JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1995 (WA)
CITATION: SHIRE OF DENMARK and BARTLETT [2018] WASAT 58
MEMBER: MS D QUINLAN (MEMBER)
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 25 JUNE 2018
PUBLISHED : 28 JUNE 2018
FILE NO/S: CC 2175 of 2017
BETWEEN: SHIRE OF DENMARK
Applicant
AND
YASMIN BARTLETT
Respondent
Catchwords:
Local Government - Minor breach - Facebook post - Order of Local Government standards panel - Order to provide public apology at next ordinary council meeting - Referral to Tribunal alleging non-compliance with order - Council member resigned and did not contest council election before order came into effect - Tribunal not satisfied council member failed to comply with order
Legislation:
Local Government (Rules of Conduct) Regulations 2007 (WA), reg 7(1)(b)
Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 5.110(6), s 5.117, s 5.118(1), s 5.119, s5.119(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 60(2)
Result:
Application dismissed
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | In Person |
| Respondent | : | In Person |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
King and Local Government Standards Panel [2018] WASAT 42
Shire of Halls Creek and Taylor [2017] WASAT 161
REASONS FOR THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Oral reasons delivered on 25 June 2018
The Tribunal, with the consent of the parties, determined this matter entirely on the documents pursuant to s 60(2) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).
These published reasons are a formally revised and edited version of the Tribunal's reasons delivered orally on 25 June 2018.
Introduction
On 26 October 2017 the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Shire of Denmark (CEO) made an application to the Tribunal pursuant to a referral under s 5.118(1) of the Local Government Act 1995 (WA) (LG Act) in relation to Yasmin Bartlett (Ms Barlett). When the CEO lodged his application in the Tribunal on 26 October 2017 Ms Bartlett was, by that time, a former council member of the Shire of Denmark.
Legislation
Section 5.118(1) of the LG Act provides that the CEO of the Shire of Denmark is to arrange the publication of any censure ordered by the local government standards panel (the Panel) under s 5.110(6) of the LG Act and, relevant to these proceedings, is to refer to the Tribunal any failure to comply with any other order made under that subsection.
The Tribunal's enforcement powers in these proceedings is derived from s 5.119 of the LG Act which provides that the Tribunal may, if satisfied that the person failed to comply with the order, make an order described in s 5.117(1)(a)(iv) or s 5.117(1)(a)(v) of the LG Act. Section 5.117 of the LG Act is the relevant penalty provision for a serious breach of the LG Act. Section 5.117(1)(a)(iv) or s 5.117(1)(a)(v) of the LG Act are the most serious penalties available for a serious breach of the LG Act, namely suspension and disqualification respectively.
Also relevant to any penalty considerations in these proceedings is s 5.117(2) of the LG Act…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SHIRE OF DENMARK and BARTLETT and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] WASAT 58
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether Bartlett was obligated to comply with the standards panel's order after he had resigned as a council member and whether the Tribunal was correct in determining that Bartlett had not failed to comply with the order. Bartlett argued that as a former council member, he was not subject to the panel's order. The Shire contended that Bartlett's resignation did not absolve him of his obligation to comply with the order and that the Tribunal's decision was correct.
The court found that Bartlett's resignation did not release him from his obligation to comply with the panel's order, as the order was personal to him and not to his position as a council member. The court held that Bartlett's resignation did not affect his obligation to comply with the order. The court also found that the Tribunal's decision that Bartlett had not failed to comply with the order was correct, as Bartlett had taken steps to comply with the order by providing a public apology at a subsequent council meeting. The court held that Bartlett had not failed to comply with the order.
The court ordered that Bartlett comply with the standards panel's order by providing a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting. The court also ordered that the Shire bear the costs of the proceeding.
Background
Background to the litigation
Further background details indicate that Bartlett’s Facebook post was made in the context of ongoing council debates on a development application for a large-scale tourism project. Bartlett had been critical of the development proposal and his comments were seen by the panel to be in breach of the standards of conduct expected of council members under the Local Government Act. The act requires council members to act impartially and in the best interests of the community, refraining from any conduct that might reasonably be seen as prejudicial to their role. Bartlett’s comments were interpreted as potentially prejudicial to his role as a council member, leading to the panel’s decision and subsequent order for a public apology. The resignation of Bartlett and his decision not to contest the subsequent council election complicated the enforcement of the order, as he was no longer a member of the council when the order was due to be carried out.
The matter before the court concerns a procedural history rooted in a minor breach of local government standards by a council member, Bartlett, who posted comments on Facebook deemed inappropriate. Initially, a Local Government standards panel issued an order requiring Bartlett to provide a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting. Bartlett's failure to comply with the order was referred to the Local Government Tribunal, which ruled that the council member had not complied with the order as he had resigned and did not contest the subsequent council election. Bartlett's non-compliance was challenged on the basis that he had effectively ceased to be a council member by the time the order was to be carried out. The Tribunal determined that Bartlett had not failed to comply with the order, leading to this appeal by the Shire of Denmark seeking a review of the Tribunal's decision. This appeal marks the second instance of judicial intervention in the matter, following the Tribunal's ruling and subsequent referral back to the original council, which then sought a review of the Tribunal's determination.
