Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 1259

File number(s): MLG 302 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 2 December 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Contributory Parent (Migrant) visas -judicial review of decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal not to grant visas – where applicants failed to disclose member of the family in visa application – where the applicants allege that daughter has been legally  “disowned” and no longer part of family unit – whether failure to declare daughter is false and misleading – where failure to meet visa criteria established - whether there compassionate or compelling grounds for waiving public interest criterion – where no grounds for waiver established – application dismissed  
Legislation: Migration Regulations1994 (Cth) cl 173.213, r 1.05
Cases cited:

Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 184

Plaintiff M64/2015 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] HCA 50

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 63
Date of hearing: 19 November 2024
Place: Melbourne
Applicants: In person
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr Orchard; Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 302 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

TARLOCHAN SINGH

First Applicant

SURINDER KAUR

Second Applicant

YUVRAJ SINGH

Third Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

2 DECEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicants’ application for judicial review filed 6 February 2019 be dismissed.

2.The Applicants pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $5,000.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE FORBES

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding concerns an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) on 1 February 2019 to affirm the decision of the Minister’s delegate (the delegate) to not grant the applicants Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) visas.

  2. The applicants are a father Mr Tarlochan Singh (first applicant), his partner Mrs Surinder Kaur (second applicant) and his son, Mr Yuvraj Singh (third applicant). The primary applicant’s first son, Mr Harmanjeet Singh, an Australian citizen, was the sponsor for the applicants’ visa application.

  3. The Tribunal found that in the course of making their application the applicants failed to mention that their family included a daughter, Ms Simranjeet Kaur. The primary applicant maintained before the delegate, the Tribunal and again before this Court that he had “disowned” the daughter and did not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 1259
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Singh and his partner, Indian nationals, sought judicial review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's (AAT) decision to affirm the delegate's decision not to grant them Contributory Parent (Migrant) visas. The applicants argued that their daughter, Simranjeet Kaur, had been legally disowned and was no longer part of their family unit, which they claimed justified their failure to disclose her in their visa applications. The legal issues before the court were whether the applicants' failure to declare their daughter constituted false or misleading information, and if there were compassionate or compelling grounds to waive the public interest criterion.

The court considered the arguments presented by the applicants and the submissions by the Minister. It found that the AAT's decision was based on the incontestable fact that the applicants failed to disclose their daughter in their visa applications. The court agreed with the AAT that disowning their daughter did not sever the parent-child relationship, and that there was nothing in the application forms or relevant legislation that limited the request for information to children in good relationships with their parents. The court also found that the timing and motive for disowning the daughter raised concerns about the genuineness of the action, as it occurred shortly before the visa application was made. The court held that the applicants were responsible for the content of the visa application documents, which were signed by them.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the application for judicial review, affirming the AAT's decision not to grant the applicants Contributory Parent (Migrant) visas. The court found that the applicants had intentionally failed to mention their daughter in the visa application, knowing the information was false or misleading, in order to meet the Balance of Family test. The court also found that the applicants' personal circumstances did not affect the interests of Australia, Australian citizens or permanent residents, or eligible New Zealand citizens, and did not constitute compelling or compassionate circumstances that would justify the grant of a visa.

