Sitte v Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[1997] QLC 168

 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE

17 October 1997

Re:     Appeal against Annual Valuation
Valuation of Land Act 1944
  Valuation Roll No:  26195/10400
  Local Government:  Redland Shire
  (AV97-246).

R and J Sitte
  v.
  Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources

D E C I S I O N

Background:

This matter relates to land at 4 Seven Oaks Street, Alexandra Hills, Parish of Capalaba, and described as Lot 2 on RP 198381.  The subject has an area of 6,001 square metres, and is located approximately 5 kms south-east of the Capalaba Post Office.  The key issues are the comparison of sales of comparable properties, the percentage increase in the valuation, the method of determining the unimproved value, the impact of overhead powerlines and adjoining public housing.
           The subject has good access to Seven Oaks Street which is part of a "Park Residential" estate with lot sizes averaging about 6,000 square metres.  There is good access to Redland Bay Road which is a major connection road to the southern Bayside suburbs and the Capalaba Commercial Centre, and also to Old Cleveland Road which connects the Redland area and Brisbane CBD.  The subject also has a small frontage to the Redland Bay Road, however the main frontage is to Seven Oaks Street.  Town water, electricity and telephone are all available.  The land is below the level of Seven Oaks Street and falls to the rear.  The subject is used as a single housesite, and is part of an estate which has been developed with large good quality residences.  Immediately to the west of the subject is a timbered Redland Shire Council reserve varying in width from 40 metres in the north to 135 metres fronting Redland Bay Road in the south.  To the west of that reserve is the suburb of Alexandra Hills, a residential area comprising lots of size from 700 square metres to 1000 square metres.  Some homes in the cul-de-sac immediately west of the reserve were built for public housing purposes for the Queensland Housing Department.
           Across the rear of the subject are overhead electricity powerlines which are protected by registered Easement in Gross No 601716074 (E899183) on Easement A on RP 132448, covering approximately 30% of the subject.  The subject is zoned as "Park Residential" under the Town Planning Scheme for Redland Shire of 20 February 1988, and effective at the date of valuation of 1 October 1996.
           The Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources, on 1 April 1997, issued a valuation at $110,000.  Following an objection the Chief Executive confirmed the valuation on 21 July 1997, at $110,000.  The appellants have now appealed that figure claiming the value should more properly be $90,000.
           Doctor J Sitte appeared and gave evidence for the appellants; and Mr J Dewar appeared for the respondent, calling evidence from Mr GW Knight, Registered Senior Valuer responsible for determining the valuation.

Evidence:
           Doctor Sitte claims that there is an inconsistency between the apparent increase in the value of sales of properties in the area,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sitte v Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QLC 168
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land Court of Brisbane, presided over by NG Divett, heard an appeal by R and J Sitte against the valuation of their property at 4 Seven Oaks Street, Alexandra Hills, which was determined by the Chief Executive of the Department of Natural Resources at $110,000. The Sittes argued that the valuation should be $90,000, citing discrepancies in the percentage increase in the unimproved value, the method of determining the unimproved value, and the impact of overhead powerlines and adjoining public housing on the property value.

The court examined several legal issues, including the appropriate method of comparing sales of comparable properties, the percentage increase in the valuation, the method of determining the unimproved value, and the impact of overhead powerlines and adjoining public housing. The Sittes argued that there was an inconsistency between the increase in the value of sales of properties in the area and the large increase in the unimproved value of their property. They also argued that the presence of overhead powerlines and adjoining public housing had a negative impact on the property value.

The court concluded that a large increase in the unimproved value alone is not evidence of an error in the valuation process. The court further found that the preferred method of comparing sales of vacant lots was the most appropriate method, and that the registered senior valuer had applied a reasonable level of care in comparing the sales. The court also found that the presence of overhead powerlines and adjoining public housing had an adequately small impact on the property value, and that the Chief Executive had already sought to provide a conservative quantum of valuation.

The court ultimately found that the appellants had failed to prove their case and had not satisfied the onus of proof that the Chief Executive had made an error in his determination. The appeal was dismissed, and the unimproved value of the property, as determined by the Chief Executive, was affirmed at $110,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established