Smith v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd and Delohery

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
11 CLR 148

HENRY CHARLES SMITH

THE PERPETUAL TRUSTEE CO. LTD. AND

RESPONDENTS.

ALFRED HENRY DELOHERY SYDNEY, August 22, 23,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Will Forfeiture clause-Equitable assignment--Direction to trustees to pay future

income to creditor-Power of attorney given to creditor-Assignment for benefit

11 CLR 149

of creditors-Intention to assign-Consideration-Revocable mandate to agent- Issue of writ of foreign attachment--Garnishee order.

The appellant was entitled to an interest under the will of his grandfather. The will provided that if the appellant should assign or charge his benefit under the will, the benefit should lapse. The appellant was indebted amongst others to the defendant D., who was his solicitor. While SO indebted the appellant, who was about to leave the State, executed a power of attorney in favour of D., empowering him to demand, sue for, and recover all moneys payable or hereafter to become payable to the appellant by the trustees of the will, for the purpose of liquidating and paying all his debts. The power of attorney contained the usual clause that it should continue in force until notice of death or revocation. The appellant also gave D. a letter addressed to the trustees of the will (to whom it was subsequently delivered), informing them that he had instructed D. to pay his creditors out of his income as it fell due, and requesting them to pay to D. all future income or corpus in the estate to which the appellant might be entitled. The intention of the appel- lant and D. was that the relationship between them should be that of principal and agent.

Held, that the documents did not in form constitute an assignment, and that the evidence did not show that the appellant intended to make over his interest under the will to D., or that he had given to any of his creditors a right of payment out of or security over the fund, and that the appellant had

Oldham v. Oldham, L.R. 3 Eq., 404, distinguished. Held, also, that the service upon the trustees of a writ of foreign attach- ment by a creditor, in an action brought by him against the appellant, did

Decision of A. H. Simpson Ch. J. in Eq.: Perpetual Trustee Co. v. Smith, 10 S.R. (N.S. W.), 429, reversed, on the first point.

APPEAL from the decision of A. H. Simpson, Ch. J. in Eq.

The late Charles Smith by his will, dated 24th December 1896, appointed the respondent company his executors and trustees, and after certain specific devises and legacies gave the residue of his estate to his trustees upon trust to sell and convert, and after payment of debts and funeral and testamentary expenses to divide the proceeds of sale into four unequal parts, which he defined, and then directed his trustees to hold the first part on trust, "First to pay out of the income to my son John Robert Smith and his present wife the sum of £200 per annum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd and Delohery and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1910] HCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, H. C. Smith, was entitled to an interest under his grandfather's will, which contained a forfeiture clause stipulating that any assignment or charge of his benefit would cause it to lapse. Smith, indebted to various creditors including his solicitor, Mr. Delohery, executed a power of attorney in favour of Delohery authorising him to collect moneys from the estate for the purpose of paying Smith's debts. Concurrently, Smith wrote to the trustees of the will, the respondent Perpetual Trustee Co. Ltd., instructing them to pay all future income and corpus to Delohery, whose receipt would suffice. The intention of both Smith and Delohery was to establish a principal-agent relationship. The Supreme Court of New South Wales had held that these documents constituted a forfeiture of Smith's interest.

The High Court of Australia was required to determine whether the power of attorney and the letter to the trustees, individually or collectively, amounted to an assignment or charge of the appellant's interest under the will, thereby triggering the forfeiture clause. Additionally, the court considered whether a writ of foreign attachment subsequently issued against the appellant's property in the hands of the trustees also operated as a forfeiture.

The Court reasoned that for a forfeiture to occur, the documents must, in form or substance, constitute an assignment or charge. It held that the documents, when viewed in light of the parties' intentions, did not demonstrate an intention to assign or charge the appellant's interest. The primary intention was to create a revocable mandate for an agent to collect and distribute funds, rather than to divest the appellant of his proprietary rights. The fact that Delohery was a creditor did not, in itself, transform the agency into an irrevocable assignment, particularly as the appellant had taken care to avoid any action that would result in forfeiture. The Court also found that the writ of foreign attachment, being an interlocutory order, did not operate as a forfeiture.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, reversing the decision of the Supreme Court. It declared that the executed documents and the writ of foreign attachment did not, either separately or together, constitute an assignment or charge that divested the appellant of his interest under the will.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.