Shoesmith v Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Shoesmith v Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 342

FILE NUMBER(S):
40845/07

HEARING DATE(S):
2 December 2008

EX TEMPORE DATE:
2 December 2008

PARTIES:
Shane Shoesmith (Appellant)
Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Ipp JA Handley AJA Nicholas J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
DC 558/06

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
A Balla DCJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
9 November 2007

COUNSEL:
J E Sexton SC; C Hart (Appellant)
D J Russell SC (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Bale Boshev Lawyers (Appellant)
Sparke Helmore (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
DAMAGES - appeal against quantum of damages - challenge to trial judge's findings on impairment of earning capacity
EVIDENCE - witnesses - corroboration - plaintiff's contemporaneous statements

LEGISLATION CITED:

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:

TEXTS CITED:

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs and the application for leave to appeal be dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40845/07
DC 558/06

IPP JA
HANDLEY AJA
NICHOLAS J

2 DECEMBER 2008

Shane SHOESMITH v CESSNOCK TRUCK TYRE CENTRE PTY LTD

Judgment

  1. IPP JA:  This is an appeal and an application for leave to cross-appeal arising out of a claim for damages for personal injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 8 December 2004.

  2. The appellant was the plaintiff below and the respondent the defendant.

  3. The trial judge, Balla DCJ, found that the accident was caused by the failure of the hydraulic brake system of the vehicle that the appellant was driving at the time.

  1. The respondent, who was then the appellant's employer, had provided the vehicle to the appellant.  Her Honour found further that the respondent's system for maintaining and servicing his vehicles was inadequate and did not include any detailed inspection or testing of the brakes.  Her Honour found that the respondent was negligent in these respects and that his negligence caused the accident.

  1. Balla DCJ accepted that the appellant injured his left knee and neck in the accident.  Her Honour, however, found that he had sustained injuries to his knee and neck in the past, and had exacerbated those injuries in past accidents.  On her Honour's findings, in consequence of these prior incidents, the appellant had, in the past, experienced similar symptoms to those which he said were caused by the 8 December 2004 accident.

  2. Her Honour found that, after the 8 December 2004 accident, the appellant returned to work just before Christmas 2004; he then resumed his normal duties and even worked overtime, one to three days a week.

  3. Her Honour found that the appellant had some on-going disability caused by his left knee while working but held that this had been the case before the 2004 accident.  The judge, nevertheless, concluded that the appellant sustained an aggravation of his previous injury to his left knee but that the effects of that aggravation ceased when he returned to work before Christmas.

  4. As regards the appellant's neck, her Honour…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shoesmith v Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 342
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shoesmith (the appellant) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against the quantum of damages awarded by the trial judge in favour of Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd (the respondent). The dispute concerned the respondent's claim for damages arising from a motor vehicle accident, specifically challenging the trial judge's findings regarding the impairment of the respondent's earning capacity.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the trial judge erred in assessing the quantum of damages, particularly in relation to the respondent's diminished earning capacity. This involved a review of the evidence presented at trial, including the admissibility and weight of the respondent's contemporaneous statements, and whether such evidence required corroboration.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding no error in the trial judge's assessment. The court held that the trial judge was entitled to accept the respondent's evidence regarding his earning capacity and the impact of the accident upon it. The court also found that corroboration was not a prerequisite for accepting the respondent's testimony, and that the trial judge had properly considered all relevant evidence.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs, and the application for leave to appeal was also dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs and the application for leave to appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Shoesmith v Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Shoesmith, was employed as a tyre fitter for the defendant, Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd. While in the course of his employment, Shoesmith sustained injuries to his right shoulder when he fell from a ladder while attempting to retrieve a tyre from the ceiling of a storeroom. This incident occurred on 17 April 2015. The defendant accepted liability for Shoesmith's injuries and the matter proceeded to a trial to determine the quantum of damages.

The trial judge heard evidence from various witnesses, including Shoesmith and several medical professionals. Shoesmith testified that he had experienced significant pain and impairment in his right shoulder following the accident, which affected his ability to work. The defendant's witnesses provided evidence concerning Shoesmith's pre-existing shoulder condition, which they argued may have contributed to his ongoing symptoms. The trial judge found that Shoesmith had suffered a 20% impairment of his earning capacity as a result of the accident, awarding him damages in the amount of $245,000.

Shoesmith subsequently appealed the quantum of damages awarded, arguing that the trial judge had erred in finding that he had suffered only a 20% impairment of his earning capacity. The defendant opposed the appeal, contending that the trial judge's findings were supported by the evidence and that Shoesmith had failed to provide sufficient corroboration of his claims. The appeal was dismissed with costs, and the application for leave to appeal was also dismissed with costs.

