Short and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Short and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 1437 (25 May 2022)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:2019/8476          

Re:JAYDEN AUSTIN SHORT  

APPLICANT

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE AGENCYAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Katter

Date:25 May 2022  

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........................[SGD]................................

Senior Member Katter

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE AGENCY – access to the scheme – multiple impairments – whether impairments are permanent – whether impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunals Act 1975 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

CASES

MRLK and NDIA [2021] AATA 3896

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 233 FCR 201

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Katter

25 May 2022

APPLICATION

  1. This is a review of the Respondent’s decision that the Applicant did “not meet the access criteria”[1] in section 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (“the Act”). 

    [1]        Exhibit 3, T2, p 22.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant, Jayden Short, is a 22-year-old[2].

    [2]        Transcript, 16 December 2021, p 54 line 38.

  3. The Applicant has been living in the State of Queensland[3]. 

    [3]        Transcript, 16 December 2021, p 26 line 10 and p 28 line 30; Exhibit 3, T4, p 29, p 1 of 8.

    4.The Applicant signed an “access request form”[4] on 11 February 2019[5].  In the form at Part E, the Applicant answered as to “my carer’s full name”:  “Elizabeth Short”[6].  At Part F of the form, the Applicant stated the following “disability, or need for early intervention supports”[7]:

    [4]        Exhibit 3, T4, p 29.

    [5]        Ibid, p 36.

    [6]        Ibid, p 32.

    [7]        Ibid, p 32.

Primary disability: 
(This is the disability that has the most impact on your daily life)
Scheuermann’s disease
Schrolosis
Chronic back pain
Please list any other disabilities (if any):
Did you acquire your disability because of an injury? No
Are you seeking, or have you previously sought compensation related to your disability or injury? No
  1. The Applicant, on the form, “asked a professional”[8], Dr Ng, a general practitioner, to complete Part F[9]:

    [8]        Ibid, pp 33-35.

    [9]        Ibid, pp 33-35.

    “ … Length of time you have known or treated the person making request?  4 years

    Primary disability and any secondary disabilities:  Scheuermanns disease

    Current treatment (if any):  Oral analgesis  Exercise

    Is there any other treatment that is likely to remedy the impairment?  No …   Does the person require assistance to be mobile because of their disability?  Yes,               needs assistance from other persons:  (physical assistance, guidance,   supervision or prompting) 

    If yes, please describe the type of assistance required:  May at times require        assistance to change positions.  Get out from a reading position.  Will   benefit from assistive technology to help with getting in and out of bed and                    chairs. …

    Does the person require assistance to communicate effectively because of their               disability?  No, does not need assistance …

    Does the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Short and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 1437
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Jayden Short (the applicant) for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the respondent) that he did not meet the access criteria for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) under section 21 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). The applicant, a 22-year-old, had lodged an access request form in February 2019, supported by medical documentation from his general practitioner and an orthopaedic surgeon, detailing his condition of Scheuermann's disease and the assistance he required with mobility, showering, and self-management tasks such as cooking and cleaning. The respondent initially decided the applicant did not meet the access requirements, specifically citing the criterion in section 24(1)(b) that an impairment must be permanent or likely to be permanent. An internal review confirmed this decision, again highlighting the permanency criteria as the primary issue. The applicant sought review of this internal review decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the access criteria for the NDIS, specifically focusing on whether his impairments were permanent or likely to be permanent, and whether these impairments resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity. The Tribunal also needed to consider whether the applicant satisfied the criteria relating to the need for lifetime NDIS support, early intervention supports, and whether the NDIS was the most appropriate support system. The applicant contended that the respondent's assessment of his functional impact was incorrect and disagreed with the overall reasoning and conclusions presented in the refusal letters.

