Singh and Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

Singh and Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2022] AATA 344 (1 March 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/6743

Re:Mr Singh

APPLICANT

Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:1 March 2022

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – accepted anxiety contributed to a significant degree by employment –– whether reasonable administrative action exclusion applies – condition arose from reasonable administrative action undertaken reasonably – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Comcare v Drinkwater (2018) 260 FCR 150
Comcare v Martin (2016) 258 CLR 467
Comcare v Stewart [2019] FCA 365
Keen v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation (1998) 71 SASR 42
O'Callaghan and Comcare (Compensation) [2019] AATA 4378

Trewin v Comcare [1998] FCA 713

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

1 March 2022

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Singh applied for a review of a decision by the Independent Review Officer of Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (RFTS) dated 3 September 2020 which denied liability for compensation under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act). This determination accepted that Mr Singh suffered from anxiety which was contributed to by a significant degree by his employment with RFTS, however found he was excluded from any entitlements as a result of the operation of the provisions set out in section 5A of the Act.

  2. Mr Singh’s application for review dated 31 October 2020 stated:

    I was suffering by Mental health problem many things was not discussed by my employer regarding my employer.

    18 June 2020 when incident happened a local driver was available and ready to unload my trailer ready to unload my trailer but Jasmine my supervisor forcely and bullied me on 18th June 2020. due to my mental health issue i also not mentioned that issue in my statements. I am still taking medical treatment but recovering. My employer did not reviewed the whole incident fairly.my both supervisor Mat and Jasmine covering each other on their mistake. and giving statements on own favours I didn't get paid 4 months not even paid for my medical bills and even the work I did under the suitable duties. I can provide all my medical documents regarding my mental health. thank you.

  3. At the time of the incident Mr Singh’s was a casual linehaul driver at RFTS, working out of the Derrimut office and traveling between Melbourne and Adelaide three times a week. Mr Singh’s role involved loading and unloading trailers, utilising proper handling techniques, and maintaining accurate completion of paperwork related to freight movements.

  4. Mr Singh’s duties required him to depart RFTS’s premises in Derrimut at 7am Monday, Wednesday and Friday each week, delivering to Woolworths Gepps Cross South Australia at 6pm and re-loading at Smiths, Regency Park at 8pm. Mr Singh would then return from South Australia each Tuesday,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh and Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (Compensat... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation by Mr Singh against Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd. Mr Singh alleged that he suffered from anxiety as a result of an incident that occurred on 18 June 2020, where he was instructed to unload his own trailers after a personal appointment, rather than having another driver assist him. The dispute centred on whether this incident constituted reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner, which would exclude Mr Singh from compensation under the relevant legislation. The decision was made by Ms A E Burke AO, Member.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Singh suffered from a ‘disease’ for the purposes of the Act, and if so, whether that disease arose from reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner in respect of his employment, thereby triggering the exclusionary proviso in section 5A(1) of the Act. While the parties accepted that Mr Singh suffered from anxiety that was significantly contributed to by his employment, the Tribunal's proceedings were confined to the question of whether the actions of his employer fell within the statutory exclusion.

The Tribunal reasoned that the direction given to Mr Singh to unload his own trailers after his appointment constituted administrative action taken in connection with his employment. This action was deemed reasonable because Mr Singh was employed as a casual linehaul driver with a rostered duty to unload at a specific time, and his request for another driver to complete this task could not be accommodated due to a lack of available staff. The Tribunal found no evidence of bullying, noting that while Ms Brocklehurst’s tone was described as ‘strong’, it was in response to Mr Singh’s argumentative and upset demeanour. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded that the administrative action was taken in a reasonable manner.

