Shun Pty Ltd v Logan City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND


CITATION:

Shun Pty Ltd v Logan City Council & Anor [2020] QPEC 31

PARTIES:

SHUN PTY LTD ACN 113 114 324 AS TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 712735276
(Appellant)

v

LOGAN CITY COUNCIL
(Respondent)

AND

CENTA UNDERWOOD PTY LTD ATF BRISBANE UNDERWOOD TRUST
(Co-respondent)

FILE NO/S:

3076 of 2017

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 June 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 and 24–28 February 2020 and further exhibit and written submissions received 28 May 2020

JUDGE:

Kefford DCJ

ORDER:

I order the appeal be allowed and the development application refused.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – APPLICATION – applications in pending proceeding – where the substantive proceeding involves an appeal by a submitter against the Council’s decision to approve a mixed use development that includes a supermarket – where the economic analysis lodged with the development application indicated an intention to seek a supermarket or variety store and that a prospective operator might be an Asian/Chinese supermarket and variety store – where the appeal was part-heard when the application was made – whether the co-respondent’s proposed change is a minor change – whether the co-respondent should be permitted to change its application

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – APPEAL – submitter appeal against Council approval of a development application seeking a development permit for material change of use for a mixed use development involving 198 multiple dwellings on top of a new shopping centre in the specialised centre zone – whether the proposed development is would complement the existing district centre, whether the proposed development would undermine the viability of the existing district centre – whether the proposed development accords with the planning strategy for new or expanded centres – whether there is a demonstrated community and economic need for the proposed development – whether the planning strategy for new or expanded centres operates as an exception to the planning policy that supermarkets are not to locate in a specialised centre – whether the proposed development could be appropriately conditioned to limit it to use for an “Asian themed” supermarket – whether the proposed development should be approved in the exercise of the planning discretion

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016 (Qld), s 45, s 59, s 60, s 65, s 66

Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld), s 43, s 45, s 47

CASES:

AAD Design Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2012] QCA 44; [2013] 1 Qd R 1, applied

Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane City Council [2019] QPEC 16; [2019] QPELR 793, approved

Australian Capital Holdings Pty Ltd v Mackay City Council & Ors [2008] QCA 157, applied

Gaven Development Pty Ltd v Scenic Rim Regional Council [2010] QPEC 51; [2010] QPELR 750, cited

Intrafield Pty Ltd v Redland City Council [2001] QCA 116; (2001) 116 LGERA 350, approved

Intrapac Parkridge Pty Ltd v Logan City Council [2014] QPEC 48; [2015] QPELR 49, approved

Isgro v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shun Pty Ltd v Logan City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QPEC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shun Pty Ltd has filed an appeal against the Logan City Council's approval of Centa’s development application, which seeks a development permit for a material change of use for a mixed-use development involving 198 multiple dwellings atop a new shopping centre in the specialised centre zone. The primary concern raised by Shun is the appropriateness of the retail and commercial aspects of Centa’s proposed development. The Court must determine whether Centa’s proposed development should be approved or refused.

The Court was tasked with assessing the appropriateness of Centa’s proposed development, considering the statutory framework provided by the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) and the Planning Act 2016 (Qld). Centa bears the onus of proving the merits of the development. The Court's discretion in determining the appeal must be exercised based on an assessment against the assessment benchmarks in the Planning Scheme, having regard to any other relevant matters, while avoiding consideration of personal circumstances. The Court considered the evidence presented by both Centa and Shun, particularly the economic analysis and the potential impact on the existing Underwood district centre. The Court found that there is no demonstrated community, economic, or planning need for the proposed development and that it would divert sales from the existing Underwood district centre, potentially jeopardising its future viability.

In conclusion, the Court found that Centa’s proposed development does not meet the necessary criteria for approval. The evidence did not support an efficient and logical extension of the existing Underwood district centre, nor did it demonstrate an economic need that could be met without unacceptable impacts. Therefore, the Court ordered that the appeal be allowed and the development application be refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

