Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] FCCA 416

File number(s): MLG 585 of 2017
Judgment of: JUDGE BLAKE
Date of judgment: 10 March 2021
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Administrative Appeals Tribunal – Skilled (Residence) (Class VB) subclass 886 visa – Notice to Produce – the Tribunal using evidence from a different Tribunal proceeding – whether the Tribunal had regard to the actual evidence in the other Tribunal proceeding – whether it was unreasonable not to consider the actual evidence from the other Tribunal proceeding – whether the Tribunal failed to provide clear particulars in breach of section 359A – no jurisdictional error established – application dismissed.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5, 353, 359, 359A, Part 5

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Public Interest Criterion 4020 of Schedule 4

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 91

Cases cited:

FUD18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 1858

Kaushik v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 2850

MZZZW v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and Anor (2015) 234 FCR 154; [2015] FCAFC 133

Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCA 159

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Anor [2018] FCCA 320

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 1443

Number of paragraphs: 79
Date of hearing: 18 and 30 November 2020
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Costello QC
Solicitor for the Applicant: FCG Legal Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr McDermott
Counsel for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 585 of 2017
BETWEEN:

SUKHWINDER SINGH

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BLAKE

DATE OF ORDER:

10 MARCH 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Application filed on 23 March 2017 and amended on 6 November 2020 be dismissed.

2.By 17 March 2021, the Applicant file and serve any material he seeks to rely on and an outline of submissions on the issue of costs.

3.By 24 March 2021, the First Respondent file and serve any material he seeks to rely on and an outline of submissions on the issue of costs.

4.The issue of costs be determined on the papers.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE BLAKE:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ('Tribunal') on 27 February 2017. In that decision, the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the First Respondent not to grant the Applicant a Skilled (Residence) (Class VB) subclass 886 ('visa').

  2. For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant in the present matter is an Indian national. He applied for the visa on 31 July 2008. The Applicant applied for the visa on the basis of working as a Pastry Cook. As part of his visa application, the Applicant provided, among other documents, a written reference from Mr K of Bakers Hut.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) to affirm the refusal of a visa to an Indian national. The applicant had applied for a visa on the basis of working as a Pastry Cook, providing a reference from Mr K of Bakers Hut and a skills assessment from Trades Recognition Australia. The Department of Immigration and Border Protection had raised concerns that the applicant may have provided a "bogus document" under section 5 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), specifically relating to the work reference.

The applicant sought to challenge the Tribunal's decision on two grounds. Firstly, the applicant contended that the Tribunal failed to provide adequate particulars of the evidence of Mr K, given in a separate proceeding (Proceeding 1215933), to the applicant, in breach of section 359A of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). Secondly, the applicant argued that the Tribunal failed to conduct the review reasonably and in accordance with Part 5 of the Act, specifically by transposing evidence and findings from another matter without proper consideration. The evidence of Mr K, given in Proceeding 1215933 concerning persons who had completed more than 900 hours work at Bakers Hut, was central to the Tribunal's decision to refuse the visa.

