Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd v Dal Broi (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd v Dal Broi (No 2) [2018] NSWSC 1697
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 08 November 2018
Decision date: 08 November 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Darke J
Decision:

Costs order varied to provide that plaintiff pay some of first to tenth defendants’ costs on an indemnity basis.

Catchwords:

COSTS – departing from general rule – first to tenth defendants’ application for indemnity costs based on Calderbank offer – offer not accepted by plaintiff – proceedings brought in name of plaintiff and conducted by third party – third party is effectively the plaintiff – offer provided for payments to be made to third party – plaintiff unsuccessful – plaintiff in position to make reasonable assessment of its prospects at time offer was made – plaintiff unreasonably rejected Calderbank offer

COSTS – departing from general rule – plaintiff’s application to limit the costs of eleventh and twelfth defendants to the proportion of costs incurred by each of the first to tenth defendants – the eleventh and twelfth defendants represented by solicitors and counsel separate from those representing the first to tenth defendants – plaintiff submitted that retaining separate legal representation was unreasonable where all defendants had same interests and s 66ZL(8) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) made the plaintiff prima facie liable for the defendants’ costs – eleventh and twelfth defendants did not act unreasonably in retaining separate legal representation in the absence of any objection raised by the plaintiff
Legislation Cited: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), s 66ZL
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 36.15, 36.16
Cases Cited: Deputy Cmr of Taxation v Meredith (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 133
DGF Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Di Federico; DGF Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Butros (No 2) [2018] NSWSC 1137
Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pte Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 344
Silver Star Fashions v Dal Broi [2018] NSWSC 1445
Category:Costs
Parties: Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Aaron Luke Dal Broi (First Defendant)
Amanda Ye May Chin (Second Defendant)
Matthew Robert Carnachan (Third Defendant)
Ashely Cliff Wong (Fourth Defendant)
Jordan Curtis Zubani (Fifth Defendant)
Courtney Zubani (Sixth Defendant)
Junmei Gu (Seventh Defendant)
Mitchell James Jordan (Eighth Defendant)
Sonja Bijou Keith (Ninth Defendant)
David Robert Grayhurst (Tenth Defendant)
Hugh Linton Selleck (Eleventh Defendant)
Thomas Edward Christensen (Twelfth Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr G A Sirtes SC with Ms A Avery-Williams (Plaintiff)
Mr P S Braham SC with Mr D Neggo (First to Tenth Defendants)
Mr J P Redmond (Eleventh and Twelfth Defendants)

  Solicitors:
Boskovitz & Associates (Plaintiff)
Deutsch Miller (First to Tenth Defendants)
CW Legal (Eleventh and Twelfth Defendants)
File Number(s): 2017/141862
Publication restriction: None

Judgment

  1. These proceedings concerned an application by the plaintiff under s 66ZL(6) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) for permission to rescind under a “sunset clause” nine off the plan contracts it entered into as vendor in 2014. On 26 September 2018 the Court dismissed the Statement of Claim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd v Dal Broi (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 1697
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, brought a legal dispute against several defendants, including Dal Broi, before the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff sought damages for breaches of contract and misrepresentations made by the defendants. The first to tenth defendants applied for indemnity costs based on a Calderbank offer, which the plaintiff did not accept. The proceedings were conducted by a third party who was effectively the plaintiff. The eleventh and twelfth defendants, who were represented by separate legal counsel, argued against the plaintiff's application to limit their costs.

The court examined the reasonableness of the plaintiff's rejection of the Calderbank offer. It considered the plaintiff's position to make a reasonable assessment of its prospects when the offer was made. The court determined that the plaintiff unreasonably rejected the offer, leading to the first to tenth defendants' application for indemnity costs being granted. The court also considered the eleventh and twelfth defendants' decision to retain separate legal representation. It found that they did not act unreasonably, as the plaintiff did not object to their separate representation, and all defendants shared common interests.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales ruled in favour of the first to tenth defendants' application for indemnity costs based on the rejected Calderbank offer. The court held that the plaintiff unreasonably rejected the offer, which warranted the imposition of indemnity costs. Regarding the eleventh and twelfth defendants' costs, the court found that their decision to retain separate legal representation was not unreasonable. Consequently, the plaintiff's application to limit the costs of the eleventh and twelfth defendants was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against multiple defendants, including individuals and companies, seeking damages for breach of contract and other claims related to the sale and purchase of a business. The plaintiff, represented by a third party, was originally the owner of the business which was sold to one of the defendants. Disputes arose regarding the terms of the sale, alleged misrepresentations, and breaches of contract. The first to tenth defendants made a Calderbank offer to the plaintiff, which the plaintiff rejected. The plaintiff was ultimately unsuccessful in the proceedings. The eleventh and twelfth defendants, who had separate legal representation from the first to tenth defendants, were also involved in the litigation.

The case, Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd v Dal Broi (No 2), was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The matter was brought by the plaintiff, Silver Star Fashions Pty Ltd, against multiple defendants for breaches of contract and other related claims. Prior to the hearing, the first to tenth defendants made a Calderbank offer to the plaintiff, which was rejected. The eleventh and twelfth defendants, who had separate legal representation from the first to tenth defendants, were also involved in the litigation. The plaintiff applied to limit the costs of the eleventh and twelfth defendants to the proportion of the costs incurred by the first to tenth defendants. The first to tenth defendants applied for indemnity costs based on their rejected Calderbank offer.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the first to tenth defendants are entitled to indemnity costs based on their Calderbank offer that was not accepted by the plaintiff.
2. Whether the costs of the eleventh and twelfth defendants should be limited to the proportion of costs incurred by the first to tenth defendants.

Held
1. The court held that the first to tenth defendants are not entitled to indemnity costs based on their Calderbank offer, which was not accepted by the plaintiff. The court found that the plaintiff was in a position to make a reasonable assessment of its prospects at the time the offer was made and that the plaintiff unreasonably rejected the offer.
2. The court also held that the costs of the eleventh and twelfth defendants should not be limited to the proportion of costs incurred by the first to tenth defendants. The court found that the eleventh and twelfth defendants did not act unreasonably in retaining separate legal representation since the plaintiff did not raise any objection to this arrangement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the first issue, the court noted that indemnity costs are generally awarded only when a party unreasonably refuses a settlement offer made under the terms of the Calderbank v Calderbank principle. The court found that the plaintiff, though unsuccessful, was in a position to reasonably assess its prospects and therefore unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer. Consequently, the first to tenth defendants were not entitled to indemnity costs. The court’s decision underscores the principle that indemnity costs can only be awarded when the refusal of a settlement offer is unreasonable and that the party making the offer must not have acted unreasonably in making it. The court's decision departed from the general rule of awarding indemnity costs in cases of unreasonable refusals of settlement offers because the plaintiff's unreasonable rejection of the Calderbank offer outweighed the general rule.
For the second issue, the court examined whether the eleventh and twelfth defendants acted unreasonably by retaining separate legal representation. The court found that the separation of legal representation did not, in itself, constitute unreasonable conduct in the absence of any objection by the plaintiff. The court emphasised the autonomy of parties in choosing their legal representation, especially where, as in this case, the eleventh and twelfth defendants had distinct legal counsel and solicitors separate from those representing the first to tenth defendants. The court's decision affirms the principle that the retention of separate legal representation is not unreasonable unless it is contested by the opposing party. The ratio decidendi here is that separate legal representation does not necessarily constitute unreasonable conduct, especially when not objected to by the other party.