Slater v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

SLATER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (SA)

[2025] SASC 11

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McDonald  

12 February 2025

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - OTHER TYPES OF POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - RELEASE ON LICENCE

On 21 April 2017, Chief Justice Kourakis ordered that the applicant be detained until further order pursuant to s 23 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) on that basis that he was unwilling to control his sexual instincts. At the commencement of these proceedings, the applicant had been serving a sentence of 10 years imprisonment for the offences of aggravated serious criminal trespass and rape. Prior to these offences, the applicant had an extensive history of similar offences.

On 5 April 2022, the applicant filed an application for release on licence pursuant to s 59(1) of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) (‘the Act’). The applicant brings this application on the basis that he is now capable of controlling, and willing to control his sexual instincts and no longer presents an appreciable risk to the safety of the community pursuant to s 59(1a)(b) of the Act. The respondent opposes the applicant’s release on licence.

In accordance with s 59(2) of the Act, the Court ordered that two legally qualified medical practitioners assess the applicant and provide a report regarding the applicant’s mental condition and whether he was capable of, or willing to control, his sexual instincts. A report from Dr Craig Raeside was received on 3 November 2022 followed by a report from Dr Narain Nambiar dated 5 December 2022. The two experts provided concurrent evidence on 22 November 2023.

Held; granting the application:

1.The Court is satisfied that the applicant is both capable of controlling and willing to control his sexual instincts.

2.The applicant is to be released on licence pursuant to s 59(1) of the Act, subject to the conditions suggested by the Parole Board.

Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) s 59(1), s 59(1a)(a) s 59(3), s 59(4a); Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 23(1), referred to.
Hore v The Queen; Wichen v The Queen (2022) 273 CLR 153; R v Slater [2017] SASC 70, applied.

SLATER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (SA)
[2025] SASC 11

Criminal:   Application

MCDONALD J

  1. On 21 April 2017, Kourakis CJ found Mr Slater to be unwilling to control his sexual instincts, as that term was defined for the purpose of s 23(1) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA).[1]  On that basis, his Honour ordered that at the expiration of the term of imprisonment that Mr Slater was serving, he be detained in custody until further order of the Court. 

    [1] Section 23 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) has since been replaced by s 57 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA), which is in substantially the same…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Slater v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Slater v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA), the primary issue before the court was the appropriate sentencing and post-custodial orders for Mr. Slater, who has a significant history of violent sexual offending and substance abuse. Mr. Slater, now 61 years old, has spent most of his adult life in custody and has a diagnosed Antisocial Personality Disorder with psychopathic features. His criminal record includes multiple instances of rape, with a particularly violent incident in 1980 where he acted as the ringleader in the gang rape of a young female hitchhiker. Despite completing a rehabilitation program, experts testified that Mr. Slater’s risk of reoffending remains high, primarily due to his enduring personality traits and continued substance abuse issues.

The court had to decide whether Mr. Slater was suitable for release on parole and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to protect the community. The legal issues centered around balancing the protection of the community against Mr. Slater’s rehabilitation efforts and the potential for successful reintegration. The court considered expert psychiatric evidence that, while Mr. Slater had made some progress in recognizing his risk factors and developing strategies to mitigate them, his superficial engagement with treatment raised concerns about his ability to sustain these efforts in the community.

The court reasoned that despite Mr. Slater's participation in the SBC-me program and some reduction in his overall risk of reoffending, his risk remained high, particularly in the presence of substance abuse or emotional distress. Both Dr. Nambiar and Dr. Raeside emphasized the necessity of closely supervised, step-down accommodation to mitigate Mr. Slater's risk to the community. The court concluded that Mr. Slater's history of non-compliance with parole conditions further underscored the need for stringent post-release supervision.

