Sino Dragon Trading Ltd v Noble Resources International Pte Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sino Dragon Trading Ltd v Noble Resources International Pte Ltd
[2015] FCA 1028

Citation: Sino Dragon Trading Ltd v Noble Resources International Pte Ltd [2015] FCA 1028
Parties: SINO DRAGON TRADING LTD v NOBLE RESOURCES INTERNATIONAL PTE LTD, MAXWELL THOMAS BENNETT BONNELL and JONATHAN KAY HOYLE
File number: NSD 1069 of 2015
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 17 September 2015
Catchwords:

ARBITRATION – challenge to arbitrators alleging “justifiable doubts as to their impartiality or independence” – application for court to “decide on the challenge” under Article 13(3) of the Model Law – court has no power to do so when challenge has not been determined by appointing authority and has not been “unsuccessful” – whether residual power exists at common law

ARBITRATION – application for removal of arbitrators on the basis of “undue delay” – meaning of “undue delay” in Article 14 of the Model Law – whether “undue delay” is occasioned by the tribunal deferring a ruling about jurisdiction to the hearing of the arbitration

ARBITRATION – application to issue subpoenas or order production of documents where arbitral tribunal refused to direct production of those documents – whether an order that contradicts a ruling of the tribunal is in aid of the arbitration – whether there is power to make such orders

ARBITRATION – declaration about invalidity of appointment of arbitrators – declaration not sought under Article 16(3) of the Model Law and the conditions of that sub-article are not satisfied

Legislation: International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) ss 2D, 16, 18, 18(3)(c), 23, 23(1), 23(2), 23(3), 23(4), 23(5), 23(6), 23A, 23A(1), 23A(2), 23A(3), 23A(4), 23A(5), 23A(6)
UNCITRALModel Law on International Commercial Arbitration (As adopted by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law on 21 June 1985, and as amended by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law on 7 July 2006) Arts 5, 6, 9, 13, 13(1), 13(2), 13(3), 14, 16(3), 17J, 27
UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (As revised in 2010) Arts 3(4)(a), 4, 4(3), 6(1), 9, 9(1), 9(2), 12, 12(1), 13, 13(2), 13(3), 13(4)
Cases cited:

Cape Lambert Resources Ltd v MCC Australia Sanjin Mining Pty Ltd [2013] WASCA 66; (2013) 298 ALR 666
Cetelem SA v Roust Holdings [2005] ECWA Civ 618; [2005] 4 All ER 52
Compagnie Nationale Air France v Mbaye [2003] RJQ 1040
Compagnie Nationale Air France v Libyan Arab Airlines [2000] RJQ 717
David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corp [1995] HCA 43; (1995) 184 CLR 265
Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 22; (2007) 230 CLR 89
Mitsui Engineering & Shipbuilding Co Ltd v Easton Graham Rush and another [2004] SGHC 26; [2004] 2 SLR(R) 14
NCC International AB v Alliance Concrete Singapore Pte Ltd [2008] SGCA 5; [2008] 2 SLR(R) 565
Sunway Damansara Sdn Bhd v Malaysia National Insurance Bhd & Anor [2008] 3 MLJ 872
Taylor v Owners - Strata Plan No 11564 [2014] HCA 9; (2014) 88 ALJR 473
teleMates (previously…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sino Dragon Trading Ltd v Noble Resources International Pte... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1028
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sino Dragon Trading Ltd, a Hong Kong company, initiated arbitration proceedings against Noble Resources International Pte Ltd, a Singaporean subsidiary of Noble Group, in relation to a contract for the sale of iron ore. The contract contained an arbitration clause, and Noble Resources appointed Mr Mehigan as an arbitrator. Sino Dragon did not appoint an arbitrator, leading the Permanent Court of Arbitration to designate Mr Bonnell as a second arbitrator and appoint Mr Kay Hoyle as the presiding arbitrator. Sino Dragon challenged the appointments of Mr Bonnell and Mr Kay Hoyle, but before the challenge was determined by the appointing authority, it brought this application seeking various orders, including the removal of the arbitrators and the issuance of subpoenas. The court had to decide whether it had the power to decide on the challenge to the arbitrators' appointments, determine the meaning of "undue delay" under Article 14 of the Model Law, and whether it could issue orders contradicting the tribunal's rulings.

