FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Sky Channel Pty Ltd v Darcy’s Tavern Pty Ltd
[2003] FCA 19SKY CHANNEL PTY LIMITED (ABN 77 009 136 010) and AUSTAR ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED (ACN 068 104 680) v DARCY’S TAVERN PTY LIMITED (ACN 005 712 318) and SHAUN MATHEW BROWN
N 31 OF 2003SKY CHANNEL PTY LIMITED (ABN 77 009 136 010) and AUSTAR ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED (ACN 068 104 680) v FIRST MITMAC PTY LIMITED (ACN 003 805 070) and ALLAN JAMES ASH
N 32 OF 2003GYLES J
SYDNEY
14 JANUARY 2003
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 31 OF 2003
BETWEEN:
SKY CHANNEL PTY LIMITED
(ABN 77 009 136 010)
FIRST APPLICANTAUSTAR ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED
(ACN 068 104 680)
SECOND APPLICANTAND:
DARCY'S TAVERN PTY LIMITED
(ACN 005 712 381)
FIRST RESPONDENTSHAUN MATHEW BROWN
SECOND RESPONDENTJUDGE:
GYLES J
DATE OF ORDER:
14 JANUARY 2003
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
UPON THE APPLICANTS BY COUNSEL UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:
(a)to submit to such order (if any) as the Court may consider to be just for the payment of compensation, to be assessed by the Court, or as it may direct, to any person, whether or not a party, adversely affected by the operation of the orders made on 14 January 2003; and
(b) to pay the compensation referred to in (a) to the person there referred to,
AND NOTING THE UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT OF KATE HARRISON, SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANTS, THE COURT ORDERS:(1)THAT the applicant’s notice of motion dated 14 January 2003 be made returnable instanter.
(2)THAT the hearing of the notice of motion take place during the fixed vacation.
Entry and search of premises and vehicles on or around the premises
(3)THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise, and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises hereafter referred to, permit a total of:
(a)not more than two (2) representatives of the applicants;
(b)not more than two (2) partners or employees of the applicants’ solicitors Gilbert + Tobin
(collectively referred to as the (“applicants’ representatives”); and
(c)a solicitor other than a member of Gilbert + Tobin (“independent solicitor”)
to enter and remain upon the premises at 145 Thompson Street, Hamilton, Victoria (the “premises”) (including the whole of the buildings and any appurtenant buildings, garages or basements on the premises) or in any of the vehicles under the control of the respondents or either of them which may be on or around the premises at any hour between 9am and 7pm on Wednesday 15 January 2003 or 9am and 3pm on Thursday 16 January 2003 and to remain, or if necessary, to re-enter the premises, until the orders have been complied with.
(4)THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises permit the applicants’ representatives to:
(a)search for,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sky Channel Pty Ltd v Darcy's Tavern Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] FCA 19
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the urgency and necessity of the applicants' claims, and the potential prejudice to the respondents if the orders were granted without proper oversight. The court found that the applicants had established a prima facie case for the relief sought and that the balance of convenience favoured the granting of the orders. The court also noted the applicants' undertaking to compensate any person adversely affected by the orders. The court issued detailed orders allowing the applicants' representatives, along with an independent solicitor, to enter and search the respondents' premises and seize the relevant decoder devices, subject to certain restrictions and oversight by the independent solicitor.
The final orders included provisions for the respondents to permit entry and search by the applicants' representatives, restrictions on the service and carrying out of the orders, and obligations on the respondents to disclose and provide assistance regarding the decoder devices. The court also expedited the proceedings and set the return date for the notice of motion. The applicants were required to undertake to pay compensation to any person adversely affected by the operation of the orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
UPON THE APPLICANTS BY COUNSEL UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:
(a) to submit to such order (if any) as the Court may consider to be just for the payment of compensation, to be assessed by the Court, or as it may direct, to any person, whether or not a party, adversely affected by the operation of the orders made on 14 January 2003; and
(b) to pay the compensation referred to in (a) to the person there referred to,
AND NOTING THE UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT OF KATE HARRISON, SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANTS, THE COURT ORDERS:
(1) THAT the applicant’s notice of motion dated 14 January 2003 be made returnable instanter.
(2) THAT the hearing of the notice of motion take place during the fixed vacation.
