Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd v The Cairns Port Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

[1991] QLC 28

 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE.

30th August, 1991.

Re:Determination of Compensation -

Resumption for Cairns Airport and to render safer or more convenient the use of the Cairns Airport for the landing and taking off of Aircraft

(A90-26)

Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd
  v.
  The Cairns Port Authority

JUDGMENT

By proclamation dated 6th September, 1986 the respondent Cairns Port Authority resumed two parcels of land comprising an aggregate area of 13.225 hectares from Shepherd's Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd for the above stated purpose.  The resumed parcels are more particularly described as Lot 1 on RP 738764, Parish of Cairns containing an area of 4708 m2 and Lot 3 on RP 738764, Parish of Cairns containing an area of 12.754 hectares.  The resumed lots are situated adjacent to the southern perimeter of the Cairns International Airport and are serviced by the Cairns Airport Access Road (Airport Avenue) which is built on land which severs the resumed parcels and which was formerly resumed by the Cairns Port Authority, being Lot 2 on RP 738764, Parish of Cairns.  The resumed lots 1 and 3 are zoned "Light Industry" under the provisions of the City of Cairns Town Planning Scheme except for a negligible area in the extreme south western corner of Lot 3. 
  On 12th June, 1990 Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd filed in the Land Court Registry a claim for compensation in the sum of $545,770.  At the outset of the hearing of the matter leave was sought and was granted to amend this claim to $439,000 so as to accord with a valuation of the resumed land by Russell Geoffrey Brown who is a registered valuer with the valuation firm Taylor Byrne.  The amended claim is made up as follows:

Value of Lot 1 on RP 738764 -             $ 25,000

Value of Lot 3 on RP 738764 -             $404,000

Value of Land resumed  $429,000

Compensation for disturbance             $ 10,000

Total Claim   $439,000
  =====

Before proceeding any further, it should be said that compensation for disturbance, comprising legal and valuation fees involved in the preparation of the amended claim for compensation, has been agreed between the parties in the sum of $3,750. As a result the claim was further amended to $432,750. To illustrate the extent of the difference in compensation assessments, I should here say that the respondent Cairns Port Authority, acting on valuation advice, advanced to the claimant company a sum of $84,200, by way of compensation on 2nd April, 1990. Soon after the hearing commenced, it became apparent that the principal cause for the widely divergent views as to the value of the resumed land was the diverse stand taken by the parties as to the potential of resumed Lot 3 on RP 738764 for light industrial subdivisional development. The claimant company on the one hand sees it as being very suitable for and capable of economic development and subdivision, while the respondent Authority considers such development as being completely uneconomic. Both resumed parcels are comprised almost…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd v The Cairns Port Authorit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] QLC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd filed a claim for compensation against The Cairns Port Authority for the resumption of two parcels of land for airport purposes. The Court had to determine the value of the resumed land and the appropriate compensation. The primary dispute was over the potential for industrial subdivision of the land, with the claimant asserting it had significant development potential and the respondent arguing it was economically unviable. The Court considered expert evidence from valuers, engineers, and planners. It found that while the land had some potential for industrial use, the subdivision was not economically viable due to high fill costs, statutory constraints, and other development hurdles. The Court determined that the land's value to the owner was $125,000 for the larger lot and $30,000 for the smaller lot, plus $3,750 for disturbance, for a total compensation of $158,750. The Court also awarded simple interest on the compensation at a rate of 12.75% per annum.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1986, the Cairns Port Authority resumed two parcels of land from Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd for the purpose of making the Cairns Airport safer and more convenient for aircraft. The resumed parcels, Lot 1 and Lot 3 on RP 738764, Parish of Cairns, are situated adjacent to the southern perimeter of the Cairns International Airport. Lot 1 is 4,708 m2 and Lot 3 is 12.754 hectares, both zoned for light industry. Shepherds Properties filed a claim for compensation in the sum of $545,770, later amended to $439,000, based on a valuation by Russell Geoffrey Brown. The principal cause of dispute is the potential for light industrial subdivisional development of Lot 3, with Shepherds Properties viewing it as economically viable and the Cairns Port Authority considering it uneconomic.

Shepherds Properties (NQ) Pty Ltd filed a claim for compensation in the Land Court Registry on 12th June, 1990. Leave to amend the claim was granted to reduce it to $439,000. The case was heard over two weeks in February and July 1991. Numerous witnesses were called, and extensive documentary evidence was presented. The Court heard evidence from valuers, engineers, and town planners on both sides. The Court also undertook a site inspection. The decision was handed down by Member C.H. Carter of the Land Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate method for valuing the resumed land and determining its compensation?
2. What is the highest and best use of the resumed land and its potential for light industrial subdivisional development?
3. Should the Court consider the offer of $500,000 made by Mr. Price for the subject lands in 1984 as evidence of value?

Held
1. The appropriate method for valuing the resumed land and determining its compensation is based on the "special value to owner" concept, taking into account the value of the land to the owner, which cannot exceed what the dispossessed owner could have obtained for it in the market place.
2. The highest and best use of the resumed land is for industrial development, but the Court found that the subdivision of Lot 3 for industrial development would not have been justifiable on economic grounds at the relevant date.
3. The Court does not consider the offer of $500,000 made by Mr. Price for the subject lands in 1984 as evidence of value because offers to buy and sell land that do not result in a concluded contract do not constitute reliable evidence as to value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the conflicting evidence of the engineers and valuers, ultimately concluding that the subdivision of Lot 3 for industrial development would not have been economically viable at the relevant date. The Court found that Mr. Brown's gross realisation lot values of $60/m2 were too high and that $45/m2 was more in line with the market. Using this lower value in Mr. Brown's hypothetical subdivision valuation exercise resulted in a significantly lower total gross realisation and a negative land value. The Court also considered the constraints on development outlined by Mr. Robinson, including statutory requirements for approval to interfere with mangroves and the need for Lands Department approval to dedicate and use part of vacant Crown Land for road purposes.

The Court found that Lot 3 had future potential for some type of industrial use, whether as a single site, for future subdivision, or as a holding proposition. Considering its favourable location, good exposure to Airport Avenue, and the negative features such as the probable difficulty to obtain a permit to destroy the mangroves, the Court determined that $125,000 would not be unrealistic in the market place for Lot 3. For Lot 1, the Court found $30,000 as just and fair compensation. Therefore, the Court determined compensation for the resumption of Lots 1 and 3 at $155,000, to which the agreed sum of $3,750 is added as compensation for disturbance.

Regarding interest on the compensation award, the Court found that the practice of the Land Court and the Land Appeal Court is to award interest on compensation awards on a simple interest basis. The Court adopted the reasoning of Jacobs J in South Australia Land Commission v. Perry (1977) 37 LGRA 25, which held that the claim to compound interest under Section 33 of the Land Acquisition Act (SA) is misconceived and dismissed the application, awarding simple interest instead. The Court ordered that the respondent Cairns Port Authority pay to the claimant company interest calculated as simple interest at the rate of 12.75% per annum on the sums and for the periods specified in the judgment.