The court found that it had no power to decide on the challenge to the arbitrators' appointments since the challenge had not been determined by the appointing authority and was not unsuccessful. The court also found that the tribunal's decision to defer the jurisdictional issue to the hearing was not "undue delay" under Article 14 of the Model Law, and any declaration by the court would be outside the Article 16 regime and subject to appeal. Additionally, the court found that it did not have the power to issue orders that contradicted the tribunal's rulings, as such orders would be in aid of the arbitration.

The court dismissed the application, concluding that there was either no power or it would be inappropriate to exercise power to make each of the orders sought by Sino Dragon. The court emphasised the importance of the International Arbitration Act and the Model Law in governing the arbitration process and found that Sino Dragon's application had the potential to cause unnecessary delay to an arbitration that was not complex. The court also noted that the appointing authority had not been criticised for failing to make a decision on the challenge to the arbitrators' appointments.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is unfortunate that this application was brought in the teeth of the express provisions of the International Arbitration Act and the Model Law. The necessary consequence of this application is the interruption of the orderly arbitration process. This application creates the potential for unnecessary delay to an arbitration which is not complex and in which the principal issues are contractual questions of mitigation, the quantum of some expenses, and an allegation of oral variation. However, the potential disruption has been minimised by the considerable co-operation of solicitors and counsel which permitted this substantial application to be prepared, heard, and decided within two weeks. For the reasons below, the application must be dismissed.The background to this application Sino Dragon is a Hong Kong company. It is in dispute with Noble Resources which is a Singaporean subsidiary of the Noble Group. The companies entered a contract on 9 January 2014 in which Sino Dragon agreed to buy 170,000 dry metric tonnes of iron ore from Noble Resources for a base price of US $119 per DMT (dry metric tonne), inclusive of the freight to ship it to China. Clause 4.1 of the contract required Sino Dragon to open an irrevocable and workable letter of credit on or before 17 January 2014, with any 1st class bank in China or Hong Kong for the amount of the shipment value. Noble Resources says that Sino Dragon breached the contract by failing to open the letter of credit or failing to perform the contract generally. Sino Dragon says that it informed Noble Resources on 23 January 2014 that it (Sino Dragon) had failed to perform the contract. Noble Resources says that, on 23 January 2014, Noble Resources terminated the contract and resold the iron ore to a third party for US $108.50 per DMT. Sino Dragon says that the parties had previously agreed to vary the contract to reduce the sale price of the iron ore to US $114 per DMT. It says that the market price on 24 January 2014 was US $114.95. In its Rejoinder, Sino Dragon says that the market price on 24 January 2014 was US $124.75. On either view, Sino Dragon says that it did not cause any loss to Noble Resources or, which on some authorities is controversially said to be the same thing, Noble Resources did not mitigate its loss. The contract of sale between the parties contains an arbitration clause. Noble Resources served a notice of arbitration on Sino Dragon. It estimated the value of its claim at $1.9 million. Noble Resources appointed Mr Mehigan as an arbitrator. Sino Dragon did not make any appointment. So an appointing authority designated by the Permanent Court of Arbitration appointed Mr Bonnell as a second arbitrator. The two appointed arbitrators appointed a third, Mr Kay Hoyle, as the presiding arbitrator. Sino Dragon challenged the appointments of Mr Bonnell and Mr Kay Hoyle several times. Before the last challenge had been determined by the appointing authority, Sino Dragon brought this application seeking to have this Court “decide on the challenge”. The Model Law power for this court to do so is subject to conditions. One of the conditions is that a challenge under any procedure agreed upon by the parties has been unsuccessful. Since Sino Dragon’s challenge has not been determined, it is not a challenge that has been unsuccessful. There is no separate common law power for this Court to decide on the challenge.