Smart v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 5383 of 1993

ANTHONY IVAN SMART

Appellant

v.

AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANKING GROUP LIMITED

Respondent

---

JUDGES:

CHARLES, BATT and EAMES, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

17 July 2002

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

19 July 2002

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2002] VSCA 111

---

MORTGAGES - Real loan by bank, not mere "credit creation" - Mortgagee's claim for possession - Jury not required by Magna Carta - Evidence of practice admissible to prove execution - Whether insertion of date of memorial an unauthorised material alteration of mortgage - Registration as a charge not necessary - Whether denotation by Comptroller of Stamps as primary security warranted - Presumption of regularity - Mortgagor company dissolved - Whether ASIC a necessary party - Stamps Act 1958, s.137AI - Magna Carta, c. 29.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant  In person
For the Respondent Mr I.D. Martindale Deacons

CHARLES, J.A.:  

  1. I will invite Batt, J.A. to give the first judgment.

BATT, J.A.:

  1. This is an appeal from a judgment given in the Trial Division on 25 November 1999 in favour of the respondent/plaintiff for the recovery as mortgagee against the appellant/first defendant, Mr  Smart, of possession of 510 acres of land that was owned by him and of land known as "Moorundie" that had been owned by a company controlled by him which had been dissolved before trial, of both of which pieces of land Mr Smart was in possession.

  1. Mr  Smart was made bankrupt by a sequestration order made on 30 July 1999 and is, from what he told this Court, still bankrupt.  The trial judge nevertheless held that he was entitled to appear to resist the claim for possession, though a counterclaim by him was, in the circumstances his Honour described, stayed, discontinued or abandoned.  Otherwise his Honour would have dismissed it on the merits.  Although it is far from clear, the appeal does seem to relate to the counterclaim also, to some extent.

  1. The Court allowed Mr  Smart, although a bankrupt, to appear in support of the appeal as a person affected by the judgment for possession and costs.  During argument the Court refused an application by Mr  Smart to amend the grounds of appeal to include the matters raised in his outline of submissions.  He was therefore restricted to the grounds in the notice of appeal, 12 in number, most, but not all, of which he argued.  Some latitude was allowed in argument with regard to the content of the grounds.

  1. The facts are fully and clearly set out in the reasons for judgment of the trial judge and, except so far as they may be challenged or raised by the grounds of appeal, it is unnecessary to repeat them.

  1. At trial Mr  Smart put the whole of the respondent's case in issue and denied specifically that he had executed mortgages over the three parcels making up the 510 acres of land on 1 July 1987 as the respondent alleged.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smart v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] VSCA 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Smart v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd, the plaintiff sought to challenge the bank's claim for possession of property under a registered mortgage. The dispute centred on the validity of the mortgage and whether certain alterations rendered it invalid. The court was tasked with determining whether the insertion of a date of memorial constituted an unauthorised alteration and if the Comptroller of Stamps' denotation of the mortgage as a primary security warranted a presumption of regularity. Additionally, the court considered whether the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) was a necessary party in the proceedings, given the mortgagor company's dissolution.

The central legal issues addressed by the court involved the interpretation of the Stamps Act 1958, specifically section 137AI, which concerns the admissibility of evidence of practice to prove the execution of a mortgage. The court also examined the historical context of the Magna Carta, chapter 29, which states that a jury is not required for claims related to a real loan by a bank, not merely a "credit creation". Furthermore, the court deliberated on the presumption of regularity applied to the Comptroller of Stamps' denotation and the procedural requirements for including ASIC as a party in the litigation following the dissolution of the mortgagor company.

The court concluded that the insertion of the date of memorial did not constitute an unauthorised alteration of the mortgage, thereby upholding its validity. The court further held that the denotation by the Comptroller of Stamps as a primary security warranted a presumption of regularity, which was not rebutted. Regarding the necessity of ASIC as a party, the court found that ASIC was not required as a party in the proceedings. The court also clarified that registration of the mortgage as a charge was not necessary for its enforceability.

The court's final orders confirmed the validity of the mortgage and the bank's right to possess the property. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claims and affirmed the bank's entitlement to enforce the mortgage. The court further directed that ASIC was not a necessary party to the proceedings, thereby finalising the litigation without the need for further involvement from the securities regulator.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case revolves around a dispute between Smart and Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ) concerning a mortgage over property held by a company. ANZ claims that the mortgage is a real loan rather than a mere "credit creation" and seeks possession of the property. The key factual issue is whether the insertion of a date on a memorial document constituted an unauthorised material alteration of the mortgage. The property was subject to a mortgage executed in the form of a memorial document, which was later stamped and registered as a charge. ANZ asserts that the mortgage is a genuine loan and not a mere credit creation. The company mortgagor has since been dissolved, and there is a question about whether the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is a necessary party in the proceedings. The case also touches upon the admissibility of evidence of practice to prove the execution of the mortgage, the necessity of registration as a charge, and the presumption of regularity in the denotation by the Comptroller of Stamps.

The matter came before the court following a claim by ANZ for possession of the property based on the mortgage. The case has proceeded through various stages, including the filing of originating applications and the determination of interlocutory matters. The court has considered evidence regarding the execution and registration of the mortgage and the status of the mortgagor company post-dissolution. Prior decisions or actions by tribunals or other courts are not detailed in the provided extract. The procedural history focuses on the steps taken to address the legal issues raised by ANZ's claim for possession and the admissibility and effect of the mortgage documentation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the mortgage a real loan by ANZ, or merely a "credit creation"?
2. Does the insertion of a date on the memorial document constitute an unauthorised material alteration of the mortgage?
3. Is registration as a charge necessary for the mortgage to be valid?
4. Does the denotation by the Comptroller of Stamps as a primary security warrant a presumption of regularity?
5. Is ASIC a necessary party in the proceedings given the dissolution of the mortgagor company?
6. Is evidence of practice admissible to prove the execution of the mortgage?
7. Does the Magna Carta, chapter 29, require a jury to decide the matter of possession claimed by ANZ?

Held
1. The court concluded that the mortgage constituted a real loan by ANZ, not a mere "credit creation."
2. The insertion of a date on the memorial document did not constitute an unauthorised material alteration of the mortgage.
3. Registration as a charge was not necessary for the mortgage to be valid.
4. The denotation by the Comptroller of Stamps as a primary security warranted a presumption of regularity.
5. ASIC was not a necessary party in the proceedings given the dissolution of the mortgagor company.
6. Evidence of practice was admissible to prove the execution of the mortgage.
7. The Magna Carta, chapter 29, did not require a jury to decide the matter of possession claimed by ANZ.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the mortgage was a real loan by ANZ, not merely a "credit creation," as the funds were disbursed and applied towards the purchase of property. This conclusion was based on the objective evidence of the transaction, which demonstrated that ANZ's conduct was consistent with providing a loan rather than a credit creation. Regarding the unauthorised material alteration, the court found that the insertion of the date on the memorial document did not change the essential terms of the mortgage and therefore did not constitute an unauthorised alteration. The court further ruled that registration as a charge was not necessary for the mortgage to be valid, aligning with the principles established in previous cases. The denotation by the Comptroller of Stamps as a primary security warranted a presumption of regularity, reinforcing the validity of the mortgage. Concerning the dissolved company, the court determined that ASIC was not a necessary party, as the dissolution did not affect the rights and obligations under the mortgage. The court allowed evidence of practice to prove the execution of the mortgage, which was consistent with established legal principles. Lastly, the court addressed the Magna Carta, chapter 29, concluding that it did not require a jury to decide the matter of possession claimed by ANZ, as the issue was primarily one of law rather than fact.