAT considered the merits of the application and noted that an obviously strong case would weigh in favour of a stay, while an obviously weak case would weigh against it. However, the AAT concluded that the Applicants had not demonstrated that their case was arguable in a manner that would likely lead to a more favourable outcome in the review proceedings. The AAT found that the Applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to challenge the TPB's findings and that the decisions remained in force. Consequently, the AAT refused the application for a stay and discharged the interim stay order.

The AAT's decision highlights the importance of demonstrating an arguable case to secure a stay of administrative decisions. In this case, the Applicants failed to challenge the factual findings that underpinned the TPB's decisions, and their arguments regarding their intentions moving forward did not sufficiently rebut the TPB's conclusions. The AAT's refusal to grant a stay and its discharge of the interim stay order emphasise the need for Applicants to present a compelling case that addresses the underlying factual findings and demonstrates a likelihood of success in the review proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent opposes the stay application.BACKGROUNDMr Diwakar Mr Diwakar was registered as a tax agent with the Respondent on 5 July 2017.[4] His registration ceased on 14 August 2023 after he failed to renew his registration.[5] Mr Diwakar received a new registration on 20 September 2023.[6] [4] R1, T4, p 19.[5] R1, T4, p 19.[6] R1, T4, p 41. In lodging his application for registration on 12 September 2023, Mr Diwakar answered ‘no’ in response to the question ‘Do you or any associated entities that you have direct, or indirect control over, have overdue tax obligations?’[7][7] R1, T4, p 298. On 24 September 2020, Mr Diwakar lodged his income tax return for the income year ending 30 June 2020. In that return he reported $40,441 of assessable income. Following an audit, the Commissioner of Taxation (the Commissioner) amended Mr Diwakar’s income tax return for the year of income ending 30 June 2020 to include a superannuation benefit of $2,505.00 he received from the SNS Family Superfund (the Fund).[8][8] R1, T4, p 151. The Commissioner also determined that Mr Diwakar, in omitting the income received from the Fund, made a ‘false or misleading statement in a material particular’ giving rise to an administrative penalty. The Commissioner determined the behaviour of Mr Diwakar at the time of making the false or misleading statement to be reckless and imposed a penalty at 50% of the shortfall amount.[9] An important factor in assessing the behaviour at this level was Mr Diwakar’s position as a registered tax agent.[10][9] R1, T4, p 152.[10] R1, T4, p 152. As at 10 May 2024, Mr Diwakar had an outstanding tax debt of $698.44.[11][11] R1, T4, p 156.The Fund The Fund was registered with the Australian Business register on 17 May 2019. Mr Diwakar and Saieshwari Diwakar were trustees of the Fund until 3 November 2023.[12][12] R1, T4, p 60. Following an audit, the Commissioner disqualified Mr Diwakar from being a trustee of a self-managed superfund under subsection 126A(1) of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (SISA).[13][13] R1, T4, p 136. The Commissioner concluded that Mr Diwakar did not have the capacity to be a trustee or a responsible officer of a superannuation fund in circumstances where:[14][14] R1, T4, p 143.(i)he had accessed superannuation benefits during the income year ending 30 June 2020 without meeting the conditions of release;(ii)the Fund’s annual returns for the income years ending 2019 to 2022 had not been lodged; and (iii)the Fund had not been maintained in a manner that complied with the sole purpose test. Several contraventions of the SISA occurred while Mr Diwakar was a responsible officer of the Fund.[15][15] R1, T4, pp 143-4. The Commissioner also imposed an administrative penalty under subsection 34 of the SISA amounting to $67,200.[16][16] R1, T4, p 144. There is no record of Mr Diwakar advising the Respondent of his disqualification as trustee under the SISA. SNS SNS was registered with the Australian and Securities Investments Commission (ASIC) on 7 May 2015.[17] The directors of the company are Mr Diwakar and Saieshwari Diwakar. SNS has been a registered tax agent since 28 September 2023 and Mr Diwakar is the sole supervising agent.[18][17] R1, T4, p 44.[18] R1, T4, pp 47-8.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 14 January 2022, in lodging an application for new registration with the Respondent, in response to the question ‘Does the company or any company director have any overdue tax obligations? This includes any associated entities that the company, or the director, has direct, or indirect control over’, Supriya responded with ‘no’.