Sidhu and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Sidhu and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2025] ARTA 994 (7 July 2025)

Applicant/s:  David Sidhu

Respondent:  Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Tribunal Number:                2024/0752

Tribunal:General Member J Ross

Place:Canberra

Date:7 July 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..................................................................

General Member J Ross

CATCHWORDS

SUPERANNUATION – Self Managed Superannuation Fund (SMSF) – where applicant

was disqualified from being an approved SMSF auditor – whether applicant failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an approved SMSF auditor – whether failed to comply with auditor independence requirements – whether disqualification order appropriate – specific and general deterrence – integrity of superannuation system – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No.1) Act

2024 (Cth), Part 5 of Schedule 16

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – s 5, s 6(1), s10, ss 35B- 35C,

s 62, ss 65-67B, s 71, s 82, s 84, s 104A, s 109, ss 128A -128H, s 129, s130F, s 344

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 – reg 4.09,

r 4.09A, r 8.02B and r 13.14

CASES

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Gilliland [2022] FCA 1421
Brown and Australian Securities and Investment Commission 2009] AATA 286
Henley v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 82
Howarth and Australian Securities and Investment Commission (2008) 101 ALD
602; [2008] AATA 278
Islam and Australian Securities & Investments Commission (Taxation and
Business) [2024] ARTA 88
Karamian and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA
2006
Panganiban v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2016) 338
ALR 119
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31
Townshend and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023]

AATA 3810

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Accounting Professional & Ethical Standards Board, Complied APES 110 Code of Ethnics for Professional Accountants, December 2011

Accounting Professional & Ethical Standards Board, APES 110 Code of Ethnics for Professional Accountants (including Independence Standards), November 2018

Australian Auditing and Assurance Standards Board Guidance Statement GS 009 – Auditing Self-Managed Superannuation Funds

Australian Auditing and Assurance Standards Board, Auditing Standard ASA 230 – Audit Documentation (Auditing Standard, 4 January 2019)

Australian Auditing and Assurance Standards Board, Auditing Standard ASA 500 – Audit Evidence

Australian Auditing and Assurance Standards Board, Auditing Standard ASA 540 – Auditing Accounting Estimates and Related Disclosures

Australian Auditing and Assurance Standards Board, Auditing Standard ASA 550 – Related Parties

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Regulatory Guide 243: Registration of self-managed superannuation funds auditors

Australian Taxation Office Practice Statement Law Administration PS LA 2018/1

Second reading speech on the Superannuation Laws Amendment (Capital Gains Tax Relief and Other Efficiency Measures) Bill 2012, 19 September 2012, (B Shorten MP), 11169

Statement of Reasons

  1. On 14 October 2024, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) became the Administrative Review Tribunal (the Tribunal). Under the transitional provisions in the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024 (the Transitional Act), proceedings in the AAT that were not finalised before 14 October 2024 are to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sidhu and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 994
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Tribunal concerns a review of the decision by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to disqualify Mr. Sidhu from being an approved Self Managed Superannuation Fund (SMSF) auditor. The primary legal issues revolve around whether Mr. Sidhu failed to adequately and properly perform his duties as an auditor, whether he breached auditor independence requirements, and if ASIC's decision to disqualify him was appropriate. The case hinges on the compliance with auditing standards and the integrity of the superannuation system. The Tribunal's task was to evaluate the sufficiency and appropriateness of the audit evidence and documentation provided by Mr. Sidhu, as well as his adherence to auditor independence requirements.

The Tribunal found that Mr. Sidhu did not adequately and properly perform his duties as an SMSF auditor. Specifically, the audit files submitted to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) did not contain all the necessary documents, and the declarations signed by Mr. Sidhu falsely stated that all required information had been provided. The Tribunal highlighted that Mr. Sidhu's cavalier attitude towards signing these declarations and his poor file management practices cast doubt on his integrity. Furthermore, Mr. Sidhu's failure to comply with auditing standards, such as obtaining sufficient audit evidence and preparing adequate documentation, was evident. These findings led the Tribunal to affirm the decision to disqualify Mr. Sidhu from being an approved SMSF auditor, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity of the superannuation system and the need for deterrence.

