SingTel Optus Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (No. 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SingTel Optus Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (No. 1) [2006] FCA 1752

Blomley v Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362 referred to
Commonwealth Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447 referred to
Crest Homes Plc v Marks (1987) 1 AC 829 cited
Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd v Bridgelands Securities Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 217 applied

SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LIMITED AND OPTUS NETWORKS PTY LIMITED v TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
NSD 1087  OF 1997

EDMONDS J
15 DECEMBER 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1087  OF 1997

BETWEEN:

SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LIMITED
First Applicant

OPTUS NETWORKS PTY LIMITED
Second Applicant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 DECEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave be granted to the applicants to file in Court an amended notice of motion moving the Court for a further, or alternative, order that leave be granted to the applicants for the use of pars 86 – 93 and 166 – 177 of, and attachments ‘SL8-C’ and ‘SL26-C’ to the Lee Outline (as referred to in orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995).

2.Leave be granted to the applicants to file and serve a Second Further Amended Application and Third Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim substantially in the form of the documents reproduced at pages 15 – 148 of Exhibit BEH-2 to the Affidavit of Bruce Eric Hambrett sworn 8 May 2006.

3.Leave be granted to the applicants for the use of pars 86 – 93 and 166 – 177 of, and attachments ‘SL8-C’ and ‘SL26-C’ to the Lee Outline (as referred to in orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995).

4.The respondent’s costs thrown away by the amendment be reserved.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1087  OF 1997

BETWEEN:

SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LIMITED
First Applicant

OPTUS NETWORKS PTY LIMITED
Second Applicant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE:

15 DECEMBER 2006

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (NO. 1)

THE MOTION

  1. This is a motion on notice filed 8 May 2006 whereby the applicants (together ‘Optus’) move the Court for, inter alia, an order that they have leave to file and serve a Second Further Amended Application (‘SFAA’) and a Third Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim (‘TCASC’) substantially in the form of the documents reproduced at pages 15 to 148 of Exhibit BEH-2 to the affidavit of Bruce Eric Hambrett sworn 8 May 2006 which was read by Optus in support of the motion (the affidavit and Exhibit BEH-2 being Ex. 2).

  2. At the outset of the hearing of the motion, Senior Counsel for Optus handed up a form of amended notice of motion, which is an attachment to Optus’ submissions filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SingTel Optus Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (No. 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1752
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

SingTel Optus Pty Ltd and Telstra Corporation Ltd appeared before the Court in a matter concerning the use of certain documents, specifically parts of the Lee Outline, in the current proceedings. Optus sought leave to file and serve a Second Further Amended Application and Third Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim, which would include references to parts 86-93 and 166-177 of, and attachments 'SL8-C' and 'SL26-C' to the Lee Outline. Telstra opposed the motion on the grounds that Optus was not entitled to rely on the Lee Outline in these proceedings and that Optus' claim for relief for unconscionable conduct was time-barred or inadequately pleaded.

The Court considered the arguments presented by both parties and examined the nature of the dispute resolution procedures outlined in the Access Agreement. The Court concluded that court proceedings, including interlocutory ones, were outside the scope of the dispute resolution procedures set out in the Access Agreement. Consequently, the use of the Lee Outline in the current proceedings was not within the terms of the leave granted by Lockhart J on 26 July 1996. However, the Court also found that 'special circumstances' existed to warrant leave being granted to Optus to use the Lee Outline in the current proceedings, as per the precedent set by Burchett J in Holpitt Pty Ltd v Varimu Pty Ltd.

Based on the reasoning provided, the Court granted Optus leave to file an amended notice of motion, a Second Further Amended Application, and a Third Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim that included references to the specified parts of the Lee Outline. The Court also granted leave for the use of the Lee Outline in the current proceedings, reserving the respondent's costs thrown away by the amendment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to the applicants to file in Court an amended notice of motion moving the Court for a further, or alternative, order that leave be granted to the applicants for the use of pars 86 – 93 and 166 – 177 of, and attachments ‘SL8-C’ and ‘SL26-C’ to the Lee Outline (as referred to in orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995).

2. Leave be granted to the applicants to file and serve a Second Further Amended Application and Third Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim substantially in the form of the documents reproduced at pages 15 – 148 of Exhibit BEH-2 to the Affidavit of Bruce Eric Hambrett sworn 8 May 2006.

3. Leave be granted to the applicants for the use of pars 86 – 93 and 166 – 177 of, and attachments ‘SL8-C’ and ‘SL26-C’ to the Lee Outline (as referred to in orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995).

