Siviour-Ashmann v Police No. Scciv-02-163

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SIVIOUR-ASHMANN v POLICE

[2002] SASC 115

Magistrates Appeal

  1. WICKS J

    Background

  2. This is an appeal against the refusal of a Magistrate to treat an offence against s 47B of the Road Traffic Act 1961 as trifling.

  3. On 14 January 2002 the appellant was convicted and penalised for driving a motor vehicle with a prescribed concentration of alcohol in her blood contrary to s 47B of the Road Traffic Act 1961.

  4. The appellant pleaded guilty before the learned Magistrate to driving with a blood alcohol content in excess of the legal limit.  The reading alleged and agreed by the appellant was 0.120 grams of alcohol in 100 mls of blood.

    Facts

  5. On 24 February 2001 the appellant and her male companion for the evening attended at the Mars Bar in Gouger Street, Adelaide.  The appellant’s companion had finished his shift at the Chifley Hotel at 11.45 pm which indicates that they arrived at the Mars Bar at approximately midnight.  The appellant gave evidence before the learned Magistrate that upon arrival she and her companion both ordered a Southern Comfort and Coke alcoholic drink.  She said that later in the night a second round of Southern Comfort and Coke was purchased and consumed and that water was being consumed between each round of drinks.  Later in the evening (at approximately 2.45 am or 3.00 am) a third round of Southern Comfort and Coke was purchased and consumed.  The appellant gave evidence that just prior to leaving the Mars Bar she asked for a glass of water.  Instead, the barman gave her a fruit drink which she assumed did not contain alcohol.  The appellant did not ask and was not told the contents of the drink.

  6. The appellant gave evidence that she commenced to consume the drink handed to her at approximately 3.30 am and that she left the Mars Bar to drive home at approximately 3.40 am.  Her car was some distance away at the Chiefley Hotel at South Terrace, Adelaide.

  7. The appellant was stopped at 4.10 to 4.15 am at a Random Breath Testing Station situated on Anzac Highway.  Her blood alcohol content was taken at 4.50 am and was found to be 0.120 grams in 100 mls of blood.

  8. The appellant was surprised by the reading and two weeks later she made enquiries of the barman at the Mars Bar.  The barman told her that he put alcohol in the last drink which she consumed.  He subsequently made a statutory declaration admitting that he had done so.  The statutory declaration was admitted by consent in evidence in the proceedings before the learned Magistrate.

  9. A Statement of Agreed Facts was put in evidence before the learned Magistrate.  It was agreed in the statement that the drink supplied to the appellant by the barman was an alcoholic drink known as a Citric Rush.  This drink included 40 mls of Vodka and 25  mls of Cointreau for a standard size glass.

  10. It was also agreed in the Statement of Agreed Facts, based on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Siviour-Ashmann v Police No. Scciv-02-163 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Siviour-Ashmann v Police, the appellant, who had pleaded guilty to driving with a blood alcohol content above the legal limit, appealed against the conviction and sentence imposed by the Magistrate. The appellant's blood alcohol level was recorded at 0.120 grams in 100 mls of blood, placing her within the category 2 offence range under Section 47A of the Road Traffic Act 1961. The appeal centred on the appellant's claim that her blood alcohol content at the time of driving was not due to alcohol she had consumed but rather due to an alcoholic drink provided to her by the barman at the Mars Bar in Adelaide, unbeknownst to her.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the appellant's blood alcohol content was influenced by an alcoholic drink she was given without her knowledge, and if so, whether this should negate her liability for the offence. The court had to determine whether the appellant's lack of knowledge about the alcoholic content of the drink she consumed immediately before driving could absolve her of responsibility for the offence. Additionally, the court needed to examine the extent to which the appellant's consumption of alcohol prior to this drink contributed to her overall blood alcohol content at the time of her arrest.

The court, in reviewing the case, considered the evidence provided by the appellant and the statutory declaration from the barman admitting that he added alcohol to the drink served to her. The court found that while the appellant had consumed alcohol prior to the drink in question, the contribution of this drink to her overall blood alcohol content was significant. Despite the appellant's lack of knowledge about the alcohol content of the drink, the court held that she was still responsible for the blood alcohol content at the time of her arrest. The court emphasised that the appellant had a duty to ensure she was not driving under the influence of alcohol, regardless of the source of that alcohol. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant pleaded guilty before the learned Magistrate to driving with a blood alcohol content in excess of the legal limit. The reading alleged and agreed by the appellant was 0.120 grams of alcohol in 100 mls of blood.Facts On 24 February 2001 the appellant and her male companion for the evening attended at the Mars Bar in Gouger Street, Adelaide. The appellant’s companion had finished his shift at the Chifley Hotel at 11.45 pm which indicates that they arrived at the Mars Bar at approximately midnight. The appellant gave evidence before the learned Magistrate that upon arrival she and her companion both ordered a Southern Comfort and Coke alcoholic drink. She said that later in the night a second round of Southern Comfort and Coke was purchased and consumed and that water was being consumed between each round of drinks. Later in the evening (at approximately 2.45 am or 3.00 am) a third round of Southern Comfort and Coke was purchased and consumed. The appellant gave evidence that just prior to leaving the Mars Bar she asked for a glass of water. Instead, the barman gave her a fruit drink which she assumed did not contain alcohol. The appellant did not ask and was not told the contents of the drink. The appellant gave evidence that she commenced to consume the drink handed to her at approximately 3.30 am and that she left the Mars Bar to drive home at approximately 3.40 am. Her car was some distance away at the Chiefley Hotel at South Terrace, Adelaide. The appellant was stopped at 4.10 to 4.15 am at a Random Breath Testing Station situated on Anzac Highway. Her blood alcohol content was taken at 4.50 am and was found to be 0.120 grams in 100 mls of blood. The appellant was surprised by the reading and two weeks later she made enquiries of the barman at the Mars Bar. The barman told her that he put alcohol in the last drink which she consumed. He subsequently made a statutory declaration admitting that he had done so. The statutory declaration was admitted by consent in evidence in the proceedings before the learned Magistrate. A Statement of Agreed Facts was put in evidence before the learned Magistrate. It was agreed in the statement that the drink supplied to the appellant by the barman was an alcoholic drink known as a Citric Rush. This drink included 40 mls of Vodka and 25 mls of Cointreau for a standard size glass. It was also agreed in the Statement of Agreed Facts, based on a report from the State Forensic Science Centre, that the consumption of three glasses of Southern Comfort and Coke by the appellant between 11.30 pm or midnight and 3.00 am would have produced a blood alcohol level of less that 0.05 per cent at the time of driving.The relevant legislation Section 47 A of the Road Traffic Act 1961 defines a “category 2 offence” as an offence against s 47B(1), where the concentration of alcohol in the blood of the convicted person was less than 0.15 grams, but not less that 0.08 grams in 100 mls of blood. The appellant therefore committed a category 2 offence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established