Sherratt v Commissioner of State Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION: Sherratt v Commissioner of State Revenue [2013] QCAT 9
PARTIES: Karl Noel Sherratt
v
Commissioner of State Revenue
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR259-12
MATTER TYPE: General administrative review matters
HEARING DATE: On the papers
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Jim Allen, Member
DELIVERED ON: 7 January 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE: 1.    The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue dated 31 May 2012 is confirmed.
CATCHWORDS:

Review of decision of Commissioner of State Revenue – exemption from duty for transfer to correct clerical error

Duties Act 2001, s 152

Pryke & Ors v Commissioner of State Revenue [2007] QCA 121

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (QCAT Act).

REASONS FOR DECISION

History of the application

  1. Mr Sherratt and his wife purchased an investment property in 2010.  The title was registered in their names jointly and it was not until Mr Sherratt came to prepare his income tax return for the 2010/11 year that he became aware of a problem in the way the title to the property was held.  Mr and Mrs Sherratt then executed a transfer of the property from themselves to themselves but with the property to be held as tenants in common in the shares of Mr Sherratt 99/100 and Mrs Sherratt 1/100.  The consideration on the transfer was said to be “The desire to change the tenancy”.

  2. The transfer with statutory declarations from both Mr and Mrs Sherratt, the Office of State Revenue Form 2.2 and a recent title search were submitted to the Office of State Revenue for an assessment of duty. The letter accompanying the documents noted that the transfer was exempt under section 152 (exemption to correct clerical error) of the Duties Act 2001.

  3. The assessor dealing with the matter requested further information and details of the value of the property, which were provided.  Ultimately an assessment of duty in the amount of $4,346.25 was issued on 13 December 2011 for duty on a transfer of 49% of the property which was then valued at $380,000.

  4. Mr Sherratt objected to the assessment on the ground that the s 152 exemption should have been granted and that objection was disallowed by the Commissioner of State Revenue on 31 May 2012. Mr Sherratt has applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Commissioner’s decision in regard to the objection.

The Legislative Framework

  1. When exercising its review jurisdiction the Tribunal steps into the shoes of the Commissioner and decides the review in accordance with the Act[1] and the enabling Acts[2] and performs the functions conferred on the Tribunal under those acts and has all of the functions of the Commissioner for the reviewable decision[3].

  2. The review of a decision of the Commissioner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sherratt v Commissioner of State Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCAT 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Karl Noel Sherratt has appealed to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) against a decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue which disallowed his objection to an assessment of duty. Mr Sherratt and his wife purchased an investment property in 2010, which was registered in their names jointly. After preparing his income tax return for the 2010/11 year, Mr Sherratt became aware of a problem in the way the title to the property was held and they executed a transfer of the property from themselves to themselves but with the property to be held as tenants in common in the shares of Mr Sherratt 99/100 and Mrs Sherratt 1/100. The transfer, with statutory declarations from Mr and Mrs Sherratt, the Office of State Revenue Form 2.2 and a recent title search, was submitted to the Office of State Revenue for an assessment of duty. The letter accompanying the documents noted that the transfer was exempt under section 152 (exemption to correct clerical error) of the Duties Act 2001. However, the assessor requested further information and details of the value of the property, which were provided. Ultimately an assessment of duty in the amount of $4,346.25 was issued for duty on a transfer of 49% of the property which was then valued at $380,000. Mr Sherratt objected to the assessment on the ground that the s 152 exemption should have been granted and that objection was disallowed by the Commissioner of State Revenue on 31 May 2012. The grounds of the objection is that the transfer should have been entitled to an exemption from duty in accordance with section 152 of the Duties Act 2001 on the basis that it was a dutiable transaction to correct a clerical error in a previous dutiable transaction about the same property.

The Tribunal considered the history of section 152 of the Duties Act 2001 and the relevant case law. It noted that the Commissioner’s practice during the first five years of the operation of the Duties Act 2001 was to limit the exemption to correction of clerical errors in the dutiable transaction itself, for example, transferring the wrong property title or misnaming a transferee. However, the Commissioner’s practice was challenged in the Pryke case, which held that the exemption could apply to transactions which were necessary to achieve a legal effect which the parties to the transaction mistakenly believed an earlier transaction would achieve. The Commissioner considered that this placed the risk of the inappropriate structuring of decisions on the State, rather than on the parties, with consequent revenue risks and uncertainty. To align the section with the consistent practice, s 152 was amended to insert the word clerical in front of the word error throughout the section, to remove any doubt about the intentions of the section.

The Tribunal examined the facts of the case and found that there was no clerical error in the preparation of the transfer as it correctly showed Mr and Mrs Sherratt were to hold the property as joint tenants in accordance with the instructions on the Conveyancing Questionnaire. The error was not discovered until Mr Sherratt's accountant advised that holding the property as joint tenants with his wife would have adverse tax consequences. The original financial advice received by Mr and Mrs Sherratt showed that the property should be held by the person who had a taxable income, which was Mr Sherratt. There was no mention of tenants in common in the financial advice until the time of the second transfer and the letter from the financial adviser. The Tribunal concluded that the error was not a clerical error but an error in terms of not understanding the legal effect of the choice to hold the property as joint tenants on the deductibility of the expenses for the property. Such an error is not a clerical error and there is no entitlement to the exemption under s 152 of the Duties Act 2001.

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue dated 31 May 2012 is confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established