Consequently, the Tribunal determined that the exclusionary provisions of section 5A(2) of the Act applied, as the incident involved reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner. Accordingly, Mr Singh was excluded from any form of compensation. The Tribunal affirmed the decision to reject Mr Singh's claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The key issues for determination are:(a)Did Mr Singh suffer from a ‘disease’ for the purposes of s 5A(1) and s 5B of the Act?(b)If so, was the ‘disease’ suffered as a result of reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner in respect of his employment, such that the exclusionary proviso in section 5A(1) of the Act applies?EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The independent review officer’s decision of 3 September 2020 sets out the events of 18 June 2020, the findings of the investigation into the incident, and consideration of Mr Singh’s claim:In emails dated 22 June 2020 and 1 September 2020 Mr Bonfield set out that you had telephoned him and requested assistance to get your trailers unloaded as you had an appointment. Mr Bonfield informed you initially that he would see what he could do with respect to arranging assistance with getting your trailer unloaded however if he could not get anyone you would need to return after your appointment. Mr Bonfield then made enquiries as to who may have been available in Melbourne to assist. No-one was available and as a result Mr Bonfield telephoned you and confirmed that he could not get the trailers unloaded by someone else so you would need to unload them following your appointment.The following day you asked Mr Bonfield again whether he could arrange someone else to unload your trailers on 18 June 2020. Mr Bonfield again explored with other drivers their availability to provide assistance and he also checked with RFTS's Wagga Wagga team if they had someone in Melbourne on 18 June 2020 who could assist. Again, Mr Bonfield was unable to obtain the assistance of any other driver to unload your trailers on 18 June 2020. On 18 June 2020 you again telephoned and requested someone else to unload your trailers. Mr Bonfield told you that you would need to unload your own trailers. You became argumentative and resistant despite Mr Bonfield giving you clear instruction and as a result Ms Brocklehurst assumed carriage of the phone call on Mr Bonfield's behalf as he was still training in the position.Ms Brocklehurst also provided an email in response to your claim. She refutes that she was abusive or aggressive towards you. Ms Brocklehurst noted that despite previously being told that there was no one to assist with unloading your trailers you sent an email to Mr Bonfield asking for them to be unloaded. Ms Brocklehurst agreed that she told you:It was your job and you were required to unload the trailers;You were to go to your appointment and come back and unload;In future if you have appointments you are required to take a day off;Do not call with two days' notice making demands;Your lime slot is 4pm and this cannot be changed;Unloading the trailer is a requirement of your job.An investigation was carried out by Mr Shane Tucker on 2 July 2020 to determine the circumstances around your conversations with Ms Brocklehurst and Mr Bonfield on 18 June 2020 and to determine whether the actions or nature of the conversations could be considered to be workplace bullying.The investigation found the following:When you first contacted operations staff on 15 June to request another driver complete the unloading of your trailer on 18 June, you were told there were not any spare drivers available;You are employed as a casual linehaul driver and you undertake three trips per week from Melbourne to Adelaide. You are rostered to unload at MSRDC at 4pm on a Thursday (18 June 2020 was a Thursday);You sent an email on 16 June 2020 with the same request and on 18 June 2020 you again contacted the operations office to request another driver unload your trailers;You were told that you were required to return to work following your appointment and complete the delivery. You subsequently did this although you were delayed due to an incident on the Monash Freeway;As a result of your appointment on 18 June the delivery had to be re-booked and the rosters had to be adjusted;You ran out of hours whilst at the MSRDC and you decided to sleep in your truck, but you had no food or water. Mr Tucker confirmed with you that you lived only a short distance (15-minute drive) from the MSRDC and he questioned you as to why you did not return home for your rest break. You were unable to provide a reason for this;Your work diaries for the period 11 May 2020 to 11 June 2020 were reviewed and the entries were consistent with your roster. With the exception of one Thursday you finished your shift on a Thursday between 5pm and 8pm within Basic Fatigue Management Standards;Ms Brocklehurst was requested to provide her account of the incident. This response is set out above. Ms Brocklehurst confirmed that you were