DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Smith v Medical Board of Queensland [2007] QDC 297
PARTIES:
BRUCE RODERICK SMITH
Appellant
and
MEDICAL BOARD OF QUEENSLAND
Respondent
FILE NO/S:
1684/07
DIVISION:
Civil
ORIGINATING COURT:
Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
16 November 2007
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
JUDGE:
Griffin SC DCJ
The Medical Board of Queensland (“the Board”) is the respondent to these proceedings, which is an Appeal by Mr Smith against the decision of the Medical Board of Queensland not to register him as a medical practitioner. The Board has applied before me for Orders which include findings that the respondent to this Application, Smith, is of impaired capacity and consequential Orders that the proceedings should be then undertaken by a legal guardian appointed in consequence of the finding I am asked to make.
The respondent Smith resists the Application.
A “person with impaired capacity” is defined, by reason of Sch 4 of the Uniform Civil Procedural Rules (UCPR), and Sch 2 of the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991, as a “person who is not capable of making the decisions required of a litigant for conducting proceedings”. A person with impaired capacity is a “person under a legal incapacity” by reason of Sch 2 of the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991.
The effect of a finding of legal incapacity is that a person under a legal incapacity may start or defend proceedings only by way of the person’s legal guardian. Further, anything in a proceeding required or permitted by the Rules to be done by a party may, if the party is a person under a legal incapacity, be done only by the party’s legal guardian.
These proceedings have of course already been commenced as an Appeal before the District Court against the decision of Medical Board of Queensland. Although Rule 91(1) of the UCPR permits a person under a legal incapacity to “start or defend” proceedings only by a litigation guardian, the Rule does not expressly deal with a case where proceedings are already on foot, or in circumstances where legal incapacity may be argued to have supervened after the proceeding had been commenced. Nonetheless, the power to appoint a litigation guardian in those circumstances is one which I consider is available to this Court.[1]
[1] See Thompson v Smith [2005] QCA 466 per McPherson J at para 6.
The evidence in these proceedings called by the applicant is based upon medical opinions expressed by two experts in psychiatry Dr Jill Reddan and Dr Nigel Prior. Dr Reddan had seen the respondent on a number of occasions since 2002, and ultimately prepared a short report focusing upon the issue of capacity on 18 October 2007 which was tendered in these proceedings. Dr Prior has had one opportunity to see and examine the respondent on 8 August 2007, consequent upon an Order made for such examination.
Dr Reddan’s reports of 26 July 2002, and 10 December 2006 come to the conclusion that the respondent suffers from a paranoid schizophrenic illness, with a differential…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v. Medical Board of Queensland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] QDC 297
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether Smith is of impaired capacity, meaning he is not capable of making the decisions required of a litigant for conducting proceedings. This issue is important as it determines whether Smith can continue with the appeal proceedings on his own or if a legal guardian needs to be appointed to represent him.
The court considered the evidence of medical experts, Dr. Jill Reddan and Dr. Nigel Prior, who diagnosed Smith with a paranoid schizophrenic illness, delusional disorder, or severe personality disorder with obsessional narcissistic and paranoid traits. The court also observed Smith's conduct during the proceedings, which demonstrated a failure to focus on the relevant issues and an almost total focus on what he perceived as a conspiracy against him by healthcare practitioners.
The court found that Smith is not capable of making the decisions required of a litigant for conducting proceedings due to his impaired capacity. The court placed the most weight on the opinion of Dr. Prior, which was based on the most recent assessment of Smith in August 2007 and considered to be the most comprehensive.
The court made the following orders: (1) No further step may be taken in the appeal until a person files written consent in the Registry to be Smith's litigation guardian pursuant to r 95(1) of the UCPR. The court will hear submissions as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi