Smallbone v New South Wales Bar Association

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Smallbone v New South Wales Bar Association [2011] FCA 1145

Citation: Smallbone v New South Wales Bar Association [2011] FCA 1145
Parties: DAVID ANDREW SMALLBONE v NEW SOUTH WALES BAR ASSOCIATION ACN 000 033 652
File number(s): NSD 1685 of 2011
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 6 October 2011
Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – privacy – personal information about applicant held by respondent – information provided for collection on express assurance of confidentiality – whether providing access would have an unreasonable impact upon the privacy of other individuals
Legislation: Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) ss 6, 16A(2), 98, Sch 3 National Privacy Principle 6
Cases cited: C v Insurance Company [2006] PrivCmrA 3
Phillips v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2006] FCA 882
Date of hearing: 5 October 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 77
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr T Molomby SC
Counsel for the Respondent: Dr J Griffiths SC with Ms S Pritchard
Solicitor for the Respondent: Hicksons Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1685 of 2011

BETWEEN:

DAVID ANDREW SMALLBONE
Applicant

AND:

THE NEW SOUTH WALES BAR ASSOCIATION
ACN 000 033 652
Respondent

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 OCTOBER 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. Pursuant to section 98 of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) the respondent, within 4 business days after the making of these orders, provide the applicant with access to the personal information about him that the respondent has collected in relation to the applicant’s application for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011, including responses that it has collected about the applicant from members of the consultation groups established under the Senior Counsel Protocol dated June 2011 published by the respondent, save that the respondent is not obliged to provide access to information which discloses:

(a)the identity of persons who are members of the consultation groups who have provided information to the respondent and, in the case of members of the consultation groups who are judicial officers, the identity of the court to which that member has been appointed, if it is a court other than the Supreme Court of New South Wales; or

(b)the identity of or information about other persons who are applicants for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011 or who have provided information about persons who are applicants for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011.

2.        The access referred to in order 1 be provided by the respondent by permitting the applicant to inspect in private the records of the information that the respondent has in its possession, custody or control, at the premises of the respondent at 174 Phillip      Street, Sydney during ordinary business hours, or by the provision of copies of those       records, or in such other manner as may be agreed in writing by the applicant and the            respondent.

3.        Until the later of:

(a)the expiry of 7 days after completion of the inspection or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smallbone v New South Wales Bar Association and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Smallbone v New South Wales Bar Association dealt with a dispute over the right of access to personal information held by the respondent, New South Wales Bar Association, regarding the applicant’s application for appointment as Senior Counsel. The applicant sought access to information collected by the respondent during the selection process, which the respondent had assured would be kept confidential. The central legal issue was whether the provision of such access would unreasonably impact the privacy of other individuals, in accordance with the National Privacy Principle 6.1(c). The applicant argued that there would be no unreasonable impact, while the respondent contended that any disclosure would infringe on the privacy of third parties who provided information about the applicant.

The court assessed the matter by considering whether the disclosure would have an unreasonable impact on the privacy of other individuals. It noted that while NPP 6.1(c) provides an exception to the general rule that access must be provided, it is not an absolute exemption. The court held that the decision to provide access must be made based on a practical judgment considering all circumstances, including the expectation of confidentiality, the extent of privacy impact, and whether masking identifying details could protect privacy. The court concluded that the applicant was entitled to access to the information, except where it involved the identities of the third parties who provided the information or other applicants for Senior Counsel. This decision was grounded in the understanding that the principle allows for exceptions based on the specific context and potential impacts on privacy.

The court ordered the respondent to provide the applicant with access to the collected personal information, excluding certain details that could identify third parties and other applicants. It further ordered that the respondent could not destroy or dispose of the information for seven days after the applicant completed their inspection or access. Additionally, the respondent was restrained from making any adverse determination of the applicant’s application within seven days of the inspection or access. The court also granted liberty to the parties to apply for further directions regarding the execution of these orders or for extensions or amendments concerning time limits. The proceeding was stood over to determine any disputed questions about costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 98 of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) the respondent, within 4 business days after the making of these orders, provide the applicant with access to the personal information about him that the respondent has collected in relation to the applicant’s application for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011, including responses that it has collected about the applicant from members of the consultation groups established under the Senior Counsel Protocol dated June 2011 published by the respondent, save that the respondent is not obliged to provide access to information which discloses:

(a) the identity of persons who are members of the consultation groups who have provided information to the respondent and, in the case of members of the consultation groups who are judicial officers, the identity of the court to which that member has been appointed, if it is a court other than the Supreme Court of New South Wales; or

(b) the identity of or information about other persons who are applicants for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011 or who have provided information about persons who are applicants for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011.

2. The access referred to in order 1 be provided by the respondent by permitting the applicant to inspect in private the records of the information that the respondent has in its possession, custody or control, at the premises of the respondent at 174 Phillip Street, Sydney during ordinary business hours, or by the provision of copies of those records, or in such other manner as may be agreed in writing by the applicant and the respondent.

3. Until the later of:

(a) the expiry of 7 days after completion of the inspection or other provision of the access provided in order 1; or

(b) the date on which the applicant notifies the respondent in writing that he no longer requires the personal information to which access has been granted to be retained for the purpose of consideration of the outcome of his application for appointment as senior counsel, or for the purpose of any complaint, review, suit, proceeding or other procedure concerning his application for appointment as senior counsel,

the respondent be restrained from, by itself, its officers, servants or agents, destroying or disposing of any record of any personal information about the applicant to which the applicant has been provided access in accordance with order 1.

4. Until the expiry of 7 days after completion of the inspection or other provision of access given in accordance with order 1, the respondent be restrained from, by itself, its officers, servants or agents, making any adverse determination of the applicant’s application for appointment as Senior Counsel lodged with the respondent in July 2011.