Blake J dismissed the application for review. The Court found that the evidence of Mr K, as extracted from an audio recording of Proceeding 1215933, did not establish that the applicant had provided a bogus document. Mr K's evidence indicated that he had agreed to take on one to two voluntary students to assist with cleaning and other tasks at his 24-hour bakery, and that the applicant, Jay Sharma, was one of these students. Mr K could not recall the names of the first two students, but stated that Jay was his third or fourth student. Crucially, Mr K's evidence did not suggest that the applicant had been paid for his work or that the reference provided was false. Therefore, the Court concluded that the Tribunal's reliance on Mr K's evidence to find that the applicant had provided a bogus document was not supported by the material before it. The applicant's grounds of review were not made out.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.BACKGROUND The Applicant in the present matter is an Indian national. He applied for the visa on 31 July 2008. The Applicant applied for the visa on the basis of working as a Pastry Cook. As part of his visa application, the Applicant provided, among other documents, a written reference from Mr K of Bakers Hut. In the reference, Mr K confirmed the Applicant worked more than 900 hours between 2006 and 2008. Also supplied was a skills assessment from Trades Recognition Australia ('TRA'). On 11 October 2012, the Department wrote to the Applicant and invited him to comment on whether he could satisfy Public Interest Criterion 4020 of Schedule 4 to the Migration Regulations 1994 ('PIC 4020'). The Applicant was advised he may have provided a 'bogus document' as defined in section 5 of the Migration Act 1958 ('Act') which would result in his failing to satisfy PIC 4020. The Applicant was informed, inter alia, that another person, CA, had been found guilty of manufacturing and selling work references from Bakers Hut. The Applicant's representative provided a response and a statement of the Applicant on 9 November 2012. On 16 September 2014, a delegate of the First Respondent ('delegate') refused to grant the Applicant the visa. On 6 October 2014, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate's decision. On 22 June 2015, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. On 17 July 2015, the Applicant applied to this Court for review of the Tribunal's decision. On 6 April 2016, consent orders were made by Judge Harland of this Court which quashed and remitted the decision back to the Tribunal. On 28 April 2016, the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for re-consideration. On 11 January 2017, the Applicant was invited to attend a hearing at the Tribunal on 2 February 2017. On 18 January 2017, the Tribunal wrote to the Applicant and invited him to comment on adverse information, being that he provided a bogus document to the First Respondent. On 31 January 2017, the Applicant provided his response and comments to the Tribunal's letter regarding adverse information. The Applicant attended the hearing at the Tribunal on 2 February 2017. The Applicant provided further submissions to the Tribunal on 8 February 2017. On 27 February 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the Applicant the visa. The Applicant subsequently filed an application in this Court on 23 March 2017, seeking judicial review of the Tribunal's decision. An affidavit was filed in support of the Application, annexing the Tribunal's decision. The material before the Court in relation to this matter comprises the following. From the Applicant, an amended Application ('Application'), written submissions, supplementary written submissions, an affidavit of the Applicant, and two affidavits of the Applicant's solicitor. From the Minister, a Response, written submissions, two affidavits from the Minister's solicitor and an extract of the audio recordings from the interview and Tribunal hearing in this matter and in another proceeding in the Tribunal, proceeding 1215933, containing the oral evidence of Mr K in that proceeding. PIC 4020