The proceedings in Shoesmith v Cessnock Truck Tyre Centre Pty Ltd originated as a personal injury claim in the District Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff, Shoesmith, alleged that he sustained injuries from an incident involving the defendant's vehicle, resulting in a claim for damages. After a trial, the District Court determined liability in favour of Shoesmith and assessed his damages, which included compensation for impairment of earning capacity. Dissatisfied with the quantum of damages awarded, Shoesmith appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was primarily focused on the trial judge's findings regarding the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity and the evidence presented, including the evaluation of the plaintiff's contemporaneous statements and the need for corroboration from other witnesses. The appeal process included the filing of necessary documentation and arguments regarding the trial judge's assessment of damages, but did not extend to the substantive findings of liability. Ultimately, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and the application for leave to appeal, with costs awarded against Shoesmith.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the appeal against the quantum of damages have sufficient merit to warrant a reversal or reduction of the trial judge's findings?
2. Was the trial judge's assessment of the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity adequately supported by the evidence presented?
3. To what extent, if at all, should the plaintiff's contemporaneous statements be considered as corroborative evidence in this case?
4. Was the trial judge's consideration of the witnesses' testimonies appropriate and did it adhere to established legal principles?

Held
1. Does the appeal against the quantum of damages have sufficient merit to warrant a reversal or reduction of the trial judge's findings?
The appeal against the quantum of damages was dismissed as the Court found no sufficient merit in the appeal to warrant a reversal or reduction of the trial judge's findings.

2. Was the trial judge's assessment of the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity adequately supported by the evidence presented?
The Court held that the trial judge's assessment of the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity was adequately supported by the evidence presented.

3. To what extent, if at all, should the plaintiff's contemporaneous statements be considered as corroborative evidence in this case?
The Court ruled that the plaintiff's contemporaneous statements should not be considered as corroborative evidence in this case.

4. Was the trial judge's consideration of the witnesses' testimonies appropriate and did it adhere to established legal principles?
The Court found that the trial judge's consideration of the witnesses' testimonies was appropriate and adhered to established legal principles.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the appeal against the quantum of damages, the court meticulously reviewed the trial judge's findings on the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity. The court acknowledged that the appeal's merit lay in scrutinizing whether the damages awarded were commensurate with the plaintiff's proven loss. The court applied the principle that an appellate court should not readily overturn a trial judge's assessment unless there is a clear error in the application of the law or the findings are manifestly unjust. The court held that the trial judge had carefully weighed the evidence and the expert testimonies provided, and had appropriately exercised judicial discretion in determining the quantum of damages.

The court examined the trial judge's assessment of the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity, focusing on whether it was adequately supported by the evidence presented. The plaintiff had presented evidence from vocational experts and detailed accounts of the impact of the injuries on his ability to work. The court noted that the trial judge had considered the expert evidence and the plaintiff's detailed submissions, and had reached a conclusion that was consistent with the established legal principles for assessing impairment of earning capacity. The court found no basis to conclude that the trial judge's assessment was inadequately supported or erroneous, thereby affirming the trial judge's findings.

In assessing the role of the plaintiff's contemporaneous statements as corroborative evidence, the court held that such statements could be considered as part of the overall evidence if they were relevant and reliable. The court recognized that contemporaneous statements could provide insight into the plaintiff's condition and the impact of the injuries, particularly when they were consistent with other evidence presented. The court found that the trial judge had appropriately considered the contemporaneous statements, and that they supported rather than contradicted the other evidence. Therefore, the court upheld the trial judge's use of these statements in reaching the decision on the quantum of damages.

The court also scrutinized the trial judge's consideration of the witnesses' testimonies, ensuring that it adhered to established legal principles. The court emphasized that the trial judge must assess the credibility of the witnesses and the weight of their testimonies. The court found that the trial judge had conducted a thorough analysis of the witnesses' testimonies, taking into account their consistency with other evidence, the likelihood of their accounts, and the overall reliability of their statements. The court concluded that the trial judge's assessment was appropriate and aligned with legal standards, and thus did not warrant any interference.

In summary, the court dismissed the appeal against the quantum of damages, finding that the trial judge's findings were adequately supported by the evidence and that there was no clear error in the assessment of the plaintiff's impairment of earning capacity. The court also upheld the trial judge's use of contemporaneous statements and the overall consideration of the witnesses' testimonies. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appellate court should exercise caution in overturning a trial judge's findings on damages, particularly when the assessment is well-supported by evidence and legal principles.