SKJ Qld Pty Ltd v Turul Building Services

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

SKJ Qld Pty Ltd v Turul Building Services & another [2024] QDC 109

PARTIES:

SKJ QLD PTY LTD A.C.N. 654 675 180 ABN 64 264 366 846 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SKJ PROPERTY TRUST

(Plaintiff)

v

TURUL BUILDING SERVICES PTY TD ABN 99 626 781 968 TRADING AS TURUL BUILDING SERVICES

(First Defendant)

And

ANDREW STEVEN LAZAR

(Second Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

3149/23

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

5 and 6 June 2024 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 and 6 June 2024

JUDGE:

Porter DCJ KC

ORDER:

IN RESPECT OF THE PLAINTIFF’S APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024:

1.      BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE DEFENDANTS ARE TO PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF:

(A)     PARAGRAPHS 14(A)(I) AND 35(C)(I) OF THE AMENDED DEFENCE; AND

(B)     PARAGRAPHS 37(A), 37(G), 45(B), 45(D) AND 45(E) OF THE AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM.

2.      THERE IS NO ORDER AS TO COSTS IN RESPECT OF THE PLAINTIFF’S APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024.

IN RESPECT OF THE DEFENDANTS’ APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024:

3.      PARAGRAPHS 15, 37, 48(E), 53 AND 55 TO 58 OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM ARE STRUCK OUT, WITH THE PLAINTIFF HAVING LEAVE TO RE-PLEAD BY 20 AUGUST 2024.

4.      BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE PLAINTIFF PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF:

(A)     PARAGRAPH 13(B) TO 13(F) OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM; AND

(B)     PARAGRAPH 35(B)(4) TO 35(E) OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM.

5.      BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE PLAINTIFF PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF THE MANNER OF CALCULATION OF EACH LINE ITEM IN “ANNEXURE A” TO THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM.

6.      THE PLAINTIFF IS TO PAY 70% OF THE DEFENDANTS’ COSTS OF THE DEFENDANTS’ APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024 ON A STANDARD BASIS.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – Civil proceedings in state and territory courts – Pleadings – Striking out – where the defendants apply to strike out parts of the claim and statement of claim – where the plaintiff home owner applies to strike out parts of the first amended defence and counter-claim of the defendants – where paragraph 13(b) of the statement of claim does not adequately particularise the extent to which, or how it is, that claims 1, 2 and 3 fail to meet the requirements of s. 34(1)(b) of the QBCC Act – where paragraph 35(b)(4)(A), (B) and (C) requires the same form of particularisation – where the rolled up allegations of the representations in paragraphs 15 and 37 of the statement of claim do not properly plead the “representations” for the purpose of the s. 18 ACL claim – where, in circumstances where paragraphs 15 to 37 are struck out, the allegations against the second defendant in paragraphs 48E and 53 of the statement of claim would require re-drafting – whether particular paragraphs of the statement of claim be struck out and given leave to re-plead.

COUNSEL:

L. M. Campbell for the Plaintiff

S. P. Taylor for the Defendants

SOLICITORS:

Holding Redlich for the Plaintiff

Wood L&M Solutions for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SKJ Qld Pty Ltd v Turul Building Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of SKJ Qld Pty Ltd versus Turul Building Services, the case presented before the court involved disputes between a homeowner and a building services company regarding the quality and completion of construction work. The homeowner alleged that the work did not meet statutory standards and that misleading representations were made. The defendants, in turn, filed a counterclaim for outstanding payments. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with deciding whether certain parts of the pleadings should be struck out due to insufficient particulars, and if so, whether the parties should be granted leave to re-plead.

The legal issues that arose in this case primarily revolved around the adequacy of particulars in the pleadings. The defendants argued that several parts of the plaintiff’s statement of claim were not sufficiently detailed to meet statutory and common law requirements. They specifically contested the lack of specificity in paragraphs 15, 37, 48(E), 53, and 55 to 58 of the statement of claim, as well as certain paragraphs of the amended defence and counterclaim. The plaintiff, on the other hand, sought further particulars from the defendants regarding specific allegations in their pleadings. The court needed to determine whether these allegations and defences met the required standards of particularisation under the law.

In its decision, the QCAT found that certain paragraphs of the plaintiff’s statement of claim did not provide adequate particulars as required by statute and common law. Specifically, paragraphs 15, 37, 48(E), 53, and 55 to 58 were struck out, as they did not sufficiently detail the nature of the alleged misrepresentations or the extent to which the work failed to meet statutory standards. The plaintiff was granted leave to re-plead these parts of the statement of claim by a specified date. Additionally, the QCAT ordered the plaintiff to provide further particulars for other parts of the statement of claim and the amended counterclaim, and set a deadline for these particulars to be submitted. The defendants were also required to provide further particulars for some of their allegations. The plaintiff was ordered to pay 70% of the defendants’ costs associated with their application.

The final orders of the tribunal mandated that the plaintiff provide further and better particulars of specified paragraphs of the statement of claim and counterclaim by a set date. The defendants were required to provide particulars of their allegations within the same timeframe. The tribunal also ordered the striking out of certain paragraphs of the plaintiff's statement of claim, with the plaintiff being granted leave to re-plead these parts. Costs were awarded to the defendants, with the plaintiff required to pay 70% of these costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

IN RESPECT OF THE PLAINTIFF’S APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024:

1. BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE DEFENDANTS ARE TO PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF:

(A) PARAGRAPHS 14(A)(I) AND 35(C)(I) OF THE AMENDED DEFENCE; AND

(B) PARAGRAPHS 37(A), 37(G), 45(B), 45(D) AND 45(E) OF THE AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM.

2. THERE IS NO ORDER AS TO COSTS IN RESPECT OF THE PLAINTIFF’S APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024.

IN RESPECT OF THE DEFENDANTS’ APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024:

3. PARAGRAPHS 15, 37, 48(E), 53 AND 55 TO 58 OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM ARE STRUCK OUT, WITH THE PLAINTIFF HAVING LEAVE TO RE-PLEAD BY 20 AUGUST 2024.

4. BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE PLAINTIFF PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF:

(A) PARAGRAPH 13(B) TO 13(F) OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM; AND

(B) PARAGRAPH 35(B)(4) TO 35(E) OF THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM.

5. BY 20 AUGUST 2024, THE PLAINTIFF PROVIDE FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS OF THE MANNER OF CALCULATION OF EACH LINE ITEM IN “ANNEXURE A” TO THE STATEMENT OF CLAIM.

6. THE PLAINTIFF IS TO PAY 70% OF THE DEFENDANTS’ COSTS OF THE DEFENDANTS’ APPLICATION FILED 1 MAY 2024 ON A STANDARD BASIS.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.