Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1407

Citation: Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1407
Appeal from: Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd [2010] FMCA 697
Parties: AUSTIN DOUGLAS SHIRREFF v BECK LEGAL PTY LTD
File number: VID 845 of 2010
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 15 December 2010
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – stay of sequestration order – interlocutory injunction restraining auction of assets or bankrupt estate – whether power to grant stay where appeal from judgment dismissing application to set aside sequestration order – whether appeal arguable – whether appeal rendered nugatory if relief not granted – balance of convenience
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 37, 52
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 29
Federal Court Rules (Cth) O 52 r 17
Cases cited: Carver v Joyce [1990] FCA 501
Coleman v Lazy Days Investments Pty Ltd (1994) 55 FCR 297
Evans v Heather Thiedeke Group Pty Ltd (1990) 95 ALR 424
Freeman v National Australia Bank Ltd [2002] FCA 427
Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 692
Date of hearing: 14 December 2010
Date of last submissions: 14 December 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr R Gordon
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr P White
Solicitor for the Respondent: Beck Legal Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Trustee in Bankruptcy: Mr M O'Brien (Solicitor)
Solicitor for the Trustee in Bankruptcy: Aitken Partners

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 845 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

AUSTIN DOUGLAS SHIRREFF
Appellant

AND:

BECK LEGAL PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 DECEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application made by notice of motion dated 7 December 2010, be refused.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 845 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

AUSTIN DOUGLAS SHIRREFF
Appellant

AND:

BECK LEGAL PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE:

15 DECEMBER 2010

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Austin Douglas Shirreff, who was made bankrupt on 30 July 2009, has filed a notice of appeal from a judgment dismissing the application to have the sequestration order set aside.  The appeal is fixed for hearing on 28 February 2011.  The bankrupt estate is estimated to have a surplus of assets over liabilities.  Mr Shirreff seeks orders staying the operation of the sequestration order and restraining the trustee in bankruptcy from holding a series of auctions of materials which are assets of the bankrupt estate, commencing on 18 December 2010, pending the hearing and determination of the appeal.  By a notice of motion dated 7 December 2010, Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Shirreff v Beck Legal Pty Ltd involves a bankruptcy appeal brought by the bankrupt, Mr Shirreff, against the decision of Whelan FM to dismiss his application to set aside the sequestration order made on 30 July 2009. Mr Shirreff applied for a stay of the sequestration order pending the hearing of the appeal. The legal issues that the court was required to decide included whether it had the power to grant a stay of the sequestration order where an appeal from a judgment dismissing an application to set aside that order had been lodged, and whether the appeal was arguable and if the stay would render the appeal nugatory. Additionally, the court had to consider the balance of convenience.

The court found that it had the power to grant a stay in the circumstances of this case, as the appeal was arguable and there was a real prospect that the appeal would succeed. The court also found that the balance of convenience favoured granting the stay, as the potential harm to Mr Shirreff if the stay was not granted outweighed any potential harm to the creditors if the stay was granted. The court considered that if the stay was not granted, the bankrupt would be unable to secure finance to pay his debts, which would ultimately benefit the creditors. The court therefore granted the stay of the sequestration order pending the hearing of the appeal.

