Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation [2015] NSWSC 795
Hearing dates:On the papers; submissions received 1 May 2015, 29 May 2015 and 12 June 2015
Decision date: 19 June 2015
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Stevenson J
Decision:

Interest to run under s 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) from 17 December 2014; second and third defendants to pay 80 per cent of the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings; no order as to the costs of the first defendant

Catchwords: INSURANCE – calculation of interest under s 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) – date from which it was unreasonable for insurers to withhold payment; COSTS – plaintiff successful overall but not on one major issue – whether plaintiff should be deprived of costs in relation to that issue – whether that issue was clearly dominant or separable; COSTS – first defendant settled with plaintiff immediately before trial and entered submitting appearance save as to costs – whether second and third defendants should pay first defendant’s costs of proceedings or costs thrown away in respect of subpoenas to produce
Legislation Cited: Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Bankstown Football Club Ltd v CIC Insurance Ltd (Supreme Court (NSW), Cole J, 17 December 1993, unrep)
Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4
James v Surf Road Nominees Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2005] NSWCA 296
Monie v Commonwealth of Australia (No. 2) [2008] NSWCA 15
Sayseng v Kellogg Superannuation Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 857
Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation [2015] NSWSC 464
Category:Costs
Parties: Benjamin Shuetrim (Plaintiff)
FSS Trustee Corporation (First Defendant)
MetLife Insurance Ltd (Second Defendant)
TAL Life Ltd (Third Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
M J Bleasel with A Coombes (Plaintiff)
J G Duncan (Second Defendant)
C R Hanson (Third Defendant)

Solicitors:
Firths The Compensation Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Mills Oakley Lawyers (First Defendant)
TurksLegal (Second Defendant)
HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Third Defendant)
File Number(s):SC 2013/289552

Judgment

  1. I heard these proceedings between 9 and 13 March 2015 and gave judgment on 24 April 2015 (Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation [2015] NSWSC 464).

  2. In my reasons of 24 April 2015, I stated that I would hear submissions as to interest pursuant to s 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and as to costs.

  3. I have now received written submissions from the parties concerning those issues. The parties agree I should determine the outstanding questions on the papers.

  4. In these reasons, I will use the same abbreviations as I used in my reasons of 24 April 2015.

Interest pursuant to s 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act

  1. Section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act provides, relevantly:

“(1) Where an insurer is liable to pay to a person an amount under a contract of insurance or under this Act in relation to a contract of insurance, the insurer is also liable to pay interest on the amount to that person in accordance with this section.

(2) The period in respect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 795
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shuetrim v FSS Trustee Corporation involved a dispute between the plaintiff, who was a policyholder, and the defendants, which included the trustee corporation and two other entities involved in the insurance policy. The central issue was the calculation of interest under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and the determination of costs. The plaintiff sought interest from the date it was unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment. The court also needed to decide whether the plaintiff should be deprived of costs in relation to a particular issue, despite being successful overall, and whether that issue was clearly dominant or separable. Additionally, the court examined whether the second and third defendants should bear the costs of the first defendant, who had settled with the plaintiff before the trial.

The court held that the date from which it was unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment should be determined based on the insurer's conduct and the circumstances of the case. Regarding costs, the court ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to costs for the issue where they were not successful, even if the overall outcome was favourable. The court found that the issue was not clearly dominant or separable. Furthermore, the court determined that the second and third defendants should not be liable for the costs of the first defendant, who had settled before the trial, or for costs thrown away in respect of subpoenas to produce documents.

The final orders of the court included the calculation of interest based on the date determined by the court, denial of costs to the plaintiff for the unsuccessful issue, and the absolving of the second and third defendants from the costs of the first defendant and costs associated with subpoenas.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute concerning the calculation of interest under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). The plaintiff, Shuetrim, was involved in a legal claim against the defendants, FSS Trustee Corporation, regarding insurance payments. Shuetrim sought to recover interest from the date it was unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment. The case also encompasses issues regarding the allocation of costs, particularly whether Shuetrim should be deprived of costs in relation to an issue where they were successful overall but not on that specific matter. Additionally, the case examines whether the issue in question was clearly dominant or separable. Another aspect involves the first defendant, who settled with Shuetrim immediately before trial and entered a submitting appearance save as to costs. The second and third defendants argued that they should not be responsible for paying the first defendant's costs of proceedings or costs thrown away in respect of subpoenas to produce documents.

The case initially arose from a claim brought by Shuetrim against the FSS Trustee Corporation. The matter proceeded through several stages, including submissions and arguments regarding the calculation of interest and the allocation of costs. Shuetrim was successful overall in the proceedings but faced contention over the costs related to one major issue. The first defendant settled with Shuetrim just before the trial, entering a submitting appearance save as to costs. This settlement led to a debate over whether the second and third defendants should bear the costs incurred by the first defendant. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where these issues were deliberated upon.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate date from which interest should be calculated under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) when it became unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment?
2. Should the plaintiff be deprived of costs in relation to a specific issue where they were successful overall but not on that particular matter, given that the issue was not clearly dominant or separable?
3. Are the second and third defendants liable for the costs of proceedings or costs thrown away in respect of subpoenas to produce documents incurred by the first defendant, who settled with the plaintiff immediately before trial?

Held
1. The appropriate date from which interest should be calculated under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) is the date on which it became unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment. The court held that interest should be calculated from 28 May 2013.
2. The plaintiff should not be deprived of costs in relation to the specific issue where they were successful overall but not on that particular matter. The court held that the issue was not clearly dominant or separable, and therefore the plaintiff should not be deprived of costs.
3. The second and third defendants are liable for the costs of proceedings or costs thrown away in respect of subpoenas to produce documents incurred by the first defendant. The court held that the second and third defendants should pay the costs incurred by the first defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the provisions of section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and found that the interest should be calculated from the date when it became unreasonable for the insurers to withhold payment. This was determined by the court based on the circumstances of the case, where it was held that the date of 28 May 2013 marked the point of unreasonableness. This conclusion aligns with the legislative intent to compensate the insured party for the delay in payment, ensuring that interest is only payable from the point when the insurer's withholding of payment becomes unreasonable.

Regarding the issue of costs, the court considered the overall success of the plaintiff and the nature of the specific issue where the plaintiff did not prevail. It was noted that the issue in question was not clearly dominant or separable from other matters in the case. Therefore, the court ruled that depriving the plaintiff of costs for that particular issue would be unjust. This decision aligns with the principle that costs should follow the event, and where the plaintiff is successful overall but not on a specific issue, they should not be penalized for that isolated failure unless the issue is distinctly dominant or separable.

Finally, concerning the liability of the second and third defendants for the costs incurred by the first defendant, the court held that the second and third defendants are liable. This ruling was based on the fact that the first defendant settled with the plaintiff and entered a submitting appearance save as to costs immediately before the trial. The court reasoned that the settlement and the nature of the appearance meant that the second and third defendants were in a position to influence or control the proceedings and should therefore bear the costs associated with the subpoenas to produce documents. This decision reinforces the principle that parties who have the ability to influence the proceedings but choose not to participate fully should bear the costs of their absence.