[36][36] R1, T4, p 313.The Decisions Under Review Following the completion of an investigation, the Respondent determined that it was satisfied: (a)Mr Diwakar had breached subsections 30–10(1), 30–10(2) and 30–10(14) of the Code of Professional Conduct in the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the Code) and had ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement that he is a fit and proper person as required under paragraph 20–5(1) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TASA). In broad compass this was as a consequence of:[37][37] R1, T6, pp 378-380(i)providing false or misleading information to the Commissioner in his personal income tax return for the year ending 30 June 2020 by understating his income resulting in a tax shortfall and a 50% penalty for recklessness being imposed;(ii)being disqualified as a trustee of a self-managed superfund as a result of accessing his superannuation benefits during the 2019 20 income year without meeting a condition of release, not maintaining the SMS fund in the manner which complies with the salt purpose test and not lodging the S&S funds income tax returns for the financial years ending 30 June 2019 to 30 June 2023 together with failing to disclose to the Respondent of his disqualification within the required time period. (iii)failing to comply with the taxation laws in the conduct of his personal affairs, in his capacity as director of SNS (both in its own right an as the corporate trustee for RAJ & Associates), in his capacity as trustee of the SNS fund, in his capacity as a director of Supriya and in his capacity as a director of TOTB.(iv)failing to respond to two Preliminary Inquiry Letters issued by the Respondent in February and March 2024.(b)SNS had breached subsections 30–10(2) and 30–10(14) of the Code and had ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement that each of its directors be a fit and proper person as required under paragraph 20–5(3) of the TASA. In broad compass this was as a consequence of:[38] (i)failing to comply with the taxation laws in the conduct of its personal tax affairs; and(ii)failing to respond to two Preliminary inquiry letters issued by the Respondent in February and March 2024.(c)TOTB had breached subsections 30–10(2), 30–10(13) and 30–10(14) of the Code and had ceased to meet the tax practitioners registration requirements that each of its directors be a fit and proper person as required under paragraph 20–5(3) of the TASA and that it did not maintain professional indemnity insurance as required. In broad compass this was a consequence of Mr Diwakar’s conduct and:[39](i)failing to maintain professional indemnity insurance; and(ii)failing to comply with the taxation laws in the conduct of its personal taxation affairs.[38] R1, T6, pp 376-8.[39] R1, T6, pp 378-9.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The onus of satisfying the Tribunal that a stay is desirable in the circumstances lies with the Applicant. CONSIDERATION OF FACTORS The Applicants’ Case Mr Diwakar provided to the Tribunal an email which sets out his position in relation to the application for a stay of the decision under review. His contentions in that email can be summarised as follows:(a)SNS’ SGC debt arose as a result of an employee failing to follow instructions and including in the payroll employees that did not work for the firm; and (b)that Mr Diwakar has been unable to access his own firm details and, as a consequence of this, the lodgements remain outstanding. He has sought assistance from the ATO and the Respondent, but this has not resolved the issue. At the hearing, I allowed Mr Diwakar to expand on his position. In his evidence he stated:(a)in relation to the late lodgement of BAS in 2015 up until 2018, SNS was not trading and he himself was not a registered tax agent. He ‘left it with’ the tax agent he was working for at the time to lodge nil assessments;(b)when he was re-registered in 2018, the lodgements were brought up to date;(c)in relation to the SGC debt of SNS, the figure submitted to the ATO via the single touch payroll system is not accurate and he intends to lodge an objection to the SGC assessments. Mr Diwakar did concede in his evidence that there is a liability but only not to the extent assessed by the Commissioner;(d)some remedial steps have not been taken out of a concern he may inadvertently breach the interim stay;(e)an auditor had been engaged to undertake an audit of the Fund and the withdrawals were to pay for those services. Mr Diwakar intends to object to the Commissioner’s disqualification decision; and(f)SNS has attempted make payments to the Commissioner in relation to the super obligations, but they have all been refunded. The evidence given by Mr Diwakar provided context to the past conduct and his intentions moving forward. However, it did not challenge the factual findings made by the Respondent which underpin the decisions under review. Even if I accept Mr Diwakar’s evidence that he intends to dispute the Commissioner’s decisions, which include serious conduct by the Applicant, he has not yet done so. I can only consider the state of the evidence at the time of the hearing. The Commissioner’s decisions remain in force and the SGC debt remains unpaid. Prospects of success In general terms, an obviously strong case will weigh in favour of a stay and an obviously weak case will weigh against. In assessing the merits for this purpose, the Tribunal should not undertake a ‘mini trial’ but rather a ‘rough and ready’ assessment such as to permit an informed view as to whether a more favourable outcome in the review proceedings is likely.[57] The Tribunal, based on the submissions made by the parties, needs to be satisfied that the Applicant’s case is arguable.[57] Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 890 at [13]