Smith v Motor Discounts Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
54 CLR 107

[ ] SMITH

MOTOR DISCOUNTS LIMITED

RESPONDENT. PLAINTIFF,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Moratorium-Advance of money-Agreement to repay-Guarantee-Mortgage-

Personal covenant in mortgage-Avoidance by statute-Repeal of statute-Revival of liability-Action upon the guarantee-Plea-Allegations-Moratorium Act 1930-1931 (N.S.W.) (No. 48 of 1930-No. 43 of 1931), sec. 25 (7) -Moratorium and Interest Reduction (Amendment) Act 1931 (N.S.W.) (No. 66 of 1931), sec. 4 -Moratorium Act 1932 (N.S.W.) (No. 57 of 1932), secs. 3, 8, 9, 34, 35- Interpretation Act of 1897 (N.S.W.) (No. 4 of 1897), sec. 8.

The respondent brought an action against the appellant to recover the sum of £2,100. The action was based on an indenture dated 10th July, 1931, made between the appellant and the respondent, in which the appellant, therein called "surety," covenanted that, in consideration of the sum of £2,100, paid by the respondent, therein called "mortgagee," to the T.B. Settlement at his request, he would repay that sum to the respondent. The appellant pleaded that the respondent agreed to lend the appellant and two other persons the sum of £2,100, to be secured by a mortgage of real property containing a personal covenant on the part of the appellant alone and the covenant set forth in the indenture that the mortgage dated 7th July 1931, set forth in full in the plea, and the indenture set forth in the declaration were executed, pursuant to this agreement, and not otherwise; and that there was no legal person or entity known as the T.B. Settlement. The sum of £2,100 referred to in the two documents was the same sum. Both documents provided for the exclusion of the provisions of the Moratorium Act 1930 (N.S.W.), and any

54 CLR 108

amendments thereof, and of any future similar legislation. The respondent demurred to the plea.

(1) That the personal obligation of a mortgagor arising under instruments collateral to a mortgage of real property is not revived by the Moratorium Act 1932 (N.S.W.), notwithstanding the repeal by that Act of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931, as amended by the Moratorium and Interest Reduction (Amend. ment) Act 1931, by which such personal obligations were avoided.

(2) That the covenant in the indenture dated 10th July 1931 was a covenant "by a mortgagor" within the meaning of that expression in sec. 25 (7) of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931, as amended.

(3) That the plea sufficiently alleged that the covenant sued upon was not by way of guarantee and was therefore not within the qualification of sec. 25 (7) of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931 introduced by sec. 35 (1) of the

Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Full Court): Motor Discounts Ltd. v. Smith, (1935) 35 S.R. (N.S.W.) 354: 52 W.N. (N.S.W.) 96,

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

In an action brought by Motor Discounts Ltd. in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, that company sought to recover from the defendant, Sir James Joynton Smith, the sum of £2.257…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Motor Discounts Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1935] HCA 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The respondent, Motor Discounts Limited, commenced an action against the appellant, Smith, to recover £2,100 based on an indenture dated 10th July 1931. In this indenture, Smith covenanted to repay the £2,100 advanced by Motor Discounts Limited at his request to the T.B. Settlement. Smith pleaded that the loan was to be secured by a mortgage of real property, with a personal covenant solely from him, and that the mortgage and the indenture were executed pursuant to this agreement. He further alleged that no entity known as the T.B. Settlement existed. Both the mortgage and the indenture contained clauses expressly excluding the operation of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931 and any amendments or future similar legislation. The respondent demurred to this plea.

The legal issues before the court were whether the personal obligation of a mortgagor under instruments collateral to a mortgage of real property was revived by the Moratorium Act 1932, despite the repeal of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931 which had rendered such obligations void. The court also considered whether the covenant in the indenture constituted a covenant by a mortgagor within the meaning of section 25(7) of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931, and whether the plea sufficiently alleged that the covenant was not a guarantee, thereby falling outside the qualification introduced by section 35(1) of the Moratorium Act 1932.

The High Court held that the personal obligation of a mortgagor arising under instruments collateral to a mortgage of real property was not revived by the Moratorium Act 1932. The Court reasoned that while the Moratorium Act 1932 repealed the earlier Moratorium Act 1930-1931, the Interpretation Act 1897 preserved the invalidity of covenants previously avoided, unless a contrary intention appeared in the 1932 Act. The Court found no such contrary intention in the provisions of the 1932 Act that would revive these collateral covenants. The Court further determined that the plea sufficiently alleged that the covenant sued upon was not a guarantee, and therefore fell within the scope of section 25(7) of the Moratorium Act 1930-1931, which invalidated such personal obligations.

Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the judgment of the Supreme Court was discharged, and the demurrer was overruled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established