In conclusion, the court refused the application for a stay of the sequestration order made by notice of motion dated 7 December 2010. However, the court's decision to grant the stay pending the hearing of the appeal indicates that the appeal has merit and the bankrupt has a real prospect of success in setting aside the sequestration order. The final orders of the court will be determined upon the outcome of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application made by notice of motion dated 7 December 2010, be refused.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The present application has arisen due to the trustee’s proposal to auction material stored on one of the properties in the bankrupt estate in a series of auctions scheduled to commence on 18 December 2010. The trustee’s letter to Mr Shirreff dated 1 December 2010 stated:Dear SirYOUR BANKRUPT ESTATE No. VIC 3732 of 2009I refer to previous communications regarding your bankrupt estate.I confirm that we have instructed Global Auctioneers and Valuers Pty Ltd ("Global") to assess the items of plant and equipment located at 117 Wimble Street, Seymour, Victoria and to provide a proposal for the realisation of same. Following Global's inspection and assessment of the site, it is their recommendation that a number of onsite clearing auction sales should be conducted to try and maximise the return to creditors of your bankrupt estate and to yourself.I note that Mr Peter Kirkham of Global is currently at the site cataloguing all items of plant and equipment in preparation for the first of a number of auctions. It is expected that approximately four (4) to six (6) auctions will need to be held to clear the external areas of the site and that this may take two (2) to six (6) months to complete. The internal warehouse will be dealt with after the external area is completed.I reiterate that, as Trustee of your bankrupt estate, I am required to comply with the Enforcement Order issued by Mitchell Shire Council currently pending against this property. Under no circumstances are you and/or any other party to enter the property during this process.I again invite you to provide me with your suggestions regarding the realisation strategy in order to achieve the best possible outcome for the assets which are currently stored at the Seymour property.Should you wish to discuss the above matter further, please do not hesitate to contact Ms Kate Fox or Mr Michael Carrafa of this office.Yours faithfully LOFTHOUSETrusteeBACKGROUND As appears from the affidavit and exhibits, on 30 July 2009, Mr Shirreff was made bankrupt pursuant to the order of Registrar Luxton who, in Mr Shirreff’s absence, made a sequestration order against his estate. On 30 July 2009, Mr Shirreff applied for a review of the sequestration order made on that day. On 16 September 2009, on the application of Beck Legal (the petitioning creditor), David Lofthouse was appointed trustee of the bankrupt estate in substitution for the original trustee, ITSA. On 3 March 2010, Burchardt FM dismissed Mr Shirreff’s application for review and affirmed the 30 July 2009 sequestration order. On 17 March 2010, Mr Shirreff lodged an appeal against Burchardt FM’s decision but subsequently, on legal advice, abandoned it, in order to apply instead for annulment of the sequestration order. (The appeal was dismissed on 30 April 2010.) On 18 May 2010, Mr Shirreff applied to set aside the sequestration order made on 30 July 2009 and for the annulment of his bankruptcy. On 10 September 2010, Whelan FM dismissed that application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Whelan FM stated:[32] The Trustee has expressed the view in his August 2010 affidavit, after sale of the Campbellfield property, that there is sufficient equity in the remaining properties to raise sufficient finance to pay out the estate in full. This may have also been the position in June 2009 and March 2010 but from the material before me, I am unable to come to such a conclusion. The Applicant’s assets may have exceeded his liabilities but it is not clear that these were realisable within a reasonable period of time.[33] A person who seeks an annulment carries what O’Loughlin J described in Re Papps; Ex parte Tapp as a “heavy burden”. On the material before me, including those matters about which Burchardt FM had no knowledge at the time of making his decision, but excluding events such as the sale of the Campbellfield property, which have occurred since, I am not satisfied that the Applicant has established that the Registrar was bound not to make the Sequestration Order and Burchardt FM was bound not to affirm that decision. I note in this regard that Flick J, in Samootin v Wagner, quoted the judgment of Fisher J in Re Franke; Ex parte Piliszky who concluded, where in considering the wording of the predecessor provision to s 153B:In my opinion it can be said that a judge “ought” not to have made an order only if he was “bound” not to make the order. In circumstances where it was open to a judge to make an order in the exercise of his discretion, it can only be said he “ought not to have made the order” if none of the circumstances could justify the making of an order.[34] Further, even if I was satisfied that the Applicant had established his solvency at the time the Sequestration Order was made, there are circumstances which would weigh against exercising my discretion in favour of the Applicant. These considerations would include the following:• The Applicant’s conduct of this matter, in particular his failure to oppose the making of the original Sequestration Order by the Registrar; the inadequacy of the information placed before Burchardt FM despite several adjournments being granted to him; his failure to lodge a statement of affairs until April 2010; and the paucity of the material which he chose to place before the court on the hearing of this application.• The fact that until the filing of this application, the Applicant had never asserted that he was solvent.• The fact that the Applicant continues to dispute some of the debts found by the Trustee in Bankruptcy and has made only vague and contradictory proposals about how, if his application was to be granted, he would pay his creditors.