Entry and search of premises and vehicles on or around the premises
(3) THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise, and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises hereafter referred to, permit a total of:
(a) not more than two (2) representatives of the applicants;
(b) not more than two (2) partners or employees of the applicants’ solicitors Gilbert + Tobin
(collectively referred to as the (“applicants’ representatives”); and
(c) a solicitor other than a member of Gilbert + Tobin (“independent solicitor”)
to enter and remain upon the premises at 145 Thompson Street, Hamilton, Victoria (the “premises”) (including the whole of the buildings and any appurtenant buildings, garages or basements on the premises) or in any of the vehicles under the control of the respondents or either of them which may be on or around the premises at any hour between 9am and 7pm on Wednesday 15 January 2003 or 9am and 3pm on Thursday 16 January 2003 and to remain, or if necessary, to re-enter the premises, until the orders have been complied with.
(4) THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises permit the applicants’ representatives to:
(a) search for, inspect, test, examine (including with the use of facilities to decode or restore data), photograph or video tape all and any smart cards and set top boxes relating to the display of subscription television (collectively, “decoder devices”); and
(b) remove into the possession and safekeeping of the applicants’ solicitors all or any decoder devices.
Restrictions on the service and carrying out of orders 3 and 4
5. THAT orders 3 and 4 are subject to the following restrictions:
(a) The orders must be served by the independent solicitor, and orders 3 and 4 must be carried out in his or her presence and under his or her supervision.
(b) At the time the orders are served on the respondents or the person in charge of the premises, the independent solicitor will also serve a notice in the form set out in the attached schedule.
(c) The orders do not require the person served with the orders to allow anyone to enter the premises who in the view of the independent solicitor could gain commercially from anything he or she might read or see on the premises if the person served with the orders objects.
(d) Nothing may be removed from the premises until a list of the items to be removed has been prepared, and a copy of the list has been supplied to the person served with the orders, and he or she has been given a reasonable opportunity to check the list.
Obtaining legal advice and applying to the Court
6. THAT before permitting entry to the premises by any person other than the independent solicitor and one of the applicants’ representatives, the respondents may seek legal advice, and apply to the Court to vary or discharge the orders provided that any such application is made promptly upon service of these orders and further provided that if the respondents wish to seek legal advice as permitted by these orders, they must so inform the independent solicitor and keep him or her informed of the steps being taken.
7. THAT while the respondents seek legal advice in accordance with paragraph (a) above, entry to the premises to any person other than the independent solicitor and one of the applicants’ representatives may be refused, and permission for the search to begin may be refused, for a period not to exceed one hour (unless the independent solicitor agrees to a longer period).
Prohibited disclosure
8. THAT forthwith upon the service of these orders, the first and second respondents whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises be restrained from informing any other person of the existence of these orders or their proposed execution, except for the purpose of obtaining legal advice, until 5pm on 17 January 2003.
Delivery of items
9. THAT forthwith upon the service of these orders the first and second respondents:
(a) must immediately disclose the whereabouts of, and make available to the applicants’ representatives, all decoder devices in their possession, custody or power whether located on the premises or otherwise; and
(b) provide to the applicants’ representatives such assistance as they may require to carry out the purposes set out in order 4.
Prohibited acts
10. THAT until further order of the Court, the first and second respondents and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises, whether by his, her or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from moving, destroying, altering, concealing, removing from the premises or parting with possession or control of any items which are or could be considered to be decoder devices (except by delivery to the applicants’ representatives in accordance with these orders).
Independent solicitor
11. (a) THAT the independent solicitor prepare a written report about the execution of the orders and as soon as practicable serve a copy of that report on each respondent and present a copy of that report to the Court; and
(b) THAT the independent solicitor be, or be accompanied by, a woman (who may be one of the applicant’s representatives).
Procedural matters
12. THAT the time for service of the applicant’s notice of motion, the application and supporting affidavits be abridged and that service be effected by 3pm on Thursday 16 January 2003.
13. THAT the notice of motion be made returnable before Gyles J at 2.15pm on Friday 17 January 2003.
14. THAT service on the respondents of these orders, the notice of motion, the application and the supporting affidavits be effected by serving a sealed copy on the second respondent or on any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises.
15. THAT entry of these orders be expedited.
16. THAT the respondents be granted liberty to apply on two (2) hours’ notice.
17. THAT the applicants be granted liberty to apply on forty-eight (48) hours’ notice.
18. THAT until further order the first and second respondents may make any application to the Court to the Duty Judge by telephone.
19. THAT the respondents be granted liberty to appear at the return of the notice of motion by telephone in a manner to be arranged with the Court.
