Smith and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Smith and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 3570 (3 November 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/5976

Re:Rangi Lee Joseph Smith

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

Date:3 November 2023

Place:Adelaide

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

...........[sgnd].............................................................

Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of applicant’s visa – applicant does not satisfy character test – whether “another reason” for the cancellation decision to be revoked – Direction no. 99 – most recent convictions involve family violence – sentencing remarks considered – applicant’s assault extremely serious – applicant re-approaches victim six days after being released on parole and after AVO made final in his presence in Court – community’s expectations weigh against the applicant – substantial risk of reoffending – applicant’s ties to Australia and the best interests of minor children weigh in applicant’s favour particularly as children are half-Aboriginal Australian – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Amendment (Aggregate Sentences) Act 2023 (Cth)

CASES

Frugtniet v ASIC [2019] HCA 16; (2019) 266 CLR 250; (2019) 79 AAR 9

FYVY and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 790

Hands v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 225; (2018) 267 FCR 268

Pearson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 203; (2022) 295 FCR 177

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286; (2008) 103 ALD 467

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Cth), Direction no. 99 — Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (23 January 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION[1]

Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

[1] These reasons contain certain standard paragraphs; namely, [10] and [46].

  1. This is an application by Mr Rangi Lee Joseph Smith seeking a review of a decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 10 August 2023. By this decision, the delegate declined to revoke the cancellation of Mr Smith’s visa[2] which had purportedly taken place under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).[3]

    [2] A Class TY subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.

    [3] For reasons to be explained, the decision was made without jurisdiction, but was retrospectively validated by the provisions of an amending Act in February 2023.

    PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND 

  2. The cancellation came about in the following circumstances.  Mr Smith was convicted on 29 June 2022 of two offences arising out of a protracted episode of family violence against his then partner. On the same day, he received an aggregate sentence of 14 months’ imprisonment for his offending, but he was released on parole immediately (as he had been remanded in custody for some five and a half months at that stage).   Six days after his release on parole (that is, on 5 July 2002), Mr Smith breached an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicul... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3570
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Rangi Lee Joseph Smith for a review of the delegate's decision to refuse to revoke the cancellation of his visa, which had been cancelled under section 501(3A) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). The cancellation was initially made due to Mr Smith having a substantial criminal record and serving a sentence of imprisonment. However, subsequent legislative amendments, enacted in response to a Full Federal Court decision, retrospectively validated the cancellation decision.

The court was required to determine whether there was "another reason" for the cancellation decision to be revoked, considering the criteria outlined in Direction 99. This involved weighing various factors, including Mr Smith's criminal history, particularly his convictions for family violence, his personal circumstances, his ties to Australia, and the best interests of his minor children, who are of Aboriginal Australian heritage. The court also had to consider the community's expectations regarding serious criminal conduct.

In its reasoning, the court acknowledged Mr Smith's difficult upbringing, his efforts to work and volunteer, and his insight into substance misuse. It also recognised the significant weight to be given to his long residence in Australia and the best interests of his Aboriginal Australian children. However, the court found that Mr Smith's family violence offences, including an assault on his former partner while pregnant and a subsequent breach of an apprehended violence order shortly after his release on parole, were extremely serious. The court concluded that these factors, coupled with a substantial risk of reoffending and community expectations, weighed heavily against revoking the visa cancellation.

