Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1616 (14 June 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2021/5751

Re:Erica Smith

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION  

Tribunal:Senior Member K. Parker

Date:14 June 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

................................[sgd]........................................

Senior Member K. Parker

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of decision relating to approval of statement of participant supports – adult participant with profound hearing impairment –Applicant already provided with hearing assistance dog free of charge by Australian Lions Hearing Dogs Inc (ALHD Inc) – Applicant requests $40,000 so she may reimburse ALHD Inc for its costs of acquiring and training hearing assistance dog – concerns held by Applicant about feeling beholden to ALHD Inc and obligated to participate in fundraising, media campaigns and to donate monies to ALHD Inc – ALHD Inc denies such obligations exist – concerns held by Applicant about local Lions club members entering her home during induction period post-placement of hearing assistance dog – meaning of “community” within s 34(1)(e) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and whether it extends to supports provided by ALHD Inc – whether “reasonable to expect” ALHD Inc to provide hearing assistance dogs to persons such as the Applicant – Tribunal found that the mandatory criterion under s 34(1)(e) not met – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Cases

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11
National Disability Insurance Agency v McGarrigle [2017] FCAFC 132

Nottle and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1014

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Memorandum, National Disability Insurance Scheme Bill 2012 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Agency, NDIS Operational Guidelines: Reasonable and Necessary Supports (Guidelines, 28 June 2022) <

National Disability Insurance Agency, NDIS Operational Guidelines: Assistance animals including dog guides (Guidelines, 20 June 2022) <

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member K. Parker

14 June 2023

  1. The Applicant, Ms Erica Smith, has a disability arising from a profound hearing impairment and is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). In short, this application involves an issue about whether Ms Smith should be funded an amount requested by her, that is, $40,000, so that she may reimburse the Australian Lion Hearing Dogs Inc (ALHD Inc) for the costs associated with providing her with a hearing assistance dog.

  2. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal has decided that this requested support is not a “reasonable and necessary support” under s 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) because it does not meet the criterion in sub-s 34(1)(e). For this reason, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review which had declined to include this requested support in Ms Smith’s statement of participant supports (SOPS

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1616
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Smith for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse to include funding for a hearing assistance dog in her statement of participant supports. Ms Smith, an adult with a profound hearing impairment, had been provided with hearing assistance dogs free of charge by the Australian Lions Hearing Dogs Inc (ALHD Inc). She sought $40,000 to reimburse ALHD Inc for its costs, expressing concerns about feeling beholden to the organisation and potential obligations regarding fundraising and media appearances, as well as the presence of local Lions club members in her home. The NDIA contended that it was reasonable to expect ALHD Inc to provide such supports.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) was required to determine whether the requested funding for the hearing assistance dog constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" under section 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the criterion under section 34(1)(e) was met, which mandates that the funding or provision of a support must take account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks, and the community to provide. The Tribunal also considered the meaning of "community" within this provision and whether it extended to supports provided by an organisation like ALHD Inc.

The Tribunal found that the criterion under section 34(1)(e) was not met. While acknowledging that ALHD Inc provided hearing assistance dogs free of charge and did not intend to charge Ms Smith, the Tribunal considered the invoice for $40,000 to represent the estimated costs to ALHD Inc rather than an obligation for Ms Smith to pay. The Tribunal rejected the NDIA's contention that it was reasonable to expect ALHD Inc to provide the support, finding that the mandatory criterion under section 34(1)(e) was not satisfied in these circumstances. The Tribunal also noted that it would not apply certain NDIA operational guidance that it considered inconsistent with the broader framework for assessing reasonable and necessary supports.

