Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Ltd v Singleton Earthmoving Pty Ltd (In Liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read
CITATION:

Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Ltd v Singleton Earthmoving Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2005] NSWSC 1334

HEARING DATE(S): 15 December 2005
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 


16 December 2005

JURISDICTION:

Equity Division

JUDGMENT OF:

Windeyer J at 1

DECISION:

Judgment for plaintiff for $121,726.33.

PARTIES:

Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Singleton Earthmoving Pty Limited (In Liquidation) (First Defendant)
Stuart Karim Ariff (Second Plaintiff)

FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 1251 of 2005

COUNSEL:

Mr R R I Harper SC (Plaintiff)
Mr D Allen (Defendants)

SOLICITORS:

Dutton Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Catalyst Legal Pty Limited (Defendants)

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

- 5 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

WINDEYER J

FRIDAY 16 DECEMBER 2005

1251/05 SINGLETON EARTHMOVING EQUIPMENT HIRE PTY LIMITED V SINGLETON EARTHMOVING PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) & ANOR

JUDGMENT on damages

1 On 30 September 2005 I determined the plaintiff (SEEH) was entitled to possession of three items of earthmoving equipment which the defendant (SE), a company in liquidation, had through its liquidator taken into possession. I stood over the question of damages for wrongful detention and the issues on the cross-claim. This judgment deals with those issues and costs.

2 The evidence on damages is to say the least sparse. However, the evidence of Mr Wood in his affidavit sworn 3 June 2005 has not been challenged and I am satisfied that two of the machines would be continued to be used as they were when seized but that SEEH would have hired them to another company controlled by Mr Wood namely, Quensor, which would have on-hired them to the original contractors. The third machine would on the evidence have continued under the contract to Roche Mining through Quensor as intermediary.

3 The machines were charged out on the basis of an hourly rate for time in operation. It is reasonable to accept the rates and working hours proved for the substitute machines hired to the operators through Quensor. The evidence of those hours up to the end of May 2005 gives the following figures.


      Item Charge Hours Amount

      Excavator $45 888.5 $ 39982.00
      D5 Dozer $45 841.5 $ 37867.50
      Dresser Dozer $45 505 $ 22725.00
      Total $100574.00

      The income lost proved in the same way for the month of September 2005 is $17,396.

4 There is no direct income proved in the same manner for the months of June, July and August 2005. However, there is evidence that the contracts continued so that the replacement machines continued to operate. As the plaintiff has not provided proper evidence an assessment should be made on a reasonable basis erring on the side of the defendant. For that I take the second lowest monthly use figures provided.

5 For the excavator the figure is 150 hours a month. For the D5 Dozer 90 hours and for the Dresser Dozer 34 hours.

6 The figures are as follows:


      Item Rate Hours Total
      Excavator $45 150 x 3 = 450 $20,250
      D5 Dozer $45 90 x 3 = 270 $12,150
      Dressing Dozer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Ltd v Singleton Ear... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 1334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division, Windeyer J delivered a judgment in the case of Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Limited versus Singleton Earthmoving Pty Limited (In Liquidation) and Anor. The plaintiff, Singleton Earthmoving Equipment Hire Pty Limited (SEEH), sought damages for the wrongful detention of three items of earthmoving equipment by the defendant, Singleton Earthmoving Pty Limited (SE), which was in liquidation. The court previously determined SEEH's entitlement to possession of the equipment, and this judgment addresses the outstanding issues of damages and the cross-claim.

The legal issues before the court involved determining the damages for the wrongful detention of the equipment and resolving the cross-claim for monies allegedly owed by SEEH to SE. The court examined the evidence of lost income due to the equipment's detention, the expenses incurred by SEEH, and the validity of the cross-claim. The court found that SEEH would have continued to use the equipment through other companies and calculated the lost income based on the hours the equipment would have been in operation. The court also assessed the expenses associated with the equipment and dismissed the cross-claim due to insufficient evidence and accounting adjustments that needed to be made between the companies.

The court reasoned that SEEH would have continued to hire out the equipment to other companies, resulting in lost income. The court accepted the evidence of the replacement hire rates and working hours and calculated the lost income for the months where SEEH provided evidence, as well as making reasonable estimates for the other months. The court also considered the expenses incurred by SEEH, adopting a conservative approach due to the lack of evidence provided by SEEH. The court dismissed the cross-claim as there was insufficient evidence to support the amount claimed by SE. Finally, the court ordered that the first defendant pay SEEH's costs of the proceedings.

The final orders of the court were as follows: (1) Judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant for $121,811.38; (2) Judgment for the second defendant on the plaintiff's claim with no order as to costs; (3) The cross-claim was dismissed; and (4) The first defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.