Ultimately, the court affirmed the delegate's decision under review, finding that the serious nature of Mr Smith's offending and the associated risks outweighed the factors favouring his continued presence in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by Mr Rangi Lee Joseph Smith seeking a review of a decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 10 August 2023. By this decision, the delegate declined to revoke the cancellation of Mr Smith’s visa[2] which had purportedly taken place under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).[3][2] A Class TY subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.[3] For reasons to be explained, the decision was made without jurisdiction, but was retrospectively validated by the provisions of an amending Act in February 2023. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The cancellation came about in the following circumstances. Mr Smith was convicted on 29 June 2022 of two offences arising out of a protracted episode of family violence against his then partner. On the same day, he received an aggregate sentence of 14 months’ imprisonment for his offending, but he was released on parole immediately (as he had been remanded in custody for some five and a half months at that stage). Six days after his release on parole (that is, on 5 July 2002), Mr Smith breached an AVO[4] protecting the same victim. As a result, he was sentenced to a fixed term of three months’ imprisonment, his parole was revoked, and he became obliged, subject to any further grant of parole, to serve the balance of his aggregate sentence in gaol. [4] Apprehended Violence Order. Mr Smith’s visa was cancelled under section 501(3A) of the Act on 25 October 2022. The delegate who made that decision proceeded as follows. First, Mr Smith was assessed to have a “substantial criminal record” by virtue of section 501(7)(c) of the Act, as he had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of at least 12 months;[5] and, secondly, he was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis in gaol at the time of the delegate’s decision.[6] Having reached these conclusions, the delegate was required to cancel Mr Smith’s visa under section 501(3A) of the Act. [5] See s 501(3A)(a)(i). [6] See s 501(3A)(b). As soon as he was released from gaol,[7] Mr Smith was taken into immigration detention. He was released from detention in late December 2022 as a result of the full Federal Court’s decision in Pearson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 203; (2022) 295 FCR 177 (“Pearson”). The Court decided in Pearson that the reference in section 501(7)(c) of the Act to “being sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more” did not include aggregate sentences. This implied that the initial cancellation of Mr Smith’s visa under section 501(3A) was not authorised. It followed that his continued detention was unlawful. [7] On 28 October 2022, see Ex R1, 123. After the decision in Pearson, the Federal Parliament amended the Act with effect from 17 February 2023.[8] The Act, as amended, required the expression “a term of imprisonment” in the Act, including in section 501(7)(c), to be read so as to include aggregate terms of imprisonment. In short, the effect of the decision in Pearson was reversed by the Federal Parliament. This amendment was retroactive, and the decision to cancel Mr Smith’s visa was validated.[9] Mr Smith was re-detained from ‒ I infer this from the records ‒ no later than 1 April 2023,[10] and he has not returned to live in the Australian community since that time.[11][8] By the insertion of a new section 5AB: see Migration Amendment (Aggregate Sentences) Act 2023 s 2(1) and Schedule 1, Item 1.[9] See Ibid Item 4(3). [10] Ex R2, 2 where Mr Smith is shown to have re-entered a correctional centre on 1 April 2023.[11] It would appear that he was detained in gaol for some time pending disposition of a charge in respect of an assault alleged to have occurred on 14 March 2023. I have no official information in respect of that matter, but Mr Smith asserts that he was acquitted of the charge on 11 September 2023 (see Ex A7, p 6/10), and I have assumed this account is accurate and truthful.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing before me, Mr Nikjoo appeared for the applicant; Mr Goodwin, for the respondent. I acknowledge their assistance to me.STATEMENT OF CONCLUSION I have decided to affirm the decision under review. I now set out now my findings of fact and my reasons for this conclusion.FINDINGS OF FACT AND REASONS(i)Findings of Fact Mr Smith was born on 7 December 1972 in Auckland, New Zealand. He remains a citizen of that country. There were a number of written submissions and statements before me that he has made, and he gave oral evidence as well.[15] I also heard evidence from Mr Smith’s foster mother, Rev Dr Hall-Smith, amongst other witnesses. She provided a statement as well.[16] Rev Dr Hall-Smith is Mr Smith’s father’s older sister, and so she is Mr Smith’s biological aunt. She currently resides in New Zealand. [15] Ex R1, 93ff, 115-119 (also reproduced at 124-128), 122, 129-31; 370ff, Ex A7.[16] Part of Ex A8. Mr Smith’s biological parents did not care for him for very long after his birth. His father died, unfortunately, when he was three or four years of age. His mother did not raise him after that point, but, rather, abandoned him without warning. It appears from Rev Dr Hall-Smith’s statement that Mr Smith first arrived in Sydney in 1977. Rev Dr Hall-Smith refers to the fact that she became Mr Smith’s guardian when he was about five years of age. Although she obtained Australian citizenship in 1978, Rev Dr Hall-Smith was not able to arrange for Mr Smith to obtain citizenship as he was a minor and the consent of Mr Smith’s remaining living parent (namely, his mother) was required. Rev Dr Hall-Smith gave evidence that she had to work at two jobs to meet her mortgage repayments after her husband left her, and she raised Mr Smith as a single parent from that point on in difficult circumstances. The tenor of her evidence to the Tribunal was that she found the child-rearing experience difficult, that she felt herself to be ill-equipped to care for Mr Smith at that point in her life, and that she had been compelled, in a sense, to assume responsibility for Mr Smith after her brother’s (Mr Smith’s father’s) untimely death and Mr Smith’s mother’s abandonment of him. Mr Smith attended primary school in Sydney. Rev Dr Hall-Smith pointed out that he was the only boy of an Indigenous background at the school.[17] She eventually sent him to a boarding school back in New Zealand. Her thinking was that he would have the benefit of a multicultural educational experience there. Rev Dr Hall Smith indicated in her evidence that, in retrospect, she appreciates that this decision was not “the right answer”. Rev Dr Hall-Smith also gave evidence that Mr Smith got into trouble while at school and that her sister, then living in New Zealand, was obliged to remove him. [17] That is, of a New Zealand Indigenous background. Rev Dr Hall-Smith gave evidence that, overall, Mr Smith had probably suffered substantially from his upbringing. I accept her evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

