Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd v Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

SKYCITY ADELAIDE PTY LTD v VALUER-GENERAL & ANOR

[2009] SASC 289

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bleby

15 September 2009

REAL PROPERTY - VALUATION OF LAND - ANNUAL VALUE

REAL PROPERTY - VALUATION OF LAND - PARTICULAR PROPERTIES AND INTERESTS - LICENSED PREMISES

Appellant operated a casino within the second respondent's council area - second respondent issued a valuation and rate notice for the casino premises - rates based on 'annual value' of the casino premises - annual value calculated by council valuer arrived at by reference to percentage of profit of the casino - whether error of law or of valuation principle - relevance of casino licence - whether licence ran with the premises - whether calculation of rent per square metre appropriate - consideration of appropriate percentage of earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation, amortisation and rent to assess gross rental value - appeal dismissed.

Casino Act 1997 (SA) s 3, s 5, s 5(3), s 6, s 6(2), s 7, s 8, s 9, s 10(1), s 11, s 12, s 13, s 16, s 18, s 21, Pt 4, Pt 4 Div 4, Pt 4 Div 4A, Pt 4 Div 5; Casino Act 1983 (SA); Independent Gambling Authority Act 1995 (SA); Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) s 72(1); Local Government Act 1999 (SA) s 169, s 169(1)(b), s 169(2), s 169(15); Local Government Act 1934 (SA) s 173(14); Valuation of Land Act 1971 (SA) s 5(1), s 22(4), s 25C, referred to.
Fenton Nominees Pty Ltd v Valuer General (1981) 27 SASR 258; Ardoch Pty Ltd v Valuer General (No 2) (2006) 148 LGERA 408; Tooth & Co Ltd v Valuer-General (1953) 19 LGR (NSW) 172; Players Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Adelaide [2001] SASC 369, applied.
Mersey Docks and Harbour Board v The Assessment Committee of the Birkenhead Union [1901] AC 175; Mersey Docks and Harbour Board v The Overseers of the Poor of the Parish of Liverpool (1873) 9 LRQB 84; Cooper v City of Perth [1961] WAR 112, distinguished.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"annual value" of land, "gross annual rental"

SKYCITY ADELAIDE PTY LTD v VALUER-GENERAL & ANOR
[2009] SASC 289

Land and Valuation Division

BLEBY J.

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd (Skycity) is the licensed operator of the Skycity Adelaide Casino (the casino) which operates from premises on North Terrace, Adelaide (the casino premises).

  2. On 2 August 2006 the second respondent, the Adelaide City Council (the Council) issued a valuation and rate notice for the casino premises in respect of the financial year ending 30 June 2007. The rates were based on the annual value of the casino premises, which was assessed at $5,998,500. Skycity, by notice dated 27 September 2006, objected to the valuation in accordance with ss 169(1)(a) and 169(3) of the Local Government Act 1999 (SA). In accordance with the requirements of s 169(5) of the Local Government Act the Council referred the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd v Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd, the operator of a casino, challenged the valuation and rate notice issued by the City of Adelaide, asserting that the annual value calculation was erroneous and the rates were excessive. The City of Adelaide determined the annual value of the casino premises by calculating a percentage of the casino's profit, leading Skycity to argue that this method was both legally flawed and based on an incorrect valuation principle. Skycity contended that the casino licence was tied to the premises and should not have been considered in the valuation process, and further argued that the rent per square metre should have been used instead. The case before the court was to determine whether the City of Adelaide's approach to calculating the annual value was legally sound and whether it adhered to proper valuation principles.

The central legal issue was whether the City of Adelaide had correctly calculated the annual value of the casino premises. The court had to examine whether the valuation was based on an appropriate percentage of the casino's earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation, amortisation, and rent (EBITDAR) to determine the gross rental value. The court also had to assess if the casino licence, which was unique and not comparable to other commercial properties, should have been excluded from the valuation or factored in differently. Moreover, the court needed to decide if the rent per square metre was a suitable alternative method for assessing the annual value of the premises.

The court found that the City of Adelaide's method of calculating the annual value, which involved a percentage of the casino's EBITDAR, was both legally sound and consistent with proper valuation principles. The court held that the casino licence, while unique, did not necessitate exclusion from the valuation process, and the figures provided reliable evidence of the reasonable profits expected from the occupation of such premises. The court concluded that the valuation was neither manifestly excessive nor legally flawed. As a result, the appeals by Skycity were dismissed.

In summary, the court upheld the City of Adelaide's valuation method, affirming that the annual value calculation was correct and the rates imposed were appropriate. Skycity's arguments regarding the exclusion of the casino licence and the use of rent per square metre were not accepted, leading to the dismissal of the appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