4. The respondent’s costs thrown away by the amendment be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the outset of the hearing of the motion, Senior Counsel for Optus handed up a form of amended notice of motion, which is an attachment to Optus’ submissions filed on 30 May 2006 in answer to the respondent’s submissions filed on 23 May 2006, moving the Court for a further, or alternative, order that leave be granted to Optus for the use of pars 86 – 93 and 166 – 77 of, and attachments ‘SL8-C’ and ‘SL26-C’ to the Lee Outline (as referred to in orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995) in the current proceedings. The references to ‘the Lee Outline’ and ‘orders made by this Court on 26 July 1996 in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995’ and the relevance of both to the current proceedings will become apparent below. Leave was sought to file the amended notice of motion in Court. It was not opposed.EVIDENCE ON THE MOTION As well as Ex. 2, the relevant background to this proceeding is set out in an anterior affidavit of Mr Hambrett sworn 30 November 2005 (including Exhibit BEH-1) which was also read in support of the motion (the affidavit and Exhibit BEH-1 being Ex. 1) The affidavit was originally filed and served in support of a notice of motion by Optus filed on 30 November 2005, the hearing of which was adjourned and, to one extent or another, I am informed that the orders sought in that motion have been superseded by subsequent events. In support of the motion, Optus also read the affidavit of Colleen Anne Platford sworn 24 September 2001 together with annexures (Ex. 3). In opposing the motion, the respondent (‘Telstra’) read the affidavit of Patricia Anne Henry sworn 23 May 2006 together with Exhibit PAH-3 being a bundle of correspondence and other documents referred to in the affidavit (the affidavit and Exhibit PAH-3 being Ex. A). Telstra also tendered a document on which there was listed nine affidavits/statements of various persons including a statement of Pushpa De Silva dated 18 December 1997 which was also tendered as being relevant to the use of the Lee Outline use (together Ex. B).TELSTRA’S POSITION ON THE MOTION Telstra opposes leave being granted to Optus to file and serve the SFAA and the TCASC on the bases that –(1)Optus is not entitled to rely in these proceedings on the outline of evidence of Stuart Alan Newton Lee dated 5 February 1996 (‘the Lee Outline’) filed in Proceedings No. 731 of 1995 in this Court (‘the 1995 Proceedings’);(2)Optus’ claim for relief for unconscionable conduct pursuant to the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (‘the TPA’) is bound to fail by reason of being time barred under s 82(2) of the TPA or has not been adequately pleaded. The first basis of opposition is a reference to the particulars provided under par (c) (but erroneously denoted sub-par (b)(vii)) to the pleading in [16] of the TCASC and to the particulars provided under par (c) to the pleading in [28] of the TCASC. The second basis of opposition is a reference to the pleading in [79] of the TCASC and the claim made and relief sought in [2](c) and [6] respectively of the SFAA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J
Telstra, in its oral submissions, submits that this latter material indicates that there are no ‘special circumstances’ of the kind referred to in Springfield Nominees to warrant a grant of leave to rely on the Lee Outline.Conclusion and Reasoning I have come to the firm view that court proceedings, whether they be interlocutory or not, are outside the dispute resolution procedures which are to apply to disputes arising under the Access Agreement. I think this follows from a reading of Schedule 7 to the Access Agreement as a whole, and in that context, cll 7.1.1, 7.5.2, 7.5.3 and 7.5.4 in particular. It follows, from this view, that the use of the Lee Outline in the current proceedings is not within the terms of the leave granted by Lockhart J on 26 July 1996, in particular the leave granted by par 2 of the orders his Honour made that day. Such proceedings are not part of the dispute resolution procedures set out in the Access Agreement. This conclusion is fortified by the very existence of par 1 of his Honour’s orders and its reference to the proposed proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Paragraph 1 would not have been necessary if such proposed proceedings were embraced by the leave granted in par 2. On the other hand, I have come to the view that ‘special circumstances’ exist to warrant leave being granted to Optus to use the Lee Outline in the current proceedings, or at least those parts of it referred to in the amended notice of motion. In Springfield Nominees 38 FCR at 223, Wilcox J referred, with approval, to what was said by Burchett J in Holpitt Pty Ltd v Varimu Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 576 at 578 – 579 of the need for ‘special circumstances’ if leave was to be granted – see too Crest Homes Plc v Marks (1987) 1 AC 829 at 860 per Lord Oliver – and as to what that required. Burchett J said:‘As far as the expression “special circumstances” is concerned, it is an expression which is liable to be misunderstood unless care is taken to ask and answer the question, special in relation to what? “Special” is one of those words which derive almost all their meaning from the context … If all that is required is that, among the great number of cases in the court in which documents have been discovered, this one must evince some special feature which affords a reason for releasing or modifying the undertaking, there will be no difficulty. Circumstances in which there is a legitimate reason why documents discovered in one proceeding should be made available in another will, viewed in this way, be rare. In the ordinary course, the ordinary rule should apply, there being no special circumstance to suggest otherwise. Cf Jess v Scott (1986) 12 FCR 187, where the Full Court was concerned with the construction of O 52, r 15(2), by which leave to file an appeal out of time could be granted “for special reasons”. The joint judgment described (at 195) the expression “special reasons” in this rule as:“an expression describing a flexible discretionary power, but one requiring a case to be made upon grounds sufficient to justify a departure, in the particular circumstances, from the ordinary rule prescribing a period within which an appeal must be filed and served.”Of course, if Lord Oliver should be taken to have required the circumstances to be special, not in relation to all the various circumstances of the actions in which the relevant implied obligation has arisen, but in relation to the very small number of cases in which a reason appears why the undertaking might be relaxed, the discretion of the court would be entangled in a rule of quite uncertain import. I do not know on what footing one would say that a particular circumstance among these relatively rare circumstances would be ‘special’ and another not. I do not think his Lordship intended to fetter the court’s discretion in this way. I think he was using the words “special circumstances” to express the same idea which is expressed in the rule discussed in Jess v Scott by the words “for special reasons” …’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J

Full text does not contain this section.