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 September 2015, the Tribunal, by Mr Kay Hoyle, contacted the parties and informed them that the Tribunal has decided to “[d]eal with all jurisdictional issues on which the Respondent relies at the hearing on 26 October 2015”. The decision by the Tribunal to defer this matter to the hearing was consistent with this option contemplated by Article 16(3) of the Model Law. The decision by the Tribunal was also made for reasons of apparent efficiency, to allow the Tribunal to consider the issue collectively with other issues. Any power to make a declaration by this Court, either of jurisdiction or of lack of jurisdiction, in the absence of any determination by the Tribunal would be outside the Article 16 regime and therefore subject to appeal. Making a declaration in this case would be contrary to the goal of efficient progress of the arbitration. Conclusion Each of the grounds of this application must be dismissed. There is either no power, or it would be inappropriate to exercise power, to make each of the orders sought by Sino Dragon. The effect of my decision on this issue of the Court’s power is that it is neither necessary nor appropriate for me to express any conclusion on the issues raised by Sino Dragon concerning the issue of apprehended bias. I express the issue as one of “apprehended bias” in neutral terms because there was substantial dispute between the parties concerning the appropriate test to apply and the meaning of s 18A of the International Arbitration Act. The reason why it is not appropriate for me to express any views on this matter is because to do so would usurp the process provided by the International Arbitration Act and Model Law in circumstances in which it is Sino Dragon’s own position that the matter is currently before the appointing authority. The pejorative overtones of counsel’s submission that the appointing authority has “held his hand” (ts 73) and delayed in making any decision concerning the challenge must be rejected. Even assuming (which I do not decide) that an election has been made by Sino Dragon under Article 13(4), the appointing authority was only notified of the issue a week before this application was brought. The 15 day period for the parties to agree to the challenge, or for the arbitrator to withdraw, had not even expired when this application was brought before this Court. On no view could the appointing authority be criticised for failing to make a decision on a matter, without submissions, while the same issue was being raised in this Court by the challenging party.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Noble Resources took an active part in this application. But Mr Bonnell and Mr Kay Hoyle filed only submitting appearances. Although, at some points, the oral submissions by counsel for Sino Dragon might have been construed as questioning this course (ts 41-42), it was entirely proper for Mr Bonnell and Mr Kay Hoyle to submit to any decision to be made by the Court, and not to oppose the application which concerned a challenge to their appointments.Key matters in the arbitration timeline As I have explained, this case concerns a contractual dispute. The governing law of the contract is the law of Western Australia (cl 40.1). Clause 39 of the contract is concerned with dispute resolution. It provides in cl 39.2 for the referral to arbitration in Australia, after a period of time, for any “dispute, controversy or claim arising out of, under, in connection with or in relation this Contract”. Clause 39.2 provides that the arbitration is to be conducted in accordance with the prevailing UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, the language of the arbitration shall be English, and the Tribunal shall consist of three arbitrators. Articles 3(4)(a) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules provides that a notice of arbitration may also include a proposal for the designation of an appointing authority. Article 6(1) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules provides that if the parties have not already agreed on the choice of an appointing authority, a party can propose the name of an appointing authority. On 1 May 2014, Noble Resources served a notice of arbitration on Sino Dragon. Noble Resources estimated the value of its claim to be $1.9 million. In the notice, Noble Resources proposed the designation of the Australian Centre for International Commercial Arbitration as appointing authority. In the notice of arbitration, Noble Resources also appointed Mr Mehigan as a member of the Tribunal. On 8 July 2014, the solicitors for Noble Resources wrote to the Permanent Court of Arbitration in the Hague. The solicitors said that Sino Dragon had failed to respond to the notice of arbitration within 30 days. They referred to Article 4 of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules which provides in Article 4(3) that “the constitution of the arbitral tribunal shall not be hindered by any controversy with respect to the respondent’s failure to communicate a response to the notice of arbitration …”. Article 9(2) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules also provides that:If within 30 days after the receipt of a party’s notification of the appointment of an arbitrator the other party has not notified the first party of the arbitrator it has appointed, the first party may request the appointing authority to appoint the second arbitrator. Noble Resources requested that the Secretary-General of the Permanent Court of Arbitration designate the appointing authority. Noble Resources also requested that the appointing authority be the Australian Centre for International Commercial Arbitration. On 23 July 2014, the Permanent Court of Arbitration wrote to Sino Dragon and to the solicitors for Noble Resources. The Permanent Court referred to the request for an appointment of an appointing authority and invited Sino Dragon to respond by 7 August 2014. There is no evidence that Sino Dragon responded.