Silk v State Rail Authority of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Silk v State Rail Authority of NSW [2006] NSWWCCPD 79

APPELLANT:  Clayton Silk

RESPONDENT:  State Rail Authority of NSW

INSURER:Self Insurer

FILE NUMBER:  WCC3974-04

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          24 March 2005

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  10 May 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Extension of time to appeal, errors of fact, adequacy of reasons, credit finding, procedural fairness

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Michael Snell

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Beilby Poulden Costello

Respondent:   Phillips Fox

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator dated 24 March 2005 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh.

The Respondent is to pay the Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 5 May 2005 Clayton Silk (‘the Appellant ’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision, dated 24 March 2005.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is the State Rail Authority of NSW (‘the Respondent’).

  1. The Appellant commenced employment with the Respondent as a carriage cleaner on 8 August 2002. After a period he commenced to suffer symptoms in the back, allegedly due to the nature of his duties. He reported the injury on 12 November 2002. He was placed off work by his general practitioner, from 30 November 2002. A claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses was lodged on 5 December 2002, and the Respondent commenced payments of “provisional compensation”. The Appellant was examined by Dr Stephen at the Respondent’s request on 9 December 2002, the same date on which the Appellant resumed duties with the Respondent, working on light duties. 

  1. Dr Stephen’s report was not supportive of the Appellant’s claim for compensation, and by letter of 11 December 2002 the Respondent denied the claim. The Respondent terminated the Appellant’s employment by letter dated 17 December 2002, effective 20 December 2002.

  1. The Appellant did not work thereafter, until obtaining work with Wilson Traffic Management as a traffic co-ordinator, from 15 November 2003 until 7 January 2004, when he was terminated from that employment.

  1. An Application to Resolve a Dispute was filed on 5 March 2004, claiming weekly payments at a rate of $546.06 from 11 December 2002 to date and continuing, together with a general order for the payment of expenses pursuant to section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’). The “Injury Details” alleged in Part 3 of that Application give the date of injury as 12 November 2002, and allege:

“The worker sustained injury as a result of the nature and condition (sic) of employment where he was required to clean, mega wash, wipe, scrub and mop trains or in the alternative the worker has sustained injury as a result of an aggravation of a disease pursuant to Section 16 of the Act.”

  1. The Respondent filed a Reply on 25 March 2004, pleading lengthy “issues in dispute…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Silk v State Rail Authority of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Silk v State Rail Authority of NSW, the appellant, Clayton Silk, appealed a decision of an arbitrator in the Workers Compensation Commission. The decision, dated 24 March 2005, dismissed Silk's claim for workers' compensation benefits and expenses. The appeal, however, was filed outside the statutory time limit, necessitating an extension of time for the appeal. The appeal was heard on the papers without a formal hearing.

The legal issues in the appeal were multiple, involving factual errors in the arbitrator's findings, inadequate reasons for preferring certain medical opinions, errors in credit findings, and alleged procedural unfairness. The appellant argued that the arbitrator misunderstood or misquoted evidence, failed to give adequate reasons for preferring certain medical opinions, and erred in indicating a finding that the appellant had sustained an injury involving the aggravation of a disease, only to approach the matter differently in the final decision.

The court found that the appeal was filed out of time due to procedural errors and that there was demonstrable and substantial injustice if the appeal were not heard. The court granted leave to extend the time to appeal, finding that the appeal was within a short period of being out of time, the reasons for it being out of time were understandable, there was no claim of prejudice by the respondent, the rights at issue were substantial, and there were reasonable prospects of the appeal succeeding.

The court found that the arbitrator had made material factual errors, misstated evidence, and misdescribed the medical reports. These errors were significant as they affected the outcome of the case. The court also found that the arbitrator erred in how she approached the conflict of medical opinions, failing to consider relevant matters and taking into account mistaken factual errors. The court held that the factual errors and the way the arbitrator dealt with the medical evidence demonstrated an error in how she went about deciding which medical views she preferred.

