Singh and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Singh and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 2307 (13 July 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/2237

Re:Harneet Pal Singh

APPLICANT

Minister for Home AffairsAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:13 July 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the Applicant not be refused a Partner (Temporary)(Class UK) visa under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958.

........................[sgd]................................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

MIGRATION – visa applicant – applicant fails character test under s 501(1) of Migration Act – sexual offending – one incident – no other relevant offending – discretion exercised on previous occasion not to cancel visa – risk of re-offending – impact on immediate family members – decision set aside

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 499, 501
Migration Amendment (Character and General Visa Cancellation) Act 2014 (Cth)

Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic)

Cases

Re Cao and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 1261

R v Singh [2010] VCC (Reasons for Sentence of Her Honour Judge Gaynor, 22 May 2008)

Secondary Materials

Direction No 65 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA
Migration Amendment (Character and General Visa Cancellation) Bill 2014 – Explanatory Memorandum – House of Representatives – Circulated by authority of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

13 July 2018

  1. Mr Harneet Pal Singh was born in 1983 in India and is a citizen of that country.  He first came to Australia on 16 October 2006 as the holder of a Student (Temporary) (Subclass 573) visa.  In December 2006 he was granted a Class TU Subclass 573 Higher Education Sector visa.  In August 2012 Mr Singh applied for a Partner (Temporary) (Subclass 820) visa and a Partner (Permanent)(Subclass 801) visa based on his relationship with his now wife, Ms Olivia Gandolfo.  He subsequently made a combined application for a Partner (Temporary)(Class UK) and a Partner (Residence)(Class BS) visa. On 23 March 2018 a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (the Minister) refused to grant this visa on character grounds under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The Applicant, through his legal representatives, advised the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (now the Department of Home Affairs) on 28 April 2016 that it was conceded that Mr Singh had a substantial criminal record as defined in section 501(7) of the Act and, as a result, that he does not pass the character test under section 501(6)(a) of the Act.

  3. The hearing was held on 2 and 5 July 2018.  Mr Sigh was represented by Mr Nicholas Poynder of counsel, instructed by Mr Erskine Rodan, OAM, of Erskine Rodan & Associates.  The Respondent was represented by Ms Ashlee Briffa of the Australian Government Solicitor.  Mr Singh gave evidence and was cross-examined.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 2307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Singh against a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to grant him a visa on character grounds. Mr Singh had failed the character test under section 501 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) due to a past sexual offence. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether to uphold the Minister's decision.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Singh continued to satisfy the character requirements for a visa, given his prior conviction for indecent assault. This involved assessing the risk of re-offending, the impact of his offending on the victim, and the weight to be given to his rehabilitation and remorse. The Tribunal also considered the significance of a previous decision in 2011 where the Department had decided not to cancel Mr Singh's visa on character grounds, and whether legislative changes and a new Ministerial Direction since that time altered the assessment.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Mr Singh had shown remorse and insight into his offending, and had no further criminal history since the incident in 2007, the seriousness of the sexual offence, particularly against a minor, could not be overlooked. Expert evidence from a forensic psychologist indicated a low risk of re-offending, but the Tribunal noted that no psychological instrument could definitively rule out future behaviour. Crucially, the Tribunal considered the impact of Mr Singh's offending on his partner's daughter, who had a vulnerable health condition and relied on Mr Singh for support. The Tribunal found that the risk of Mr Singh's conduct causing further distress to this vulnerable individual was a significant factor.

Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the Minister's decision and remitted the matter to the Minister for reconsideration. The Tribunal concluded that while the character test had not been met, the discretion to grant a visa could still be exercised, taking into account all relevant factors, including the positive aspects of Mr Singh's conduct and his support for his partner, balanced against the seriousness of his past offending.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Gandolfo said, in response to a direct question from the Tribunal, that his paramount concern, when he learned about the conviction, was whether there was a risk to his daughter and he had concluded on basis of the conduct of Mr Singh since he had commenced his relationship with his daughter, that Ms Gandolfo was ‘perfectly safe.’Evidence from professional witnessesMs Carla Lechner, clinical and forensic psychologist Ms Lechner gave evidence at the hearing. She stated that she had first seen Mr Singh in May 2008 and had completed a number of reports on him, in 2008, 2011, 2016, 2017 and 2018. These reports were before the Tribunal. In her 2008 report, written before Mr Singh appeared before the Court to plead guilty to two counts of indecent assault, Ms Lechner wrote (GD, p 336):I note that Mr. Singh has no prior criminal history and has been in no known further trouble since his apprehension… Mr. Singh, who emanates from the Punjabi region in India, had moved to Australia on a student visa, just two months before the incident. It would appear that he was still adjusting to cultural and social differences with a poor grasp of appropriate interaction between the sexes. He is immensely sorry for his actions and the distress he has caused the victim. Mr. Singh does not present with symptoms of an underlying psychological or psychiatric disorder, nor of a psychosexual disorder. His rehabilitation prospects are favourable, especially given the degree of insight that he has developed about his actions. In her 2017 report (GD, p 147), Ms Lechner wrote:There are no psychological instruments that can indicate that there is no risk of any repeat behaviour. However there are attitudinal and behavioural indicators that would indicate the risk is extremely low. These include i) the passage of time with no offending of any nature; ii) the good works conducted by Mr. Singh over the past eleven years both towards his wife and the broader community; iii) his insight in respect of both his offending and the adverse impact that his actions had on the victim and attendant remorse; iv) his lack of underlying psychological and psychiatric problems; and v) absence of a substance abuse problems. Ms Lechner said her opinion was that Mr Singh committed the offences in 2007 because he was unfamiliar with gender roles and somewhat naïve. She said he had a constrained relationship with women at that time and the culture he grew up in did not allow him easily to get to know a person of the other sex. Ms Lechner said she was aware of Mr Singh’s drink-driving offence. It was her view that the Applicant had matured over the last 10 years and has given thought to his offending behaviour. She formed the professional view that Mr Singh was regretful and ashamed. She said it was her view that Mr Singh had a good insight into the nature of his offending and the impact on the victim and was at ‘low risk’ of re-offending. When asked specifically whether she thought Mr Singh was in denial about his past behaviour, Ms Lechner said she did not consider he was in denial. She stated that Mr Singh had a sense of shame and the close relationship he had developed with his (now) wife had ‘heightened his sense of disgust’ about what he had done in 2007.Mr Tim Watson-Munro, forensic psychologist