Background

Background to the litigation

Accordingly, the application will be dismissed. BACKGROUND The applicants are nationals of India. The primary applicant’s first son is an Australian citizen. On 18 October 2012, the applicants made an application for Contributory Parent (Temporary) visas in Subclass 173. The application for the visa which was prepared by the applicant’s representative required the applicant to give details of all “Your children (including step children from both current and previous marriages/relationships and the child sponsoring this application)”. In response to that request the primary applicant listed his son Yuvraj Singh (born 22 March 1988) and his Australian citizen sponsor son, Harmanjeet Singh[1]. They were also listed as his partner’s children[2]. The application did not disclose any other children.[1] Court Book (CB) 15[2] CB 16 In another form, Yuvraj was listed as a dependent of the principal applicant and Harmanjeet was identified as his brother[3]. Again there was no mention of other children of the applicant.[3] CB 26 On 25 April 2014, the Department was sent a completed and signed Form 80 [Personal particulars for assessment including character assessment] on behalf of the each of the applicants. These forms required disclosure of personal information including family members with whom each applicant was associated. Again the primary applicant and his partner disclosed the children Yuvraj Singh and Harmanjeet Singh but no others[4]. In his Form 80[5], Yuvraj disclosed Harmanjeet as his only sibling.[4] CB 56, CB 74[5] CB 95 To meet the requirements for the grant of the visas, the applicants had to meet the “Balance of Family test” in cl 173.213 and r 1.05 of the Migration Regulations1994 (Cth). The balance of family test ensures that visas are granted to parents who have a significant connection to Australia. This connection is measured by how many of the children live in Australia compared to other countries. In simple terms, the balance of family test evaluates whether at least half of an applicant’s children live in Australia (eligible children). A parent satisfies the test if the number of eligible children is greater than or equal to the number of ineligible children. The test must be satisfied at the time of application for the visa. The applicants were also required to meet PIC4020 which, among other things, proscribed the giving of any “information that is false or misleading in a material particular”. Unbeknown to the Department and not disclosed in the visa application material was the fact that the primary applicant had a daughter named Simranjeet Kaur. Also unbeknown to the Department and not disclosed by the primary applicant was the fact that he had initiated a formal process to “disown” his daughter on 11 October 2012, one week prior to lodging the temporary Contributory Parent application. That process involved him filing a notice in the Tribune Chandigarh newspaper in India which refers to his daughter being “disowned from movable and immovable properties”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 25 January 2019, the applicant emailed the Tribunal further evidence. The primary applicant submitted that he had put money into his eldest son’s account to provide financial support for him and his family. The Tribunal was provided with various bank statements including transfers between the father and son. The applicants relied on this information as evidence of compassionate or compelling circumstances warranting the waiver of their requirement to satisfy PIC4020.Tribunal decision On 1 February 2019 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the applicant’s Contributory Parent (Migrant) visas. In written submissions dated 4 November 2024 filed in the judicial review application, the Minister summarises the Tribunal’s key findings. I have carefully perused the Tribunal’s reasons and I am satisfied that the following summary as set out at [10]-[18] of the Minister’s submissions is an accurate record of why the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision:[10] The Tribunal found the applicants’ claims in relation to their daughter to be problematic. It found the “extremely close proximity” of the act of “disowning” their daughter and the temporary visa application suggested it was arranged for the purpose of the visa application and not for any other reason, which brought into question the genuine nature of the action. It also noted that despite the claimed deterioration of the relationship, no attempt was made to “disown” the daughter until the applicants were preparing their visa application. The Tribunal did not consider the fact that the applicants decided to disown their daughter changed the parent-child relationship with the daughter. In this regard, it noted that there was nothing in the wording of the application forms or relevant legislation that limits the request for information to children who are in good relationships with their parents: CB 350-351 [18]-[20]. [11] To the extent that the applicants claimed the court order severed the relationship, the Tribunal considered it significant that the court order was dated 2015 while their application for the temporary visa was made in 2012. It did not consider that the applicants believed that they no longer had a daughter on the basis of a newspaper publication alone. It also noted that the newspaper article and the court order appeared to relate to financial obligations and not custody arrangements. The Tribunal did not consider it sufficient to sever the parent-child relationship for the purpose of r 1.05: CB 351 [21]-[22]. [12] The Tribunal did not consider the newspaper article sufficient, nor did it accept that the applicants believed the newspaper article was sufficient because their agent had advised them that this was the case. It also did not accept that the application had been prepared by an agent, the applicant had made no inquiries and did not know whether the daughter’s name had been mentioned in the application. The Tribunal noted that the applications were signed by the applicants and that PIC 4020 applied even if the form was completed on their behalf. In this regard, it found that they had instructed the false or misleading information to be given: CB 351 [22]-[25]. [13] The Tribunal found that the applicants had failed to disclose their daughter in two applications. It formed the view that they arranged for the daughter to be “disowned” shortly before making the application because they knew they could not otherwise meet the balance of family test. The Tribunal found that the applicants had intentionally failed to mention their daughter, knowing the information was false or misleading, in order to obtain the visa: CB 351 [26]. [14] The Tribunal found that the applicants had “held” the temporary visa at the time the present application was made and therefore within the 12 months before the application was made. It found that the applicants had, by failing to mention their daughter in the various forms for the temporary visa application, given or caused to be given to the Minister or an officer information that was false or misleading, that the information was relevant for the purpose of the family balance test in cl 173.213, and therefore false or misleading in a material particular. The Tribunal found that the applicants did not meet PIC 4020(1)(b): CB 351-352 [27]-[28]. [15] The Tribunal accepted that the applicant provided limited financial support to his son’s family, but was not satisfied that the support was necessary or that alternative arrangements could not be put in place. It accepted that the applicants support the son’s family by other means, including raising the children, but did not consider such arrangements to give rise to compelling or compassionate circumstances. It accepted that an emotional connection may exist between the applicants and their grandchildren, but was not satisfied that such a connection could only exist when the parties live in the same household and found that it could continue even if the applicants were to leave Australia. It found that the applicants’ personal circumstances did not affect the interests of Australia, Australian citizens/permanent residents or New Zealand citizens, and to the extent it was claimed that these circumstances affected the son, it did not consider them to be compelling because the applicants had never held a right to remain in Australia permanently: CB 352-354 [29]-[42]. [16] The Tribunal, having considered the totality of their circumstances, was not satisfied that there were compelling circumstances that affect the interests of Australia, an Australian citizen or permanent resident, or an eligible New Zealand citizen that justified the grant of a visa: CB 354 [43]. [17] The Tribunal noted that even if it had found the circumstances put forward by the applicants to be of a compassionate or compelling nature (which it did not accept), it would not have exercised its discretion in circumstances where the misleading information provided was central to the applicant’s eligibility for the visa and their present circumstances arose as a result: CB 354 [44]. [18] The Tribunal found that the requirements of PIC 4020(1) should not be waived: CB 354 [45].Application for judicial review