20. THAT the proceedings stand over until 2.15pm on Friday 17 January 2003 before Gyles J.
SCHEDULE
1. This order orders you to allow the persons mentioned in the order to enter the premises described in the order and to search for, examine and remove or copy the decoder devices referred to specified in the order. The persons mentioned will have no right to enter the premises or, having entered, to remain at the premises, unless you give your consent to their doing so. If, however, you withhold your consent you will be in breach of this order and may be held to be in contempt of court. The order also requires you to make available any of the decoder devices which are in your possession, custody or power and to provide information to the applicant’s solicitor, and prohibits you from doing certain acts. This part of the order is subject to restrictions.
2 You should read the terms of the order very carefully. You are advised to consult a lawyer as soon as possible.
3. Before you, the respondent, or the person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises allow anybody onto the premises to carry out this order you are entitled to have the solicitor who serves you with this order explain to you what it means in everyday language.
4. You are entitled to request that there is nobody present who could gain commercially from anything he might read or see on the premises.
5. You may be entitled to refuse to permit disclosure of any documents which may incriminate you (“incriminating documents”) or to answer any questions if to do so may incriminate you. It may be prudent to take advice, because if you so refuse, your refusal may be taken into account by the court at a later stage.
6. You are entitled to refuse to permit disclosure of any documents passing between you and your solicitors for the purpose of obtaining advice (“privileged documents”).
7. You are entitled to seek legal advice, and to ask the court to vary or discharge this order, provided you do so at once, and provided that meanwhile you permit the independent solicitor (who is a solicitor acting independently of the applicants) and one of the applicant’s representatives to enter, but not start to search.
8. If you, the respondent or the person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises, disobey this order you may be found guilty of contempt of court.
9. If any person with knowledge of this order procures, encourages or assists in its breach, that person will also be guilty of contempt of court.
UPON THE APPLICANTS BY COUNSEL UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:
(a) to submit to such order (if any) as the Court may consider to be just for the payment of compensation, to be assessed by the Court, or as it may direct, to any person, whether or not a party, adversely affected by the operation of the orders made on 14 January 2003; and
(b) to pay the compensation referred to in (a) to the person there referred to,
AND NOTING THE UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT OF KATE HARRISON, SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANTS, THE COURT ORDERS:
(1) THAT the applicant’s notice of motion dated 14 January 2003 be made returnable instanter.
(2) THAT the hearing of the notice of motion take place during the fixed vacation.
Entry and search of premises and vehicles on or around the premises
(3) THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise, and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises hereafter referred to, permit a total of:
(a) not more than two (2) representatives of the applicants;
(b) not more than two (2) partners or employees of the applicants’ solicitors Gilbert + Tobin
(collectively referred to as the “applicants’ representatives”); and
(c) a solicitor other than a member of Gilbert + Tobin (“independent solicitor”)
to enter and remain upon the premises at corner of Livingstone and Lawrence Streets, Mathoura, New South Wales (the “premises”) (including the whole of the buildings and any appurtenant buildings, garages or basements on the premises) or in any of the vehicles under the control of the respondents or either of them which may be on or around the premises at any hour between 9am and 7pm on Wednesday 15 January 2003 or 9am and 3pm on Thursday 16 January 2003 and to remain, or if necessary, to re-enter the premises, under the orders have been complied with.
(4) THAT forthwith upon service of these orders, the first and second respondents and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises permit the applicants’ representatives to:
(a) search for, inspect, test, examine (including with the use of facilities to decode or restore data), photograph or video tape all and any smart cards and set top boxes relating to the display of subscription television (collectively, “decoder devices”); and
(b) remove into the possession and safekeeping of the applicants’ solicitors all or any decoder devices.
Restrictions on the service and carrying out of orders 3 and 4
5. THAT orders 3 and 4 are subject to the following restrictions:
(a) The orders must be served by the independent solicitor, and orders 3 and 4 must be carried out in his or her presence and under his or her supervision.
(b) At the time the orders are served on the respondents or the person in charge of the premises, the independent solicitor will also serve a notice in the form set out in the attached schedule.
(c) The orders do not require the person served with the orders to allow anyone to enter the premises who in the view of the independent solicitor could gain commercially from anything he or she might read or see on the premises if the person served with the orders objects.
(d) Nothing may be removed from the premises until a list of the items to be removed has been prepared, and a copy of the list has been supplied to the person served with the orders, and he or she has been given a reasonable opportunity to check the list.