The Tribunal considered various medical reports and assessments, including those from a rehabilitation physician, general practitioner, orthopaedic surgeon, and an exercise physiologist. The respondent's internal review report indicated that while the applicant met the age and residence criteria, he failed to satisfy the disability requirements under section 24, including permanence, and the early intervention criteria under section 25. The applicant's grounds for review specifically challenged the assessment of his functional impact and the respondent's interpretation of the relevant rules. The Tribunal's reasoning and final orders are not detailed in the provided text.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a review of the Respondent’s decision that the Applicant did “not meet the access criteria”[1] in section 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (“the Act”). [1] Exhibit 3, T2, p 22.BACKGROUND The Applicant, Jayden Short, is a 22-year-old[2]. [2] Transcript, 16 December 2021, p 54 line 38. The Applicant has been living in the State of Queensland[3]. [3] Transcript, 16 December 2021, p 26 line 10 and p 28 line 30; Exhibit 3, T4, p 29, p 1 of 8.4.The Applicant signed an “access request form”[4] on 11 February 2019[5]. In the form at Part E, the Applicant answered as to “my carer’s full name”: “Elizabeth Short”[6]. At Part F of the form, the Applicant stated the following “disability, or need for early intervention supports”[7]:[4] Exhibit 3, T4, p 29.[5] Ibid, p 36.[6] Ibid, p 32.[7] Ibid, p 32. The Applicant, on the form, “asked a professional”[8], Dr Ng, a general practitioner, to complete Part F[9]: [8] Ibid, pp 33-35.[9] Ibid, pp 33-35.“ … Length of time you have known or treated the person making request? 4 years Primary disability and any secondary disabilities: Scheuermanns disease Current treatment (if any): Oral analgesis Exercise Is there any other treatment that is likely to remedy the impairment? No … Does the person require assistance to be mobile because of their disability? Yes, needs assistance from other persons: (physical assistance, guidance, supervision or prompting) If yes, please describe the type of assistance required: May at times require assistance to change positions. Get out from a reading position. Will benefit from assistive technology to help with getting in and out of bed and chairs. … Does the person require assistance to communicate effectively because of their disability? No, does not need assistance … Does the person require assistance to interact socially because of their disability? No, does not need assistance … Does the person require assistance to learn effectively because of their disability? No, does not need assistance … Does the person require assistance with self-care because of their disability? Yes, need assistance from another person in the areas of: showering/bathing …If yes, please describe the type of assistance required: At times may require assistance after bathing to change position. Difficulty washing his own back and legs, needs assistance with this. … Does the person require assistance with self-management because of their disability? Yes, needs assistance from other persons: (physical assistance, guidance, supervision or prompting)If yes, please describe the type of assistance required: Needs assistance with cooking and cleaning as has difficulty lifting. … Date 10/2/2019” With that access request form[10] there were documents as to the Applicant, by Dr Ng and Dr Albietz, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon[11]. [10] Ibid, p 29.[11] Exhibit 3, T4A, pp 37-39. By a letter dated 23 August 2019, stated to be by a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) of the Respondent[12], it was stated[13]: “I am writing to let you know the outcome of your request to access the National Disability Insurance Scheme … . Unfortunately, based on the information provided, you do not meet the access requirements set out in the [Act] to become a participant of the [National Disability Insurance Scheme]. … Section 24 of the … Act outlines specific disability requirements to access the [National Disability Insurance Scheme]. Based on the information provided, you do not meet these requirements. More specifically, the requirement in: Section 24(1)(b) of the … Act, which requires that you must have an impairment that is permanent, or is likely to be permanent. … While you are not able to access supports through the [National Disability Insurance Scheme], this decision in no way affects any existing supports you receive. … If you disagree with this decision or have new information, you can submit a request for the decision to be reviewed within 3 months from the date of this letter. Details about how to do this are at the end of this letter.”[12] Exhibit 3, T8, p 42.[13] Ibid.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

By a letter dated 21 November 2019, stated to be by a delegate of the CEO of the Respondent[17], the following was stated[18]: “ … Internal review (s 100) of our earlier access decision (s 20) … I am writing [in] response to your request of 4/09/2019 that the National Disability Insurance Agency … review our earlier decision made on 21/08/2019 that you did not meet the access criteria to become a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme … . After careful consideration of your review request and the evidence you have provided, I have decided to confirm the earlier decision. This means that you will not be able to access the [NDIS] at this time. The main issue … with your application is the permanency criteria. My full reasons are set out in the enclosed review report, which also suggests other community and government programs that may support your needs. Please note that the staff member who made the earlier decision was not involved in this review. I understand that this response may not be what you had hoped for. If you would like to discuss the reasons, please contact the [National Disability Insurance Agency] on the numbers below to make a time to do so. You may also apply to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal … within 28 days of receiving this letter for a further, external review of the decision. More information about external reviews of [NDIS] guidelines is available at part 6 of the [NDIS] Operational Guideline – Review of Decisions. … ” [17] Exhibit 3, T2, p 21.[18] Ibid, p 20. The reasons as to the internal review[19] referred to consideration of the following documents[20]:“ … 1. Dr Leah Goodwin (Rehabilitation Physician), letter, 27 April 2018. 2. Dr Reynard Ng (General Practitioner), Access Request Form, 10 February 2019. 3. Dr John Albeitz (Orthopaedic Surgeon), letter, 23 April 2019. 4. Dr Reynard Ng (General Practitioner), letter, 2 May 2019. 5. Ian Montgomery (Exercise Physiologist), assessment report, 1 May 2019. 6. Jayden Short, Email, 26 June 2019 … ”[19] Ibid, p 20.[20] Ibid, p 22. The reasons stated that the following access criteria were satisfied[21]: section 22 age and section 23 residence. The reasons stated that the following access criteria were not satisfied[22]: section 24 disability (criteria (a) on impairments, (b) on permanence, (e) on lifetime NDIS support), section 25 early intervention (criteria (a) on impairments, (b) on reducing future need for support and (c) on improving capacity) and section 25(3) that the NDIS is the most appropriate support system. [21] Ibid, p 22.[22] Ibid, pp 23-26. An application for review of decision was submitted to the Tribunal on 17 December 2019[23]. In the application for review form, the Applicant seeks review of the decision made on 21 November 2019[24]. “As to why the decision of 21 November 2019 is wrong”, the Applicant stated[25]: “ … they have stated things on their refusal letter which I do not agree with and [I] feel that the decision needs to be reviewed by the [Tribunal]. Criteria (c) on functional impact is wrong[;] rule 5.4 I do not agree with. I do not agree with the whole letter and why they have reached the decision and the things that have been stated in the letter.”[23] Exhibit 3, T1, p 15.[24] Exhibit 3, T2, p 20.[25] Exhibit 3, T1, p 19. SECTION 24

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established