None of the other listed considerations in section 9 applies. In particular, I note that I have no statement from Ms F to weigh up.WEIGHING THE CONSIDERATIONS I now turn to weighing the considerations. This has not been an easy task. There is much in Mr Smith’s background that elicits concern. He was badly neglected by his biological mother, he lost his father at a young age, and he appears to have grown up haphazardly without adequate guidance, affection, and supervision. He has shown himself to be capable of working effectively, particularly as a roofing contractor in a family business, and has volunteered in his community. There have been times in his life where there has not been criminal offending, even if, when viewed as a whole, Mr Smith’s criminal record is quite extensive. He has sufficient insight to appreciate that alcohol and drug misuse have not helped him but have, to the contrary, been harmful. I believe his own personal prospects for building a better life are more likely to be fulfilled in Australia than in New Zealand, where I have found that he would face the immediate prospect of not having accommodation or family to turn to for practical support. He would not have immediate work available to him in New Zealand either. The interests of his Aboriginal Australian children (particularly his minor children) do favour his retention in the Australian community so that, hopefully, over time, he might rebuild a relationship with them and support them financially. Dislocation within Australian Aboriginal families is a very concerning aspect of our society. I appreciate also that the Direction indicates expressly that considerable weight should be given to the fact that a non-citizen has been ordinarily resident in Australia during and since their formative years,[78] which is the case with Mr Smith. Moreover, I bear in mind paragraph 5.2(5) of the Direction, which is in the following terms:With respect to decisions to refuse, cancel, and revoke cancellation of a visa, Australia will generally afford a higher level of tolerance of criminal or other serious conduct by non-citizens who have lived in the Australian community for most of their life, or from a very young age. The level of tolerance will rise with the length of time a non-citizen has spent in the Australian community, particularly in their formative years. [78] Paragraph 8.3(4)(a)(i) of the Direction. I do need to weigh carefully, however, Mr Smith’s family violence in relation to Ms F. The Direction plainly makes violence against domestic partners a matter of concern. The assault upon Ms F was of a most serious kind as the sentencing Court found. Ms F was pregnant at the time, and the offending took place in breach of a community corrections order. There was not only substantial physical violence inflicted upon Ms F, but a credible threat to her life was made. The physical assault only stopped when she managed to lock Mr Smith out of her unit. Having spent five and a half months in jail, Mr Smith was then released on parole. When releasing Mr Smith into the community, the Court made its AVO in respect of Ms F final in his presence, and he knew full well that he was not to re-approach his victim. He did so within a very short period, namely after just six days, which is a very serious matter, even if the breach of the order was found to be at the lower end of the scale of seriousness for offences of that type. I have found that Mr Smith remains a substantial risk to the community (to Ms F or to any other future domestic partner he might have). That is a very serious matter for me to weigh. His violence toward Ms F was quite extreme, and his flouting of the AVO that had been made final by the sentencing Court just six days earlier was egregious. It is clear the community-expectations consideration in this case counts substantially against Mr Smith remaining in Australia.