Sherwood v The ANI Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Sherwood v The ANI Corporation Limited [1988] NSWLEC 147
PARTIES:

APPICANT
Sherwood

RESPONDENT
The ANI Corporation Limited
FILE NUMBER(S): 50019 of 1985
CORAM: Cripps J
KEY ISSUES: :-
LEGISLATION CITED: The Clean Air Act
CASES CITED:
DATES OF HEARING:
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
11/22/1988
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES: RESPONDENT
Mr Cox
Mr Ambler


JUDGMENT:

His Honour: Yesterday I dismissed four charges brought by Mr Sherwood on behalf of the State Pollution Control Commission against ANI with respect to offences under s 14(2) and I now formally dismiss the summonses.

So far as the remaining four charges are concerned, charges 1 and 4 have been the subject of a plea and I shall return to these matters later.

Charges 2 and 3 have been subject of further evidence after I rejected a submission on behalf of the Corporation that no prima facie case had been established, that is that there had been no case to answer.

It is true, as Mr Hall has submitted, that the evidence was much the same as it was at the end of the prosecution case with perhaps the charge of failing to control equipment, being the wet cap scrubber on the northern cupola, the evidence in chief and in the defendant's case persuades me that what occurred was the blow out of the ring spray at the joining flange. That resulted in a jet of water penetrating the water veil over the wet cap with the result that blue smoke was emitted, as seen by Mr Sherwood. Later Mr Cox, an employee, was asked about the matter. I assume he had some understanding of what had taken place, and he said: "I had inspected the cupola wet cap yesterday while it was in operation. The ring spray was fractured at the joining flange. The leaking water was under such pressure and of such volume being supplied by 3 inch water pipe from a supply pump that it was colliding with and disrupting the water curtain over the wet cap". He vouchsafed no reason why the ring spray should have fractured


, or indeed what knowledge the company had, if any, concerning the matter other than that stated.

Mr Ambler told Mr Sherwood: "My maintenance staff failed to either detect or rectify malfunctions of the cupola wet cap, the bag filter serving the wheel abrader, or the set scrubber serving the fettling shop. The wet scrubber has only recently been fitted with a new fan motor and when it was first switched on the current draw had been excessive". Pausing there, the reference to the bag filter serving the wheel abrader is a reference to one of the matters with respect to which a plea has been entered.

So it is reasonable, I think, to conclude that the spray pipe was fractured - it was not a new pipe. The company does not know why it fractured and, although I know that the company undertook some maintenance work designed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sherwood v The ANI Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1988] NSWLEC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, Sherwood brought a case against The ANI Corporation Limited, alleging violations of the Clean Air Act. The crux of the matter was whether The ANI Corporation Limited was guilty of failing to maintain its control equipment in an efficient condition, as stipulated by Section 14(1) of the Act. Sherwood claimed that the corporation's negligence led to the emission of blue smoke and other pollutants, contravening the Act's requirements.

The primary legal issue before the court was the interpretation of the phrase "maintain" in Section 14(1) of the Clean Air Act. Sherwood argued for a strict interpretation, asserting that the corporation's failure to maintain equipment efficiently constituted an offence regardless of their maintenance practices. Conversely, The ANI Corporation Limited contended that the term "maintain" implied that the corporation must have failed to undertake proper maintenance to prevent or rectify equipment malfunctions. The court had to determine whether the statutory obligation was absolute or whether it required a demonstration of the corporation's failure in proper maintenance.

The court held that the obligation imposed by Section 14(1) was indeed absolute or strict. The judge found that the corporation was guilty of failing to maintain equipment in an efficient condition, as evidenced by the incidents of equipment failure and resultant emissions. Despite the corporation's arguments and evidence presented, the court found no defence available under the statutes imposing strict liability. Consequently, The ANI Corporation Limited was convicted on all counts, and fines were imposed for each offence. The court also granted the company until a specified date to pay the fines.

In conclusion, the court ordered The ANI Corporation Limited to pay fines totalling $2000, with each fine amounting to $500 for each of the four offences. The court further noted that Sherwood would be entitled to costs related to the convictions and pleas, but the corporation would bear the costs of the stated case unless otherwise determined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established