Singh (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Singh (Migration) [2022] AATA 2706 (27 June 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REVIEW APPLICANT:  Mr Dashmesh Singh

VISA APPLICANT:  Ms Rinki Singh

REPRESENTATIVE:  Ms Sara Khodajoo

CASE NUMBER:  2101180

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2015/3388796

MEMBER:Meredith Jackson

DATE:27 June 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the visa applicant a Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) visa.

Statement made on 27 June 2022 at 2:34pm

MIGRATION – Contributory Parent (Class CA) visa – Subclass 143 (Migrant) visa –Health Public Interest Criterion 4005 not met– a valid MOC opinion – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, s 65

Migration Regulations 1994, rr 1.03,1.16, 2.25, Schedule 2, cl 143.230, Schedule 4

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 13 January 2021 to refuse to grant the visa applicant a Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The visa applicant applied for the visa on 17 November 2015. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that she did not satisfy cl 143.230 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations) because the health criteria in Public Interest Criterion (‘PIC’) 4005 of Schedule 4 to the Regulations was not met.

  3. The review applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 27 June 2022 to give evidence and present arguments.

  4. The review applicant was represented in relation to the review.

  5. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.

    BACKGROUND

  6. The review applicant is Dashmesh Singh, born in 1980. He is a citizen of Australia by grant. The visa applicant, his mother Rinki Singh, was born in 1958. Ms Singh is a resident of India. Her other son, Manjeet Singh, who was also an Australian resident, passed away on 26 December 2020. Ms Singh’s spouse, Trilok Singh, and another child live in India. Rinki Singh applied for the visa on 17 November 2015. Trilok Singh is not an applicant for the visa, however non-migrating members of the applicant’s family unit are required to satisfy the health requirement. Trilok Singh was found on 23 November 2020 by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth not to meet the medical requirement for the visa PIC 4005. The visa was refused and the applicant sought review. On 12 April 2021 the review applicant declined the Tribunal’s invitation to seek a further MOC opinion.

    ISSUES AND LAW

  7. The issue in this review is whether each member of the family unit of the visa applicant meets Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4005 as required by the criteria for the grant of the visa. PIC 4005, as it applies to this case, is extracted in the attachment to this decision. It requires the visa applicant, in certain circumstances, to undergo medical assessment and to be free of certain diseases or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2706
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Dashmesh Singh on behalf of his mother, Rinki Singh, against the refusal of a Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) visa (Subclass 143). Rinki Singh, a resident of India, applied for the visa in November 2015. The dispute centred on whether Rinki Singh's spouse, Trilok Singh, who was a non-migrating member of her family unit, met the health requirement stipulated by Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4005.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Trilok Singh satisfied PIC 4005, which requires that a visa applicant and non-migrating family members be free from diseases or conditions that could result in significant costs to the Australian community or prejudice access to health services for Australian citizens and residents. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the Medical Officer of the Commonwealth's (MOC) opinion that Trilok Singh did not meet this criterion was valid, and whether the applicant had complied with requests for medical assessments.