The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 3 August 2021, a different delegate of the NDIA CEO made a decision under s 100(6) of the NDIS Act (internal review decision) refusing to include additional funding in Ms Smith’s SOPS because the delegate (that is, the “reviewer”) was not satisfied that her requests for funding for the acquisition and training of a hearing assistance animal, met the “reasonable and necessary supports” criteria under s 34(1) of the NDIS Act (in particular, sub-ss 34(1)(c) and (e) and r 5.1(d) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) (Support Rules)). On 18 August 2021, Ms Smith sought review of the internal review decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal). After Zara’s passing, the ALHD Inc gave a new hearing assistance dog to Ms Smith, free of charge, whom Ms Smith named “Alfie”. She was a Labrador and Ms Smith told the Tribunal that Alfie did not turn out to be suitable. Ms Smith returned Alfie to the ALHD Inc in about September 2021. After this, Ms Smith was provided with Bella in January 2022 and Bella has remained with Ms Smith ever since. The ALHD Inc had not ever charged Ms Smith for providing her with Zara, nor Alfie, nor Bella. The ALHD Inc CEO, at the hearing, confirmed that the ALHD Inc does not ever intend to do so. An invoice dated 1 November 2022 for $40,000, issued by the ALHD Inc, was lodged by Ms Smith with the Tribunal on 22 May 2023. The intention of Ms Smith in submitting this updated invoice was to show that the costs associated with acquiring and training a hearing assistance dog at the current time (borne by the ALHD Inc) had increased since the time this application was first lodged with the Tribunal in 2021. It was accepted by both parties that this invoice does not represent or give rise to any obligation upon Ms Smith to pay the ALHD Inc the sum of $40,000 for the ALHD Inc having provided her with a hearing assistance dog, that is, Bella. The Tribunal takes this invoice as representing nothing more than an indication of the current estimated costs to the ALHD Inc to breed, vaccinate, raise, and train accredited hearing assistance dogs to provide free of charge to hearing impaired persons at the present time. Hearing of this application An in-person hearing took place at the Tribunal on 1 and 2 June 2023. Ms Smith was self-represented and gave evidence, with the use of captioning services. Ms Smith called one other witness, being Mr Horne, who gave evidence by telephone. The NDIA was represented by a lawyer from HWL Ebsworth Lawyers, Ms Tegan Weir, and the relevant NDIA case manager also appeared at the hearing. The NDIA did not call any witnesses. In about February 2022, the NDIA indicated that it wished to arrange for an independent assessment of Ms Smith by a specialist in assistance animals. Ms Smith did not consent to this request and expressed her view that it would be a waste of time and money. Both parties lodged written statements of facts, issues and contentions and a joint hearing tender bundle (HTB) before the substantive hearing. Specifically, the Tribunal notes:(a)the Statement by Ms Smith, lodged on 19 April 2023 (Ms Smith’s Statement); and(b)the Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, lodged by the NDIA on 9 May 2023 (NDIA’s SFIC).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If the NDIA operational guidance as referred to above is implemented, it would mean that an applicant’s claim for an assistance animal may be defeated by the mere passage of time as a review application makes its way through the NDIA’s internal review process, and subsequent Tribunal process, from lodgement to final decision, because the applicant has, during that period, decided to make other arrangements to acquire the requested support. If this takes place, the Tribunal is not convinced that there is any provision in the NDIS Act or Support Rules prohibiting the applicant from continuing on with their original request for funding for the cost of this support, and then, when is it subsequently approved under the participant’s NDIS plan, the applicant could acquit that amount to whomever has paid for the support in the interim. The Tribunal will not apply this policy guidance (as referred to in the first sentence of paragraph [35] above) as it considers it to be inconsistent with the broader framework provided under the NDIS Act for the assessment of whether a support is a “reasonable and necessary support” under s 34(1) and should be included in a statement of participant’s supports. CONSIDERATION Section 33(5) of the NDIS Act requires that the NDIA CEO (or delegate), in deciding whether to approve the SOPS under s 33(2), have regard to a number of factors including the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations, the relevant assessments conducted in relation to the participant, and to be satisfied that the supports to be included in the SOPS are “reasonable and necessary supports” within the meaning of s 34(1) of the NDIS Act. Section 34(1) of the NDIS Act mandates that six separate criteria must be met before a support is considered to be a “reasonable and necessary support”. Section 34(2) provides that the NDIS rules may prescribe methods or criteria to be applied or matters to which the decision-maker is to have regard, in deciding whether they are satisfied that the criteria under s 34(1) have been met in respect of a requested support.Section 34(1)(e) - the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks, and community to provide The Tribunal will consider first whether the criterion under s 34(1)(e) of the NDIS Act has been met in respect of the Requested Support. Section 34(1)(e) of the NDIS Act requires that “the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks, and the community to provide”. The NDIA contends that it is reasonable for the funding of a hearing assistance dog to be provided to Ms Smith by the community organisation, ALHD Inc. Ms Smith contends that this criteria under s 34(1)(e) was not intended to apply to the current circumstances, that is, where a large organisation such as the ALHD Inc is providing supports to hearing impaired persons, but rather it was intended to apply only to smaller local community groups.