Obtaining legal advice and applying to the Court
6. THAT before permitting entry to the premises by any person other than the independent solicitor and one of the applicants’ representatives, the respondents may seek legal advice, and apply to the Court to vary or discharge the orders provided that any such application is made promptly upon service of these orders and further provided that if the respondents wish to seek legal advice as permitted by these orders, they must so inform the independent solicitor and keep him or her informed of the steps being taken.
7. THAT while the respondents seek legal advice in accordance with paragraph (a) above, entry to the premises to any person other than the independent solicitor and one of the applicants’ representatives may be refused, and permission for the search to begin may be refused, for a period not to exceed one hour (unless the independent solicitor agrees to a longer period).
Prohibited disclosure
8. THAT forthwith upon the service of these orders, the first and second respondents whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises be restrained from informing any other person of the existence of these orders or their proposed execution, except for the purpose of obtaining legal advice, until 5pm on 17 January 2003.
Delivery of items
9. THAT forthwith upon the service of these orders, the first and second respondents:
(a) must immediately disclose the whereabouts of, and make available to the applicants’ representatives, all decoder devices in their possession, custody or power whether located on the premises or otherwise; and
(b) provide to the applicants’ representatives such assistance as they may require to carry out the purposes set out in order 4.
Prohibited acts
10. THAT until further order of the Court, the first and second respondents and any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises, whether by his, her or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from moving, destroying, altering, concealing, removing from the premises or parting with possession or control of any items which are or could be considered to be decoder devices (except by delivery to the applicants’ representatives in accordance with these orders).
Independent solicitor
11. (a) THAT the independent solicitor prepare a written report about the execution of the orders and as soon as practicable serve a copy of that report on each respondent and present a copy of that report to the Court; and
(b) THAT the independent solicitor be, or be accompanied by, a woman (who may be one of the applicant’s representatives).
Procedural matters
12. THAT the time for service of the applicant’s notice of motion, the application and supporting affidavits be abridged and that service be effected by 3pm on Thursday 16 January 2003.
13. THAT the notice of motion be made returnable before Gyles J at 2.15pm on Friday 17 January 2003.
14. THAT service on the respondents of these orders, the notice of motion, the application and the supporting affidavits be effected by serving a sealed copy on the second respondent or on any person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises.
15. THAT entry of these orders be expedited.
16. THAT the respondents be granted liberty to apply on two (2) hours’ notice.
17. THAT the applicants be granted liberty to apply on forty-eight (48) hours’ notice.
18. THAT until further order the first and second respondents may make any application to the Court to the Duty Judge by telephone.
19. THAT the respondents be granted liberty to appear at the return of the notice of motion by telephone in a manner to be arranged with the Court.
20. THAT the proceedings stand over until 2.15pm on Friday 17 January 2003 before Gyles J.
SCHEDULE
1. This order orders you to allow the persons mentioned in the order to enter the premises described in the order and to search for, examine and remove or copy the decoder devices referred to specified in the order. The persons mentioned will have no right to enter the premises or, having entered, to remain at the premises, unless you give your consent to their doing so. If, however, you withhold your consent you will be in breach of this order and may be held to be in contempt of court. The order also requires you to make available any of the decoder devices which are in your possession, custody or power and to provide information to the applicant’s solicitor, and prohibits you from doing certain acts. This part of the order is subject to restrictions.
2 You should read the terms of the order very carefully. You are advised to consult a lawyer as soon as possible.
3. Before you, the respondent, or the person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises allow anybody onto the premises to carry out this order you are entitled to have the solicitor who serves you with this order explain to you what it means in everyday language.
4. You are entitled to request that there is nobody present who could gain commercially from anything he might read or see on the premises.
5. You may be entitled to refuse to permit disclosure of any documents which may incriminate you (“incriminating documents”) or to answer any questions if to do so may incriminate you. It may be prudent to take advice, because if you so refuse, your refusal may be taken into account by the court at a later stage.
6. You are entitled to refuse to permit disclosure of any documents passing between you and your solicitors for the purpose of obtaining advice (“privileged documents”).
7. You are entitled to seek legal advice, and to ask the court to vary or discharge this order, provided you do so at once, and provided that meanwhile you permit the independent solicitor (who is a solicitor acting independently of the applicants) and one of the applicant’s representatives to enter, but not start to search.
8. If you, the respondent or the person apparently occupying or in charge of the premises, disobey this order you may be found guilty of contempt of court.
9. If any person with knowledge of this order procures, encourages or assists in its breach, that person will also be guilty of contempt of court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GYLES J