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Respondent submitted that the nature of Mr Singh’s criminal offending is so serious that ‘any’ risk of similar conduct in the future is unacceptable.2011 decision On 11 November 2010 the Department notified Mr Singh that his visa may be cancelled on character grounds under section 501 of the Act. On 30 March 2011 the Department wrote to Mr Singh (GD2, p 468) stating:After taking into account all relevant considerations, a delegate of the Minister has made a decision not to cancel your visa on character grounds on this occasion. Your current Student (Temporary)(Class TU) Subclass 573 – Higher Education Sector visa will continue to provide you with permission to remain in and re-enter Australia for the period specified in the visa.Please note: this decision does not mean that your case cannot be considered again under s501 in the event of further criminal offending by you.(Emboldening in the original.) Before the hearing, solicitors for the Applicant made submissions that the exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa, having been undertaken in 2011 and determined in Mr Singh’s favour, for the Respondent to, some years later, revisit the matter and exercise the discretion differently was a case of ‘re-prosecuting’. The Tribunal asked both Mr Poynder and Ms Briffa to make submissions on this point at the hearing. Mr Poynder advised that this argument would not be pressed by the Applicant. For completeness, the Tribunal emphasises the following points, which it also made at the hearing. In 2014 the Parliament passed the Migration Amendment (Character and General Visa Cancellation) Act 2014. That Act inserted additional grounds on which a person will not pass the character test, (as set out in the Explanatory Memorandum tabled when the Bill was before the House of Representatives) that is when:·a court in Australia or a foreign country has convicted the person of one or more sexually based offences involving a child, or found the person guilty of such an offence, or found a charge against the person proved for such an offence, even if the person was charged without a conviction. The Act thus has been explicitly amended since the 2011 decision not to cancel Mr Singh’s visa and, in addition, the Minister made a fresh Direction (Direction No. 65) as to how decision-makers should consider section 501 character visa refusals or cancellations. The Tribunal pointed out, and parties accepted, that each application for a visa is properly considered on its own merits by the Department, and freshly so. The solicitor for the Minister also mentioned that Mr Singh’s application for a partner visa, if granted, would provide him a pathway to permanent residence in Australia, which is also a relevant consideration. The Respondent drew the attention of the Tribunal to the recent decision of Senior Member Pintos-Lopez in ReCao and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 1261, which considered the general question of whether a discretionary power can be considered again when a previous decision-maker has exercised it in a particular way. With respect, the Tribunal agrees with the learned Senior Member in his conclusion at [59]:In relation to the Applicant’s third submission, if accepted, that submission would be entirely contrary to the requirement that decision-makers, once empowered by statute to make a decision, must exercise that power independently (not substituting the decision of another) and for a proper purpose, that is, by turning their mind to the decision before them. The Applicant’s third submission proposes, in effect, that a decision be made without consideration and application of the relevant facts that bear upon that decision. I reject that submission.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal had several reports of Dr Simons before it (GD1, p 101 to 111). Dr Simons confirmed Ms Gandolfo’s evidence that she had been on Lithium carbonate and that this drug can cause renal failure and death in extreme circumstances if the taker becomes dehydrated. Dr Simons confirmed that Ms Gandolfo was not currently prescribed this medication but stated that her health was very vulnerable and the pathology of her condition meant she was particularly susceptible to stress. Dr Simons said that Mr Singh had been “remarkable support” for Ms Gandolfo and that such biological anchors were very important with the care of persons with mental health conditions of this nature.Consideration of the DirectionPrimary consideration - paragraph 11.1 Protection of the Australian community The Direction requires the decision-maker to give consideration to the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date and the risk to the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. The Tribunal takes a very dim view of any crimes against the person, and in particular sexual crimes committed, as in this case, against a minor. While the Tribunal notes that Mr Singh was open in his evidence about what occurred during the encounter at the shop where the offending took place, his suggestion that he thought either the victim was closer to his own age or, at least, much older is not plausible. Mr Singh knew that the victim had come to work at the shop on a work experience trial and that she was still at school. He at this time was 23 years of age; he had finished school and on his own evidence had studied for three years at university, gaining a Bachelor’s degree. He was not a callow youth. The victim was aged 15. I do not accept that he could have thought she was close to his own age. The offending was rightly acknowledged by the Applicant and by Mr Poynder in his submissions as serious. Mr Singh did not cavil about that, but was also unable to articulate precisely why he acted the way he did. The most consistent view he has proffered to the Tribunal and in statements at the time is simply that the victim was pleasant towards him and smiled. Her friendly disposition should not have been interpreted as any invitation for him to force himself upon her, causing her significant distress. While I accept (from the evidence of Ms Lechner) that Mr Singh may have been naïve and perhaps unworldly at the time, he was, in my view, old enough and mature enough to know better. The Direction requires me to consider the sentence imposed by the Court. Judge Gaynor imposed a 13-month cumulative sentence for both counts to which the Applicant pleaded guilty. However, Her Honour wholly suspended the sentences on the basis of Mr Singh having no prior criminal history. It is not necessary for the Tribunal to repeat the conclusions of the Judge; noting the concession by Mr Poynder that this was serious offending. However, it is relevant to my consideration that, with a range of sentencing options available to the sentencing judge, a suspended sentence was imposed, which could have been made substantive if Mr Singh re-offended.