5. Liberty be granted to each of the parties to apply upon 1 day’s notice for further directions concerning the manner of executing these orders or otherwise for the working out of these orders and/or for extension or amendment of any time limited by these orders for the taking of any step.

6. The proceeding stand over to a date to be fixed to determine any disputed question about costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

It is common ground between the parties that the respondent is an organisation within the meaning of s 6C(1) of the Act and that the collection, use and destruction of information relating to the appointment of Senior Counsel is governed by the National Privacy Principles (NPPs) set out in Schedule 3 of the Act. The respondent is not bound by a privacy code approved by the Privacy Commissioner or by the Australian Information Commissioner.BACKGROUNDThe protocol for the appointment of Senior Counsel Since 1992 the respondent has had a protocol for the appointment of Senior Counsel. The protocol is approved by the Bar Council which, in accordance with clause 14.1.1 of the respondent’s Constitution, administers the respondent’s business and affairs. The protocol sets out the process by which Senior Counsel are selected by the Senior Counsel Selection Committee each year. The Selection Committee comprises the President and Senior Vice President of the respondent, three other senior counsel (whether Queen’s Counsel or Senior Counsel) nominated by the President and approved by the Bar Council (not more than one of whom may be a member of the Bar Council) and one person who is not a practising barrister but who, by virtue of that person’s qualifications, is an appropriate person to be the non-practising representative on the Committee. The protocol is written for members of the respondent who are considering making application for appointment as Senior Counsel. It also provides information to members of the public who wish to be informed of that process. Clause 27 of the Senior Counsel Protocol as at June 2011 (the Protocol) provides that the Selection Committee should use its best endeavours to ensure that the process of selection is completed so as to permit public announcements of the successful applications on or before the first Friday in October. This year that date is 7 October 2011. The urgency of the present proceeding resides in the fact that the applicant seeks, as part of his claimed relief, an injunction that the respondent be restrained from making any adverse determination of his application for Senior Counsel for a period of seven days after completion of his inspection or other access to the information he seeks.Provisions in relation to the confidentiality of information The Protocol contains the following provisions in relation to the confidentiality of information collected as part of the selection process: 15.The collection of information relating to appointment of Senior Counsel is governed by National Privacy Principle 2 and will not be used or disclosed for a purpose other than the selection of Senior Counsel and the giving of counselling by the President to unsuccessful applicants.16.In accordance with National Privacy Principle 4, to protect the confidentiality of the material it gathers, the Bar Association will destroy or permanently de-identify all documentation in its possession in relation to the selection process as soon as practicable after each year’s appointments are announced.17.It is a requirement of making an application for appointment of Senior Counsel that the applicant agrees that information collected by the Bar Association in conjunction with their application, including information obtained by third parties, is confidential information in terms of the National Privacy Principle 6(1)(c).18.Applicants are to be made aware that their applications will be the subject of distribution during the selection process and it will therefore be impossible to keep confidential the fact that an application has been made.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the respondent challenged the utility of any recourse by the applicant to NPPs 6.5 and 6.6 in relation to information that was essentially an expression of personal opinion conveyed by certain designated answers: cf Phillips v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2006] FCA 882 at [31]. I will return to that matter.CONSIDERATION The following matters should be noted at the outset. First, the parties did not dispute the fact that the respondent is an organisation to which NPP 6.1 applies. Thus, if it holds personal information about an individual, it must provide the individual with access to the information on request by the individual. Secondly, the parties did not dispute the fact that the information collected by the respondent about the applicant in relation to his application for appointment as Senior Counsel in 2011 was “personal information” for the purposes of the Act and the NPPs, and that the applicant had requested access to that information. The matter that divided the parties was the extent to which NPP 6.1(c) applies to limit the applicant’s right of access to that information. The applicant’s primary position was that providing access to all of the information in respect of the applicant, including the identity of persons who had supplied that information, would not have an unreasonable impact upon the privacy of other individuals. In essence his position was that NPP 6.1(c) had no relevant application in the circumstances of his case. The respondent’s position was that providing access to any of that information to the applicant would have an unreasonable impact upon the privacy of other individuals, being the persons who participated in the selection process and supplied the information in respect of the applicant. In essence its position was that NPP 6.1(c) provided an absolute exemption to providing access to that information to the applicant. In my view neither position is the correct position. NPP 6.1(c) provides an exception to a general rule. The general rule is that, if an organisation (such as the respondent) holds personal information (such as the information held by the respondent as a result of the selection process) about an individual (such as the applicant), access must be provided to the individual upon that person’s request. The exception provided by NPP 6.1(c) is one among a number of possible exceptions that might apply in a given case. But it is not necessarily an absolute exemption. This is made clear by the words “except to the extent that” in the chapeau to NPP 6.1(c). What is required is that access to the information be provided except to the extent that it would have the unreasonable impact to which NPP 6.1(c) refers. Whether providing access to the information would have that unreasonable impact is essentially a matter of practical judgment having regard to all the circumstances of the case. In short, a factual evaluation is involved. In C v Insurance Company [2006] PrivCmrA 3 the Commissioner identified the following factors as being relevant to the assessment of whether the provision of access to documents containing the personal information of third parties would have an unreasonable impact on the privacy of those individuals:·Whether the individual would expect that his or her information would be disclosed to a third party, including whether an assurance of confidentiality was provided.·The extent of the impact on the individual’s privacy.·Whether any public interest reasons for providing access to the information outweigh any expectation of confidentiality.·Whether masking the identifying details of the third parties would sufficiently protect the privacy of these individuals.