SLOWIAK v DIRECTOR PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (COMMONWEALTH)
[2000] SASC 282
Magistrates Appeal
ex tempore
1................ Gray J This is an appeal against a sentence imposed by a magistrate.
The appellant was charged with eight counts of knowingly or recklessly making a false statement in connection with or in support of a claim for a social security payment under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth), namely a widow allowance for herself, contrary to Section 1344(1)(a) and Section 1350 of the Social Security Act 1991. She was further charged with twenty four counts of knowingly obtaining a payment of an instalment of a social security payment under the Social Security Act of 1991, namely a widow allowance which was not payable at all, contrary to Section 1347(b) and Section 1350 of the Social Security Act 1991.
The appellant pleaded guilty to all counts. The offending behaviour took place between 1 December 1997 and 25 June 1999.
The Grounds of Appeal are as follows:
1...... The Learned Special Magistrate erred in declining to order the Appellant's release from custody forthwith.
2.The Learned Special Magistrate erred in giving insufficient regard to the Appellant's personal circumstances.
In the course of argument it was submitted that the magistrate had erred in two particular respects, first that he failed to allow a reduction in penalty for the plea of guilty and secondly, that he should not have treated overpayments received by the appellant in 1995 and 1996 as matters of aggravation.
In an affidavit placed before this Court, the appellant's counsel deposed:-
"The appellant has since instructed me that at the time she appeared for sentence before the Learned Special Magistrate she had been too ashamed to tell her mother and family that she had committed these offences. She instructs me that she has since then told them what she has done. She instructs that her mother and family are supportive of her and have paid on her behalf the amount of $13,964.24 that sum completing restitution in full of the total sum $15,279.89 ordered by the Learned Special Magistrate."
In Kovacevic v Mills (2000) 207 LSJS 158, in their joint judgment, Doyle CJ and Mullighan, Bleby and Martin JJ said at (178):
"Pursuant to s 16A(2)(f)(i), the Court is obliged to take into account any action by the appellant to make reparation in the context of contrition. As has been mentioned, the total amount received has now been repaid. It may be said that in arranging for reparation to be made, the appellant was doing no more than meeting an obligation imposed by law and repaying what he had illegally received by his own conduct. It should also be said that offenders cannot buy their way out of severe punishment by repaying what they should never have received. However, the Courts are obliged to regard reparation as a positive matter so far as an offender is concerned. In SA Police v John (1995) 181 LSJS 20, King CJ, with whom the other members of the Court agreed,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Slowiak v Director Public Prosecutions (Cth) No. Scgrg-00-62... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 282
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several legal issues, including whether the magistrate should have reduced the penalty due to the appellant's guilty plea, and whether the previous overpayments should have been considered as aggravating factors. The court found that the magistrate failed to appropriately acknowledge the appellant's guilty plea and contrition, which should have resulted in a reduction in penalty. Furthermore, the court disagreed with the magistrate's assessment that the previous overpayments were aggravating factors, noting that the circumstances could be equally explained by mistake or negligence. The court also highlighted the importance of full restitution in sentencing and its positive impact on the appellant's rehabilitation prospects.
The court allowed the appeal, reducing the sentence to 12 months, with a 25% reduction for the guilty plea. However, considering the appellant's age, health, and full restitution, the court ordered her immediate release and instead required her to enter into a recognizance of $200 to be of good behaviour for two years, under the supervision of a probation officer. This decision emphasised the importance of personal circumstances and contrition in sentencing, as well as the court's encouragement of full restitution as a factor in favour of leniency.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi