Simundic v University of Newcastle

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Simundic v University of Newcastle [2007] FCA 676

VESNA SIMUNDIC v UNIVERSITY OF NEWCASTLE
NSD 2344 OF 2006

MOORE J
11 MAY 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2344 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

VESNA SIMUNDIC
Applicant

AND:

UNIVERSITY OF NEWCASTLE
Respondent

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 MAY 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applications be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent's costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2344 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

VESNA SIMUNDIC
Applicant

AND:

UNIVERSITY OF NEWCASTLE
Respondent

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

11 MAY 2007

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. By notice of motion filed 18 December 2006, the respondent, the University of Newcastle, seeks orders that the proceedings instituted by the applicant on 29 November 2006 be dismissed with costs.  The applicant filed a general application (Form 5) and a claim under the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ("HREOC Act") alleging unlawful discrimination (Form 167), together with a supporting affidavit. The Form 5 application and affidavit state that the applicant withdrew her case from the Supreme Court of New South Wales due to the behaviour of the University's legal representatives and that she wishes to have her case transferred to this Court. In the Form 5 application, the proceedings are described simply as concerning personal injury, defamation, breach of contract and the conduct of the University's legal representatives for which she claims the University is responsible. In the Form 167, next to "Describe the discrimination you are complaining of", the applicant has written "PTSD [Post Traumatic Stress-Disorder] that University ignored" and "abuse; defamation". The Disability Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) ("DD Act") is identified as the relevant Act which renders unlawful the conduct about which the applicant complained. 

    Background

  2. It is convenient to outline briefly the history of the applicant's grievance with the University and its legal representatives.  In 1996, the applicant enrolled in a Bachelor of Social Work at the University of Newcastle.  She ceased to be enrolled in 2000.  She did not obtain the qualification.

  3. The applicant lodged a complaint against the University with the Anti-Discrimination Board of New South Wales ("ADB") on 7 November 2000.  The complaint concerned, inter alia, things allegedly said and done by certain University employees, in particular, Lianne Flynn, who was a lecturer in the Department of Social Work, and Jo Gaha, the Head of the Department, between August 1998 and August 2000.  One particular incident concerned an email sent by Ms Gaha to the Vice Chancellor in August 1999, and seen by other staff, indicating that she thought the applicant was "clinically disturbed" and posed a risk to staff and students.

  4. The complaint was referred to the Administrative Decisions Tribunal of New South Wales ("ADT") after unsuccessful conciliation in the ADB.  On 21 September 2004,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simundic v University of Newcastle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 676
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The University of Newcastle filed a motion seeking dismissal of proceedings brought by the applicant, who alleged unlawful discrimination under the HREOC Act, personal injury, defamation, breach of contract, and misconduct by the University's legal representatives. The applicant, who had previously enrolled in a Bachelor of Social Work at the University and ceased her enrolment in 2000, lodged a complaint with the Anti-Discrimination Board of New South Wales (ADB) in 2000 and subsequently with the HREOC in 2001, though the latter was dismissed. The applicant commenced proceedings against the University in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which were dismissed. The applicant now sought to transfer her case to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether it had jurisdiction to hear the applicant's claims. The court examined whether the applicant's claims under the HREOC Act were valid and whether the court had jurisdiction over the other claims of negligence, contract, and defamation. The court concluded that the applicant's claim under the HREOC Act was invalid as she had already lodged a complaint with the ADB, which precluded her from making a subsequent complaint to the HREOC. Furthermore, the court found no basis for its jurisdiction to hear the other claims. The court also noted that the applicant had not provided any meaningful submissions to support the court's jurisdiction over these claims.

The court held that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the applicant's claims. The court determined that the applicant's claim under the HREOC Act was invalid because she had already lodged a complaint with the ADB, which precluded her from making a subsequent complaint to the HREOC. The court found no basis for its jurisdiction to hear the other claims, as the applicant did not provide any meaningful submissions to support the court's jurisdiction over these claims. The court dismissed the applicant's applications and ordered the applicant to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applications be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

By notice of motion filed 18 December 2006, the respondent, the University of Newcastle, seeks orders that the proceedings instituted by the applicant on 29 November 2006 be dismissed with costs. The applicant filed a general application (Form 5) and a claim under the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ("HREOC Act") alleging unlawful discrimination (Form 167), together with a supporting affidavit. The Form 5 application and affidavit state that the applicant withdrew her case from the Supreme Court of New South Wales due to the behaviour of the University's legal representatives and that she wishes to have her case transferred to this Court. In the Form 5 application, the proceedings are described simply as concerning personal injury, defamation, breach of contract and the conduct of the University's legal representatives for which she claims the University is responsible. In the Form 167, next to "Describe the discrimination you are complaining of", the applicant has written "PTSD [Post Traumatic Stress-Disorder] that University ignored" and "abuse; defamation". The Disability Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) ("DD Act") is identified as the relevant Act which renders unlawful the conduct about which the applicant complained. Background It is convenient to outline briefly the history of the applicant's grievance with the University and its legal representatives. In 1996, the applicant enrolled in a Bachelor of Social Work at the University of Newcastle. She ceased to be enrolled in 2000. She did not obtain the qualification. The applicant lodged a complaint against the University with the Anti-Discrimination Board of New South Wales ("ADB") on 7 November 2000. The complaint concerned, inter alia, things allegedly said and done by certain University employees, in particular, Lianne Flynn, who was a lecturer in the Department of Social Work, and Jo Gaha, the Head of the Department, between August 1998 and August 2000. One particular incident concerned an email sent by Ms Gaha to the Vice Chancellor in August 1999, and seen by other staff, indicating that she thought the applicant was "clinically disturbed" and posed a risk to staff and students. The complaint was referred to the Administrative Decisions Tribunal of New South Wales ("ADT") after unsuccessful conciliation in the ADB. On 21 September 2004, the ADT dismissed the complaint: see Simundic v University of Newcastle [2004] NSWADT 206. On 18 October 2004, the applicant commenced proceedings against the University in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The amended statement of claim filed 7 April 2005 pleaded causes of action in negligence, contract and defamation, the last of which concerned the email of August 1999. On 6 June 2006, Associate Justice Harrison dismissed a motion by the University to have the proceedings summarily dismissed or the statement of claim struck out: see Simundic v University of Newcastle [2005] NSWSC 586. The applicant was directed to file an application for extension of time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MOORE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MOORE J

In relation to the defamation claim, the applicant submitted that this claim would have been appropriately addressed in the Supreme Court if not for the action of the University's solicitors. The applicant also explained the circumstances in which she came to consent to the dismissal of the defamation proceedings in the Supreme Court, which were, briefly, her lack of confidence in the process and the University's alleged failure to comply with orders of the Court.Consideration This Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the proceeding brought by the applicant. It is to be remembered that these proceedings are brought against the University and no one else. It is convenient to deal firstly with the claim under the HREOC Act. An application of this kind can only be made to this Court when a complaint is terminated by the President of HREOC and a notice is given under s 46PH(2) of the HREOC Act in relation to the termination: see s 46PO(1) of the Act. Plainly, a complaint in the relevant sense must be made before it can be terminated by the President of HREOC. The applicant stated that she did in fact make a complaint to HREOC in 2001. However, the effect of s 13(4) of the DD Act is that having already lodged a complaint with the ADB in 2000, the applicant was not entitled to make a complaint to HREOC at that later date. This is the likely explanation as to why HREOC did not accept her complaint, although there was no evidence on this point. The applicant has stated that the discrimination claims the subject of these proceedings concern discrimination in the Supreme Court, rather than discrimination by the University which was the subject of the complaint to the ADB and the proceedings in the ADT and Supreme Court. However, this distinction does not overcome the hurdle imposed by s 46PO(1) of the HREOC Act. There has been no suggestion that the applicant has at any time complained to HREOC about the discrimination she allegedly suffered in the Supreme Court. In the absence of such a complaint having been made, and the requirements of s 46PO(1) having been met, this Court has no jurisdiction to deal with these claims. To the extent that these proceedings raise causes of action in negligence, contract and defamation, the University's contention that the Court has no jurisdiction to deal with these aspects of the proceedings must be accepted. The applicant, who was unrepresented, did not make any meaningful submissions as to the source of any jurisdiction this Court might have to determine these aspects of her application and none can be discerned. In the absence of any matter of substance engaging jurisdiction to deal with the application under the HREOC Act the accrued jurisdiction has not been enlivened. It is unnecessary to consider the argument that causes of action in negligence and contract are statute barred. The applicant has made an application that a jury determine her case. It is clear that the immediate issues in this case concern the Court's jurisdiction. The applicant's case fails at the outset. Unfortunately for the applicant, this cannot be overcome by her evident conviction, no doubt earnestly held, that she has been ill treated by the University and its legal representatives.