Smith v Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
11 CLR 667

ALFRED GEORGE SMITH

THE COMMERCIAL BANKING CO.

RESPONDENTS.

OF SYDNEY LTD. DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Banker and customer-Bill payable to order on demand-Forged indorsement- H. C.

Payment in good faith and in the ordinary course of business-Negligence of banker-Liability of banker-Bills of Exchange Act 1887 ( V.S. W.), (51 Vict., No. 2), sec. 60-Bills of Exchange Act 1909, (No. 27 of 1909), sec. 65. Bill of Exchange-Acceptance of bill-Signature of officer of bank-Acceptance on Dec. 6, 7, 15.

behalf of company-Evidence of promise to pay-Communication to payee- Bills of Exchange Act 1887 (N.S.W.) (51 Vict., No. 2), sec. 17 - Bills of Exchange Act 1909 (No. 27 of 1909), secs. 17, 22-Companies Act 1899 (N.S.W.), (No. 40), sec. 244.

The appellant, who was about to proceed from England to Sydney, obtained a draft for £30 issued in two parts, and payable to his order. He retained the first of exchange in his possession, and posted the second of exchange to his own address at the G.P.O., Sydney. On arrival at Sydney he found that the second of exchange had been delivered by the Post Office to some other person, to whom, on presenting the first of exchange at the bank, he was informed that the £30 had already been paid by the bank. The appellant sued the bank as acceptors of the draft. The bank denied acceptance, and claimed the benefit of sec. 60 of the Bills of Exchange Act 1887, by which a banker is protected where he pays in good faith and in the ordinary course of business, on a forged indorsement, in the case of a bill drawn on the banker and payable to order on demand.

It appeared at the trial that the thief had presented the draft at the bank, representing himself to be the payee, and that in order to prove his identity

11 CLR 668

he was asked to write his signature for the purpose of comparison with a specimen signature of the payee sent to the bank by the drawers. The thief accordingly wrote his name twice on the back of the draft, and an officer of the bank then wrote his name " John Bull" on the draft as authority for its payment, and it was paid accordingly. The draft when produced in Court bore on its face the name of the bank, impressed with a circular rubber stamp, over the signature of the.drawers, with the word "paid" within the circle.

Held, that sec. 60 protects a banker only when a bill has been negotiated by indorsement before it comes to him for payment, and that the signature of the thief on the back of the draft did not relieve the bank from its liability to the appellant.

Per O'Connor J. and Isaacs J.-Negligence, per se, does not disentitle the bank to the protection of sec. 60.

But, held, also, that neither the signature of the bank's officer on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1910] HCA 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Mr. Smith, sued the Commercial Banking Company of Sydney Ltd. as the acceptor of a £30 draft. Smith had obtained the draft in England, payable to his order, and posted one part to himself in Sydney. Upon arrival, he discovered the draft had been misdelivered by the Post Office and that the bank had already paid the £30 based on the first part of the draft. The bank denied acceptance and sought protection under section 60 of the Bills of Exchange Act 1887 (NSW), which provides a defence for bankers paying bills in good faith and in the ordinary course of business despite a forged indorsement.

The court was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the actions of the bank constituted an acceptance of the bill, thereby making them liable to the appellant. Secondly, if an acceptance was found, whether the bank was nevertheless protected by section 60 of the Bills of Exchange Act 1887 (NSW) from liability due to the forged indorsement.

The court held that the signature of the bank's officer, "John Bull," and the bank's stamp on the draft did not amount to a valid acceptance under the Bills of Exchange Act 1887 (NSW). Acceptance requires the signification of assent to the drawer's order, which must be written on the bill and completed by delivery. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the bank's signature or stamp was on the bill at the time of delivery to the thief, which is a necessary element for acceptance. Furthermore, the court determined that section 60 of the Bills of Exchange Act 1887 (NSW) only protects a banker when a bill has been negotiated by indorsement before it is presented for payment. In this case, the thief's signature was obtained for identification purposes, not for negotiation, and therefore did not fall within the protection of the section.

The High Court affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had set aside the verdict for the plaintiff and entered a verdict for the defendants. However, the High Court reached this conclusion on different grounds, finding that no valid acceptance had occurred, and therefore the bank was not liable as an acceptor.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established