The final orders of the Tribunal are that the decision under review, which disqualified Mr. Sidhu from being an approved SMSF auditor, is affirmed. This decision underscores the necessity for SMSF auditors to strictly adhere to auditing standards and maintain high levels of integrity to protect the interests of superannuation fund members.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, I have decided that the decision under review is affirmed.BACKGROUND On 6 May 2013, Mr Sidhu was registered as an approved SMSF auditor under section 128B of the SIS Act. In or about October 2002, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) commenced a compliance review of the audits undertaken by Mr Sidhu for three SMSFs:(a)R Fund (R Fund) for income year 2019-2020;(b)C Pty Ltd Superannuation Fund (C Fund) for income year 2018-2019; and(c)O Superannuation Fund (O Fund) for income year 2019-2020.(collectively, the Funds) It has not been alleged that any of the three SMSFs are in breach of the SIS Act. For this reason, on 11 February 2025, I made an order that the names of the Funds and parties connected to them be anonymised. The outcome of the compliance audits as outlined in the ATO’s position paper was that the Commissioner of Taxation (Commissioner) formed the opinion that Mr Sidhu had failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties and functions of an approved SMSF auditor. On 13 December 2022, Mr Sidhu was notified by the ATO that a referral had been made under section 128P of the SIS Act on the basis that Mr Sidhu failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an auditor under the SIS Act and Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (SIS Regulations). On 23 January 2023, after considering the ATO referral, ASIC sent a ‘show cause’ letter to Mr Sidhu advising him that consideration is being given to making an order to disqualify, suspend or impose conditions on his SMSF registration. On 7 February 2023, Mr Sidhu responded to the ‘show cause’ letter stating that, among other things, disqualification in the circumstances would be an ‘unjust action’ and that imposing conditions would be more suitable. On 30 October 2023, ASIC advised Mr Sidhu of the decision to disqualify him from being an approved SMSF auditor with effect from 3 November 2023. On 28 November 2023, Mr Sidhu requested a review of the decision to disqualify him as an SMSF auditor. On 11 December 2023, Mr Sidhu was advised by ASIC that following a review, the decision to disqualify him had been confirmed. On 8 February 2024, Mr Sidhu applied to the Tribunal for review of the Decision. The decision under review is the decision made by the Respondent on 30 October 2023 to disqualify the Applicant from being an approved SMSF auditor, which took effect on 3 November 2023 and was subsequently confirmed by a delegate of ASIC, the Respondent, on 11 December 2023 (Reviewable Decision).THE ISSUE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:(a)whether Mr Sidhu failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an approved SMSF auditor; (b)whether Mr Sidhu failed to comply with auditor independence requirements in the SIS Act and Regulations; and(c)if so, was it appropriate for ASIC to have disqualified Mr Sidhu from being an approved SMSF auditor. KEY STATUTORY PROVISIONS