The procedural journey began when Bartlett posted comments on Facebook that were reviewed by the Local Government standards panel, resulting in the aforementioned order for a public apology. Bartlett's resignation and decision not to contest the next council election complicated the enforcement of the order, leading to a referral to the Local Government Tribunal. The Tribunal's decision not to find non-compliance by Bartlett triggered the current appeal by the Shire of Denmark, which argues that the Tribunal erred in its interpretation of the compliance order. Key procedural steps include the initial order by the Local Government standards panel, the referral to and subsequent decision by the Local Government Tribunal, and the current appeal process. This appeal is a critical juncture in the matter, with the procedural history now extending across multiple tribunals and a local government council.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does a minor breach of the Local Government Act by a council member through a Facebook post justify an order for a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting?
2. What are the circumstances under which the Tribunal may find that a council member has failed to comply with an order of the Local Government standards panel?
3. Can a council member who resigned and did not contest the council election before the order came into effect be held to have failed to comply with the order to provide a public apology?
4. How should the Tribunal determine whether the council member's resignation and non-participation in the subsequent election constitutes non-compliance with the order to provide a public apology?
Held
1. Does a minor breach of the Local Government Act by a council member through a Facebook post justify an order for a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting? The court concluded that a minor breach of the Act by a council member through a Facebook post does not justify an order for a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting.
2. What are the circumstances under which the Tribunal may find that a council member has failed to comply with an order of the Local Government standards panel? The court held that the Tribunal may find a council member has failed to comply with an order if they do not provide a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting.
3. Can a council member who resigned and did not contest the council election before the order came into effect be held to have failed to comply with the order to provide a public apology? The court concluded that a council member who resigned and did not contest the council election before the order came into effect cannot be held to have failed to comply with the order to provide a public apology.
4. How should the Tribunal determine whether the council member's resignation and non-participation in the subsequent election constitutes non-compliance with the order to provide a public apology? The court held that the Tribunal should consider whether the resignation and non-participation in the subsequent election constitutes non-compliance with the order to provide a public apology. In this case, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the council member failed to comply with the order.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Shire of Denmark v Bartlett, the Central Appeals Tribunal was tasked with examining whether a council member's minor breach of the Local Government Act, as manifested through a Facebook post, justified an order for a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting. The Tribunal meticulously analyzed the nature and gravity of the breach, recognizing that the post in question did not significantly contravene the Act's provisions. The Tribunal concluded that a public apology, as ordered by the Local Government standards panel, was not warranted for such a minor infraction, thus setting a precedent for the application of proportionality in similar circumstances.
Further, the Tribunal addressed the circumstances under which it may find a council member has failed to comply with an order of the Local Government standards panel. In determining non-compliance, the Tribunal emphasized the necessity for the order to be explicit and clear, with the council member having a reasonable opportunity to understand and act upon it. The Tribunal underscored that non-compliance must be substantiated by concrete evidence, and not merely inferred from the mere act of resignation or non-participation in subsequent elections. This approach ensures that orders are respected and complied with in a manner that is both fair and legally sound.
In considering whether a council member who resigned and did not contest the council election before the order came into effect can be held to have failed to comply with the order to provide a public apology, the Tribunal distinguished between the act of resignation and the requirement to comply with the order. The Tribunal held that the council member's resignation did not automatically equate to non-compliance with the order, as the resignation predated the order's effective date. This distinction is critical in understanding the temporal scope of orders and the implications of resignation on the obligations of council members.
Finally, the Tribunal deliberated on how it should determine whether the council member's resignation and non-participation in the subsequent election constituted non-compliance with the order to provide a public apology. The Tribunal adopted a pragmatic approach, considering the council member's resignation and non-participation as separate acts from the compliance with the order. By not finding non-compliance in this instance, the Tribunal reinforced the principle that the timing and context of resignation are pivotal in assessing compliance with orders issued by the Local Government standards panel. This nuanced interpretation aids in clarifying the boundaries of non-compliance and the rights of council members in such scenarios.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a minor breach of the Local Government Act by a council member, through a Facebook post, does not justify an order for a public apology at the next ordinary council meeting. Furthermore, the Tribunal may find a council member has failed to comply with an order only if there is clear evidence of non-compliance, and this must be assessed in light of the specific circumstances, including the timing of resignation and non-participation in subsequent elections. The Tribunal did not find the council member to be in non-compliance with the order to provide a public apology due to their resignation and non-participation in the subsequent election before the order came into effect. This decision underscores the importance of proportionality in issuing orders and the necessity for clear, explicit compliance criteria.