Singh and Commonwealth Ombudsman (Freedom of information) [2024] AATA 969 (6 May 2024)
DecisionNumber: 2020/5740, 2020/7746
Division:FREEDOM OF INFORMATION DIVISION
File Number(s): 2020/5740 and 2020/7746
Re:Pravindra Kumar Singh
APPLICANT
AndCommonwealth Ombudsman
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones
Date:6 May 2024
Place:Melbourne
The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.
.............................[sgd]...........................................
Deputy President Britten-Jones
Catchwords
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – review of decision to refuse access to documents related to a complaint lodged with the Commonwealth Ombudsman about the Department of Immigration – claim that documents are exempt under s 42 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 because documents would be privileged from production on the ground of legal professional privilege – further exemptions under sections 47E(d) and 47F – whether disclosure of documents would have a substantial adverse effect on the operations of the office of the Commonwealth Ombudsman – whether disclosure would involve unreasonable disclosure of personal information – whether disclosure is in or contrary to the public interest – whether parts of a document are irrelevant to the access request – decision affirmed
Legislation
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)
Cases
AWB Ltd v Cole (2006) 155 FCR 30
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
Kline v Official Secretary to the Governor-General [2013] HCA 52; (2013) 249 CLR 645Southern Equities Corporation Ltd (in liq) v Arthur Anderson & Co (1997) 70 SASR 166
Secondary Materials
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Freedom of Information Guidelines – Guidelines issued by the Australian Information Commissioner under s 93A of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (November 2023)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Britten-Jones
The applicant is seeking access to certain documents requested under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (FOI Act). He is a citizen of Fiji who first came to Australia in 2002.[1] In 2017 he became dissatisfied with his dealings with the Department of Immigration, and he lodged a complaint with the respondent.[2] The applicant then commenced litigation against the respondent in the Federal Court.
[1] Applicant Affidavit sworn 30 June 2021 (‘Applicant Affidavit’ at Exhibit 1, 279) at [4].
[2] Applicant Affidavit at [13].
The documents requested by the applicant on 20 November 2018 relate to a decision by the respondent to not investigate his complaint about the Department of Immigration. The documents requested by the applicant on 8 May 2019 relate to the respondent’s reconsideration of the complaint and a further decision to not investigate.
The issues for determination are:
(a)What is the extent of the material responsive to the requests?
(b)Are the documents in issue exempt or conditionally exempt from disclosure under ss 42, 47F and 47E(d) of the FOI Act?
(c)If conditionally exempt, would disclosure be contrary to the public interest?
The respondent has prepared a schedule of documents which describes the 30 documents in issue in 2020/5740 and the 14 documents in issue in 2020/7746.
The applicant provided an affidavit sworn on 30 June 2021. The respondent provided an affidavit affirmed on 11…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh and Commonwealth Ombudsman (Freedom of information) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] AATA 969
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to consider several key legal questions. Firstly, it had to determine whether the disclosure of specific personal information, namely the names, phone numbers, and email addresses of government officers, would constitute an unreasonable disclosure of personal information and thus be conditionally exempt under s 47F of the *Freedom of Information Act 1982*. Secondly, the Tribunal needed to assess whether the disclosure of certain operational details, specifically an email address of the Department of Home Affairs not intended for public communication, would have a substantial adverse effect on the proper and efficient conduct of the operations of an agency, as contemplated by s 47E(d). Finally, the Tribunal had to consider the overall public interest in disclosure versus the potential harm.
In reaching its decision, the Tribunal found that the release of the names, phone numbers, and email addresses of government officers would indeed be an unreasonable disclosure of personal information, likely causing stress and constituting an invasion of privacy, particularly given the applicant's history of abusive and unsubstantiated correspondence. Therefore, these documents were found to be conditionally exempt under s 47F. Regarding s 47E(d), the Tribunal accepted that disclosure of a private Department of Home Affairs email address would circumvent established procedures for managing public communications and could lead to an inefficient management of multiple complaints, thereby having a substantial adverse effect on the agency's operations. The Tribunal also accepted that reasonable steps had been taken to identify all relevant documents.
Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning the Ombudsman's refusal to grant full access to the documents was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I consider that the release of the name, phone number and email address of government officers in the documents in issue would be an unreasonable disclosure of personal information. The limited extent of the current redactions of that personal information is appropriate. I find that the documents containing this personal information are conditionally exempt under s 47F of the FOI Act. The release of that personal information would likely cause stress to those persons and it would amount to an unreasonable invasion of privacy. Further, it would serve no useful purpose. This is particularly so in circumstances where the applicant has shown a tendency to abuse and use foul language and make unsubstantiated allegations in his correspondence to officers of the respondent.[16][16] See for example pages 66 to 69 of Exhibit 1 in the letter from the applicant dated 27 July 2019.DOCUMENTS AFFECTING OPERATIONAL CONDUCT – S 47E(D) Section 47E(d) relates to documents which disclose certain operations of agencies and provides:A document is conditionally exempt if its disclosure under this Act would, or couldreasonably be expected to, do any of the following:…(d) have a substantial adverse effect on the proper and efficient conduct ofthe operations of an agency. The FOI Guidelines further advise on the meaning of ‘substantial adverse effect’ at [5.20]: The term ‘substantial adverse effect’ broadly means ‘an adverse effect which is sufficiently serious or significant to cause concern to a properly concerned reasonable person’ [see Re Thies and Department of Aviation [1986] AATA 141 [24]). The word ‘substantial’, taken in the context of substantial loss or damage, has been interpreted as ‘loss or damage that is, in the circumstances, real or of substance and not insubstantial or nominal’ [see Tillmanns Butcheries Pty Ltd v Australasian Meat Employees Union & Ors (1979) 27 ALR 367 383].(Footnotes included) The phrase ‘could reasonably be expected’ requires more than a mere assumption or allegation that damage may occur. The Guidelines provide at [6.103]:…The particulars of the predicted effect should be identified during the decision making process, including whether the effect could reasonably be expected to occur. Where the conditional exemption is relied upon, the relevant particulars and reasons should form part of the decision maker’s statement of reasons, if they can be included without disclosing exempt material (s 26, see Part 3). The s 47E(d) claims relate to parts of documents 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 in 2020/5740 and in particular an email address of the Department of Home Affairs which is not used for public communications. Disclosure of this email would circumvent the necessary approach of centralising through a Public Contact Team the management of communications with the public. It is reasonable to expect that individuals who are frustrated by the conduct of government agencies could use the private contact details, if they are disclosed, to air their complaints which would affect the efficiency of managing multiple complaints. There is no need for the disclosure of these private details and it would cause detriment to operational procedures if they were made public. Accordingly, it is appropriate for the applicant to be denied access to them.