(footnotes omitted)Parties’ evidence on stay applicationAffidavit in support In his affidavit in support of the application for a stay, Mr Shirreff:1.deposed that Beck Legal was the petitioning creditor which claimed he owed $7,526.31 plus interest and costs;2.disputed the trustee’s estimates of his debts and liabilities set out in the trustee’s letter of 14 September 2010, both in relation to some items and to quantum. Mr Shirreff set out his own estimate of the liabilities, or stated that they were “to be taxed”;3.assessed the value of his assets at $4,020,000 with a net value of $3,620,000;4.deposed to rental income of approximately $60,000, which could rise to $100,000 if the properties could be leased;5.stated that if the sequestration order was annulled, he could operate his business to produce substantial additional income;6.deposed that a private lender had “verbally agreed” to provide finance to pay the debts and costs, and had submitted draft mortgages, but Mr Shirreff required the co‑operation of the trustee to obtain the finance, which Mr Lofthouse had refused; and7.further deposed:The trustee in a previous affidavit sworn in August 2010 has stated that there is sufficient equity in my remaining properties to raise finance to pay out the estate in full and has also in correspondence to and discussions with me stated that the best option for me is to seek finance and pay out all my debts and costs in relation to the sequestration order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DAVID J
The appeal, pursuant to the order of Gray J, is listed for hearing on 7 February 2011.Whelan FM’s decision Whelan FM observed that Mr Shirreff contended that the sequestration order should not have been made on 30 July 2009, because he was able to pay his debts as they fell due and had remained solvent thereafter. Whelan FM referred to the evidence on which Mr Shirreff (who was self‑represented) relied, including the affidavit of the trustee in bankruptcy, Mr Lofthouse, sworn on 10 August 2010, which identified four properties belonging to Mr Shirreff as follows:Airport West: subject to a mortgage to Australian Securities LimitedCampbellfield: which had been subject to a mortgage to Australian Securities Limited but had since been soldSeymour: subject to a mortgage to Australian Securities LimitedCoolaroo:subject to a mortgage to RMBL Investments Pty Ltd. Mr Lofthouse deposed that as at 2 December 2009, he had been unable to say if the realisation of the properties would produce sufficient funds to pay the costs of the bankruptcy administration and the proved debts in full. Mr Lofthouse also deposed that the applicant owned assets stored at the Coolaroo and Seymour properties. The Seymour property was subject to a VCAT Enforcement Order obtained by the local council in relation to unlawful storage of, inter alia¸ hazardous material. The Airport West property was also subject to council notices to comply, as the land was in an “unsightly, dangerous or detrimental state”. Mr Lofthouse was unable to estimate the cost of remediating the Seymour property to a saleable condition or whether the sale of the stored material would cover it. The Airport West property was valued at $1,450,000 but had a mortgage securing a debt of $300,000; the Coolaroo property had an estimated market value of $380,000 and was subject to a mortgage securing $110,000. Mr Lofthouse deposed that he could not verify the applicant’s claimed assets of $800,000 in scrap steel, and amounts he claimed regarding Kingfisher and Aussie Shelving. The Federal Magistrate stated:[16] The Trustee’s report set out a total of $481,500.00 owing to secured creditors and based on investigations to date, a total of $111,204.20 owed to unsecured creditors. The total costs and expenses of the Trustee was approaching $100,000.00.[17] Mr Lofthouse expressed the view that there was sufficient equity in the Airport West, the Coolaroo and Seymour properties to raise finance to pay out the estate in full if the bankrupt, with his consent, was able to have such a proposal approved by a financier. Otherwise it would be necessary for the Trustee to sell one or more of the properties in order to achieve this. The Federal Magistrate observed that the applicant asserted his solvency, disputed the amounts owed to creditors, and stated that if the bankruptcy were annulled, he would pay the trustee’s costs from the proceeds of sale of the Campbellfield property, but wished to control the refinancing himself.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DAVID J

In determining whether to grant a stay of the sequestration order, the court considered the power to do so in the context of a pending appeal. The court referenced established case law to conclude that it lacks the jurisdiction to grant a stay in these circumstances, as the power to grant a stay is discretionary and typically exercised when there is a real prospect of success on the merits of the appeal, or when there are significant hardships associated with not granting a stay. The court found that the appeal was arguable because the applicant had raised a genuine issue regarding his solvency at the time the sequestration order was made and had presented evidence suggesting that there was sufficient equity in his properties to raise finance to pay off the estate's debts. The court also found that the appeal would not be rendered nugatory if relief was not granted, as the applicant had not demonstrated that the sale of the assets would not proceed in the absence of a stay. Finally, the court considered the balance of convenience and concluded that it favoured denying the stay, as the trustee had already incurred significant costs in the administration of the estate and there was no clear indication that the applicant would be able to pay off the debts if the sequestration order were set aside. The court also noted that the applicant's conduct in the proceedings had been unsatisfactory, and that he had not provided sufficient information to the trustee to enable a proper assessment of his financial position.