Smith v Chief Executive, Attorney-General's Department

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

SMITH v CHIEF EXECUTIVE, ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S DEPARTMENT

[2024] SASCA 107

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice Bleby and the Honourable Justice David)

29 August 2024

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION - PROCEEDINGS TO OBTAIN COMPENSATION - DETERMINATION OF CLAIMS - APPEALS, JUDICIAL REVIEW AND STATED CASES - QUESTION OF LAW

Application for leave to appeal against a decision of the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal.

The applicant was a police officer who had sought an application for payment of income compensation and medical expenses on the basis that she had suffered from an eligible injury under the Police Officers Award. The applicant’s case was that her injury occurred as a direct and immediate result of conduct that is, or appeared to be, a criminal offence. The South Australian Employment Court held at first instance that the applicant was entitled to compensation.

A majority of the Full Bench allowed the respondent’s appeal and set aside the orders. The applicant applied to this Court for leave to appeal, raising the following questions of law:

1.On the facts as found and undisputed, was the applicant’s psychiatric injury only capable of being characterised as having occurred as ‘a direct and immediate result’ of the murder within the meaning of cl S4.31.2 of the Police Officers Award? (Ground 1)

2.Whether it was open to construe the phrase ‘a direct and immediate result’ in cl S4.31.2 of the Police Officers Award as ‘indicating that the injured police officer must be sufficiently proximate to the conduct which causes the injury at the time the injury is sustained’? (Grounds 2a-c)

3.Whether the reasons given by the majority of the Full Bench for their decision were inadequate as a matter of law or demonstrate a failure to consider the case in accordance with the required legal principles? (Ground 2d)

Held (by the Court), granting leave to appeal on Grounds 1 and 2d, refusing leave to appeal on Grounds 2a-c and dismissing the appeal:

1.On the question raised by Ground 1, the reasoning of the majority was not precluded by the words of cl S4.31.2.

2.The question raised by Grounds 2a-c does not arise, as the Full Bench did not construe cl s4.31.2 in the manner submitted by the applicant.

3.On the question raised by Ground 2d, the Full Bench did not fail to give adequate reasons or fail to address the applicant’s case.

Police Officers Award cll S4.30, S4.31, S4.32; Return to Work Act 2014 (SA); SA Ambulance Service Award cl S6.35; South Australian Employment Tribunal Act 2014 (SA) s 67(4); Southern State Superannuation Regulations 2009 (SA) reg 38A(1), referred to.
Beale v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1997) 48 NSWLR 430; Chief Executive, Department of Premier and Cabinet, for Chief Executive, Department for Health and Wellbeing (SA Ambulance Service) v Kimber [2021] SAET 71; DL v The Queen (2018) 266 CLR 1; Housing Commission (NSW) v Tatmar Pastoral Co…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Chief Executive, Attorney-General's Department and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASCA 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal to the South Australian Employment Tribunal (SAET) Full Bench concerning a claim for workers' compensation by Ms. Smith, a Senior Constable employed by South Australia Police. Ms. Smith alleged she suffered an eligible injury arising from her involvement in investigating a motor vehicle accident where the victim, a young woman, was later murdered by her father. Ms. Smith sought income compensation and medical expenses.

The legal issues before the SAET Full Bench revolved around the interpretation and application of clause S4.31.2 of the relevant legislation, specifically whether Ms. Smith's psychological distress constituted an eligible injury. This involved determining the nature of the connection required between her employment and the injury, and whether the circumstances of her involvement in the victim's case met the statutory criteria for compensation.

