JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: SMITH -v- PATERSON [2023] WASC 215
CORAM: MASTER SANDERSON
HEARD: 24 JANUARY 2023
DELIVERED : 30 JUNE 2023
FILE NO/S: CIV 2024 of 2022
BETWEEN: DARRYL LAWRENCE SMITH
Plaintiff
AND
PETA PATERSON
First Defendant
WAYNE JAMES PATERSON
Second Defendant
Catchwords:
Pre-action discovery - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | AJ Power |
| First Defendant | : | EM Heenan |
| Second Defendant | : | EM Heenan |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Zafra Legal |
| First Defendant | : | Lane Buck & Higgins Narrogin |
| Second Defendant | : | Lane Buck & Higgins Narrogin |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Cock v Cooke (1866) LR 1 P&D 241
Kelbush Pty Ltd v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] WASCA 14
Re Anziani [1930] 1 Ch 407
MASTER SANDERSON:
This was the plaintiff's application for pre‑action discovery. It is one of those unusual cases where the defendant says even on the most cursory examination of the relevant facts, the plaintiff simply has no cause of action. The defendants' accept for the purposes of an application of this nature it is only necessary for the plaintiff to establish it 'may' have a cause of action. That is a low threshold - a lower threshold than would be applicable on a defendant's summary judgment application. Nonetheless that was the basis upon which the application was defended.
Given the narrow basis of the defendants' opposition to the application, it is unnecessary for me to recite the law or deal with the other factors to be considered when determining whether pre‑action discovery is appropriate. The defendants conceded the only issue between the parties was the strength of the plaintiff's case. For the sake of completeness, I need only mention the parties accepted the application was to be determined in line with the principles set out by Buss JA (as his Honour then was) in Kelbush Pty Ltd v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd.[1]
[1] Kelbush Pty Ltd v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] WASCA 14 [18] ‑ [19].
At the centre of the dispute between the parties is a document which is titled 'Deed of Declaration of Trust'. A copy of this document appears as attachment DLS‑1 to an affidavit of the plaintiff sworn 29 August 2022. I will set out the document in full.
DEED OF DECLARATION OF TRUST is made on 17th October 2004
I Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith, both of Care of Post Office Box 8, Pingelly, Western Australia.
Both Mr Stuart Bruce Smith and Mrs Thelma Dawn Smith have decided to give all our properties, land bonds, shares, live stock and farm machinery to Darryl Lawrence Smith. This to take effect when Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith are deceased.
We are giving permission for Darryl Lawrence Smith to take control of all our belongings and the above items listed when myself and my…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Paterson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] WASC 215
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Deed of Declaration of Trust was validly executed and whether there had been a breach of trust by the trustees, Peta Paterson and Wayne. The court had to determine the validity of the Deed, which was signed by the purported transferors, Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith, and the trustees, Darryl Lawrence Smith, Peta Paterson, and Wayne. Additionally, the court had to consider whether there was sufficient evidence of a breach of trust and whether the plaintiff had a legitimate claim for declaratory relief and compensation.
The court found that the Deed of Declaration of Trust was not validly executed as it lacked proper attestation. The signatures of Karen Annette Smith, who is not mentioned in the document, further complicate the validity of the Deed. The court determined that the Deed did not meet the necessary requirements for a valid trust deed, particularly as it was not properly witnessed. Consequently, the court held that the plaintiff's claims for declaratory relief and compensation were not supported by a valid trust arrangement.
The court ordered that the plaintiff's claims be dismissed. The plaintiff's claims for a declaration that the trust property is held for his benefit, for compensation and an account of profits for breach of trust, and for the vesting of the trust property were all rejected due to the invalidity of the Deed of Declaration of Trust.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
At the centre of the dispute between the parties is a document which is titled 'Deed of Declaration of Trust'. A copy of this document appears as attachment DLS‑1 to an affidavit of the plaintiff sworn 29 August 2022. I will set out the document in full.DEED OF DECLARATION OF TRUST is made on 17th October 2004I Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith, both of Care of Post Office Box 8, Pingelly, Western Australia.Both Mr Stuart Bruce Smith and Mrs Thelma Dawn Smith have decided to give all our properties, land bonds, shares, live stock and farm machinery to Darryl Lawrence Smith. This to take effect when Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith are deceased.We are giving permission for Darryl Lawrence Smith to take control of all our belongings and the above items listed when myself and my wife are deceased.From the above if there has been any changes Darryl Lawrence Smith will be notified with in Seven days in writing what has been altered, if this has not done the items listed in this document is not legal.If myself Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith become mentally ill unable to act of sound mind we both give Darryl Lawrence Smith permission to take over all the above. This is to take effect on the day dated above._________________________________________________________Dated this 17th day of October 192004_________________________________________________________ At the foot of the same page as the above appears, there is a heading 'TRANSFEROR/S SIGN HERE (NOTE 7)'. The document bears what appears to be the signatures of Stuart Bruce Smith and Thelma Dawn Smith. On the following page, there are signatures of the three parties to the Deed. The Deed is also signed by Karen Annette Smith who is not mentioned in the document. Nor does she feature in the plaintiff's affidavit. The fact that she has signed the document adds another layer of confusion to what is already a confusing document. The background facts as taken from the plaintiff's affidavit are as follows. The plaintiff is a retired farmer who lived in the Pingelly region until he was 21. His mother was Thelma Dawn Smith. Stuart Bruce Smith was his stepfather. The plaintiff has two sisters, Noelene Dowsett and Peta Paterson. It is Ms Paterson who has witnessed the signatures on the document. The plaintiff says during their lifetimes, his mother and stepfather acquired a large amount of farming land as well as livestock, personal property and personal wealth. He says they had a significant share portfolio, including shares in the Commonwealth Bank and Wesfarmers. The parties entered into the Deed on 17 October 2004. The Deed was prepared by Mr Stuart Smith. Why the parties entered into the Deed is not explained in the affidavit of the plaintiff and is probably irrelevant in any event. The way the plaintiff frames his case is set out in par 24 of his affidavit. That paragraph reads as follows:Based on the foregoing, I honestly believe I may have a legal cause of action against Peta and Wayne on the basis that:a.there is credible evidence that the trust property secured by the Deed on 17 October 2004 has been dissipated to other parties, in breach of trust;b.I am entitled to declaratory relief that the trust property currently held by Stuart's deceased estate, Wayne, Peta, or any other third party, is in fact held on trust for my benefit;c.I am further entitled to consequential orders for the vesting of that trust property to myself;d.I am entitled to claim for compensation and / or an account of profits for the breach of trust.