There are many other regulatory provisions contained in the Act. I have said enough, however, to indicate that the nature and suitability of the licensed premises and the manner in which the business under the licence may be conducted are highly regulated in many ways, including ways which will have an effect on profits which may be generated by the licensee.The relevant facts There is no dispute as to the relevant facts underlying the valuations in dispute. The casino premises occupy the major portion of a heritage-listed building formerly part of the Adelaide Railway Station. The building is on Crown land abutting North Terrace and a private road known as Station Place. The casino has operated from the same premises since a licence was first granted under the Casino Act 1983. The current licence was granted to Skycity, then known as Adelaide Casino Pty Ltd, on 25 November 1999. All of the shares in Skycity were purchased by Skycity Australia Pty Ltd on 30 June 2000 for $182.553 million, including a cash component of $4.621 million. There were additional capitalised costs of the transaction, including stamp duty, reflecting a total consideration of $185.851 million. In its financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2000 Skycity Australia Pty Ltd attributed a value of $174.312 million to the casino licence. Following the adoption of those financial statements the directors of Skycity reassessed the fair values of the licence and property, plant and equipment and increased the carrying value of the licence to $178.058 million, with a corresponding decrease in property, plant and equipment carrying values. Skycity has stated in its accounts that the benefits of the licence are expected to be realised over 85 years. Value is amortised accordingly each year. I was not informed of the current term of licence provided for in the approved licensing agreement. However, from the amortisation rate and the length of the lease available to Skycity, I infer that it is of the order of 85 years. In accordance with s 6 of the Casino Act the licence granted is in respect of the North Terrace premises. On surrender or termination of the current licence, a casino licence may be granted for different premises.[14][14] Casino Act s 6(2). Skycity leases the casino premises from the Department of Transport, Energy and Infrastructure, formerly TransAdelaide, pursuant to a lease dated 30 June 1998. The initial term expires in March 2025 and is subject thereafter to three rights of renewal of 20 years each. The initial annual rent payable under the lease was $1,457,454. As at 1 July 2006 it was $1,843,781.28 excluding GST. The rent is subject to annual review under cl 5.10 of the lease. Pursuant to that clause, the rent is to be mutually agreed between the lessor and the lessee, but failing agreement is to be adjusted in accordance with increases in the Consumer Price Index (All Groups) for Adelaide. This applies throughout the whole of the term of the lease, including renewals. There is no right to any “market review” based on market rentals for equivalent premises. This would suggest a probable significant long-term advantage to the lessee.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Hayes QC, counsel for the appellant, in support of his argument cited a passage from the judgment of Blackburn J, with whom Quain and Archibald JJ agreed, in Mersey Docks and Harbour Board v The Overseers of the Poor of the Parish of Liverpool:[24]If the hereditaments are such as to afford peculiar facilities for carrying on any kind of business, that facility does, beyond all question, enhance the value of the occupation; but though the profits which may be reasonably expected to arise from such a business no doubt form an element in estimating the enhanced value of the occupation of the premises, the actual profits made do not form any element, except in so far as they afford evidence of what might be reasonably expected to be made from the occupation of premises affording facility for carrying on such a business. For instance, to explain our meaning, there can be no doubt that the annual rent of a shop in Cheapside is higher than the annual rent of a similar shop in a back street; and that the reason why tenants give a higher rent is because of the superior facility for carrying on business there. But the rent and the rateable value of the shop are quite independent of the amount of the shopkeeper’s actual gains. The rateable value is the same whether the tenant is a flourishing trader or is carrying on business at a loss. So, no doubt, in fixing the rent of chambers in one of the Inns of Court, the facility for carrying on the legal profession in them is an element, and an important one, but the actual income of the tenant is not. The chambers command no more rent when let to the Attorney General than they would do if let to a young barrister just called who does not as yet pay his expenses.[Emphasis added].[24] (1873) 9 LRQB 84, 97. Leaving aside the exception referred to in bold, that approach is entirely correct in the case of a shop or barrister’s chambers where reasonable comparisons may be made with rentals charged for like premises. However, that cannot apply here. There are no like premises with which a comparison can be made. Even Skycity in support of its original objection described its business as “a business which is, by statutory mandate, entirely sui generis”. Furthermore, the method adopted by Messrs Brogan and Dudakov does no more than apply the exception emphasised in the passage above. Both valuers agreed that the actual trading figures of Skycity could not be taken without question. Both satisfied themselves that the figures represented fair average management of such a facility. Both in fact made some appropriate adjustments to the bare EBITDAR figures. Once the appropriate adjustments were made, the figures provided good evidence of what “might be reasonably expected to be made from the occupation of premises affording facility for carrying on such a business”. Reference was also made to the judgment of the Earl of Halsbury LC in Mersey Docks and Harbour Board v The Assessment Committee of the Birkenhead Union.[25] That case was concerned with the assessment of net annual value under s 1 of the Parochial Assessment Act 1836. The Lord Chancellor said:[26]Now, my Lords, the first part of the proposition is that you are to rate–what? Not the tenant's trade. … The trade is excluded from valuation by the terms of the statute. You are to rate the premises according to their value; therefore it would be very wrong indeed to rate the trade, or to treat it as you would if you were dealing with the question for the income tax. You are not rating the income–you are rating the premises; so that where you have premises of a similar character with equal facilities for carrying on trade you have a very facile mode of coming to the conclusion what sum would reasonably be given by any tenant from year to year for such premises.It will be noted that the basis on which his Lordship proceeded was that there were premises of a similar character with equal facilities for carrying on trade. That is not the case here. The exception was recognised by his Lordship a little later on:[27]Again, my Lords, I find that Collins L.J. says in the same way: "Hence the rule that in ordinary cases where the standard of rent is applicable evidence of actual profit made cannot be received. But it is equally true that where no such standard of comparison exists, it is legitimate to inquire into the profits actually earned." Again I am compelled to say that I cannot concur with the form in which that proposition is put. It is not a question of deciding what according to the law of evidence is receivable, but what is the natural and ordinary and usual mode by which you can answer the proposition put by the Legislature to the overseers.The criticism of the form of the statement does not affect the validity of the qualification acceded to which has relevance to this case.[25] [1901] AC 175.[26] Ibid 180-181.[27] Ibid 182.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLEBY J
Mr Dudakov’s check valuation by this method is within sufficiently close range also to justify the valuation under challenge.Conclusion For these reasons I consider that there has been demonstrated no error of law or principle of valuation in respect of the annual value adopted by the respondent, and the valuation has not been shown to be manifestly excessive. The appeals are therefore dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLEBY J

Full text does not contain this section.