The Tribunal considered multiple MOC opinions, the most recent of which, dated 23 November 2020, estimated the cost of Trilok Singh's potential medical services and pharmaceuticals at $391,000 over five years, significantly exceeding the $51,000 annual threshold for a "significant cost." While the review applicant later provided new medical information suggesting Trilok Singh was in remission and his medication costs were substantially lower, he had declined the Tribunal's invitation to obtain a further MOC opinion on 12 April 2021. The Tribunal noted that Regulation 2.25A of the Migration Regulations 1994 provides that the MOC's opinion is to be taken as correct for the purposes of deciding whether a person meets a criterion.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the visa. The Tribunal found that as Trilok Singh had not satisfied the health requirements of PIC 4005, and the applicant had declined the opportunity to obtain a further MOC opinion to address the concerns raised by the existing opinions, the criteria for the grant of the visa were not met.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.BACKGROUND The review applicant is Dashmesh Singh, born in 1980. He is a citizen of Australia by grant. The visa applicant, his mother Rinki Singh, was born in 1958. Ms Singh is a resident of India. Her other son, Manjeet Singh, who was also an Australian resident, passed away on 26 December 2020. Ms Singh’s spouse, Trilok Singh, and another child live in India. Rinki Singh applied for the visa on 17 November 2015. Trilok Singh is not an applicant for the visa, however non-migrating members of the applicant’s family unit are required to satisfy the health requirement. Trilok Singh was found on 23 November 2020 by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth not to meet the medical requirement for the visa PIC 4005. The visa was refused and the applicant sought review. On 12 April 2021 the review applicant declined the Tribunal’s invitation to seek a further MOC opinion.ISSUES AND LAW The issue in this review is whether each member of the family unit of the visa applicant meets Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4005 as required by the criteria for the grant of the visa. PIC 4005, as it applies to this case, is extracted in the attachment to this decision. It requires the visa applicant, in certain circumstances, to undergo medical assessment and to be free of certain diseases or conditions that may impact on the community. Clause 143.230 of the Regulations requires that if the applicant was not the holder of a Subclass 173 (Contributory Parent (Temporary)) visa at the time of application, each member of the family unit of the applicant who is not an applicant for a Subclass 143 (Contributory Parent) visa must satisfy the public interest criteria mentioned in the item in the table that relates to the applicant. Public interest criterion 4005(1)(ab) requires that the applicant comply with any request by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth (MOC) to undertake a medical assessment.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEHas the applicant complied with a request to undertake a medical assessment (PIC 4005(1)(ab)? At the time of the visa application, the visa applicant was not the holder of a Subclass 173 visa. An opinion of the MOC has been provided on three occasions, on 21 August 2019, on 7 April 2020 and most recently, on 23 November 2020. On each occasion, the MOC formed an opinion that Trilok Singh did not meet the health requirements in PIC 4005. The opinion of 23 November 2020, which is the particular focus of this review being the most recent opinion issued, estimated the total cost for medical services and pharmaceuticals to be at a significant level, that of $391,000 over five years, where the significance threshold is set at $AUD51,000 per year. The review applicant provided the delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. It records that following requests from the Department, advice was received from medical practitioners which was passed on to the MOC for consideration. The delegate states that on 23 November 2020, after taking all additional information into consideration, the MOC determined that Trilok Singh did not meet the medical requirements of PIC 4005. As a result, the visa was refused and the applicant applied for review of the decision.Invitation for a further Medical Officer of the Commonwealth opinion