upset and yelling on the telephone on 18 June 2020 and described her tone of voice as strong;Mr Bonfield was requested to provide his account of the incident which is also set out above. Mr Bonfield confirmed that he had attempted to locate another driver but could not find a spare driver to unload your trailer on 18 June 2020. He agreed that you were argumentative towards him and Ms Brocklehurst;Mr Tucker interviewed you on 2 July 2020 about your claim. You were informed you could have a support person present but you declined this offer. Mr Tucker explained the process to you;You provided Mr Tucker with a version of events that was consistent with the statement attached to your claim form. You also raised issues regarding your vehicle being limited to 96kph, timeslots and pay discrepancies. You confirmed that you felt bullied and stressed as a result of the conversation with Ms Brocklehurst;You told Mr Tucker that you are a good worker and you should have been given help with the trailer. You stated that your behaviour was acceptable, and that Ms Brocklehurst should not have told you that your behaviour was unacceptable;You informed Mr Tucker that you would return to work when the doctor said that you could and that you knew your rights. When Mr Tucker queried what you meant by this you told him that he was a company man and that you were going to the Union;You also raised the issue of your suitable duties and you stated that you should be given better duties. Mr Tucker discussed the fact that there were duties available in Wodonga RFTS however you had requested to stay in Melbourne to be close to your family. You then disclosed that your partner was in England and the rest of your family was in India;You subsequently became aggressive towards Mr Tucker and told him that you knew the law and your rights. You reiterated that you were speaking with the Union and then left the room;The Investigation report concluded that:the versions of events in the statements and business records were consistent without major discrepancy;You were working regular duties set out in a documented roster;You made a personal appointment at a time you would normally be expected to work;You requested another driver to finish your shift. Your request was acknowledged but another driver was not available and this was communicated to you;On 18 June 2020 you again requested assistance to unload your trailer however arrangements were made and agreed to by all parties for you to return after your appointment and complete the delivery;On 19 and 20 June 2020 you completed a trip from Melbourne to Adelaide and return;You were given a reasonable management direction by Ms Brocklehurst, the language used in the conversation did not constitute workplace bullying as it was not repeated, unreasonable or a risk to health and safety;Your decision to sleep in your vehicle at the MSRDC was not a reasonable decision given the proximity to your residence and you did not contact the operations team or take reasonable steps to manage your fatigue.ConsiderationExclusionary provisionsLiability for an injury is excluded if it is suffered as a result of reasonable administrative action, taken in a reasonable manner in respect of an employee's employment under section 5A(2) of the Act.In your claim form you allege that your injury arose as a result of bullying by your supervisor who shouted at you over the phone. Your hand-written statement provides further insight into the incident as a whole and it appears to have commenced on 15 June 2020 when you first requested someone else to unload your trailers. You state that you did not receive a response from Mr Bonfield in relation to your request to have someone else unload your trailers on 18 June 2020. However, Mr Bonfield has stated that he told you over the phone on 15 June 2020 that he would check and see if there were any other drivers available to unload your trailer. Mr Bonfield subsequently telephoned you back and informed you that there was no-one else available and that you would need to unload your trailers yourself. Mr Bonfield told you that he would make arrangements with the DC to re-book your slot so that you could unload the trailers after your appointment. In the following days you made further requests of Mr Bonfield to have someone else unload your trailers on 18 June 2020 and again, after making enquiries, Mr Bonfield told you on 18 June 2020 that there was no availability for an alternate driver to do this task, and further confirmed with you that you would be required to return after your appointment to complete the unloading. You became argumentative with Mr Bonfield during this telephone call and as a result Ms Brocklehurst entered the conversation in place of Mr Bonfield as Mr Bonfield was still being trained in his position. Ms Brocklehurst agrees that she told you that it was your job to unload your trailers and that you would need to return after your appointment to do so.Reasonable administrative action includes anything reasonable done in connection with the employee's