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

He conceded that the Tribunal and the delegate had considered various arguments they raised, but he did not believe that they did so properly. He said he was looking to the Court for justice.Minister submissions and consideration Mr Orchard on behalf of the Minister submitted that each of the grounds raised by the applicants lacked merit and that the applicants were, in effect, seeking merits review of the Tribunal’s decision. He submitted that nothing raised by the principal applicant in oral submissions was new or revealed judicial error. The Minister submitted that the difficulty for the applicants in this case is the incontestable fact that they failed to disclose their daughter and sister Simranjeet in previous applications. The Minister acknowledges the applicant’s belief that they did not have to do so, but submits that the Tribunal properly found that “disowning” the daughter from various property rights did nothing to change the parent-child relationship. The Minister submitted, consistent with the finding of the Tribunal, that there was nothing in the wording of the application forms or relevant legislation which limits the request for information to children who are in a good relationship with their parents. The Minister submitted that it was open to the Tribunal to express concern about the timing and motive for disowning the daughter. The background facts reveal that the notice disowning Simranjeet was placed in the local paper just one week before one of the visa applications. It is also curious that the principal applicant obtained what appears to be an uncontested court order against his daughter after the delegate received information about her existence as a member of the family. It will be recalled that the applicants were invited by the Department to comment on adverse information arising from the Ration Card and that they then withdrew their application before doing so. It was only after this that the court decree was obtained. The Minister also notes that the court decree which disowned the daughter significantly post- dated the various visa forms and documents in which the applicants failed to mention her existence. Moreover, the court decree related to financial and property matters, not parent/child custodial matters. The Minister submits that these events and evidence reasonably support the Tribunal’s suspicion that the daughter was not disclosed as a family member so that the applicants could meet the Balance of Family test. If the daughter had been included in the various application forms as a member of the family, she would have been considered another ineligible family member for the purposes of the test. By concealing her existence the applicants were able to argue that the number of eligible children was equal to or greater than those who were ineligible. The Minister reiterated that the relevant criteria for the visa included the requirement that the applicants meet PIC 4020, including the prohibition on bogus documents and false or misleading information. The Minister submitted that it was plainly open to the Tribunal to find that the applicants had failed to tell the truth in visa application documentation and that they only had themselves to blame. Although the applicants may have received some assistance from representatives, all documents which required disclosure of family members were signed by them and they were responsible for their content.