I order the appeal be allowed and the development application refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the heart of the issues raised by Shun is the appropriateness of the retail and commercial aspects of Centa’s proposed development. The issue for me to determine is whether the proposed development should be approved or refused.The decision framework The statutory framework in the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) and the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) applies. The appeal proceeds by way of hearing anew.[1] Centa bears the onus.[2] [1]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 43.[2]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 45. Centa seeks a development permit to authorise it to carry out a material change of use of the subject land from its presently vacant state to use for multiple dwellings (198 units), food and drink outlets, function facility, offices, health care services, shops and shopping centre generally in accordance with the design reflected in the plans provided as Exhibit 4. In deciding the appeal, the Court must confirm the decision appealed against, change the decision appealed against, or set it aside and either make a decision replacing it or return the matter to the Council with directions the Court considers appropriate.[3] [3]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 47. There is a broad discretion in determining the appeal.[4] The exercise of the discretion must be based on an assessment that:[5](a)must be carried out:(i)against the assessment benchmarks in the Planning Scheme to the extent relevant;[6](ii)having regard to any matters prescribed by the Planning Regulation 2017 (Qld);[7] (b)may be carried out against, or having regard to, any other relevant matter, other than a person’s personal circumstances (financial or otherwise); and(c)may give the weight the Court considers appropriate to any amendments to the Planning Scheme. (Although there were amendments to the Planning Scheme following the lodgement of the development application, the town planning experts agree that there are no significant differences in policy intent between the versions. None of the parties contended otherwise. As such, it is unnecessary to consider any amendments.)[4]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 47; Planning Act 2016, s 60(3). [5]Planning Act 2016, s 59 and s 45(5).[6]Version 2.1 of the Logan Planning Scheme 2015 was the categorising instrument for the development in effect when Centa’s application was properly made. Any reference to the Planning Scheme is a reference to version 2.1 unless expressly stated otherwise or unless otherwise apparent from the context. [7]None of the parties asserts that there are any such matters of particular relevance in this case. His Honour Judge Williamson QC comprehensively, and in my view correctly, analysed how impact assessable development applications are to be assessed and decided in Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane City Council.[8] I have also further considered the approach in Murphy v Moreton Bay Regional Council & Anor; Australian National Homes Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council & Anor.[9] All of the parties contend that the approach referred to in those judgments is the correct one.[8][2019] QPEC 16; [2019] QPELR 793, 803-13 [35]-[86].[9][2019] QPEC 46, [12]-[22].Should the appeal proceed based on further proposed changes?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the reasons provided in paragraphs [36] to [150] above, I am not satisfied that there is a community, economic or planning need for the proposed development. Does the subject land’s configuration and location lend support to approval? Lot 1 is irregularly shaped and that portion of it that comprises the subject land is wedged between the former Bunnings and Australia post sites, at the back of the Underwood Central shopping centre. Centa submits that the proposed development will make efficient use of this unusually configured and located land parcel and existing infrastructure, and will provide an opportunity to integrate physically and functionally with the existing District centre. In that respect, it relies on the evidence of Mr Schomburgk and Mr Ovenden. Mr Schomburgk says that the proposed development will fill in a currently-vacant part of a larger site that is landlocked behind the existing centre, thereby making efficient use of that balance area and resulting in orderly and logical development. He also says that the proposed development represents an efficient and logical extension to the existing centre in circumstances where there is a need for additional centre uses. Mr Ovenden opines that the proposed development complements the adjoining district centre zone through its proximity to land in that zone and the opportunity to integrate both physically and functionally. He says it does so by providing a range of residential and commercial uses, such as the office component and the health care services and function facilities, which are not provided for in the Underwood district centre. He says the proposed supermarket and office uses will, in effect, integrate with the designated district centre. Given the absence of a demonstrated need for the proposed development, I do not accept Mr Schomburgk’s opinion that the proposed development represents an efficient and logical extension to the existing centre. I also do not accept the opinion of Mr Ovenden. For the reasons provided in paragraph [119] above, I do not accept that the proposed development will integrate with the designated district centre. Although the subject land’s location lends support to approval of a development designed to complement the existing Underwood district centre, this is not such a development.Does the proposed development meet an economic need absent any unacceptable impacts? A relevant matter identified by both the Council and Centa is that the need for the development can be satisfied by the proposal without detrimental impacts upon traffic and amenity. For the reasons provided in paragraphs [36] to [150] above, I am not satisfied that there is a community, economic or planning need for the proposed development. By themselves, the absence of unacceptable traffic and amenity impacts provide little support to an approval of the proposed development. Would the proposed development consolidate rather than fragment the Underwood district centre? As I have already explained above, I do not accept the evidence of Ms Meulman that the proposed development will consolidate retail expenditure that is currently escaping the trade area. On this issue, I prefer the evidence of Mr Duane, that the proposed development would divert a high volume of sales from the Underwood district centre. As was explained by Mr Duane, this may place the future of tenants in the Underwood district centre in jeopardy. The matters referred to in paragraph [119] above would compound the unacceptable impact occasioned by the diversion of sales.