Ultimately, the court determined that Mr. Slater should be released on parole but with strict conditions to ensure public safety. These conditions included mandatory participation in a rehabilitation program, regular reporting to a parole officer, and restrictions on his freedom of movement and association. The court recognized the importance of Mr. Slater's rehabilitation but stressed the paramount need to protect the community from the significant risk he still posed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In making this assessment the “paramount consideration” is to protect the safety of the community.Mr Slater’s background and criminal record In order to put this application into context, it is necessary to set out some of the more pertinent aspects of Mr Slater’s background and criminal record.Personal circumstances Mr Slater is now 61 years old. He has a lifelong history of disturbed behaviour associated with physical abuse in his childhood, early onset offending, alcohol related violence, and institutionalisation in custodial settings. As one of 13 children, Mr Slater’s anti‑social behaviour commenced at school resulting in him spending periods of time in juvenile detention. He has worked for very limited periods of time, with his longest term of employment being three years in 1999. He has spent most of his adult life in custody.Psychiatric History Mr Slater has been assessed by many forensic psychiatrists over the years. He satisfies the criteria for an Antisocial Personality Disorder with significant psychopathic features.Substance Abuse Mr Slater has a significant history of substance abuse. He has a past history of drug and alcohol abuse including cannabis, amphetamines, heroin, other opiates and tranquilisers. Mr Slater commenced abusing alcohol at the age of 14. By the 1990’s, he was a regular heroin user. Over time, he moved on to use methamphetamines.Criminal Record Mr Slater first appeared in the Adelaide Childrens Court in 1975 for offences of larceny. Since that time his offending has continued unabated with the exception of a period from about 1998 until about 2007. It would appear that during this period Mr Slater managed to sustain a relationship. However, when that relationship ended, he increased his use of illicit drugs and alcohol and recommenced offending. June 1980 offending Mr Slater’s incursion into more serious offending occurred in 1980 when he committed three counts of rape. On that occasion he was involved with five others in the gang rape of a young female hitchhiker. Mr Slater was the first to assault and rape the victim and was described by the sentencing Judge as the ‘ring leader’. For that offending Mr Slater was sentenced to three years and six months imprisonment with a non‑parole period of six months. By current standards that was a very merciful sentence.November 1983 offending Mr Slater was released from custody on 7 April 1983. In October 1983 he committed a further offence of rape. On this occasion Mr Slater had been drinking with his 16-year-old victim. He pushed her to the ground and slapped her face before raping her. At the time, Mr Slater was on parole for the 1980 rape. For this offence Mr Slater was sentenced to two years and six months imprisonment, which was to be served cumulatively on a sentence of two years and six months for housebreaking offences. A non-parole period of three years and six months was fixed. That sentence was increased on an appeal by the prosecution. Mr Slater was resentenced in 1984 to five years imprisonment, which was cumulative on the housebreaking offences. That amounted to a total head sentence of seven years and six months. A non‑parole period of six years was fixed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Nambiar explained that “the real test will be how his learnings translate into the general community. The safest approach to do this would be by a step-down from prison to accommodation where he could be highly supervised, with restrictions placed on him in order to mitigate the risk”.[23][23] Ibid at 13.The evidence of Dr Nambiar and Dr Raeside On 22 November 2023, Dr Nambiar and Dr Raeside gave evidence concurrently. For that reason, it is convenient to deal with their evidence compositely.Risk factors Dr Nambiar identified a number of static and dynamic risk factors relevant to Mr Slater’s risk of re-offending and willingness to control his sexual instincts. The static factors relate to his extensive history of violent sexual offending. The dynamic risk factors currently operating include his “enduring personality style, that being antisocial with psychopathic traits”.[24] Also significant is his reliance on alcohol and substances in order to regulate his emotions.[25][24] 22 November 2023 T4.[25] T4. Dr Nambiar agreed that Mr Slater’s dynamic risk factors had reduced after completing the SBC-me program, however, Mr Slater’s risk of re-offending was at a very high bar before completing the course.[26] [26] T44. Dr Nambiar explained that although Mr Slater is able to identify some of his risk factors and articulate simplistic strategies to mitigate risk, it is unclear whether he will apply these strategies when exposed to these situations in the community.[27] Dr Nambiar emphasised that his engagement with treatment and acknowledgement of his risk factors, although positive, is superficial, and merely the first steps towards controlling his urges.[28] To determine whether Mr Slater has understood the treatment, he must be observed in a non-artificial environment.[29][27] T58.[28] T41, 58, 61, 67, 70.[29] T42. Finally, on the topic of risk factors, Dr Nambiar raised concerns about Mr Slater’s previous poor compliance with parole conditions. Dr Nambiar assumed that in the past Mr Slater had indicated a willingness to comply with parole conditions however had not done so.[30][30] T74. Dr Raeside shared Dr Nambiar’s concerns about Mr Slater’s previous poor compliance with parole conditions and reoffending whilst under supervision. Dr Raeside also generally agreed with Dr Nambiar about Mr Slater’s risk factors. It was Dr Raeside’s evidence that whilst Mr Slater’s identification of his risk factors, and the development of simple strategies to mitigate those risks was positive and reasonable, it was only the initial steps, and at a superficial level.[31][31] T60-63, 65. Dr Raeside agreed with Dr Nambiar and observed that Mr Slater’s recent willingness to participate in the SBC-me program was a significant, positive difference from his earlier indication that he did not want to participate.[32] However, whilst he agreed that the program addressed a number of Mr Slater’s risk factors, he could not conclude whether those risk factors had changed. Dr Raeside observed that although there had been a reduction in his overall risk of re‑offending, that risk was still considered to be high.[33] He said that risk would increase if there was substance abuse or Mr Slater was experiencing frustration and anger.[34] It was Dr Raeside’s view that Mr Slater requires further work and support to reduce his dynamic risk factors in order to be successful in the community, however the skills he has learnt would be best tested in the community environment.[32] T69.[33] T44.[34] T44.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established