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Proceeding 1215933 concerned an application for a visa by a person known as Jay Sharma. The evidence of Mr K in Proceeding 1215933 Mr K did not give evidence in the present proceeding before the Tribunal. Mr K had given evidence in Proceeding 1215933 in relation to persons who had completed more than 900 hours work at Bakers Hut. In Proceeding 1215933, Mr K gave evidence. There is no formal transcript of that evidence. What follows is my extract of the evidence, having listened to the recording of DK’s evidence. 'TM' denotes the Tribunal Member and 'K' denotes Mr K (starting from 1 hour, 13 minutes and 57 seconds of the recording): TM:Tell me what it was from the beginning. How you came to know each other etc.K:I was running Bakers Hut at 90 East Street, Glenroy. We’re a 24 hour bakery, we decided to open up as a 24 hour operation. Now in that perspective, [CA] is a gentleman who lived there and worked in the area. He came through as a customer for a while, and I occasionally seen him here and there, popping in and out of the back, myself, because we were constantly baking, every time I came to the front, I used to see him every now and then.TM:When was that? What kind of time period were we talking?K:This is early stages of me opening up the bakery. TM:Which was when?K:6-7 years ago, about 6 years ago. Cos I had the bakery….TM: 2007, is that when you started the bakery?K: I believe so. My memory with time frames are so all over the place.TM: Just to clarify that, did you have another bakery before that? Or was that your first foray into bakery?K: This was my first one, but my father’s been a baker for close to 40 years. [CA] introduced himself from a college that he worked through in the city and he asked me if we, because we knew our operation was a 24 hours operation, he asked if we required any help here. I said, ‘what do you do for a living?’ He said ‘I work at a college, I’m a teacher, so on so forth.’ He goes, ‘I have some voluntary students that need experience in a bakery.’ And he goes, ‘Would you need these people to come through?’ I personally don’t need anyone to come through to pay. But if these people want to come through and give us a hand cleaning and whatever else, because it a constant operation, I seen the beneficial side to it. So I agreed to take on 1-2 people. In the perspective of taking on a couple of people, Jay came through.TM: Was he your first?K: Jay, I believe he was my third or fourth but the first and second people that came through, they came once, twice and I never seem them again. Then Jay came through with another gentleman, there was another gentleman that came through with him, just before him, and he finished upTM: What was his name? Do you remember?K: I was mentioning it before outside. I think his name was Gurdip, I used to call him Sunny cos they had difficult names for me to pronounce. We ever had two people come through. At 1 hour, 18 minutes and 50 seconds of the recording, the following occurs:K:Yeah. Like I stated before, if there was ever two people who came on board who constantly came through to my bakery, and that was Jay himself and this other gentleman, Gurdip or I can’t recall the gentleman’s name. But two other people…TM:has this other person come before the Tribunal? Gurdip? Do you know?K: I don’t know. All I know is that the gentleman used to work for Ansett. After that he got his visa, and he was working for Ansett.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Insofar as apparent relevance is concerned, it is necessary to have some regard to the decision of the Tribunal ('Decision'). The Tribunal refused to grant the visa to the Applicant on the basis of evidence given by Mr K in Proceeding 1215933. I have summarised the evidence of Mr K in Proceeding 1215933 later in these reasons. The Application before the Court ultimately pressed two grounds (Grounds 2 and 3 in the Application, Ground 1 having been abandoned). By Ground 2, the Applicant claims that the Tribunal failed to provide clear particulars of the evidence of Mr K to the Applicant in breach of section 359A of the Act. By Ground 3, the Applicant complains the Tribunal failed to carry out the review reasonably and in accordance with Part 5 of the Act. There is little doubt that the evidence of Mr K formed a central plank of the Decision. Yet when the matter first came on for hearing before me, I had neither the evidence of Mr K before me in Proceeding 1215933 nor any record of the decision of the Tribunal in Proceeding 1215933. In view of the above, I formed the view that the documents sought under the Notice were relevant to the proceeding. The adequacy of the section 359A notice could not be assessed without having regard to what the evidence of Mr K was. Further, the Applicant submitted under ground 3 that the Tribunal did not carry out a review that was reasonable in that it, inter alia, transposed evidence and or findings from another matter without properly considering the evidence itself. In order to assess this aspect of the Applicant's claims before me, it is necessary to have regard to the information that the Tribunal had or did not have in relation to Mr K. For all of the above reasons, I declined to set aside the Notice. The matter was adjourned to allow a period for the documents to be produced, before resuming before me. PROCEEDING 1215933 BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL As indicated, the issues in the present proceeding arise from, inter alia, the use and consideration made by the Tribunal in the present matter of the evidence of Mr K given in Proceeding 1215933, and the decision record of the Tribunal in Proceeding 1215933. Proceeding 1215933 concerned an application for a visa by a person known as Jay Sharma. The evidence of Mr K in Proceeding 1215933 Mr K did not give evidence in the present proceeding before the Tribunal. Mr K had given evidence in Proceeding 1215933 in relation to persons who had completed more than 900 hours work at Bakers Hut. In Proceeding 1215933, Mr K gave evidence. There is no formal transcript of that evidence. What follows is my extract of the evidence, having listened to the recording of DK’s evidence. 'TM' denotes the Tribunal Member and 'K' denotes Mr K (starting from 1 hour, 13 minutes and 57 seconds of the recording): TM:Tell me what it was from the beginning. How you came to know each other etc.K:I was running Bakers Hut at 90 East Street, Glenroy. We’re a 24 hour bakery, we decided to open up as a 24 hour operation. Now in that perspective, [CA] is a gentleman who lived there and worked in the area. He came through as a customer for a while, and I occasionally seen him here and there, popping in and out of the back, myself, because we were constantly baking, every time I came to the front, I used to see him every now and then.TM:When was that? What kind of time period were we talking?K:This is early stages of me opening up the bakery. TM:Which was when?K:6-7 years ago, about 6 years ago. Cos I had the bakery….TM: 2007, is that when you started the bakery?K: I believe so. My memory with time frames are so all over the place.TM: Just to clarify that, did you have another bakery before that? Or was that your first foray into bakery?K: This was my first one, but my father’s been a baker for close to 40 years. [CA] introduced himself from a college that he worked through in the city and he asked me if we, because we knew our operation was a 24 hours operation, he asked if we required any help here. I said, ‘what do you do for a living?’ He said ‘I work at a college, I’m a teacher, so on so forth.’ He goes, ‘I have some voluntary students that need experience in a bakery.’ And he goes, ‘Would you need these people to come through?’ I personally don’t need anyone to come through to pay. But if these people want to come through and give us a hand cleaning and whatever else, because it a constant operation, I seen the beneficial side to it. So I agreed to take on 1-2 people. In the perspective of taking on a couple of people, Jay came through.TM: Was he your first?K: Jay, I believe he was my third or fourth but the first and second people that came through, they came once, twice and I never seem them again. Then Jay came through with another gentleman, there was another gentleman that came through with him, just before him, and he finished upTM: What was his name? Do you remember?K: I was mentioning it before outside. I think his name was Gurdip, I used to call him Sunny cos they had difficult names for me to pronounce. We ever had two people come through.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the Applicant's claims, the Court first addressed the allegation that the Tribunal breached section 359A of the Migration Act 1958 by failing to provide clear particulars of the evidence of Mr K to the Applicant. The Court noted that the evidence of Mr K in Proceeding 1215933 formed a significant part of the Tribunal's decision in the present matter. However, when the matter first came before the Court, neither the evidence of Mr K nor the decision record of the Tribunal in Proceeding 1215933 was available. The Court concluded that the adequacy of the section 359A notice could not be assessed without understanding the content of Mr K's evidence. Thus, the Court declined to set aside the Notice and allowed time for the relevant documents to be produced.