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Public interest criterion 4005(1)(ab) requires that the applicant comply with any request by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth (MOC) to undertake a medical assessment.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEHas the applicant complied with a request to undertake a medical assessment (PIC 4005(1)(ab)? At the time of the visa application, the visa applicant was not the holder of a Subclass 173 visa. An opinion of the MOC has been provided on three occasions, on 21 August 2019, on 7 April 2020 and most recently, on 23 November 2020. On each occasion, the MOC formed an opinion that Trilok Singh did not meet the health requirements in PIC 4005. The opinion of 23 November 2020, which is the particular focus of this review being the most recent opinion issued, estimated the total cost for medical services and pharmaceuticals to be at a significant level, that of $391,000 over five years, where the significance threshold is set at $AUD51,000 per year. The review applicant provided the delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. It records that following requests from the Department, advice was received from medical practitioners which was passed on to the MOC for consideration. The delegate states that on 23 November 2020, after taking all additional information into consideration, the MOC determined that Trilok Singh did not meet the medical requirements of PIC 4005. As a result, the visa was refused and the applicant applied for review of the decision.Invitation for a further Medical Officer of the Commonwealth opinion On 16 March 2021, the Tribunal wrote to the review applicant to ask whether Trilok Singh wished to obtain a further MOC opinion. The Tribunal enclosed a copy of the MOC opinion of 23 November 2020, which disclosed that Trilok Singh is a 70 year old person with severe multiple myeloma; and that a hypothetical person with the same condition at the same severity would be likely to require health care and/or community services likely to result in a significant cost to the Australian community. The Tribunal offered to arrange for a further opinion to be obtained. The Tribunal advised that, if the review applicant wished to proceed to a further opinion, it was important to provide any new medical information to the Tribunal as soon as possible so that it may be taken into consideration. On 12 April 2021 the review applicant advised the Tribunal that Trilok Singh did not wish to obtain a further MOC opinion. Claims on review On 9 June 2022, the Tribunal wrote to the review applicant inviting him to provide information in support of his claim that the non-migrating family member of the visa applicant, Trilok Singh, met PIC 4005. The Tribunal noted that the review applicant had on 12 April 2021, declined to obtain a further MOC and indicated that if he wished to proceed, any response or information was to be provided by 23 June 2022. The applicant was also invited to a hearing set down for 27 June 2022. On 16 June 2022, the review applicant accepted the hearing invitation. In an accompanying email, his representative described the specified date for receipt of information as “short notice”. On 23 June the representative submitted a support letter from Trilok Singh’s treating physician in India, Dr Gautam Goyal (oncologist) dated 16 June 2022; a medication receipt dated 16 June 2022, a pathology report dated 20 June 2022; and a submission addressing the applicant’s case. The submission stated that the MOC opinion of 23 November 2020 should be re-assessed to determine whether it had been lawfully made. In particular, the representative raised the method of assessment of Trilok Singh’s condition which, she claimed, did not indicate the stage of his cancer and took into account information that was over 14 months old. The representative referred the Tribunal to a medical report and supporting evidence provided by Dr Goyal, in which he stated that Trilok Singh was in “complete remission” and the cost of his medication in India is the equivalent of approximately $AUD200 a month. Further, the submission stated, Trilok Singh had been assessed in India and granted a Visitor visa to travel to Australia in January 2022, with no medical treatment for his multiple myeloma required during the ensuing six-week visit. The representative also stated that Trilok Singh had advised the Department he had no intention of migrating to Australia on a permanent basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the visa applicant has not satisfied the requirements for the grant of the visa, the Tribunal must affirm the decision under review.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the visa applicant a Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) visa.Meredith JacksonMemberATTACHMENTMigration Regulations 1994Schedule 44005(1) The applicant:(aa)if the applicant is in a class of persons specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this paragraph:(i)must undertake any medical assessment specified in the instrument; and(ii)must be assessed by the person specified in the instrument;unless a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth decides otherwise; and(ab)must comply with any request by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth to undertake a medical assessment; and(a)is free from tuberculosis; and(b)is free from a disease or condition that is, or may result in the applicant being, a threat to public health in Australia or a danger to the Australian community; and(c)is free from a disease or condition in relation to which:(i)a person who has it would be likely to:(A)require health care or community services; or(B)meet the medical criteria for the provision of a community service;during the period described in subclause (2); and(ii)the provision of the health care or community services would be likely to:(A)result in a significant cost to the Australian community in the areas of health care and community services; or(B)prejudice the access of an Australian citizen or permanent resident to health care or community services;regardless of whether the health care or community services will actually be used in connection with the applicant; and(d)if the applicant is a person from whom a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth has requested a signed undertaking to present himself or herself to a health authority in the State or Territory of intended residence in Australia for a follow-up medical assessment — has provided the undertaking.(2)For subparagraph (1) (c) (i), the period is:(a)for an application for a permanent visa — the period commencing when the application is made; or(b)for an application for a temporary visa:(i)the period for which the Minister intends to grant the visa; or(ii)if the visa is of a subclass specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this subparagraph — the period commencing when the application is made.…Regulation 2.25A Referral to Medical Officers of the Commonwealth(1) In determining whether an applicant satisfies the criteria for the grant of a visa, the Minister must seek the opinion of a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth on whether a person (whether the applicant or another person) meets the requirements of paragraph 4005(1)(a), 4005(1)(b), 4005(1)(c), 4007(1)(a), 4007(1)(b) or 4007(1)(c) of Schedule 4 unless: (a) the application is for a temporary visa and there is no information known to Immigration (either through the application or otherwise) to the effect that the person may not meet any of those requirements; or (b) the application is for a permanent visa that is made from a country (whether Australia or a foreign country) specified in a legislative instrument made by the Minister for the purposes of this paragraph and there is no information known to Immigration (either through the application or otherwise) to the effect that the person may not meet any of those requirements. Note: For foreign country, see section 2B of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901.(2) In determining whether an applicant satisfies the criteria for the grant of a Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa, if there is information known to Immigration (either through the application or otherwise) to the effect that the requirement in subclause 602.212(2)(d) has not been met, the Minister must seek the opinion of a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth on whether the requirement has been met. (3) The Minister is to take the opinion of the Medical Officer of the Commonwealth on a matter referred to in subregulation (1) or (2) to be correct for the purposes of deciding whether a person meets a requirement or satisfies a criterion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.