The court found that the arbitrator's reasons for her credit finding were sufficient, as they were capable of conveying adequately the basis upon which she came to the decision. The court also found that the appellant's claim of procedural unfairness was misconceived, as there was no breach of procedural fairness in the arbitrator's conduct.

The appeal was upheld, and the decision of the arbitrator was revoked. The matter was remitted to another arbitrator for determination afresh. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Clayton Silk commenced employment with the State Rail Authority of NSW as a carriage cleaner on 8 August 2002. He reported an injury on 12 November 2002 and was placed off work by his general practitioner from 30 November 2002. A claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses was lodged on 5 December 2002, and the Respondent commenced payments of "provisional compensation". The Appellant was examined by Dr Stephen at the Respondent’s request on 9 December 2002, the same date on which the Appellant resumed duties with the Respondent, working on light duties. The Respondent terminated the Appellant’s employment by letter dated 17 December 2002, effective 20 December 2002. The Appellant subsequently attended medical and vocational assessment appointments arranged by the Respondent, including an assessment by Dr Bodel on 12 November 2004. The matter proceeded to Arbitration on 3 March 2005, where the Arbitrator issued a Certificate of Determination on 24 March 2005, awarding in favour of the respondent regarding the Appellant’s claims for weekly payments of compensation and expenses under section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

Clayton Silk sought leave to appeal the decision of the Arbitrator dated 24 March 2005 in the Workers Compensation Commission. The appeal was filed on 5 May 2005, outside the standard 28-day appeal period. The Appellant argued for an extension of time to lodge the appeal, citing procedural errors and the significant rights at stake. The appeal was heard on the papers, and the Acting Deputy President Michael Snell granted leave to appeal. The appeal was reviewed for errors of law, fact, or discretion. The decision of the Arbitrator was revoked, and the matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Has the Arbitrator made material mistakes as regards various facts, and has not given an accurate account of the evidence before her?
2. Has the Arbitrator failed to give any or any adequate reasons for preferring the opinion of Dr Stephen over the opinions of Drs. Bentivoglio and Berry and the approved medical specialist Dr Bodel?
3. Has the Arbitrator failed to give any or any adequate reasons for her finding regarding the credit of the Appellant?
4. Has the Arbitrator erred in indicating, during the running of the Arbitration, that she proposed making a finding that the Appellant had sustained injury involving the aggravation of a disease process within the meaning of section 16 of the 1987 Act, and then approached the matter in a contrary manner, finding "injury by way of the nature and conditions of his employment"?

Held
1. The appeal is upheld and the decision of the Arbitrator dated 24 March 2005 is revoked.
2. The matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh.
3. The Respondent is ordered to pay the Appellant's costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal was heard on the papers and the Acting Deputy President found that the Appellant was entitled to an extension of time to lodge the appeal. The key issues raised by the Appellant were whether the Arbitrator made material factual errors, failed to provide adequate reasons for preferring certain medical opinions, failed to provide adequate reasons for the credit finding, and whether the Appellant was denied procedural fairness. The Acting Deputy President found that the Arbitrator did indeed make material factual errors in her assessment of the evidence, particularly in relation to the nature and arduousness of the Appellant's work duties, and the circumstances surrounding the termination of his employment. These errors were significant and had the potential to affect the outcome of the case. Furthermore, the Arbitrator failed to consider relevant material in evaluating the medical evidence, specifically that Dr Bodel had access to the clinical findings of Dr Stephen, contrary to the Arbitrator's belief. The Acting Deputy President also found that while the reasons provided by the Arbitrator for preferring certain medical opinions were sufficient, the way in which she went about deciding which medical views to prefer demonstrated error. The credit finding made by the Arbitrator was not found to be in error, as the reasons provided were adequate and the Appellant was not denied procedural fairness. As a result of these findings, the appeal was upheld and the Arbitrator's decision was revoked, with the matter to be remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh. The Respondent was ordered to pay the Appellant's costs of the appeal.