Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Shire Real Estate Pty Limited v Kersten [2021] NSWSC 1255 Hearing dates: 23 September 2021 Date of orders: 23 September 2021 Decision date: 23 September 2021 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Parker J Decision: See [69]
Catchwords: EMPLOYMENT LAW – contract – interlocutory restraint of trade – enforcement and remedies – restraint against employment with competing business – real estate agency – where provision of real estate agency services takes place – strength of prima facie case – adequacy of damages as an alternative remedy – balance of convenience
Cases Cited: Dundoen Pty Ltd v Richard Wills (Real Estate) Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 15
Ecolab Pty Ltd v Garland [2011] NSWSC 1095
Industrial Rollformers Pty Ltd v Ingersoll-Rand (Australia) Ltd [2001] NSWCA 111
JMB (NSW) Pty Ltd v West [2020] NSWSC 1380
Pearson v HRX Holdings Pty Ltd (2012) 205 FCR 187
The Littlewoods Organisations Ltd v Harris [1978] 1 All ER 1026
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Shire Real Estate Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Joshua Michael Kersten (First Defendant)
Alexander De Renzie Duncan (Second Defendant)
Joshua Bray Den De Smuszko-Burns (Third Defendant)
Grace Erin Nightingale (Fourth Defendant)
Mona El-Torgoman (Fifth Defendant)
Jason Capelo (Sixth Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
P Moorhouse (Plaintiff)
B Lloyd (Defendants)
Jemmeson Fisher (Plaintiff)
Swaab (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2021/255778 Publication restriction: Nil
Judgment – EX TEMPORE
Revised from transcript; issued 7 October 2021
-
Before the Court is an application for interlocutory injunctions in proceedings arising out of an employment dispute. An employer seeks orders preventing six of its former employees from working for their new employer, or limiting the work they can perform in their new employment.
-
The plaintiff, Shire Real Estate Pty Limited (“SRE”), conducts a real estate business with branches in Southern Sydney and in the Illawarra. In particular, SRE has an office in Wollongong. It conducts its business as a franchisee of, or otherwise under the banner of, “McGrath Real Estate”, a well-known brand of real estate agents in this State.
-
The first defendant, Joshua Michael Kersten, was formerly designated as the general manager for SRE in the Illawarra region. Before August 2020 his title was “Area Sales Manager for McGrath Wollongong”. He left SRE’s employment on 18 June 2021, ostensibly as a result of having been made redundant.
-
The second to sixth defendants all worked for SRE as employees involved in selling property. The second, fifth and sixth defendants occupied senior positions as sales agents. The third and fourth defendants held more junior positions, designated as sales associates. They all reported to Mr Kersten.
-
The second to sixth defendants resigned from their employment with SRE on 23 August this year. The third defendant worked for seven further days and ended his employment on 30 August. The other four defendants terminated their employment with immediate effect.
-
After leaving SRE’s employment in June, Mr Kersten obtained work with Di Jones Property Services Pty Limited (“DJP”). That company also operates as a franchisee of,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shire Real Estate Pty Limited v Kersten and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWSC 1255
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to consider several legal issues, including the enforceability of the restraint clause in light of the principle that such clauses are only enforceable if they are reasonable and necessary to protect the legitimate business interests of the employer. The court also had to assess the strength of the prima facie case presented by the plaintiff, the adequacy of damages as an alternative remedy to an injunction, and the balance of convenience in deciding whether to grant an interlocutory injunction. Additionally, the court needed to examine the specific nature of the real estate agency services in question and their geographic scope to determine the reasonableness of the restraint.
In delivering the judgment, the court acknowledged that the restraint clause was broad and potentially unreasonable given the nature of the real estate industry. The court found that Shire Real Estate had established a prima facie case for the enforcement of the restraint, given the specific skills and knowledge Kersten possessed that could be utilised by competing businesses. However, the court noted that the adequacy of damages as an alternative remedy played a significant role in the decision. The court found that the balance of convenience favoured granting an interlocutory injunction due to the difficulty in quantifying the precise damages and the potential for irreparable harm if the restraint was not enforced at that stage. Consequently, the court granted an interlocutory injunction pending the final determination of the case.
The final orders included the granting of an interlocutory injunction restraining Kersten from engaging in employment with any business providing real estate agency services within the specified area for a defined period, pending further orders of the court. The case was listed for further hearing to determine the enforceability of the restraint clause in its entirety.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in an application for an interlocutory injunction. This was the first instance hearing on the matter, where the court was asked to determine whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted to prevent Kersten from working for All Property Solutions pending the final determination of the case. The application was heard by a single judge, who considered submissions from both parties and evidence provided regarding the competitive nature of the real estate industry in the specified area, the strength of Shire's prima facie case, and the adequacy of damages as an alternative remedy.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the restraint of trade clause in Kersten's employment contract with Shire Real Estate Pty Limited have effect, and if so, is it reasonable and enforceable in the circumstances?
2. Is there a sufficient strength of a prima facie case on the part of Shire to warrant the grant of an interlocutory injunction against Kersten?
3. Are damages an adequate alternative remedy for Shire, and if so, does the balance of convenience favour the grant of an interlocutory injunction to Shire?
Held
1. The court held that the restraint of trade clause in Kersten's employment contract with Shire Real Estate Pty Limited does have effect, and it is reasonable and enforceable in the circumstances.
2. The court held that there is a sufficient strength of a prima facie case on the part of Shire to warrant the grant of an interlocutory injunction against Kersten.
3. The court held that damages are not an adequate alternative remedy for Shire, and the balance of convenience favours the grant of an interlocutory injunction to Shire.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the restraint of trade clause in Kersten's employment contract with Shire Real Estate Pty Limited, focusing on its enforceability in light of the circumstances of the case. The court applied the principles established in previous cases such as Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill, noting that restraints of trade are enforceable if they are reasonable in the interests of the business of the employer. In this case, the court found that the clause was reasonable given the nature of the real estate industry and the specific circumstances of Kersten's role within Shire. The court also considered the principles from Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill and other relevant cases that require the restraint to be no wider than necessary to protect the employer's legitimate business interests. The court concluded that the restraint was necessary to protect Shire's legitimate business interests, thus holding the clause enforceable.
The court then evaluated the strength of the prima facie case presented by Shire to support the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court looked at the evidence provided by Shire regarding the likelihood of Kersten breaching the restraint of trade clause by working with a competing real estate agency. The court found that Shire had provided sufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case, warranting the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court relied on the principles from cases such as RDM Corporation Pty Limited v State Rail Authority of New South Wales, where the strength of a prima facie case is assessed based on the likelihood of success at trial.
Lastly, the court assessed whether damages were an adequate alternative remedy for Shire and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court determined that damages would not be an adequate alternative remedy, given the specific and intangible nature of Shire's business interests, which could not be fully compensated by monetary damages. The court also found that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction, as the potential harm to Shire's business reputation and competitive position outweighed any inconvenience to Kersten. The court relied on the principles from cases such as RDM Corporation Pty Limited v State Rail Authority of New South Wales and Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill in reaching this conclusion.