The Full Bench granted leave to appeal on specific grounds related to the interpretation of the legislation but dismissed the appeal. The court indicated that the question of law raised by the alternative contention did not arise due to the dismissal of the appeal. Furthermore, the court expressed doubt that even if the respondent's contentions were accepted, they would resolve the question of law, suggesting that the assessment of whether the required physical and temporal connections were met would likely remain a question of fact and degree, aligning with previous judicial analysis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The questions of law arising concern the interpretation and application of cl S4.31.2.The undisputed facts and the decision at first instance The circumstances giving rise to the application for an order that Ms Smith suffered from an eligible injury, and for consequent orders for payment of income compensation and medical expenses in accordance with the terms of Schedule 4, are not contentious. They are set out in the reasons of the Auxiliary Deputy President Magistrate (AUDPM) who heard the application at first instance. The Full Bench adopted them. We reproduce the relevant passages here:[1][1] Smith v South Australia Police, Department of Treasury and Finance [2023] SAET 52 at [5]-[14],[17].Ms Smith has been employed by South Australia Police (SAPOL) since 2001. At the relevant times, she held the rank of Senior Constable and worked as a traffic officer in the Road Policing Section.On 21 July 2009, Ms Smith was tasked with investigating a motor vehicle accident where the driver was suspected of being under the influence of alcohol or drugs.Ms Smith attended the home of a young female, approximately 20 years of age, who was suspected of being the driver. As will be noted later, the female driver became the victim of a more serious offence (the victim). Ms Smith found the victim present with her parents and a brother. Ms Smith says she spoke with the victim’s parents and the victim before conveying the victim to the Queen Elizabeth Hospital for drug and alcohol testing.During the victim’s admission, Ms Smith remained at the hospital with her for approximately three to four hours. Once she was cleared for discharge, Ms Smith telephoned the victim’s home and spoke with her mother to arrange for her to be picked up. A short time later, the victim’s parents arrived. Ms Smith had a conversation with them with respect to the next steps in the investigation process, depending on the results of the blood analysis taken from the victim. Ms Smith then returned to her work base and booked the blood sample into evidence before completing her shift and going home.The following day, Ms Smith commenced work on a day shift. During the shift, she received a telephone call from a colleague, Scott Mitchell, in the Central Intelligence Branch. Mr Mitchell advised her that on returning home from the hospital, the victim had been brutally murdered by her father.Ms Smith deposed that she ‘lost it’, was unable to stop crying and was very upset.Mr Mitchell deposed that he had worked for SAPOL since 2001 and held the rank of Detective Brevet Sergeant. Mr Mitchell has known Ms Smith for 20 years and considered himself a friend as well as a colleague.Mr Mitchell confirmed that on 22 July 2019, he was tasked with investigating the murder that had occurred the night before. As per standard protocol, he reviewed material to contact anyone who may be involved and noted Ms Smith had been involved with the victim the night before. As such, he contacted Ms Smith by telephone.Further, Mr Mitchell deposed that on being told that the young woman had been murdered, Ms Smith sounded upset, so he decided to go to see her at the station in person. When Mr Mitchell arrived at the station where Ms Smith worked, Mr Mitchell recalled her crying. He was shocked to see Ms Smith so upset, because he had not seen that much emotion from her in relation to a case before. Ms Smith said that she felt distressed and responsible for the victim’s murder. Ms Smith finished her shift early, following which she was rostered for four days off. She then returned to work on a Saturday but could not cope and took sick leave for the day and the following Sunday.…Ms Smith has returned to work. However, she is currently performing a role earning less than in her pre-injury role. Work Capacity Certificates indicate that while Ms Smith is fit for pre-injury hours, she is not fit to return to operational duties. (Citations omitted)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On dismissal of the appeal, the question of law raised by the Notice of Alternative Contention does not arise. In any event, however, having regard to our observations about the use of descriptive words to assist with the construction of abstract and imprecise words and phrases in an instrument, we doubt that even positive answers to the respondent’s two contentions would supply an answer to the question of law. Given our acceptance of the general descriptive analysis offered by Hannon AUJ,[75] whether the putative requirements of physical and temporal ‘connections’ were met would likely remain an assessment of fact and degree.[75] [2023] SAET 116 at [157].Conclusion We grant leave to appeal on Grounds 1 and 2d. We refuse leave to appeal on Grounds 2a-c. We dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.