failure to obtain a benefit in connection with his or her employment (s5A(2)(f) of the Act). I am satisfied that the declinature of your request to have another driver unload your trailers on 18 June 2020 and the direction that you return to work and unload the trailers after your appointment was an administrative action taken by Mr Bonfield (and confirmed by Ms Brocklehurst) in connection with your employment. The benefit that you were seeking was to be able to finish work early on 18 June 2020 without completing your duties and without losing any time from your leave balances.I have had regard to your statement, the investigation report and the statements of Mr Bonfield and Ms Brocklehurst in considering the manner in which this administrative action was undertaken. I find that there is no evidence to support your allegations that you were bullied by either Mr Bonfield or Ms Brocklehurst during 15 to 18 June 2020. Ms Brocklehurst has agreed that her tone of voice was 'strong' on the telephone call on 18 June 2020 in response to your own demeanour which was described as being 'upset and yelling'. Mr Bonfield has also stated that you were being argumentative on 18 June 2020. As such I find that Ms Brocklehurst and Mr Bonfield's actions in discussing the requirement for you to unload your own trailers to have been taken in a reasonable manner.…..I therefore consider that the exclusionary provisions apply to exclude liability in respect of your claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal, having considered all the evidence before it, determines that Mr Singh is excluded from any form of compensation under the Act as it has determined the incident on 18 June 2020 was a reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner for the purposes of section 5A(2) of the Act.DECISION Under section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review to reject Mr Singh claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In summary, the Respondent submitted that Mr Singh made a request for time off work, he was told that this request would be complied with if certain arrangements could be made, and the evidence before the Tribunal shows this was conveyed to Mr Singh. Therefore, the Respondent contended that the discussion between Mr Bonfield, Ms Brocklehurst and Mr Singh on 18 June 2020 was reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner for the purposes of section 5A(2)(f) of the Act and the Tribunal should affirm the determination.CONSIDERATION Neither party sought to present medical arguments as RFTS has accepted that Mr Singh was suffering from anxiety as a result of the workplace incident on 18 June 2020. As such the Tribunal proceedings were confined to a narrow consideration of the issue of reasonable administrative action. As a self-represented Applicant, Mr Singh presented as a credible witness who did not overstate the situation, nor did he attempt to argue with the Respondent about their differing views of the facts. Additionally, both Mr Bonfield and Ms Brocklehurst described Mr Singh as a reliable worker, who they had been able to call upon to assist with numerous tasks. Neither Mr Bonfield nor Ms Brocklehurst expressed any concerns about Mr Singh’s work performance.DISEASE Whilst there was very limited medical evidence before the Tribunal to be satisfied of a diagnoses of Mr Singh’s condition, the Tribunal accepted the evidence of Mr Singh and medical reports that prior to the incident on 18 June 2020 he had not been suffering from any mental health issues. There was little evidence to support the agreed position between the parties that as a result of this one-off incident Mr Singh had suffered a mental health condition of anxiety, presenting with symptoms of agitation, resentfulness, insomnia and lack of concentration. However, as this was not in dispute, the Tribunal adopted the findings of the independent reviewer that:Based on the contemporaneous nature of the events of 15-18 June 2020 with your subsequent attendance at the doctor, I consider that if you had not been told by Mr Bonfield and Ms Brocklehurst that there was no-one else to unload your trailers and that you would have to return to work after your appointment and complete your duties, you would not have suffered your condition of 'Anxiety'. The Tribunal concluded that considering the medical evidence, it was probable that, but for the incident of 18 June 2020, Mr Singh’s ‘significant anxiety’ would not have arisen. The Tribunal was satisfied that Mr Singh’s mental health condition was significantly contributed to by his employment, such that it is a ‘disease’ within the terms of section 5B(1) of the Act.REASONABLE ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION There seems to be no disagreement that the ‘administrative action’ taken in this case was the direction to Mr Singh that he was required to return to work to complete his duties after he had finished with his personal appointments. The Tribunal was satisfied that this was an administrative action as envisaged by the Act.