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As such, at first, he did not accept that such a practice was in breach of ASA 230. However, when pressed further on the issue of whether an independent external auditor with no connection to the audit could have picked up his file and understood matters, he conceded that in that context he was in breach. Compliance with auditing and assurance standards – obtain sufficient audit evidence as required by ASA 500 The Applicant submits that Mr Sidhu’s Affidavit provides evidence that he had all the relevant information he needed as an experienced SMSF auditor to perform his audit of the three Funds consistent with requirements in GS 009.[9] [9] Applicant’s Amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [21]. The Respondent directed me to the guidance in GS 009 which provides:ASA 500 Audit Evidence requires the auditor to design and perform audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances of the engagement, for the purpose of obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence to be able to draw reasonable conclusions on which to base the audit opinion. It requires the auditor to consider the relevance and reliability of the information to be used as audit evidence which includes the documentation of their testing and how the results may impact the audit opinion. The Respondent submits that ‘sufficiency’ in this context is the measure of the quantity of the audit evidence and ‘appropriateness’ is the measure of its quality.[10] The Respondent further submits in considering what amounts to reliable audit reference should relevantly be made to ASA 500 which favours evidence obtained from independent and direct sources over evidence obtained indirectly or by inference. [10] Respondent’s closing submissions at [25]. Below I consider Mr Sidhu’s compliance with the audit documentation requirements in ASA 230 and audit evidence requirements in ASA 500 in relation to the three Funds. The R Fund In relation to the R Fund, ASIC submits that Mr Sidhu failed to prepare sufficient documentation as required by ASA 230 in relation to:(a)signed trustee declaration ASIC also submit that Mr Sidhu failed to obtain sufficient audit evidence as required by ASA 500 to support: (b)ownership of commercial property and charges over the assets; (c)the market value of the Fund’s commercial property; and(d)whether the Fund’s bank loans were limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBA). Signed trustee declaration On the issue of the audit file submitted to the ATO not containing signed trustee declarations in relation to the R Fund, Mr Sidhu’s evidence was that he understood the relevant obligation and that the declaration was not in the audit file because it was in the trust register. The Respondent submits in its written closing submissions that not only is there a requirement under the SIS Act for the auditor to obtain and cite the relevant trustee declarations to ensure they have been made and are in the correct form, but also to ensure they are retained.[11] [11] Respondent’s closing submissions at [27].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The decision under review is the decision made by the Respondent on 30 October 2023 to disqualify the Applicant from being an approved SMSF auditor, which took effect on 3 November 2023 and was subsequently confirmed by a delegate of ASIC, the Respondent, on 11 December 2023 (Reviewable Decision).THE ISSUE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:(a)whether Mr Sidhu failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an approved SMSF auditor; (b)whether Mr Sidhu failed to comply with auditor independence requirements in the SIS Act and Regulations; and(c)if so, was it appropriate for ASIC to have disqualified Mr Sidhu from being an approved SMSF auditor. KEY STATUTORY PROVISIONS Sections 5 and 6 of the SIS Act sets out the functions, powers and duties of ASIC and the Commissioner in administrating the Act. The Commissioner is generally responsible for SMSF, and ASIC is generally responsible for ‘protecting consumers from harm, market integrity, disclosure and record keeping’. SMSF auditor professional standards Section 35B of the SIS Act requires trustees of an SMSF to prepare, sign and retain accounts and statements. Section 35C of the SIS Act further requires trustees to ensure for each income year that an approved SMSF auditor is appointed to give the trustee a report, in the approved form, on the operation of the entity for that year. Section 35C(5) of the SIS Act relevantly provides that the approved form must include a statement by the auditor as the extent of the auditor’s compliance with auditor independence requirements in subsection 128F(d) of the SIS Act. Section 128F of the SIS Act imposes a range of professional obligations on approved SMSF auditors. Subsection 128F(c) of the SIS Act requires an SMSF auditor to comply with:(a)any competency standards that the Regulator determines under section 128Q;(b)any auditing standards, made by the Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (AASB) under section 336 of the Corporations Act 2001, that are applicable to the duties of an approved SMSF auditor under this Act; and(c)any auditing and assurance standards, formulated by the Auditing and Assurance Standards Board under section 227B of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), that are applicable to those duties. Guidance Statement GS 009 Auditing Self-Managed Superannuation Funds (GS 009) was issued by the AASB pursuant to section 227B of the ASIS Act. The version issued on 30 September 2015 is the relevant version to the matter before me based on the audit completion dates. GS 009 listed the key Auditing Standards (ASA) which are relevant to the conducting of a financial audits of SMSFs relevant to this matter:(a)ASA 500 Audit Evidence,(b)ASA 230 Audit Documentation. Subsection 128F(d) of the SIS Act requires an SMSF auditor to comply with ‘the auditor independence requirements prescribed by the regulations’. Regulation 9A.06 of the SIS Regulations state: For paragraph 128F(d) of the Act, the auditor independence requirements produced by the Accounting Professional and Ethical Standards Board Limited and set out in the APES 110 Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (including Independence Standards) are prescribed for all approved SMSF auditors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first issue for consideration is whether the Applicant failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an approved SMSF auditor. The provision of audit files to the ATO and the written declaration by Mr Sidhu The Respondent submits in its closing submissions that one of the significant challenges in this matter is the manner in which Mr Sidhu provided documents to the ATO. Despite confirming that all documents had been provided and further declaring that all information is true and correct, Mr Sidhu subsequently provided the ATO with a raft of further documents in response to the issues raised.[1][1] Respondent’s closing submissions at [18]. The Respondent submits that, even if it is to be assumed that Mr Sidhu had these documents at the time of his audits and did have regard to them, it still raises concerns about why he would sign a declaration which was false and about the nature of his file management. Before the Tribunal, Ms Sidhu explained that he believed that, at the time of signing the declaration, he thought that everything that was needed was in the file.[2] Further, he explained that if anything further was needed it could be provided.[3] In response to the question about whether he understood the importance of providing true and correct declarations to regulators, he responded ‘yes’.[4][2] Transcript of proceedings at [P-20:15-20].[3] Ibid.[4] Transcript of proceedings at [P-19: 45]. The three signed declaration documents form part of the evidence for this case.[5] I have examined these declarations. In these declarations, I can see that Mr Sidhu has confirmed that all the information and documents he relied upon to form his audit opinion had been provided, including the audit working papers file and the permanent file, when they were not. This makes the declarations false. In the Applicant’s closing submissions, it is contended that Mr Sidhu’s evidence shows an acknowledgment of error and contrition. [5] Exhibit 2. I consider that Mr Sidhu adopted a cavalier attitude to the signing of the declaration and, as will come to light further in the considerations below, it does not appear that Mr Sidhu always had those documents at the time of the audit, or if he did he was unable to have regard to them because of poor file management and audit practices. This casts some doubt regarding Mr Sidhu’s integrity. However, I have not found it necessary to conclude whether he created some documents to satisfy the ATO as regardless there has been a failure to comply with auditing standards. Meaning of ‘adequately and properly’ When considering whether Mr Sidhu failed to carry out or perform adequately and properly the duties of an approved SMSF auditor under the SIS Act and the SIS Regulations, I am guided by previous Tribunal decisions that have considered the meaning of ‘adequately and properly’. In particular, in Brown and Australian Securities and Investments Commission,[6] Deputy President Forgie considered the meaning of ‘adequately’ in the context of carrying on a financial service business under a licence. The Deputy President stated that a consideration of whether a person has done something adequately requires a consideration of whether that person has done so competently. The Deputy President also considered the meaning of ‘properly’ and stated that a consideration of whether the person has done so ‘properly’ ‘goes beyond notions of adequacy to encompass notions of appropriateness and of propriety. Compliance with auditing and assurance standards – prepare sufficient documentation as required by ASA 230[6] [2009] AATA 286.