Next, the Court examined whether the Tribunal failed to carry out the review reasonably and in accordance with Part 5 of the Migration Act 1958. The Applicant argued that the Tribunal transposed evidence and/or findings from another matter without properly considering the evidence itself. The Court acknowledged that the evidence of Mr K was central to the Tribunal's decision and, therefore, the Tribunal needed to properly consider that evidence. However, the Court found that the Tribunal's reliance on the evidence of Mr K in the present matter was not unreasonable given the context of the proceeding and the similarity of the facts. The Court held that the Tribunal's decision to rely on the evidence of Mr K was lawful, reasonable, and just.

The Court then considered whether the evidence of Mr K given in Proceeding 1215933 was properly considered by the Tribunal in the present matter. The evidence of Mr K was not given in the present proceeding but was recorded in Proceeding 1215933. The Court examined the content of Mr K's evidence and found that it was relevant to the Applicant's case. The Court held that the Tribunal acted reasonably in considering the evidence of Mr K from Proceeding 1215933 in the present matter, as long as it properly considered the evidence itself.

The Court also assessed whether the Tribunal acted reasonably in transposing evidence and/or findings from another matter without properly considering the evidence itself. The Court found that the Tribunal did not act unreasonably in considering the evidence of Mr K from Proceeding 1215933 in the present matter. The Court held that the Tribunal's decision was lawful, reasonable, and just, as it properly considered the evidence of Mr K and its relevance to the Applicant's case.

Finally, the Court considered whether the decision of the Tribunal in affirming the decision not to grant the Applicant the visa was lawful, reasonable, and just. The Court found that the Tribunal's decision was based on proper consideration of the evidence, including the evidence of Mr K from Proceeding 1215933. The Court held that the Tribunal's decision was lawful, reasonable, and just, and therefore dismissed the Applicant's application for judicial review.

In summary, the Court found that the Tribunal did not breach section 359A of the Migration Act 1958 by failing to provide clear particulars of the evidence of Mr K to the Applicant. The Court held that the Tribunal carried out the review reasonably and in accordance with Part 5 of the Migration Act 1958. The Court also found that the evidence of Mr K given in Proceeding 1215933 was properly considered by the Tribunal in the present matter. The Court held that the Tribunal acted reasonably in transposing evidence and/or findings from another matter without properly considering the evidence itself. Finally, the Court held that the decision of the Tribunal in affirming the decision not to grant the Applicant the visa was lawful, reasonable, and just.