Shuk v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Shuk v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPIC 438

CLAIMANT:

Shuveccha Islam Shuk

INSURER:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

MEMBER:

Terence Stern OAM

DATE OF DECISION:

1 September 2023

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Torts; negligence; motor vehicle colliding with pedestrian; whether contributory negligence greater than 61%; application of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 section 3.11 and Civil Liability Act 2002 section 5R; Held – the accident was not caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the Claimant.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.36(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 and cl 7.497 of the Motor

Accident Guidelines

The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows:

1. For the purposes of s 3.11 the motor accident was not caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the Claimant.

2.        For the purposes of ss 3.28 or 3.36 the motor accident was not caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the Claimant.

3.        Legal Costs: The amount of the claimant’s costs assessed in accordance with the Motor

Accident Injuries Regulation 2017, Personal Injury Commission Regulation 2020 is $1,980.00 inclusive of GST.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

Issued under s 7.36(5) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

Background

  1. Shuveccha Islam Shuk (the Claimant) was involved in a motor vehicle accident on 5 March 2021.

  2. On 2 July 2021, the insurer determined that the claimant was mostly at fault for the subject accident.

  3. On 4 August 2021, the Claimant sought an internal review of this decision. By Certificate of Determination of the internal review dated 24 August 2021, the Insurer affirmed its position that the Claimant was mostly at fault. The Claimant has brought this Miscellaneous Claim application to dispute that outcome.

The accident

  1. The Application for Personal Injury Benefits dated 31 March 2021 states that at the Claimant was crossing the road in an attempt to catch a connecting bus on the other side of the road when she was hit by the insured vehicle. More specifically, the insured vehicle ran over her right foot.

  2. The incident was caught on CCTV footage taken from the front of the Collector Hotel out of the front of the EAT GRK Restaurant. I will set out my findings based on the CCTV footage below.

  3. An independent witness, Scott Williams, provided an account of the circumstances of the accident in his signed statement dated 18 June 2021 stating that:

    “…he noted a bus stopped on his right and he saw a woman who was hit, get out the front door and walk towards the rear of the bus towards him. He saw the second bus then pull in behind the one from which the claimant alighted, stopping two or three metres behind it. He then saw the claimant step off the kerb onto the road between the two buses and walk quickly out into the second lane. He said that the claimant did not appear to look right to oncoming traffic at all. He…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shuk v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shuk was a pedestrian who was struck by a vehicle driven by Allianz. Shuk sought damages for her injuries. The primary legal issue was whether Shuk's contributory negligence exceeded 61%, and if so, whether Allianz was entitled to a reduction in damages under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 and Civil Liability Act 2002. The court had to consider the degree of fault on both sides, the circumstances of the accident, and the evidence provided by witnesses and CCTV footage.

The court considered the evidence of the Claimant, who stated that she believed she had sufficient distance to cross the road and walk behind the bus, and the driver, who claimed to be looking ahead and focusing on the road. The CCTV footage was critical in determining the sequence of events, revealing that the Claimant stepped off the bus and walked between it and another bus before the second bus arrived. The court found that the Claimant was not contributory negligent to the extent of 61% or more, as she had a reasonable belief that she had enough distance to cross the road and was not looking in the driver's direction. Additionally, the driver was found to not have kept a proper lookout, as she could have seen the Claimant had she been paying attention.

Based on the findings, the court ruled that Shuk's contributory negligence did not exceed 61%, and Allianz was not entitled to a reduction in damages. The court emphasised that the accident was not caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the Claimant.

The court ordered Allianz to pay damages to Shuk without any reduction for contributory negligence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the risk of duplication, I repeat by way of emphasis, key parts of the evidence:·Oral evidence“…As she alighted from the bus and walked alongside to its rear, she was looking in the direction from which the insured vehicle was travelling… (believed) that she had sufficient distance to be able to cross the road and walked behind the bus..”·Constable BogaertsObtains CCTV footage from Collector Hotel. With cameras outside.·Ashtarout Mokdad Statement [34].. She was also wearing a cap, sunglasses, a Covid mask and she had earbuds in her ears. I saw all of that after the accident. [35]… Had turned right from Phillip St in Smith St… Travelled in a single southbound land on Smith St at about 45-50 km/h… At the most… [36] Saw that there were two buses parked on the left hand side of the road, about 75 metres south of Philip St, but I saw no other pedestrians about and I did not see any other vehicles heading [in] my direction… [37] I was looking ahead and focusing on the road. Next thing when I was about halfway along the length of the rear bus, when I saw the pedestrian pop out between the two buses that were only a metre or two apart. She appeared to be looking directly across the road and not in my direction.”·Scott Thomas[8] Was walking to pick up my child out along Smith St, past the Collector Hotel.[9] A bus stopped on my right, and I saw the woman… get out of the front door and walk towards the rear of the bus towards me.[10] I saw a second bus then pull up behind the one she got off and it stopped about two or three metres behind the front one. I then saw the female step off the kerb onto the road between the two buses and walk fairly quickly out into the second through lane. Viewed carefully, the CCTV footage is helpful in showing what happened. Firstly, Mr Thomas was incorrect in what he said at [10]. The second bus did not pull up as he said, nor did the Claimant walk between the two buses. Rather, the second bus pulled up about 6 seconds after the accident. Further, as a matter of common sense, the second bus would have taken some time, in slowing down from whatever speed it was travelling at, before pulling up, and this would have affected the amount of time that would have been available to the Insured driver to observe the presence of the Claimant, assuming the driver was keeping a proper lookout. The Claimant stated in her evidence at the Assessment Conference that as she stepped off the bus and walked alongside to its rear, she was looking in the direction from which the Insured vehicle was coming. She told Member Nolan words to the effect that she perceived that she had sufficient distance to be able to cross the road and walk behind the bus. There is no reason to doubt the truthfulness of that testimony. The Claimant has been, for example, honest about having to catch the bus on the other side of the road and about not having looked to the right before she actually stepped onto the road. The next significant fact I find is that the Insured driver was looking directly ahead and “focusing on the road.” Had she been keeping a proper lookout, I infer that she would, on the balance of probabilities, have been able to see the Claimant, who had left the back of the parked bus well before the arrival of the second bus, which was not in the CCTV frame until after the accident had taken place.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established